Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Rakesh KumarversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The writ petition is dismissed as the certificate proceeding is not maintainable in the absence of a due and payable amount under a written agreement or law.

Summary

Rakesh Kumar filed a writ petition seeking certiorari to quash a certificate proceeding (Case No. 19 of 2015-16) initiated by the Certificate Officer, Vaishali, for recovery of Rs.8,45,256.33 under the Bihar & Orissa Public Demand Recovery Act, 1914. He challenged the notice, order, and a bailable warrant issued in the proceeding, arguing that the demand was based merely on an alleged defalcation and lacked a written agreement making it a public demand. The Court referred to the precedent of The Certificate Officer of Siwan Central Co‑operative Bank v. State of Bihar (2006) 2 PLJR 176, which held that a certificate proceeding cannot be sustained without a due and payable amount under an agreement or law. Applying that principle, the Court found the present certificate case untenable and dismissed the petition. The petition was therefore disposed of in accordance with the earlier judgment.

Issues considered

  • What is the maintainability of a certificate proceeding under the Bihar & Orissa Public Demand Recovery Act when the demand is based solely on an alleged defalcation without a written agreement?
  • Whether the writ petition seeking quashing of the certificate proceeding, notice, and orders should be dismissed.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • certificate proceeding
  • public demand recovery
  • certiorari
  • quashing
  • Bihar & Orissa Act
  • defalcation
  • writ petition
  • public demand

Judgment

          IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.13598 of 2017
     ======================================================
     Rakesh Kumar Son of Sri Banwari Prasad Resident of Village- Suzawalpur,
     Police Station- Saraiya, District- Muzaffarpur.

                                                            ... ... Petitioner/s
                                    Versus
1.   The State Of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Food and Consumer
     Protection Department, Patna
2.   The District Magistrate, Vaishali at Hajipur.
3.   The Certificate Office, Vaishali at Hajipur.

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s   :       M/s Bindyachal SIngh, Sr. Advocate
                                    Vipin Kumar Singh,
                                    Aakash SIngh, Advocate
     For the Respondent/s   :       Mr. Arvind Ujjwal-SC 4
     ======================================================
        CORAM: HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. G. ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY

                                 ORAL JUDGMENT
                                 Date : 02-07-2026

                    1. The petitioner has filed the instant

      application for the following reliefs:

                                         “i) For issuance of writ in the

                        nature      of     certiorari      or     any    other

                        appropriate writ for quashing the entire

                        proceeding of Certificate Case no. 19 of

                        2015-16,         pending      in    the     court   of

                        Certificate Officer, Hajipur at Vaishali

                        whereby Certificate proceeding has been

                        initiated     against        the    petitioner      for

                        recovery of Rs. 8,45,256.33/-.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13598 of 2017 dt.02-07-2026
                                             2/6




                                             ii) For issuance of writ in the

                          nature        of         certiorari     or   any       other

                          appropriate writ for quashing the notice

                          U/S 7 of Bihar & Orissa Act no.4, 1914

                          dated 15.04.2015 issued under signature

                          of Certificate Officer, Vaishali whereby a

                          demand of Rs. 8,45,256.33/- has of been

                          raised against the petitioner.

                                             iii) For issuance of writ in the

                          nature        of         certiorari     or   any       other

                          appropriate writ for quashing the order

                          dated 13.08.2015, passed in Certificate

                          Case no. 19 of 2015-16, by the Certificate

                          Officer,      Vaishali        at      Hajipur,   whereby

                          bailable warrant has been issued against

                          the petitioner for alleged recovery of Rs.

                          8,45,256.33/-.

                                             iv) For issuance of writ in the

                          nature        of         certiorari     or   any       other

                          appropriate writ for quashing                    the order

                          dated 12.12.2016, passed in Certificate

                          Case       No.       19      of    2015-16,       by    the

                          Certificate Officer, Vaishali at Hajipur,
Patna High Court CWJC No.13598 of 2017 dt.02-07-2026
                                           3/6




                          whereby         the      objection       filed    by    the

                          petitioner under Section 9 of the                      Bihar

                          and Orissa Public Demand Recovery Act,

                          1914 (hereinafter refer as 'Act' only) has

                          been rejected on the ground of limitation

                          as the objection of petitioner is time

                          barred, however the petitioner has raised

                          several                objections                including

                          maintainability of the certificate case as

                          well as demand.

                                            v) For issuance of any other

                          writ,     order        or    direction     which       your

                          Lordships may deem fit and proper in the

                          facts and circumstances of the case.”



                           2. At the very outset, Learned Senior

         counsel for the petitioner contended that since this

         matter is squarely covered under the order passed

         by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of The

         Certificate           Officer        of       Siwan       Central        Co-

         operative Bank -Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.

         reported in (2006) 2 PLJR 176,                        this writ petition

         may also be disposed of on the same terms and
Patna High Court CWJC No.13598 of 2017 dt.02-07-2026
                                           4/6




         conditions.

                           3.    In    The       Certificate         Officer   of

         Siwan Central Co-operative Bank (supra) their

         Lordships have held as follows:

                                         “6. It is noticed by us that the
                       action of the appellant for the recovery of
                       the alleged amount of defalcation under
                       the      provisions             of   the   Bihar   Public
                       Demands Recovery Act cannot be justified
                       in absence of any due and payable
                       amount to the Bank in terms of the
                       provision of the agreement or under the
                       provisions of the aforesaid Acts. The
                       observations made by the learned Single
                       Judge in latter part in paragraph 4 of the
                       impugned judgment are quite weighty and
                       cannot be dislodged in course of the
                       submissions before us.
                                         7.      A     certificate   proceeding
                       contemplated under law proceeded on the
                       premise that there is money due and
                       payable either in terms of the agreement
                       or contract or under the provisions of law.
                       Mere an allegation of the Bank with regard
                       to the defalcation by the employee in
                       course of the period of his service would
                       not tantamount “Ipso Facto” that the
                       amount due was legally payable to the
Patna High Court CWJC No.13598 of 2017 dt.02-07-2026
                                             5/6




                       Bank by the person against whom such
                       allegations are made. It is in this context,
                       there would not arise any question of
                       grant       of    a         certificate    and        resultant
                       recovery thereof under the provisions of
                       the said Acts.
                                         8.        This   Court    in     Murlidhar
                       Sohanlal v. State of Bihar, 1998 (3) Patna
                       Law Journal Reports 526, had an occasion
                       to deal with similar situation and upon
                       evaluation of the relevant provisions of
                       law and similar facts situation has held
                       that the Corporation, in the present case
                       Bank, can avail the remedy of certificate
                       proceeding treating it to be a public
                       demand provided the person liable to pay
                       the     same        has         agreed     by     a     written
                       instrument that it shall be recoverable as
                       a public demand. Apart from the fact that
                       there is no such agreement and there is
                       mere allegation of defalcation of the
                       aforesaid amount by the employee of the
                       Bank, the proposition of law enunciated in
                       the said judgment in the said case by this
                       Court, after examining and appreciating
                       the provision of Section 9 read with Item
                       No. 15 of Schedule I of Bihar and Orissa
                       Public      Demands             Recovery         Act,    1914,
                       would directly cover the facts of the
             Patna High Court CWJC No.13598 of 2017 dt.02-07-2026
                                                        6/6




                                     present case and, therefore, the appeal on
                                     hand is without any substance and merit
                                     and deserves to be dismissed at the
                                     threshold.
                                                      9.      Accordingly,   this   appeal
                                     shall stand dismissed with costs.”
                                        4. Having regard to the submissions

                      made by the parties, the present writ petition

                      stands disposed of in terms of the aforesaid

                      judgment passed in                   The Certificate Officer of

                      Siwan Central Co-operative Bank (supra).

                                        5. Interlocutory Application, if any, shall

                      stands disposed of.




                                         (G. Anupama Chakravarthy, J)
Spd/-
AFR/NAFR                NAFR
CAV DATE                NA
Uploading Date          02.07.2026
Transmission Date


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.