C. ANIL CHANDRANversusM.K. RAGHAVAN AND OTHERS
2023 INSC 96230 October 2023Dismissed
The appellant, a graduate engineer appointed as Overseer Grade‑III on compassionate grounds, was later promoted to Assistant Engineer in 1995 and sought seniority for further promotion. Private respondents, diploma holders, were granted back‑dated promotions to Assistant Engineer effective 01‑08‑1993 by an order dated …
R. JAYARAMA AND ORS.versusSTATE OF KERALA AND ORS.
2010 INSC 83429 November 2010Dismissed
The appellants, selected by the Kerala State Public Service Commission for direct recruitment as Reserve Sub Inspectors, were advised of vacancies between 1990 and 1993 but were not appointed until a Government Order dated 17‑06‑1999 invoked Rule 39 of the Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules, 1958 to retain the…
AJITH K & ORS.versusANEESH K.S. & ORS.
2019 INSC 94021 August 2019Dismissed
The appellants challenged the inclusion of candidates holding a two‑year Diploma in Health Inspectors Course (DHIC) in the short‑list for the post of Junior Health Inspector Grade‑II in the Municipal Common Service, arguing that DHIC was a higher qualification and should be treated as equivalent under Rule 10(a)(ii) of…
MAYA MATHEWversusSTATE OF KERALA & ORS.
2010 INSC 11218 February 2010Dismissed
Maya Mathew, a pharmacist in the Kerala State Homeopathy Services, challenged the method used to allocate vacancies for Medical Officer posts, arguing that the ratio of direct recruitment to transfers should be applied to the cadre strength of the post as mandated by Note (3) of Rule 5 of the General Rules, not to the …
PRAVEEN KUMAR C.PversusKERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION & ORS.
2021 INSC 40417 August 2021Appeal(s) allowed
The appellants, Praveen Kumar C.P. and Anitha Devi, applied for High School Assistant posts in Kerala where the recruitment notification required a B.Ed. in the concerned subject (Natural Science). Their B.Ed. degrees were in Biological Science (and related subjects) obtained from universities outside Kerala. They obta…
DR. SHARMADversusSTATE OF KERALA AND OTHERS
2025 INSC 709 January 2025Appeal(s) allowed
Dr. Sharmad, an Assistant Professor of Neurosurgery in Kerala's Medical Education Service, was promoted to Associate Professor on 6 February 2013. The promotion was challenged by a third respondent who argued that the promotion required five years of physical teaching experience as an Assistant Professor after obtainin…
V. K. GIRIJA V. RESHMA PARAYIL & ORS.versusRESHMA PARAYIL & ORS.
2018 INSC 11474 December 2018Dismissed
V.K. Girija was appointed as a Higher Secondary School Teacher (Economics) by direct recruitment. Reshma Parayil, a Higher Secondary School Assistant, claimed that the vacancy should have been filled by transfer under Rule 4(2) of the Kerala Education Rules, 1959. The State Government ordered her transfer, but a Single…
C. JAYACHANDRANversusSTATE OF KERALA & ORS. ETC.
2020 INSC 2654 March 2020Appeal(s) allowed
The appellant, C. Jayachandran, applied for a District Judge post under a 2007 advertisement for six Higher Judicial Service vacancies. After the High Court annulled the grant of moderation marks to other candidates, the revised select list placed Jayachandran at rank 3, but his appointment was delayed until 24 Februar…