Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Abha KumariversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The Municipal Officers and Servants (Appointments, Duties, Discipline and Appeal) Rules continue in force under Section 488(4)(b) of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007, and the petitioner may withdraw the writ and file an appeal within 90 days, with any delay condoned.

Summary

Abha Kumari, an assistant in Gaya Municipal Corporation, filed a writ petition challenging a minor punishment order and sought to withdraw the petition to pursue an appeal under the Municipal Officers and Servants (Appointments, Duties, Discipline and Appeal) Rules. The respondents argued that the service of municipal employees is governed by those rules, which remain in force despite the repeal of earlier statutes. The court examined the effect of Section 488(4)(b) of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007, which preserves actions and rules made under repealed Acts, and held that the Rules continue to operate. Accordingly, the court granted the petitioner liberty to file an appeal within 90 days and ordered any delay in filing to be condoned. The writ petition was dismissed as withdrawn.

Issues considered

  • Whether the Municipal Officers and Servants (Appointments, Duties, Discipline and Appeal) Rules remain in force despite the repeal of earlier municipal statutes.
  • Whether the petitioner may withdraw the writ petition and avail the remedy of appeal under those Rules.
  • Whether a delay in filing the appeal can be condoned.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • municipal law
  • service rules
  • appeal
  • writ petition
  • withdrawal
  • condonation of delay
  • Bihar Municipal Act

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.13280 of 2025
     ======================================================
     Abha Kumari Wife of Anmol kumar at present Posted as Assistant Gaya
     Nagar Nigam, R/o-village-mokama, p.s- Mokama, Dist-patna, P.S. - Kotwali,
     District -Gaya.

                                                                    ... ... Petitioner/s
                                        Versus

1.   The State of Bihar through the Secretary Urban Development and Housing
     Department, Bihar, Patna.
2.   The District Magistrate, Gaya, P.S. and District Gaya.
3.   The Municipal Commissioner, Gaya Municipal Corporation, P.S. and
     District - Gaya.
4.   The Executive Officer, Gaya Municipal Corporation P.S. and District Gaya.

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s   :      Dr. Anjani Pd. Singh, Advocate
     For the Respondent/s   :      Mr. Shiv Kumar, AC to GA- 3
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DR. ANSHUMAN
     ORAL JUDGMENT
     Date : 23-06-2026


                  Heard learned counsel for the petitioner, learned

      counsel for the State and learned counsel for the Gaya

      Municipal Corporation.

                     2. Learned counsel for the petitioner, after some

      arguments, submits that the final order of punishment, though

      minor in nature, has been challenged before this Hon’ble Court.

                     3. Learned counsel for the Gaya Municipal

      Corporation raised a preliminary objection and submits that the

      service of the petitioner, who is an employee of the Gaya

      Municipal Corporation, is governed by the Municipal Officers
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           2/11




         and Servants (Appointments, Duties, Discipline and Appeal)

         Rules, wherein a provision for appeal is available.

                        4. After hearing the argument, it transpires to this

         Court that Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 (Bihar Act 11, 2007)

         (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Bihar Act, 2007) has been

         notified in the Bihar Gazette (Extra Ordinary) on 05.04.2007. It

         is clear that Organizational Structure of Municipality has been

         described in Chapter V of Sections 36 to 44 of the Bihar Act,

         2007. Subsequently, amendment has been made, which was

         notified on 31.03.2021, in Section 36 of Bihar Act, 2007 and

         thereafter Section 36 shall be read as follows:

                                        “36. Officers of Municipality.- (1)
                         Subject to the provisions of Section 41 and need for
                         ensuring maximum possible economy in municipal
                         administration, the Municipality shall have the
                         following posts of Officers namely-
                                        (a)       in    the    case   of   Municipal
                         Corporation,-
                                        (i) the Municipal Commissioner, an
                         Officer of Indian Administrative Service or Bihar
                         Administrative Service               [or non- Government
                         officers, Managers, Administrators or Engineers
                         who have experience/specialization in urban sector
                         management- Added by Bihar Act 2 of 2012, dated
                         23.1.2012],
                                        (ii)      the   Controller    of   Municipal
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           3/11




                         Finances       and        Accounts,         a    senior   Audit
                         Officer/Accounts Officer from Accountant General
                         Office or senior member of Bihar Finance Service
                         [or a member of Bihar Account Service- Added, by
                         Bihar Act 7 of 2011, dated 27.5.2011],                    [or a
                         Chartered       Accountant            under     the   Chartered
                         Accountants Act, 1949, or a Cost and Management
                         Accountant under the Cost and Works Accountants
                         Act, 1959.-Added by Bihar Act 2 of 2012, dated
                         23.1.2012]
                                        (iii) the Municipal Internal Auditor,
                                        (iv) the Chief Municipal Engineer,
                                        (v) the Municipal Architect and Town
                                            Planner,
                                        (vi) the Chief Municipal Health
                                               Officer,
                                        (vii) the Municipal Law Officer,
                                        (viii) the Municipal Secretary,
                                        (ix)       three       Additional      Municipal
                         Commissioners, preferably in the rank of A.D.M.
                         but not below the rank of S.D.M. of Bihar
                         Administrative Service, and
                                        (x) Such number of Joint Municipal
                         Commissioners                 or       Deputy         Municipal
                         Commissioners            or        Deputy     Chief   Municipal
                         Engineers as the Empowered Standing Committee
                         may, from time to time, determine, and
                                        (b) in the case of a Municipal Council
                                               or Nagar Panchayat,-
                                        (i) the Municipal Executive Officer,
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           4/11




                                        (ii) the Municipal Finance Officer,
                                        (iii) the Municipal Engineer,
                                        (iv) the Municipal Health Officer,
                                        (v) the Municipal Secretary, and
                                        (vi) such other officers as may be
                                            designated by the State Government
                                            in this behalf:
                                        (vii) The Municipal Internal Auditor-
                                              Ins. by ibid.
                                        Provided that the State Government
                         may reduce the number of posts of the officers as
                         aforesaid:
                                        Provided       further   that    the    State
                         Government may re-designate any of the posts of
                         the officers as aforesaid.
                                        [Provided further that the Government
                         may appoint a Non-Government person who has
                         experience/specialization         in    urban         sector
                         management and administration who can be a
                         qualified Manager/Administrator/Engineer on the
                         post of Municipal Executive Officer even in
                         Municipal Council and Nagar Panchayat.- Inserted
                         by Bihar Act 2 of 2012, dated 23.01.2012.]
                                        [Provided also that the Government
                         may by order to the Municipalities subtract, add,
                         change the number and structure of posts, abolish
                         a post or posts, determine and abolish cadres,
                         create new cadres, restructure their administrative
                         structure and establishment or can give any other
                         direction in this regard which shall be binding on
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           5/11




                         the Urban Local Bodies.-Inserted by Bihar Act 2 of
                         2012, dated 23.01.2012.]
                                        (2). Amendment of Section 36 of
                         Bihar Act 11, 2007.- (i) Sub-section (2) of Section
                         36 of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 shall be
                         substituted by following:-
                                                            "36 (2) Appointments of
                                         officers mentioned in sub-section (1)
                                         may be made either on a regular basis
                                         or on a contract basis for such term as
                                         the      State      Government      may     be
                                         prescribe."
                                                            (ii) Sub-section (3) of
                                         Section 36 of the Bihar Municipal Act,
                                         2007       shall       be    substituted    by
                                         following:-
                                                            "36 (3) Subject to the
                                         provisions of sub-section (2) officers
                                         mentioned in sub-section (1) and other
                                         employees of the Municipality, the
                                         method        of     appointment,     required
                                         qualification, conduct and discipline,
                                         control and other conditions of service
                                         shall be such as may be prescribed."
                                                            (iii) Sub-sections (4), (5),
                                         (6), (7), (8) and (9) of Section 36 of
                                         the Bihar Act, 2007 shall be deleted by
                                         the Bihar Municipal (Amendment) Act,
                                         2021 published in Bihar Gazette (Ex.
                                         Ord.) No.231, dated 31.03.2021.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           6/11




                        5. Section 488 of Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 is the

         repeal and savings clause which states as follows:

                                        “488. Repeal and Savings.-(1) With
                         effect from the date of coming into force of this Act,
                         the Bihar Municipal Act, 1922, Patna Municipal
                         Corporation          Act       1951,   Bihar     Municipal
                         Corporation          Act,      1978,    Bihar     Regional
                         Development Authority Act, 1981, Bihar Town
                         Planning & Improvement Trust Act, 1951, Bihar
                         Restrictions of Uses of Land Act, 1948, Bihar
                         Municipal Ordinance, 2007 shall stand repealed.
                                        (2)       Gram     Panchayats,    Panchayat
                         Samities and Zila Parishads, constituted under the
                         Bihar Panchyat Raj Act 2006, whose jurisdiction
                         extend over the Municipal Area shall not exercise
                         powers and functions as have been entrusted to the
                         Municipality under this Act.
                                        (3)       The      Regional     Development
                         Authorities set up under the Bihar Regional
                         Development Authority Act, 1981, the Improvement
                         Trust or Town Planning Authority set up under the
                         Bihar Town Planning and Improvement Trust, Act,
                         1951, Controlling Authority Constituted under the
                         Bihar Restriction of Uses of Land Act 1948, shall
                         cease to exist with effect from the date of this Act
                         comes into force.
                                        (4) Notwithstanding the provisions of
                         sub-section (1) : and sub-section (3)(a) Subject to
                         the scrutiny of the requirements of the Municipality
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           7/11




                         assessed by an officer or officers appointed by the
                         State Government, every such officer or other
                         employee       serving        with   various     authorities,
                         organisations set up under the Acts listed in sub-
                         section (1) and (3) of this Section, immediately
                         before the date of the commencement of this Act
                         and on and from such date shall be deemed to have
                         been transferred to and become an officer or other
                         employee of the Municipality-with such designation
                         as the Municipality may determine and may hold
                         office by the same tenure, at the same remuneration
                         and on the same terms and conditions of service as
                         he would have held if the Acts were not repealed,
                         and shall continue to do so unless and until such
                         tenure, remuneration and terms and conditions are
                         duly altered by the Municipality:
                                        Provided that any service rendered by
                         such an officer or other regular employees before
                         the repeal of the Act shall be deemed to be service
                         rendered under the Municipality:
                                        Provided further that the officer or
                         officers appointed by the State Government shall
                         screen and verify service record of each officer and
                         employee and only such officers and employees
                         shall be absorbed in the municipality which have
                         been appointed against duly sanctioned posts in
                         accordance with law by a Competent Authority.
                                        (b) Anything done or any action taken
                         (including      any      appointment,    Rule,     bye-laws,
                         Regulation made, granted or issued under various
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           8/11




                         Acts listed in sub-section (1) and (3) of this Section
                         shall, continue to be in force and be deemed to
                         have been done or taken under the provisions of
                         this Act unless it is superceded modified/altered by
                         any thing done or any action taken under this Act.
                                        (c) All debts, obligations and liabilities
                         incurred, all contracts entered into and all matters
                         and things engaged to be done by, with or for the
                         various authorities organisations set up under the
                         Acts listed in sub-section 3 of this Section shall be
                         deemed to have been incurred, entered into or
                         engaged to be done by, with or for the Municipality.
                                        (d)       All   properties   movable   and
                         immovable and all rights, title, and interest in any
                         property vested in the authorities organisations (set
                         up under the Acts) listed in sub-section (1) and (3)
                         of this Section shall vest in the Municipality and all
                         properties in possession of such organisations shall
                         be deemed to be due to the Municipality.
                                        (e) All suits, prosecution, and other
                         legal proceedings instituted or which might have
                         been instituted by, for, or against the said
                         authorities organisation listed in sub-section (1)
                         and (3) of this Section may be continued or
                         instituted by, for or against the Municipality.
                                        (f) All sums charged on any property
                         under various Acts listed in sub section (1) of this
                         Section or the Rules or Regulations framed there
                         under      shall continue to be charged on that
                         property and the charge shall enforceable by the
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                           9/11




                         Municipality.
                                        (g) From the date Act comes into
                         existence, Municipality will have same right as the
                         said various authorities, organisations had in lands
                         within the area notified under sub-section (1) and
                         (3) of the Act, which were previously held by the
                         said various authorities, organizations on lease
                         from the State Government for a certain period or
                         the possession of which has been delivered to the
                         aforesaid authority/organisations.
                                        (h) The Municipality shall continue to
                         enjoy the powers to realise the various sources of
                         income in terms of levies, fees, cess, etc.; otherwise
                         empowered to be realised by said various
                         authorities organisation         under their respective
                         Acts and Rules and Regulations framed thereunder
                         specified under sub-section (3) of this Section of
                         the Ac if the said authorities were still functioning
                         under their respective Statutes until the same are
                         amended by the Municipality from time to time.
                                        (5)       Notwithstanding    such   repeal,
                         anything done or any action taken in exercise of
                         any     power        conferred    by   or    under    the
                         Acts/Ordinance referred in sub-section (1) shall be
                         deemed to have been done or taken in exercise of
                         the powers conferred under this Act, as if this Act
                         were in force on the day on which such things or a
                         was done or taken.”
                        6. By Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 the Bihar
Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                          10/11




         Municipal Act, 1922 and others as mentioned in Section 488(1)

         of the Act has been repealed but according to Section 488(4)(b)

         of Bihar Municipal Act, 2007, anything done or any action taken

         including any appointment, Rule, bye-laws, regulation made,

         granted or issued under various acts listed in 488(1) and 488(3)

         shall continue to be in force and be deemed to have been done or

         taken under the provisions of this Act unless it is proceeded

         modified/altered by anything done or any action taken under this

         Act. Under Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act, 1922, Model Rules

         for appointments, duties, discipline and appeal for Officers and

         Servants of Municipality has been framed by virtue of Section

         42 (1)(a) of the Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act, 1922 (Act

         No.7 of 1922) the name of the said Rule is “Municipal Officers

         and Servants (Appointments, Duties, Discipline and Appeal)

         Rules is still in existence by virtue of provision under Section

         488(4)(b) of the Bihar Municipal Act, 2007.

                        7. The petitioner seeks permission to withdraw the

         present writ petition with liberty to avail the remedy of appeal

         under the said rule.

                        8. In the light of the discussions made above and

         request made by learned Counsel for the petitioner, this writ

         petition stands disposed off granting liberty to the petitioner to
             Patna High Court CWJC No.13280 of 2025 dt.23-06-2026
                                                       11/11




                      avail the remedy under the Municipal Officers and Servants

                      (Appointments, Duties, Discipline and Appeal) Rules already

                      continued in force by virtue of Section 488(4)(b) of Bihar

                      Municipal Act, 2007.

                                     9. It is made clear that if petitioner files appeal

                      within 90 days from today before the Appellate Authority

                      concerned, the Appellate Authority shall entertain the appeal.

                      Delay, if any, in filing the appeal is hereby directed to be

                      condoned.

                                     10. Accordingly, the present writ petition stands

                      dismissed as withdrawn with the aforesaid liberty.




                                                                    (Dr. Anshuman, J)
Mkr./Rakesh/-
AFR/NAFR                AFR
CAV DATE                NA
Uploading Date          01/07/2026
Transmission Date       NA


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.