Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Dr. Madhurendra Kumar SinhaversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool with this judgment prefilled as editable reference text. Add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The Court quashed FIR No. 373 of 2018, holding that the allegations do not constitute a criminal offence and the proceeding is an abuse of process.

Summary

Dr. Madhurendra Kumar Sinha and his wife Dr. Anuja M. Sinha filed a petition under Section 528 of the B.N.S.S. seeking to quash FIR No. 373 of 2018, which alleged that they, together with a third person, broke into a premises and stole furniture and cash belonging to the informant, Poonam Keshri. The petitioners contended that the dispute was purely civil, arising from an oral agreement for the sale/ tenancy of the property and that the FIR lacked essential particulars such as date, time and description of stolen items. They argued that no element of theft, cheating or criminal intimidation was proved and that the criminal provisions of the IPC were being misused to settle a civil score. The Court examined the material and found that the informant had indeed misused the law to harass the petitioners, noting that the property belonged to the petitioners and the allegations were baseless. Consequently, the Court quashed the FIR and allowed the petition, holding that criminal prosecution cannot be employed for a civil contractual dispute.

Issues considered

  • Whether the allegations in FIR No. 373 of 2018 disclose a cognizable offence under Sections 504, 379 and 34 of the IPC.
  • Whether the FIR is liable to be quashed under Section 528 of the B.N.S.S. on the ground that the dispute is civil in nature.
  • Whether the use of criminal provisions in a civil property dispute amounts to an abuse of process.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • quash of FIR
  • civil dispute
  • criminal law
  • IPC sections 504, 379, 34
  • Section 528 B.N.S.S.
  • abuse of process
  • property dispute
  • malicious prosecution

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                              CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.85170 of 2025
                     Arising Out of PS. Case No.-373 Year-2018 Thana- KADAMKUAN District- Patna
                 ======================================================
           1.     Dr. Madhurendra Kumar Sinha S/o- Birendra Kumar Sinha R/V- Flat No
                  1605, B Wing, Mantri Serene, Film City Road, Dindoshi, Next To Mantri
                  Park, Goregaon East, PS- Dindoshi, District - Mumbai
           2.    Dr. Anuja M. Sinha W/o- Dr. Madhurendra Kumar Sinha R/V- Flat No 1605,
                 B Wing, Mantri Serene, Film City Road, Dindoshi, Next To Mantri Park,
                 Goregaon East, PS- Dindoshi, District - Mumbai, State - Maharashtra, Pin -
                 400065
                                                                          ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                  Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar
           2.     Poonam Keshri W/o- Smt. Anil Keshri R/o- Flat No. B-603, Saket Plaza,
                  Jamal Road, P.S- Kotwali, District - Patna, Pin - 800001
                                                                         ... ... Opposite Party/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s     :      Mr. Anuj Kumar, Advocate
                                                 Mr. Eashita Raj, Advocate
                 For the Opposite Party/s :      Mr. Mrityunjaya Kr. Gautam, APP
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRAVEEN KUMAR
                                       ORAL ORDER

3   16-06-2026                   Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned

                   APP for the State.

                                 2. By order dated 08.01.2026, notices were issued to

                   Opposite Party No.2 and even after valid service of notice,

                   Opposite Party No.2 has chosen not to appear and get herself

                   represented through an advocate.

                                 3. This petition has been preferred under Section 528

                   of the B.N.S.S. seeking quashing of Kadamkuan P.S. Case No.

                   373 of 2018, registered on 01.07.2018 under Sections 504, 379

                   and 34 of the Indian Penal Code against the petitioners.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.85170 of 2025(3) dt.16-06-2026
                                            2/6




                       4. As per the prosecution, the informant, namely,

          Poonam Kesari, alleged that she was running an educational

          institution known as “Poonam Stepping Stone Tutorial Study

          Centre” from a portion of the residential premises belonging to

          the petitioner no.1 (Dr. Madhurendra Kumar Sinha), situated at

          Sinha Mansion, M.P. Sinha Road, Kadamkuan, Patna, after

          paying Rs. 1,50,000/- towards renovation and agreeing to a

          monthly rent of Rs. 23,000/-. It is alleged that the petitioner no.1

          (Dr. Madhurendra Kumar Sinha) later expressed his intention to

          sell the property and demanded an earnest money amount of Rs.

          5,00,000/-, which the informant claims to have paid in cash on

          the understanding that the ownership of the premises would be

          transferred to her under the applicable norms. It is further

          alleged that despite repeated requests, the petitioner no.1 did not

          execute the registration deed. Instead, on a specified day, the

          petitioners and one Rajesh Kumar allegedly broke open the lock

          of the ground floor, entered the premises, and removed school

          furniture, swings, and other items belonging to the institution. It

          is further alleged that Rajesh Kumar snatched her handbag

          containing Rs. 5,000/- in cash, along with a cheque book, and

          fled away. It is further alleged that Rajesh Kumar and his wife

          abused and threatened her to implicate in a case in the presence
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.85170 of 2025(3) dt.16-06-2026
                                            3/6




          of staff members.

                       5. Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted

          that the present allegation is false and a serious attempt has been

          made to falsely implicate the petitioners. It has further been

          submitted that no date of occurrence has been mentioned in the

          FIR, making the petitioners victim of circumstances. It has

          further been submitted that petitioner no.1 (Dr. Madhurendra

          Kumar Sinha) is the owner of the property and petitioner no.2

          (Dr. Anuja M. Sinha) is his wife. It has further been submitted

          that the dispute as narrated in the FIR revolves around an

          alleged oral agreement for sale of immovable property, which is

          a civil dispute and cannot constitute a criminal offence, unless

          deception at the very inception is pleaded and proved, which is

          completely absent here. It has further been submitted that the

          FIR shows that the informant has been repeatedly asking for

          registration of the premises, which further confirms that the

          issue pertains to a contractual disagreement over transfer of

          property rather than any criminal activity. It has further been

          submitted that suddenly, in order to give criminal colour to a

          civil dispute, the FIR alleged that the petitioners and one Rajesh

          Kumar entered the premises, broke open the lock of the ground

          floor and removed school furniture, without mentioning any
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.85170 of 2025(3) dt.16-06-2026
                                            4/6




          specific date, time, witnesses, seizure list, or recovery of the

          alleged articles. It has further been submitted that the allegation

          of theft is baseless because the allegations pertains to premises

          owned by the petitioners’ family and no document has been

          produced to show that the alleged furniture or articles belonged

          exclusively to the informant. It has further been submitted that

          the allegation that Rajesh Kumar and the petitioners’ son took

          her bag containing Rs, 5,000/- and a cheque book and ran away,

          the same is inherently unnatural, improbable, and clearly an

          afterthought, introduced solely to invoke Section 379 IPC. It has

          further been submitted that no ingredient of cheating, criminal

          intimidation, misappropriation, house trespass, or theft is made

          out against the petitioner in the facts and circumstances of the

          case. It has further been submitted that the dispute on the face of

          it is undeniably civil in nature, as it arises out of tenancy,

          advance money for renovation, and alleged oral agreement to

          sell, and criminal prosecution cannot be permitted to continue in

          such circumstances.

                       6. Learned counsel for the petitioners has also referred

          to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of

          State of Haryana vs. Bhajan Lal; reported in 1992

          Supplementary (1) SCC Page 335 and has submitted that the
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.85170 of 2025(3) dt.16-06-2026
                                            5/6




          allegation is levelled with malice, personal vendetta and to spite

          personal score. Learned counsel for the petitioners has further

          referred to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court as rendered

          in Mitesh Kumar J. Shah vs. State of Karnataka; reported in

          (2021) 15 SCC 595 and has submitted that criminal prosecution

          is not a remedy for breach of contract, if any, and cannot be a

          weapon to settle civil scores. Learned counsel for the petitioners

          has further referred to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court

          of G. Sagar Suri vs. State of UP; (2000) 2 SCC 636 and has

          submitted that the criminal proceedings cannot be used as a

          means of harassment. It has further been submitted that

          petitioners are doctors by profession and reside in Mumbai

          (Maharashtra) and in order to grab the property, the informant

          has misused the provisions of law in falsely implicating the

          petitioners.

                       7. Considering the totality of the materials and

          evidence on record and the facts and circumstances of this case,

          this Court having observed that the informant has misused the

          provisions of law to spite personal score when the petitioner

          no.1 is the owner of the property in question and petitioner No.2

          being wife of petitioner no.1, this Court has no option, but to

          quash the FIR bearing Kadamkuan P.S. Case No. 373 of 2018.
           Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.85170 of 2025(3) dt.16-06-2026
                                                       6/6




                                  8. This application stands allowed.



                                                (Praveen Kumar, J)
shivam/-

U      T


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.