Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Mamta DeviversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The Court set aside the cancellation, appellate and revisional orders and restored the petitioner’s PDS licence.

Summary

Mamta Devi, operating a PDS shop in Buxar, had her licence cancelled on the ground that the shop was closed on the day of an inspection. The show‑cause notice issued on 13‑09‑2022 alleged only this single breach and did not mention any prior misconduct, yet the cancellation order of 17‑12‑2022 considered alleged earlier violations. The petitioner filed a statutory appeal and a revision, both of which were dismissed, and then moved this Court seeking a writ of certiorari on the basis that the orders were passed in violation of natural justice. The Court held that closing the shop for one day, while a breach, was not a grave violation warranting licence cancellation and that the authority could not rely on unrecorded prior conduct. Consequently, the Court set aside the cancellation, appellate and revisional orders, restored the licence, and directed the respondents to resume food‑grain supply within four weeks.

Issues considered

  • Whether the cancellation of a PDS licence for the petitioner’s shop being closed on a single day, without a proper hearing, violates the principles of natural justice.
  • Whether an authority may consider alleged prior misconduct not mentioned in the show‑cause notice when cancelling a licence.
  • Whether the petitioner has an alternative remedy under Rule 32(vii) of the Bihar Targeted Public Distribution System (Control) Order that bars the writ petition.
  • Whether a writ of certiorari is the appropriate remedy to quash the cancellation order.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • PDS licence
  • cancellation
  • natural justice
  • certiorari
  • administrative law
  • show‑cause notice
  • Bihar
  • food grain supply

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                               Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.14593 of 2025
                 ======================================================
                 Mamta Devi, Wife of Omkar Nath Prasad, Resident of Panchayat-, Bijhaura,
                 Village- Jamuaon P.S. - Itarhi, Block- Itarhi, District- Buxar.

                                                                        ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                 Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Food and Consumer
                 Protection Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           2.    The Divisional Commissioner, Patna.
           3.    The District Magistrate, Buxar.
           4.    The Sub Divisional Officer, Buxar.
           5.    The Block Supply Officer, Buxar.

                                                           ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s    :      Mr. N. K. Agrawal, Sr. Advocate with
                                                Mr. Kumar Rajdeep, Advocate.
                 For the Respondent/s    :      Mr. Government Pleader 14
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. ABHISHEK REDDY
                                    ORAL ORDER

4   11-05-2026                   Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

                                 2. The present Writ Petition has been filed for the

                   following reliefs:-

                                                        “For issuance of a writ in the
                                              nature of Certiorari for quashing the
                                              order dated 04.02.2025 passed in BTPDS
                                              Control Revision No. 355 of 2023 by the
                                              Divisional Commissioner, Patna which
                                              was filed against the order dated
                                              07.07.2023 in Supply appeal No. 05/2023
                                              passed by District Collector, Buxar
                                              which was filed against the order dated
                                              17.12.2022 passed by the Sub-Divisional
                                              Officer, Buxar by which PDS License No.
Patna High Court CWJC No.14593 of 2025(4) dt.11-05-2026
                                            2/6




                                09/2018 of the petitioner was cancelled
                                on the ground that the petitioner was
                                closed for one day during inspection are
                                liable to be set-aside as same have been
                                passed in violation of the principles of
                                Natural Justice, in as much as the
                                impugned orders have been passed
                                without considering the facts and
                                circumstances of the case.”
                      3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

          petitioner has drawn the attention of this Court to the show-

          cause notice issued by the Sub-Divisional Officer, Buxar dated

          13.09.2022 (Annexure-P/1). Learned counsel submits that the

          shop of the petitioner was closed on the day of inspection and

          besides the fact that the shop was closed on one day, there are

          no allegations against the petitioner. That the petitioner has filed

          her explanation on 22.10.2022 to the said show-cause notice

          vide (Annexure P/2). However, the authority without taking the

          same into consideration has passed the impugned order of

          cancellation dated 17.12.2022 (Annexure-P/3). Learned counsel

          has stated that the authority while passing the impugned order

          dated 17.12.2022 has taken into consideration the fact that on an

          earlier occasion also there were allegations against the

          petitioner. However, in the show-cause notice dated 13.09.2022

          there was no averment to that effect. Though the petitioner has

          preferred a statutory appeal and revision, both the appellate as
Patna High Court CWJC No.14593 of 2025(4) dt.11-05-2026
                                            3/6




          well as the revisional authority have not considered the matter in

          a proper perspective and dismissed the appeal vide order dated

          07.07.2023 and revision vide dated 04.02.2025 respectively

          (Annexures-P/4         & P/5). Learned counsel has relied on the

          judgment of this Hon’ble Court in CWJC No. 10213 of 2010

          dated 22.06.2012 in support of his case and also a judgment

          passed by this Court in CWJC No.                3493 of 2025 dated

          01.05.2025 (Annexure-P-7). Learned counsel, therefore, prayed

          this Hon’ble Court to set aside the impugned order and direct

          the authority to restore the PDS license of the petitioner.

                      4. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on behalf

          of the Respondent-State has vehemently opposed the very

          maintainability of the present writ petition. Learned counsel

          submits that the petitioner is having an alternate remedy of

          filing a representation before the secretary under Rule 32(vii) of

          the Bihar Targeted Public Distribution System (Control) Order.

          Learned counsel submits that though the show-cause notice does

          not contain the details of the previous shortfalls of the petitioner

          while conducting her business. The authority is well within its

          rights to take into consideration the previous conduct of the

          petitioner and the same has been taken into consideration while

          passing the impugned order of cancellation. Learned counsel
Patna High Court CWJC No.14593 of 2025(4) dt.11-05-2026
                                            4/6




          submits that all the authorities have found that the petitioner was

          negligent in conducting the business and the previous

          allegations were serious in nature and the same was taken into

          consideration while passing the impugned order. That all the

          orders are well reasoned orders and no interference is needed by

          this Court in the present writ petition. Learned counsel has,

          therefore, prayed this Hon’ble Court to dismiss the present writ

          petition.

                      5. Admittedly, as seen from the show-cause notice, the

          only allegation against the petitioner is that the petitioner’s shop

          was closed on the day of inspection. Except the said allegation,

          there is no other allegation made against the petitioner in the

          said show-cause notice. Further, it is to be noted that while

          issuing a show-cause notice, the authority should include all the

          allegations or shortcomings of the person in running of the PDS

          shop, however in this case, the authority has not alleged

          anything with regard to the previous conduct of the petitioner.

          The only allegation found in the show-cause notice against the

          petitioner was that the PDS shop was closed on the day of

          inspection, however, in the impugned order of cancellation, the

          authority has taken into consideration the previous conduct of

          the petitioner also which is not permissible under law.
Patna High Court CWJC No.14593 of 2025(4) dt.11-05-2026
                                            5/6




                      6. A Division Bench of this Hon’ble Court under

          similar circumstances in CWJC No. 10213 of 2010 dated

          22.06.2012 has held as under:-

                                            “We find that admittedly the
                                 petitioner did close the shop on the
                                 particular day. Though, the action of
                                 keeping the shop closed on one
                                 particular day was in breach of the terms
                                 and conditions of the licence and may not
                                 be justified, it was not such grave
                                 violation that would entail cancellation
                                 of licence.”
                      7. Having regard to the above, the impugned order

          passed by the revisional authority dated 04.02.2025, the

          appellate authority dated dated 07.07.2023 and the order of

          cancellation dated 17.12.2022 are all set aside. Further, it is to

          be noted that the license of the petitioner was cancelled in the

          year 2022 and this Court is of the opinion that the petitioner has

          already suffered enough for the lapse of closing the shop on one

          particular day without informing or taking prior permission of

          the authority.

                      8. Having regard to the same, the CWJC is allowed

          and the license of the petitioner is restored. The respondent-

          authorities are directed to resume the supply of the food-grains

          as expeditiously as possible preferable within a period of 4

          weeks from the date of the receipt of the copy of this order.
           Patna High Court CWJC No.14593 of 2025(4) dt.11-05-2026
                                                       6/6




                                 9. With the above directions, the present Writ Petition

                     is allowed to the extent indicated above.



                                                         (A. Abhishek Reddy, J)
shakir/-

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.