Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969

59 judgments · newest first · showing 1–59

M/S SUNEJA TOWERS PRIVATE LIMITED & ANR.versusANITA MERCHANT

2023 INSC 391Appeal(s) allowed

Anita Merchant booked three flats from Suneja Towers Private Limited, paid 60% of the price, but the builder failed to deliver possession even after the agreed period, leading her to file consumer complaints. The District Forum dismissed the complaints, but the State Consumer Commission reversed the …

K. L. SUNEJA & ANRversusDR. (MRS.) MANJEET KAUR MONGA (D) THROUGH HER LR & ANR

2023 INSC 89Disposed off

The case concerned a flat purchase where the buyer paid seven instalments totalling Rs 4,53,750, but the developer cancelled the allotment in April 2005 and issued a pay order for refund. The buyer filed a complaint under the MRTP Act (later transferred to the Competition Appellate Tribunal) seeking …

B.B. PATEL & ORSversusDLF UNIVERSAL LTD

2022 INSC 91Disposed off

The appellants, buyers of apartments from DLF Universal Ltd., entered into an Apartment Buyer Agreement in 1993 promising possession within 2½‑3 years. Possession was delayed and the builder imposed extra charges, leading the buyers to allege unfair trade practice under the Monopolies and …

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIAversusSHRI KANAIYALAL BALDEVBHAI PATEL

2017 INSC 963Disposed off

The Supreme Court examined whether non‑intermediary front‑running—where a person receives confidential information about a forthcoming large block trade and trades ahead of it—constitutes a prohibited fraudulent or unfair trade practice under SEBI’s Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade …

LAUREL ENERGETICS PVT. LTD.versusSECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA

2017 INSC 616Dismissed

Laurel Energetics Pvt. Ltd. (appellant) acquired 18% of Rattan India Infrastructure Ltd., the target company, in July 2014 at Rs 6.30 per share. In October 2015 it made an open offer to acquire the remaining shares at Rs 3.20 per share. SEBI held that the acquisition was not exempt under Regulation …

M/S. PUROLATOR INDIA LTD.versusCOMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE DELHI-ILL

2015 INSC 604Disposed off

M/s Purolator India Ltd, a manufacturer of excisable filter elements, claimed deductions for cash discount, volume discount and sales tax while filing excise returns. The Commissioner of Central Excise rejected the cash‑discount deduction and affirmed duty on other items, leading to an appeal. The …

DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITYversusP.R. SAMANTA

2015 INSC 501Appeal(s) allowed

The Delhi Development Authority (DDA) invited applications for a self‑financing housing scheme in 1985. The respondent paid a registration deposit of Rs.15,000 and later declined the flat allotment, seeking a refund with 15% interest instead of the 7% stipulated in the scheme brochure. DDA refunded …

BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITEDversusTELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA AND OTHERS

2013 INSC 808Reference answered

The Supreme Court examined whether the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) could entertain challenges to regulations made by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) under Section 36 of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997. It held that the power …

RANGI INTERNATIONAL LTD .versusNOVA SCOTIA BANK & ORS.

2013 INSC 315Appeal(s) allowed

Rangi International Ltd appealed against orders of the Competition Commission and the Competition Appellate Tribunal that dismissed its claim of unfair trade practice under the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969. The Supreme Court observed that both the Commission and the Tribunal …

PREM NATH MOTORS LTD.versusANURAG MITTAL

2008 INSC 1302Appeal(s) allowed

An international car manufacturer entered into a joint venture with an Indian company that appointed Prem Nath Motors Ltd as its dealer. In response to advertisements, individuals applied for a Peugeot 309 car through Prem Nath Motors, paying a booking amount of Rs.25,000 in the name of the Indian …

M/S KLM ROYAL DUTCH AIRLINESversusDIRECTOR GENERAL OF INVESTIGATION & REGISTRATION

2008 INSC 1129Appeal(s) allowed

M/s. KLM Royal Dutch Airlines appealed against an order of the MRTP Commission that held it guilty of unfair trade practice for a deficiency in cargo service. The complainant alleged that two parcels were delayed, causing loss, and the Commission treated the delay as an unfair trade practice under …

V.N. BHARATversusD.D.A. AND ANR.

2008 INSC 1003Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant applied for a self‑financing flat under a Delhi Development Authority scheme, paid the first four instalments and was allotted a flat. The DOA issued a show‑cause notice for non‑payment of the fifth instalment and claimed that a demand letter dated 11‑Sept‑1996 had been served, …

MANJUL SRIVASTAVAversusGOVT. OF U.P. & ORS.

2008 INSC 995Case Partly allowed

Manjul Srivastava applied for a residential plot in the Ghaziabad Development Authority's 1988 housing scheme, paid the full amount and received a reservation letter, but after nine years was informed she had not been allotted a plot and was offered a refund with 5% interest. She claimed the …

DLF UNIVERSAL LTD.versusEKTA SETH & ANR.

2008 INSC 832Disposed off

DLF Universal Ltd sold a flat to Ekta Seth & others under an Apartment Buyer’s Agreement that allowed the seller to increase the price and stipulated forfeiture of earnest money for default. The buyers paid installments for five years but stopped after the seller demanded a cost‑escalation sum and …

GHAZIABAD DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITYversusVED PRAKASH AGGARWAL

2008 INSC 667Appeal(s) allowed

The Ghaziabad Development Authority (GOA) allotted a plot to Ved Prakash Aggarwal under its 1988 housing scheme, for which the respondent paid the full consideration. Years later GOA cancelled the allotment, claiming the respondent had failed in the lottery draw, and offered a refund. The respondent …

BAJAJ AUTO LTD.versusDIRECTOR GENERAL (I & R) & ANR.

2008 INSC 642Appeal(s) allowed

Bajaj Auto Ltd. challenged a Notice of Enquiry issued by the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices (MRTP) Commission alleging that its dealer agreements involved restrictive trade practices under Section 33 of the MRTP Act. The appellant argued that the alleged clauses—territorial appointment, …

ALOK SHANKER PANDEYversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2007 INSC 150Disposed off

The appellant applied for a flat under the Indira Puram Housing Scheme in 1994 and paid all required installments, but the flat was never allotted. In 2001 he demanded a refund of the installments with 21% interest, but the authority refunded only the principal amount. He filed a claim under Section …

SAURABH PRAKASHversusDLF UNIVERSAL LTD.

2006 INSC 912Disposed off

The appellant purchased a flat from DLF Universal Ltd. and paid earnest money and instalments, but later could not continue payments and sought a refund of the amounts paid, proposing a swap for a smaller property. DLF refused to adjust the earnest money and the appellant filed an application before …

TECHNIP SAversusSMS HOLDING (PVT.) LTD. AND ORS.

2005 INSC 272Appeal(s) allowed

Technip SA and its French subsidiary Coflexip acquired a controlling stake in SEAMEC, an Indian company, prompting SEBI to invoke the Substantial Acquisition of Shares and Takeover Regulations, 1997. SEBI held that French law governed the determination of when control was obtained, concluding that …

J.K. GUPTAversusD.G. INVESTIGATION AND REGISTRATION AND ORS.

2004 INSC 640

A complaint was lodged before the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices (MRTP) Commission against a computer training institute for admitting students to unrecognised courses and for publishing misleading advertisements. The Commission issued an interim injunction and, after the institute’s …

MAN ROLAND DRUCKIMACHINEN AGversusMULTICOLOUR OFFSET LTD. AND ANR.

2004 INSC 287Disposed off

The appellant, a German manufacturer of printing machines, sold a machine to the Indian respondent and was later accused before the MRTP Commission of unfair trade practices and faced a compensation claim. The appellant challenged the Commission's jurisdiction on two grounds: a contractual clause …

M/S. PEICO ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRICALS AND ANR.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2004 INSC 149Disposed off

The appellant, Mis. Peico Electronics, terminated the dealership of its second dealer (R‑2) under Clause 29 of a standard form agreement. R‑2 complained before the MRTP Commission alleging several restrictive trade practices, including territorial allocation, discrimination, and a clause (Clause 7) …

STATE OF UTTAR PRADESHversusGIR PRASAD AND ORS.

2004 INSC 129Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Uttar Pradesh introduced an irrigation programme that affected the agricultural lands of Gir Prasad, who filed a complaint under the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969 alleging that the State had manipulated the conditions of water supply and engaged in a restrictive …

M/S. PAWAN HANS LTD.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2003 INSC 220Dismissed

Mis. Pawan Hans Ltd. sought flats for its employees and entered negotiations with Mis. Lokhandwala Construction Industries Ltd. over price and the requirement of an unconditional bank guarantee. The parties could not agree on the guarantee clause, the Memorandum of Understanding was never signed and …

CELLULAR OPERATORS ASSOCIATION OF INDIA AND ORS.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2002 INSC 542Appeal(s) allowed

The Cellular Operators Association of India (appellants) challenged the Government's decision to permit Fixed Service Providers to offer Wireless in Local Loop (WLL) with limited mobility, arguing that the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) failed to consider the …

COLGATE PALMOLIVE (INDIA) LTD .versusM.R.T.P. COMMISSION AND ORS.

2002 INSC 480Appeal(s) allowed

Colgate Palmolive (India) Ltd ran a newspaper contest that required consumers to purchase two toothbrushes to enter, offering various prizes. A complaint was filed with the MRTP Commission alleging that the contest was an unfair trade practice under Section 36A(3)(b) of the Monopolies and …

HINDUSTAN CIBA GEIGYversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2002 INSC 476Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Hindustan Ciba Geigy, placed an advertisement claiming its product Aerocol was manufactured by it and was a market leader in the UK. A complaint was filed alleging unfair trade practice under Section 36A of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969, leading the MRTP …

R.D. GOYAL AND ANR.versusRELIANCE INDUSTRIES LTD.

2002 INSC 477Dismissed

The appellants R.D. Goyal and others challenged the MRTP Commission’s finding that the issue of equity shares linked with redeemable non‑convertible debentures, before allotment, did not constitute "goods" under Section 2(e) of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969. They argued …

M/S. HARIDAS EXPORTSversusALL INDIA FLOAT GLASS MFRS. ASSOCIATION AND ORS.

2002 INSC 306Disposed off

The All India Float Glass Manufacturers Association complained that Indonesian exporters were selling float glass in India at predatory prices, alleging a restrictive trade practice under the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices (MRTP) Act. The MRTP Commission issued an interim injunction …

GHAZIABAD DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY ETC. ETC.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2000 INSC 331

Ghaziabad Development Authority (GDA) advertised several schemes for allotment of developed plots, collected deposits from allottees, and then failed to deliver possession within a reasonable time. The aggrieved allottees obtained orders from the MRTP Commission, Consumer Forum and High Court …

RAJASTHAN HOUSING BOARDversusSMT. PARVATI DEVI ETC.

2000 INSC 279Disposed off

The Rajasthan Housing Board (RHB) was alleged by several homebuyers, including Parvati Devi, to have delayed construction, demanded additional payments and failed to hand over possession of allotted houses. The complainants filed a petition before the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices …

PRASHANT KUMAR SHARIversusGHAZIABAD DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

2000 INSC 183Dismissed

The appellant had been allotted a plot by the Ghaziabad Development Authority (GDA) after paying registration, reservation and the first two instalments. He delayed further payments, alleging that the Authority had not completed development and therefore possession was delayed. The GDA issued a …

COLGATE PALMOLIVE (INDIA) LTD.versusHINDUSTAN LEVER LTD.

1999 INSC 340Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court examined two appeals arising from an order of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices (MRTP) Commission that restrained Colgate Palmolive India Ltd. from using the phrase "Suraksha Chakra" in its Colgate Dental Cream advertisements. The Commission had granted a temporary …

ION EXCHANGE (INDIA) LTD.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

1998 INSC 412Appeal(s) allowed

Ion Exchange (India) Ltd., a manufacturer of water purifiers, advertised that its products provided 100% safe drinking water instantly and remained bacteria‑free in storage. The Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission, under the MRTP Act, instituted an inquiry and the company accepted …

BAJAJ AUTO LTD.versusCOMPANY LAW BOARD AND ORS.

1998 INSC 270Appeal(s) allowed

Bajaj Auto Ltd. and its subsidiary purchased 13,200 shares in Bajaj Tempo Ltd., a listed public company. The Board of Directors of Bajaj Tempo refused to register the transfer, citing four reasons: potential inter‑connection, lack of bona‑fide investment, competition, and the transferees being …

HINDUSTAN LEVER LTD.versusCOLGATE PALMOLIVE (I) LTD. AND ANR.

1997 INSC 823Dismissed

Hindustan Lever Ltd. advertised its New Pepsodent toothpaste as 102% superior in antibacterial action to the "leading toothpaste", which the MRTP Commission identified as Colgate Dental Cream. Colgate Palmolive (India) Ltd. and a consumer filed a complaint under Sections 10, 36A(viii), 36A(x) and …

NIRMA INDUSTRIES LTD.versusDIRECTOR GENERAL OF INVESTIGATION AND REGISTRATION

1997 INSC 484Disposed off

Nirma Industries Ltd., a manufacturer of washing powders, launched a prize‑lottery scheme by placing coupons in its detergent packs. A consumer complaint alleged that Nirma had raised the price of its detergent shortly before the scheme to recover the value of the prizes, constituting an unfair …

M/S VOLTAS LTD. BOMBAYversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

1995 INSC 102Appeal(s) allowed

Mis Voltas Ltd. entered into exclusive distribution agreements with numerous manufacturers, containing territorial and exclusive dealing clauses. The Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission (MRTPC) issued notices under Section 10(a)(iii) and Section 37 of the Monopolies and Restrictive …

HINDUSTAN LEVER EMPLOYEES' UNIONversusHINDUSTAN LEVER LIMITED AND ORS

1994 INSC 483Dismissed

The Supreme Court considered the sanction of a scheme of amalgamation between Tata Oil Mills Company Ltd. (TOMCO) and Hindustan Lever Ltd. (HLL), a subsidiary of the foreign multinational Unilever. The petitioners – nominal TOMCO shareholders, employee unions and consumer groups – challenged the …

OM PRAKASHversusASSISTANT ENGINEER, HARYANA AGRO INDUSTRIES CORPORATION AND ORS.

1994 INSC 151Appeal(s) allowed

Om Prakash booked a tractor on 12‑12‑1990, paying an advance and was first on the dealer's booking list. The dealer delayed delivery, supplied tractors to lower‑ranked customers, and when the tractor was finally delivered on 21‑9‑1991 the price had risen, causing a loss of Rs 40,690 to the consumer. …

UNION OF INDIA AND ORSversusHINDUSTAN DEVELOPMENT CORPN. AND ORS

1993 INSC 154Disposed off

The Railway Board invited tenders for cast steel bogies and three large manufacturers (H.D.C., Mukand and Bharatiya) quoted an identical low price, leading the Tender Committee to suspect a cartel and recommend a counter‑offer of Rs. 76,000 per bogie. Post‑tender, the three firms offered a further …

RAYMOND WOOLLEN MILLS LTD.versusM.R.T.P. COMMISSIONS AND ANR.

1993 INSC 72Dismissed

The Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices (M.R.T.P.) Commission issued a notice alleging that Raymond Woollen Mills Ltd. engaged in resale price maintenance because its price lists did not state that dealers could charge lower prices. The Commission held that the price lists merely indicated …

N. PARTHASARATHY ETC.versusCONTROLLER OF CAPITAL ISSUES AND ANOTHER ETC.

1991 INSC 104Dismissed

The Supreme Court examined whether the sale of 39 lakh shares of Larsen & Toubro Ltd. by public financial institutions to Trishna Investments through BOB Fiscal Services, and the Controller of Capital Issues' consent to a mega issue of convertible debentures (including a Rs.310 crore preferential …

M.L. SACHDEVversusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

1990 INSC 337Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court, hearing a public‑interest writ under Article 32, directed the Union of India to fill the vacancies in the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission within three weeks, later extending the deadline to 7 July 1990. The Union, represented by Secretary A.N. Verma, failed …

COLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, MADRASversusSTANDARD MOTOR PRODUCTS, ETC.

1989 INSC 70Dismissed

The Collector of Central Excise, Madras filed statutory appeals against orders of the Customs, Excise and Gold Control Appellate Tribunal and sought condonation of delay for those appeals. A Single Judge of the Supreme Court dismissed the condonation applications under Order VI Rule 2(14) of the …

BOMBAY OIL INDUSTRIESversusUNION OF INDIA

1983 INSC 174Dismissed

Bombay Oil Industries challenged a Government order issued under Sections 21, 22 and 23 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969, alleging that it was not supplied with material necessary to contest the order. The Court examined whether the Government, as an administrative …