Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

M/s Jai Bhagwati MinesversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The Court set aside the penalty imposed under the vitiated inspection while affirming that the Commissioner’s powers under Rule 7(c) and Rule 68 are separate and distinct.

Summary

M/s Jai Bhagwati Mines was awarded a sand ghat in Gaya through an e‑auction by the Bihar State Mining Corporation Limited (BSMCL). After a penalty of Rs 19.35 crore was imposed for alleged illegal mining, the High Court quashed that penalty and directed a fresh inspection, leading to a reduced penalty of Rs 6.81 lakh, which the petitioner paid. The Mines Commissioner later initiated a suo‑motu revision under Rule 7(c) of the Bihar Minerals Rules, 2019, and imposed a fresh penalty of Rs 19.35 crore. The petitioner challenged the Commissioner’s jurisdiction, arguing that revision could only be filed under Rule 68 against an order of the Collector and that the inspection was conducted without his presence, violating natural justice. The Court held that the powers under Rule 7(c) and Rule 68 are distinct, but the penalty order was vitiated because the inspection breached natural‑justice principles. Consequently, the penalty was set aside and the matter remitted to the Commissioner for a fresh inspection in the petitioner’s presence.

Issues considered

  • The Mines Commissioner’s power to initiate a suo‑motu revision under Rule 7(c) against an order of the Mineral Development Officer.
  • Whether revision under Rule 68 is limited to orders of the Collector and thus precludes the Commissioner’s action.
  • The validity of the penalty order imposed on the basis of an inspection conducted without the petitioner’s presence.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • e‑auction
  • sand ghat
  • penalty
  • revision
  • Mines Commissioner
  • Rule 7(c)
  • Rule 68
  • natural justice
  • illegal mining
  • mineral concession

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                   Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.17509 of 2024
     ======================================================
     M/s Jai Bhagwati Mines a partnership firm having its office at 3F Siddarth
     Market, Lal Kothi Compound, Near Civil Lines, Gaya, through its authorised
     signatory, Sanjeeva Shyam Singh, aged about 59 years (male), son of
     Ghanshyam Prasad Singh, Resident of HIG 57, Chanakya Puri Colony, P.S.
     Rampur, District Gaya.
                                                                ... ... Petitioner
                                       Versus

1.   The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Mines and Geology
     Department, Government of Bihar, Vikas Bhawan, Bailey Road, Patna.
2.   The Principal Secretary cum Mines Commissioner, Mines and Geology
     Department, Government of Bihar, Vikas Bhawan, Bailey Road, Patna.
3.   The Director, Mines and Geology Department, Government of Bihar, Vikas
     Bhawan, Bailey Road, Patna.
4.   The District Magistrate, Gaya.
5.   The Mineral Development Officer, Gaya.
6.   Bihar State Mining Corporation Limited, Through its Managing Director,
     Room No. 164, Vikas Bhawan, (New Secretariate), Bailey Road, Patna
     800015.
7.    The Managing Director, Bihar State Mining Corporation Limited, Room No.
      164, Vikas Bhawan, (New Secretariate), Bailey Road, Patna 800015.
                                                              ... ... Respondents
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner         :         Mr. Suraj Samdarshi, Advocate
     For the State              :         Mr. Majid Mahboob Khan, A.C. to AAG-12
     For the B.S.M.C.L.         :         Mr. Ranjeet Kumar Pandey, Advocate
                                          Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Advocate
     For the Mines Department:            Mr. Naresh Dikshit, Spl. P.P.
                                          Ms. Shruti Singh, Advocate
                                          Mr. Utkarsh Pathak, Advocate
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP KUMAR
                         C.A.V. JUDGMENT
                                       Date : 12-03-2026

                      By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has

       prayed for the following reliefs:-

                          “i.       To issue an appropriate writ, order or
                                    direction in the nature of certiorari for
                                    quashing the notice contained in memo
                                    no.2772 dated 20.09.2024 intimating
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                            2/30




                                  the petitioner regarding Revision Case
                                  No. 01/2024 started before Respondent
                                  Mines Commissioner against the order
                                  contained in memo no.1784 dated
                                  21.05.2024 passed by the Mineral
                                  Development Officer, Gaya consequent
                                  to order dated 21.09.2023 passed by
                                  this Hon'ble Court in CWJC No.
                                  8436/2023.
                           ii.    This Hon'ble Court may adjudicate and
                                  hold that Revision Case No.01/2024 is
                                  fraught with arbitrariness, started in
                                  violation of the provisions of the Bihar
                                  Minerals (Concession, Prevention of
                                  Illegal     Mining,      Transportation       &
                                  Storage) Rules, 2019 and is therefore
                                  bad in the eyes of law.
                           iii.   This Hon'ble Court may adjudicate and
                                  hold that no revision could lie against
                                  the order of the Respondent Mineral
                                  Development Officer, Gaya which was
                                  passed in pursuance of the order dated
                                  21.09.2023 passed by this Hon'ble
                                  Court in CWJC No.8436/2023 that too
                                  after conducting a fresh enquiry.
                           iv.    This      Hon'ble      Court      may    further
                                  adjudicate       and       hold       that   the
                                  respondents       cannot       approbate     and
                                  reprobate at the same time.
                           v.     This      Hon'ble      Court      may    further
                                  adjudicate       and    hold      that    having
                                  accepted the payment of Rs.6,81,494/-as
                                  penalty      levied     by      the      Mineral
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           3/30




                                 Development Officer, Gaya that too
                                 without any protest, it did not lie with
                                 the Respondents to prefer revision
                                 against the order contained in memo no.
                                 1784 dated 21.05.2024 passed by the
                                 Respondent        Mineral   Development
                                 Officer, Gaya.
                           vi.   To award any other relief or reliefs for
                                 which the petitioner is found entitled in
                                 the facts and the circumstances of the
                                 case.”
                         2.      The       respondent-Bihar      State       Mining

         Corporation Limited (for short “BSMCL”) published a notice

         inviting e-auction for selection of sub-contractors for operation

         of sand ghats in the district of Gaya. The petitioner participated

         in the said tender process and being the highest bidder he was

         allotted Khijarsarai sand ghat after quoting Rs.77,71,363/- in

         the bidding process. Thereafter, a Letter of Intent was issued to

         the petitioner indicating the term of contract till 31.03.2022.

         The term of contract was extended from time to time and lastly,

         it was extended from 27.12.2022 till 31.03.2023. The

         respondent-Managing Director, BSMCL, vide letter dated

         06.03.2023 directed the petitioner to deposit a penalty of

         Rs.19,35,47,820/- for excavating the sand, outside the mining

         area and selling the same using the user-id of the sand ghat and

         thereafter the respondents also suspended the generation of e-
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           4/30




         transit challans.

                         3. The aforesaid letter dated 06.03.2023 is

         reproduced herein below:-




                         4.      After receiving the aforesaid letter, the

         petitioner submitted a representation dated 13.03.2023 to the

         respondent-Managing             Director,     BSMCL,   requesting   to
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           5/30




         reconsider the matter in view of the fact that no notice of any

         inspection was given to him and the inspection was conducted

         in his absence, but the Managing Director vide letter dated

         28.03.2023 once again directed the petitioner to deposit the

         penalty amount. The petitioner was not granted further

         extension for Khijarsarai sand ghat on account of the fact that

         he has not deposited the penalty amount and subsequent thereto,

         the respondents conducted a fresh auction and settled the said

         sand ghat in favour of another person vide letter dated

         10.05.2023.

                         5.      Being aggrieved with the action of the

         respondents, the petitioner preferred a writ petition being

         C.W.J.C. No.8436 of 2023 titled as ‘M/s Jai Bhagwati Mines

         vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.’ before this Court and a

         coordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment and order dated

         21.09.2023 had quashed the order of penalty. The relevant

         portion of the aforesaid order reads as under::-

                              “4. Learned counsel for the petitioner by
                                 elaborating his submissions further submits
                                 that neither any plant, machinery and tool
                                 installed by the petitioner have been seized
                                 from the mining area where the petitioner
                                 had allegedly carried out mining activity
                                 beyond     the   area   under   environmental
                                 clearance nor any vehicle of the petitioner
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           6/30




                                 has     been     intercepted   by    the   district
                                 administration on the ground of non-
                                 availability of transportation challan or
                                 stock of mineral illegally extracted from any
                                 mining site being transported by such
                                 vehicle. While concluding his submissions,
                                 he drew the attention of this Court on a
                                 judgment passed in the case of M/s Uma
                                 Associates vs. The State of Bihar and
                                 Others (CWJC No. 3400 of 2023) vide
                                 order dated 09.05.2023, wherein while
                                 adjudicating the similar issue, the Court has
                                 held as follows:-
                                       “8. On perusal of the said order, the
                                          Court does not find that either the
                                          inspection     by     the    so    called
                                          departmental team was carried out
                                          in presence of the petitioner, whether
                                          the copy of the inspection report was
                                          provided to the petitioner or that
                                          proper opportunity to show-cause
                                          was issued to the petitioner prior to
                                          passing the order of penalty. In view
                                          of these facts, in the opinion of the
                                          Court the order of penalty dated
                                          24.2.2023 issued under the signature
                                          of the Mineral Development Officer,
                                          Rohtas, Sasaram, is not sustainable
                                          and is hereby quashed, with liberty
                                          to the respondents that if so advised,
                                          they will be at liberty to proceed
                                          afresh in accordance with law.”
                                 xxxxx
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           7/30




                              6.   Having considered the aforesaid facts and
                                   circumstances and the settled position of
                                   law, this Court also feels it appropriate to
                                   dispose of the writ petition in terms of the
                                   order passed by the learned coordinate
                                   Bench of this Court in the case of Uma
                                   Associates (supra) and accordingly in
                                   consequence thereof, the impugned order of
                                   penalty as contained in letter no.400 dated
                                   06.03.2023     by   respondent   no.7,   the
                                   Managing Director, Bihar State Mining
                                   Corporation Limited, Patna, is hereby
                                   quashed and cancelled with a liberty to the
                                   respondents that if so advised, they will be
                                   at liberty to proceed afresh in accordance
                                   with law.”

                         6.        In pursuance of the order of this Court, a

         fresh proceeding was initiated by the respondent-Mineral

         Development Officer, Gaya, who had directed the Mines

         Inspector to conduct a fresh inspection of the sand ghat. After

         inspection, the Mines Inspector submitted his report and based

         upon the said report, the penalty was revised to the tune of

         Rs.6,81,494/-. Thereafter, the petitioner deposited the said

         revised penalty amount and the Mineral Development Officer,

         Gaya also informed this fact to the Managing Director, BSMCL

         vide his letter dated 25.05.2024. Subsequently, the petitioner

         received the impugned notice dated 20.09.2024 intimating him

         that a Revision Case No.01 of 2024 has been instituted and he
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           8/30




         was directed to appear on 04.10.2024.

                         7.      On 04.10.2024 the petitioner appeared

         before the Mines Commissioner and requested for providing a

         copy of the memo of revision, which was provided to him

         including the letter dated 13.09.2024, by which the Mineral

         Development          Officer,    Gaya         had   requested   the    Mines

         Commissioner to condone the delay in filing the revision.

         During the course of hearing, the Mines Commissioner vide

         order dated 12.11.2024 directed for conducting a fresh

         inspection by a team consisting of Assistant Director, Bhojpur,

         Mineral Development Officer, Patna and Mineral Development

         Officer, Gaya. After inspection, the inspecting team submitted

         its report vide letter dated 13.12.2024. Finally, vide order dated

         24.02.2025 the Mines Commissioner imposed a penalty of

         Rs.19,35,22,820/- upon the petitioner.

                         8.      Learned counsel for the petitioner has

         submitted that after receipt of the said notice dated 20.09.2024

         the petitioner made enquiry from the District Mining Officer

         and he came to know that the Mines Commissioner had suo

         motu instituted the Revision under Rule 68 of the Bihar

         Minerals       (Concession,        Prevention        of   Illegal     Mining,

         Transportation & Storage) Rules, 2019. He has further
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           9/30




         submitted that since the Mineral Development Officer, Gaya

         had passed the order in pursuance to the order dated 21.09.2023

         passed in C.W.J.C. No.8436 of 2024, by which respondents

         were granted liberty to proceed afresh, and in pursuance

         thereof, he had passed the order dated 21.09.2023, no revision

         should have been filed either by the Mineral Development

         Officer or suo motu by the respondent-Mines Commissioner.

                         9.      Learned counsel for the petitioner has

         further submitted that the action of the respondent Mines

         Commissioner in filing the revision suo motu against the order

         of the Mineral Development Officer amounts to approbation

         and re-probation at the same time. It is the submission of

         learned counsel for the petitioner that after having accepted the

         penalty of Rs.6,81,404/- imposed by the Mineral Development

         Officer, that too, without any protest, it did not lie with the

         respondents to start a revision proceeding against the order of

         penalty.

                         10.     It is the categorical submission of learned

         counsel for the petitioner that the incumbent Mineral

         Development Officer could not have been aggrieved by an

         order passed by his predecessor. It is submitted on behalf of the

         petitioner that mere change of officer will not permit the
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          10/30




         subsequent officer to question the order of his predecessor. It is

         submitted that successor on a post cannot be aggrieved by any

         order passed by his predecessor. Further, it has been submitted

         that a perusal of memo no.2685 dated 13.09.2024 and memo

         no.2694 dated 13.09.2024, it is evident that application for

         revision was filed by Mineral Development Officer under Rule

         68 of the 2019 Rules along with petition for condonation of

         delay. In order to overcome the issue of limitation and alternate

         remedy of appeal, the Mines Commissioner purportedly

         commenced suo motu proceeding under Rule 7(c) of the 2019

         Rules.

                         11.     It has been submitted on behalf of the

         petitioner that the Mines Commissioner could not have suo

         motu instituted a revision against the order of the Mineral

         Development Officer, since he can start a proceeding of

         revision on its own motion only against an order of a Collector

         and not against any order passed by any other sub-ordinate

         authority. Adverting to Rule 68 of 2019 Rules, it has been

         submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that the

         aforesaid Rule contemplates revision only against an order of a

         Collector. It does not contemplate revision against an order of

         any other mining officer. The intent of the Rule is evident from
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          11/30




         the words "and where any person aggrieved by any order

         passed by the collector under these rules files an application"

         appearing in the Rule. Further, the Mines Commissioner could

         also not have initiated the revision against the order of the

         Mineral Development Officer, Gaya since the same has been

         filed without exhausting the remedy of appeal under Rule 67

         (1). Even a perusal of the order passed by the Mines

         Commissioner dated 25.02.2025, it would reveal that it has

         been admitted that a revision proceeding under Rule 68 can be

         initiated only against an order of the Collector. However, the

         Mines Commissioner has opined that under Rule-7(c), he can

         initiate revision proceeding against any order passed by any

         authority, if the same is against the interest of revenue and

         environmental conditions. It has also been recorded that the

         instant proceeding was initiated upon coming to know about the

         order dated 21.05.2024 passed by Mineral Development

         Officer, Gaya and therefore, it is submitted that it does not lie

         with the respondents to suggest and argue that the instant

         proceeding has been initiated under Rule-7(c). The entire

         argument of the respondents revolving around Rule-7(c) is

         nothing but a convoluted attempt to surpass the impediment

         created by Rule 68 which stipulates that revision shall lie only
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          12/30




         against an order passed by the Collector. Moreover, insofar as

         Rule-7(c) of the 2019 Rules to commence the suo motu

         proceeding is concerned, it is submitted that the same only

         prescribes the powers of the Mines Commissioner to suo motu

         call for and examine the records of any proceeding conducted

         by any authority, officer or persons subordinate to him under

         the act and the rules. However, the manner and the procedure of

         exercising such power has been detailed under Rule 68 of the

         2019 Rules. The intent of the legislature is not to confer two

         separate powers of revision i.e. one under Rule 7(c) and the

         other under Rule 68. Therefore, the suo motu powers provided

         under Rule 7(c) have to be exercised as per Rule 68 and both

         are not independent of each other so as to lead to two different

         proceedings.

                         12.     It has next been submitted by learned

         counsel for the petitioner that the respondents in counter

         affidavit have admitted that the Mineral Development Officer,

         Gaya filed a petition before the Mines Commissioner. As

         illustrated above, the said petition was filed under Rule 68

         along with a petition for condonation of delay. However, the

         Mines Commissioner for reasons, best known to him,

         proceeded under Rule-7(c) of 2019 Rules. In fact, the delay
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          13/30




         seems to have been condoned without issuing any notice to the

         petitioner. Moreover, since it has been admitted in the order

         dated 25.02.2025 that a revision petition under Rule 68 is

         maintainable only against an order of the Collector, the only

         recourse available to the Mines Commissioner upon receipt of

         the said letter no.2685 dated 13.09.2024 was to dismiss the

         same and direct the concerned authority to avail the remedy of

         appeal under Rule 67. However, the Mines Commissioner went

         on to constitute a Committee to conduct fresh inspection and

         pass the order dated 25.02.2025 based upon the inspection

         report.

                         13.     It is further submitted that without any

         specific finding of irregularity in the memo no.1784 dated

         21.05.2024 issued by the then respondent Mineral Development

         Officer, Gaya, the respondent Mines Commissioner could not

         have saddled the petitioner with a penalty of Rs. 19,35,22,820/-

         only upon the consideration that the revised penalty, earlier

         levied upon the petitioner, was much less than the penalty

         proposed initially.

                         14.     It is the submission of learned counsel for

         the petitioner that the order of the respondent Mineral

         Development Officer was passed on 21.05.2024 and to the best
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          14/30




         knowledge of the petitioner, the instant revision has been

         initiated after lapse of more than three months. In this context,

         it is submitted that though no time limit has been prescribed

         under Rule 68 to start the revision proceeding on its own

         motion, however, when the statute does not prescribe the time

         limit for exercise of revisional power, it must be exercised

         within a reasonable time frame. The aforesaid proposition of

         law has been laid down in the case of B.S. Sheshagiri Setty vs

         State of Karnataka reported in (2016) 2 SCC 123. In the

         present case, the revision has been instituted after lapse of more

         than three months without any justification. Further, as per Rule

         68 (2), the respondents were duty bound to supply the reasons

         for starting the revision proceeding but, no such reasons have

         been supplied to the petitioner.

                         15.     It is the next submission of learned counsel

         for the petitioner that, it is settled proposition of law that

         revisional power is a discretionary power of a higher authority

         to examine the correctness, legality, or propriety of an order or

         decision of the subordinate authority, primarily focusing on

         jurisdictional errors or ensuring justice and fairness in the legal

         process. It is submitted that the records of the entire case do not

         allege any jurisdictional error or impropriety on the part of the
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          15/30




         Mineral Development Officer. The only ground raised is that

         revised penalty is much less than the original penalty and has

         caused loss of revenue to the State, which cannot be a ground

         for initiating the revisional jurisdiction. Moreover, the fallacy of

         the above argument lies in the underlying presumption of the

         respondent department that levy of penalty for illegal mining is

         a source of revenue. It is further submitted that neither penalty

         can be equated with State revenue nor penalty can be

         considered as a stream for generating revenue. Penalty under

         the 2019 Rule is imposed by the State as measure of

         compensation for causing environmental damage and also as a

         deterrent from causing further damage in the future. Lastly, it

         has been submitted that the entire proceeding before the Mines

         Commissioner is in gross violation of the 2019 Rules and

         therefore the same is fit to be quashed.

                         16.     The respondents, at the outset, has submitted

         that the present writ petition is not maintainable since this writ

         petition involves disputed questions of fact such as, competing

         inspection reports, discrepancies in penalty calculations,

         technical questions involving PMU reports, Google earth data

         and the factual assessment of mining activity carried out by the

         petitioner over the period of time. Therefore, these disputed
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          16/30




         questions of fact can only be adjudicated in statutory revisional

         jurisdiction and writ jurisdiction cannot be invoked for the

         same.

                         17.     Learned counsel for the respondents has

         submitted that in this case the petitioner has challenged the

         notice dated 20.09.2024, by which it has been informed to the

         petitioner that Revision Case No.01 of 2024 has been initiated

         before the Mines Commissioner under Rule-7(c) of the Rules,

         2019 and the petitioner was directed to appear. The impugned

         notice neither determines rights nor imposes any liability rather,

         it merely affords the petitioner an opportunity of hearing before

         the revisional authority. Further, it is a settled law that the writ

         petition does not lie against the show-cause notice unless the

         notice is without jurisdiction or patently illegal.

                         18.     In support of this submission, the learned

         counsel for the respondents has relied upon the decisions

         rendered in the case of Union of India vs. Kunisetty

         Satyanarayana reported as (2006) 12 SCC 28 and in the case of

         Special Director vs. Mohammed Ghulam Ghouse reported as

         (2004) 3 SCC 440 and has submitted that in the aforesaid

         decisions it has been held that the Courts should not interfere at

         the stage of show-cause notice unless the notice is wholly
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          17/30




         without jurisdiction.

                         19.     Adverting to Rule 7(c) of the Rules, 2019, it

         has been submitted by learned counsel for the respondents that

         the     aforesaid     provision       clearly   empowers   the   Mines

         Commissioner to assume suo motu jurisdiction and call for

         examining the records of any proceeding by any authority

         subordinate to him and pass such orders as he may deem fit or

         when the order of his subordinate is erroneous or prejudicial to

         revenue, mining rules or environmental clearance. It is,

         therefore, the submission of learned counsel for the respondents

         that the power of Mines Commissioner is supervisory,

         corrective and independent of powers under Rules 67 and 68.

                         20.     It is the categorical submission of learned

         counsel for the respondents that Rule-7(c) and Rule 68 of the

         Rules, 2019 are not tied together and the argument of the

         petitioner that they must always be read together is wholly

         incorrect. It is argued that Rule 68 is a special statutory revision

         against an order of the Collector and by contrast Rule-7(c) is

         much wider in scope since it is not restricted to the revisionary

         power exercisable only against the orders passed by the

         Collector but against any order passed by any subordinate

         officer including the Mines Development Officer. It has also
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          18/30




         been submitted that the contention of the petitioner that the

         scheme of the 2019 Rules, links Rule 7(c) with Rule 68 is also

         an incorrect proposition.

                         21.     It is next submitted by learned counsel for

         the respondents that suo motu jurisdiction of the Mines

         Commissioner can be triggered by an internal departmental

         communication and the request made by the Mineral

         Development Officer, Gaya vide letter dated 13.09.2024 is

         merely that trigger for exercise of this suo motu independent

         power of the Mines Commissioner. A mere reference from a

         subordinate authority does not convert the proceeding into an

         appeal under Rule 67 nor into a revision under Rule 68 of the

         2019 Rules.

                         22.     It is also submitted by learned counsel for

         the respondents that by the order dated 21.09.2023 passed in

         C.W.J.C. No.8436 of 2023 titled as ‘M/s Jai Bhagwati Mines

         vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.’ the coordinate Bench had

         merely quashed the earlier demand notice dated 06.03.2023 for

         violation of principles of natural justice and granted explicit

         liberty to the respondents to proceed afresh. In compliance

         thereto, fresh order dated 21.05.2024 was passed. It is therefore,

         the submission, that the aforesaid order dated 21.05.2024 was
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          19/30




         passed in exercise of statutory powers, upon remand, from this

         Court and therefore, it does not attain finality merely because

         the petitioner had deposited the penalty amount. Further, the

         aforesaid order dated 21.05.2024 is also not immune from

         revisional jurisdiction of the Mines Commissioner.

                         23.     Learned counsel for the respondents has

         categorically submitted that after the first inspection conducted

         in the month of February, 2023 a penalty of Rs.19,35,22,820/-

         was imposed upon the petitioner, however, upon remand from

         this Court, again a fresh inspection was carried out in the month

         of May, 2024 whereafter, a penalty of only Rs.6,81,494/- came

         to be imposed, which clearly shows that there is huge difference

         between the two penalty amounts, which raises serious doubt

         about the authenticity of both the penalties. Therefore, it is the

         submission of learned counsel for the respondents that it is the

         solemn duty of the Mines Commissioner to protect the public

         interest in exercise of his supervisory powers, which has been

         correctly exercised by the Mines Commissioner in the facts of

         the present case.

                         24.     Lastly, it has been submitted by learned

         counsel for the respondents that the petitioner was given due

         notice and informed about the suo motu case before the Mines
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                              20/30




         Commissioner and was invited to participate in order to defend

         his case, however, the petitioner chose to preempt the statutory

         proceeding by invoking the writ jurisdiction of this Court.

                         25.        I have considered the submissions of learned

         counsel for the parties and perused the materials on record.

                         26.        Considering the facts of this case, it would

         be apposite to refer to the Rule-7 and Rule 68 of the Bihar

         Minerals       (Concession,            Prevention        of     Illegal      Mining,

         Transportation and Storage) Rule, 2019.

                                    “CHAPTER-II
                                    Establishment and Control
                                    xxxx
                         7.    Powers         and     functions     of    the      Mines
                         Commissioner- The Mines Commissioner:-
                         (a)    Shall        exercise   over      all    control     and
                         superintendence over all Mining Officers in the
                         State;
                         (b) may require any Mineral Concession holder by
                         notice to produce or caused to be produced before
                         him such documents, accounts or other evidence
                         which may be deemed fit;
                         (c) may suo motto call for and examine the record
                         of any proceeding conducted by any authority,
                         officer or person subordinate to him under the Act
                         and these rules and if he considers that any order
                         passed therein is erroneous or is prejudicial to the
                         interest       of     revenue,     mining        rules      and
                         environmental conditions, pass such order as he
                         deems fit after giving the Mineral Concession
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          21/30




                         holder or the person concerned an opportunity of
                         being heard;
                         xxx”
                                         CHAPTER-XVI
                                         Appeals And Revision
                                 xxxxx
                         68. Revision–(1) The Mines Commissioner, at any
                         time for reason to be recorded in writing, may on
                         his own motion, and where any person aggrieved
                         by any order passed by the Collector under these
                         rules files an application within 60 days from the
                         date of communication of the order, and within 75
                         days from the date on which an application is
                         deemed to have been refused by the Collector, if no
                         communication is made of such refusal, shall start
                         a proceeding for revision of the order:
                                 Provided that an application for revision
                         may be entertained even after the time specified as
                         above if the applicant satisfies the Mines
                         Commissioner that he had sufficient cause for not
                         making the application within time.
                         (2) On receipt of the application and copies thereof
                         under sub-rule (1), the Commissioner shall send a
                         copy of the application, and where proceeding is
                         started by him on his own motion, under sub-rule
                         (1) he shall send notices of starting the proceeding
                         and reasons thereof to each of the parties
                         impleaded specifying a date on or before which he
                         may make representation, if any, against the
                         revision application.
                         (3) After considering the records referred to in
                         sub-rule (2) the Mines Commissioner may confirm,
                         modify or set aside the order or pass such other
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          22/30




                         order     in   relation       thereto   as   the   Mines
                         Commissioner may deem just and proper and his
                         order shall be final.
                         (4) Pending the final disposal of an application for
                         revision, the Mines Commissioner may, for
                         sufficient cause, stay the execution of the order
                         against which any revision application has been
                         made.”

                         27.      From a bare perusal of these two Rules, that

         is, the powers of the Mines Commissioner exercisable under

         Rule-7(c) and the revisional jurisdiction under Rule 68 of the

         Bihar Mineral Rules, 2019 clearly show that the powers are

         independent, separate and distinct.

                         28.      The Rule 7(c) is seated under Rule-7 which

         is clearly titled ‘Powers and functions of the Mines

         Commissioner’ which in turn is under Chapter-II titled

         ‘Establishment & Control’. The Mines Commissioner exercises

         overall control and superintendence over all Mining Officers of

         the State and is responsible for administration of these Rules of

         2019 at the State level. In contrast, the Rule-68 falls under

         Chapter- XVI titled ‘Appeals and Revision’ and the aforesaid

         Rule-68 itself is clearly titled ‘Revision’.

                         29.      Pertinently, from the reading of Rule 7(c), it

         is clear that the Mines Commissioner is duly empowered to call

         for and examine the records of any proceedings conducted by
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          23/30




         any authority, officer or person subordinate to him, if he

         considers that any order passed is erroneous or is prejudicial to

         the interest of revenue, Mining Rules and Environmental

         conditions and thereafter, pass such appropriate orders as he

         may deem fit after giving an opportunity of hearing.

                         30.     On the one hand, under Rule-7(c), is the

         institutional supervisory correctional jurisdiction, whereunder

         the Mines Commissioner can suo motu call for records in order

         to scrutinise or examine records of proceedings by any

         subordinate authority and, if an order is “erroneous” or

         “prejudicial” to specified public interest grounds viz. prejudicial

         to the interest of revenue, mining rules or environmental

         conditions, then he may pass an appropriate order, as he deems

         fit and proper, after affording an opportunity of hearing to the

         concerned concession holder or the person concerned. This is

         the source of superintending or supervisory powers of the

         Mines Commissioner to correct errors and protect public

         interest.

                         31.     While on the other hand, Rule-68, by

         contrast, is expressly labelled as “revision” and prescribes a

         somewhat more complete procedural code, i.e., it contemplates

         revision either on the own motion of the Mines Commissioner
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          24/30




         with reasons to be recorded, or on an application by the

         aggrieved person within specified limitation periods. It also

         contemplates notices, representations, and final revisional

         outcomes such as confirm, modify or set aside, with even

         interim protection pending final disposal. Therefore, Rule-68

         provides for the revisional adjudicatory jurisdiction of the

         Mines Commissioner which is distinct from the powers under

         Rule-7(c).

                         32.     The Rule-68 clearly mandates that, it is

         imperative that there must exist an order of the Collector,

         where-from the matter may travel to the Mines Commissioner

         either on his own motion or on an application by the aggrieved

         person. However, Rule 7(c) is much wider in its ambit for the

         Mines Commissioner to initiate suo motu proceeding against

         any order. The Mines Commissioner is empowered to call for

         any record from any proceedings under the Act or the Rules

         made thereunder and this power is exercisable exclusively suo

         motu by the Mines Commissioner. The restriction, as provided

         statutorily for exercise of the powers under rule 7(c) are two

         folds, first, that the order passed by a subordinate officer be

         erroneous or second, that the order passed be prejudicial to the

         interest of revenue, mining rules or environmental conditions.
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          25/30




                         33.     It is settled law that when two provisions

         appear to be conflicting, Courts must harmonize the

         interpretation so as to prevent any provision from being

         rendered redundant, nugatory or otiose. In the present case, it is

         abundantly clear that the powers of the Mines Commissioner

         under Rule-7(c) and Rule-68 are distinct and separate.

                         34.     While the powers under Rule-7(c) are

         supervisory or superintending in nature, execrable exclusively

         suo motu and can emanate from any proceeding from any

         subordinate officer. On the other hand, the powers under Rule-

         68 are revisional and adjudicatory simpliciter, wherein the

         orders passed by the Collector may be subjected to revisional

         scrutiny before the Mines Commissioner.

                         35.     Merely because Rule 68 also uses the words

         ‘may on his own motion’ it does not subsume the separate and

         distinct powers of the Mines Commissioner under Rule-7(c).

                         36.     From the reading of both these afore-quoted

         Rules, this Court is of the view that the contention of the

         petitioner that the powers of the Mines Commissioner under

         Rule 7(c) must always and mandatorily be read conjointly with

         the Revisional powers of the Mines Commissioner under Rule

         68 is not appealing to this Court. It is, therefore, inescapable
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           26/30




         that the provisions provides for two different streams of powers

         to the Mines Commissioner and such powers are distinct and

         separate, which can be triggered by way of an internal

         communication.

                         37.      In the present case, this Court has perused

         the order dated 24.02.2025 passed by the Mines Commissioner

         in Revision Case No.01 of 2024 which has been brought on

         record by the petitioner by way of a rejoinder to the counter

         affidavit. The relevant portion of the order of penalty dated

         24.02.2025 passed by the Mines Commissioner is reproduced

         herein-below:-

                                  “miLFkkfir vfHkys[kksa dks ns[kkA ekuuh; iVuk mPp
                         U;k;ky; }kjk 8436 @ 2023 esa fnukad 21-09-2023 dks ikfjr
                         vkns”k ls iwoZ ds ekax i= dks laosnd dks viuk i{k j[kus dk ekSdk
                         fn;s fcuk fuxZr djus ds vk/kkj ij [kkfjt fd;k x;k Fkk ,oa
                         fu;ekuqlkj dkjZOkkbZ dh Lora=rk nh x;h FkhA orZeku ekeys esa
                         [kfut fodkl inkf/kdkjh] x;k us fnukad 21-05-2024 ds vkns”k ls
                         lfefr }kjk iwoZ esa izfrosfnr voS/k [kuu ds fo:) vf/kjksfir n.M
                         dh jkf”k vR;ar de dj fn;kA Ik;kZoj.k laj{k.k ,oa jktLofgr esa
                         voS/k [kuu ds fo:) dBksj dkjZokbZ lqfuf”pr djus ds fy, fnukad
                         21-05-2024 ds vkns”k dh leh{kk vko”;d gSA fu;e&68 ds rgr
                         lekgRRkkZ }kjk ikfjr vkns”k ds ekeys esa iqujh{k.k izkjaHk dh tk
                         ldrh gSA ;g rF; lgh gS fdURkq fu;e&7 (x) ds rgr                    [kku
                         vk;qDr fdlh Hkh izkf/kdkj }kjk ikfjr xyr vkns”k vFkok jkTkLo]
                         [kku fu;ekoyh ds fgrksa rFkk Ik;kZoj.kh; “krksZa ds izfrdwy vkns”kksa ds
                         fy, Loizsj.; ls dk;Zokgh dk ijh{k.k dj lacaf/kr O;fDr dks lquokbZ
                         dk volj nsdj mi;qDr vkns”k ikfjr dj ldrs gSA orZeku [kfut
                         fodkl inkf/kdkjh }kjk lefiZr vkosnu ds lkFk fnukad 21-05-2024
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                           27/30




                         dks ikfjr vkns”k ds laKku esa vkrs gh ;g dk;Zokgh izkjaHk dh x;h
                         gS] ftlesa laosnd dks uksfVl fuxZr djus] tkWap esa mifLFkfr
                         lqfuf”pr djus ,oa tkWap izfrosnu ij viuk i{k j[kus dk iw.kZ ekSdk
                         nsus ds i”pkr ;g vkns”k ikfjr fd;k tk jgk gSA blfy, laosnd
                         dh iqujh{k.k dk;Zokgh ds oS/krk ds laca/k esa pqukSrh Lohdkj ;ksX; ugha
                         gSA fu;e&7 (x) ds rgr dk;Zokgh izkjaHk djus ds fy, dksbZ le;
                         lhek ugha gSA oSls Hkh orZeku dk;Zokgh lafLFkr djus gsrq Ik;kZIRk
                         vk/kkj gS] ftldk mYYks[k vkns”k ds izkjaHk esa gh fd;k x;k gSA bl
                         U;k;ky; }kjk xfBr lfefr us laosnd dh mifLFkfr esa vk/kqfud
                         rduhd ds vk/kkj ij tkWap dj izfrosnu lefiZr fd;k gS ,oa blij
                         viuk i{k j[kus gsrq laosnd dks ekSdk fn;k x;k gSA fcgkj [kfut
                         (lekuqnku] voS/k [kuu] ifjogu ,oa HkaMkj.k fuokj.k) fu;ekoyh]
                         2019 ds fu;e 46 (6) ds rgr ys[kk@ fjVuZ ;k vU; lk{; ds
                         vfrfjDr vk/kqfud izkS|ksfxdh ;k v|Rku jhfr dk iz;ksx dj [kuu
                         dh ek=k dks fofuf”pr fd;k tk ldrk gSA blfy, laosnd dk ;g
                         dFku fd Google Earth Software ij vk/kkfjr n.M yxkus dk
                         dksbZ izko/kku ugha gS] vk/kkjghu gSA blds vfrfjDr lfefr }kjk
                         fu/kkZfjr {ks= ls ckgj izfrosfnr voS/k [kuu ds laca/k esa laosnd }kjk
                         dksbZ rF; ugha j[kk x;k gS] ftlls Li’V gksrk gS fd lfefr }kjk
                         izfrosfnr voS/k [kuu dks og Lohdkj dj jgs gSaA fcgkj [kfut
                         (lekuqnku] voS/k [kuu] ifjogu ,oa HkaMkj.k fuokj.k) fu;ekoyh]
                         2019 dk fu;e&11(1)fuEu izdkj gS%&
                                   ‘‘11 (1) &dksbZ O;fDr fdlh {ks= esa] [kuu lafØ;k, bl
                                 fu;ekoyh ds v/khu vuqnRRk] ;Fkk fLFkfr] vuqKfIr ;k
                                 [kuu iV~Vsa ds v/khu rFkk mlds fuca/kuksa vkSj “krksZa ds
                                 vuqlkj djsxk] vFkok ugha’’

                         fcgkj [kfut (lekuqnku] voS/k [kuu] ifjogu ,oa HkaMkj.k fuokj.k)
                         (la”kks/ku) fu;ekoyh] 2021 dk fu;e&56 (1) fuEu izdkj gS%&

                                 ‘‘56(1)&dksbZ O;fDr fdlh {ks= esa] mR[kuu ;k fudklh ;k
                                 [kuu lafØ;k,a bl fu;ekoyh ds v/khu lekuqnku] ;k
                                 vuqKfIRk ;k vU; fdlh vuqefr ds fcuk ;k ifjogu ;k
                                 Hk.Mkj.k ;k ifjogu dk dkj.k ;k fdlh [kfut dk
                                 Hk.Mkj.k fcuk oS/k pkyku ;k vuqKfIr ds ugha djsxkA’’
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                            28/30




                         esllZ t; Hkxorh ekbUl dks fcgkj jkT; [kuu fuxe }kjk fuf”pr
                         {ks= ds fy, [kuu dh vuqefr nh x;h FkhA fu/kkZfjr {ks= ls ckgj
                         [kuu mijksDr fu;eksa dk mYya?ku gSA rRdkyhu [kfut fodkl
                         inkf/kdkjh] x;k }kjk fnukad 16-11-2023 dks ikfjr vkns”k fcuk
                         rduhdh leh{kk ds ikfjr fd;k x;k gS] tks [kkfjt djus ;ksX; gSA
                         fnukad 05-11-2024 dks funs”kd] [kku dh          v/;{krk esa xfBr
                         lfefr }kjk fu;e&46 (6) ds rgr vuqekU; vk/kqfud@             v|ru
                         rduhd dk mi;ksx djrs gq, fnukad 13-12-2024 dks lefiZr
                         izfrosnu dh dafMdk &1 esa f[ktjljk; ckyw?kkV esa laosnd dks [kuu
                         ds fy, vuqekU; vof/k esa dksbZ [kuu dk lk{; ugha ik;k x;k]
                         tcfd laosnd }kjk mDr vof/k esa 72]855-65 MT dk pkyku fuxZr
                         fd;k x;k gSA blls Li’V gS fd laosnd }kjk Ik;kZoj.kh Lohd`r {ks=
                         ls fdlh brj fdlh vU; LFkku ls] tks muds i{k esa Lohd`r ugha Fkk]
                         ls 72]855-65 MT ckyw dk voS/k [kuu fd;k x;k gSA

                                 vr% laosnd }kjk fnukad &29-10-2024 ,oa 18-02-2025 dks
                         lefiZr fyf[kr vfHkdFku rF; ls ijs gksus ds dkj.k [kkfjt fd;k
                         tkrk gS ,oa lfefr }kjk fnuakd 13-12-2024 dks lefiZr tkWaPk
                         izfrosnu ls lger gksrs gq, fcgkj [kfut (lekuqnku] voS/k [kuu]
                         ifjogu ,oa HkaMkj.k fuokj.k) fu;ekoyh] 2019 ds fu;e&7 (x) esa
                         iznRRk “kfDr;ksa dk iz;ksx djrs gq, laosnd esllZ t; Hkxorh ekbUl
                         ds fo:) Ik;kZoj.kh; Lohd`fr esa fu/kkZfjr {ks= ls ckgj voS/k [kuu
                         ds fy, : 19]35]22]820@& (mUUkhl djksM iSarhl yk[k ckbZLk gtkj
                         vkB lkS chl) dk n.M vf/kjksfir fd;k tkrk gSA fu/kkZfjr vof/k esa
                         jkf”k tek ugha djus dh fLFkfr esa jkf”k dh olwyh gsrq fu;ekuqlkj
                         vxzsrj dkjZokbZ dk vkns”k lekgRrkZ] x;k dks fn;k tkrk gSA


                         ys[kkfir ,oa la”kksf/kr
                              g0@&                                          g0@&
                         (ueZns”oj yky)                                 (ueZns”oj yky)
                         [kku vk;qDr] fcgkj                          [kku vk;qDr] fcgkj”

                         38.      The Mines Commissioner in the aforesaid

         order has drawn strength from Rule-7(c) of the Rules, 2019 and

         the inspection report dated 13.12.2024 and thereafter imposed a
Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                          29/30




         penalty of Rs.19,35,22,820/- upon the petitioner. Therefore, in

         the opinion of this Court, the exercise of powers under Rule

         7(c) by the Mines Commissioner cannot be said to be suffering

         from any illegality or infirmity on the score of jurisdiction

         exercised by the Mines Commissioner.

                         39.     However, this Court has noted that the

         inspection report submitted by the Joint Committee constituted

         by the Mines Commissioner was the very basis on which the

         aforesaid penalty was imposed upon the petitioner. The

         inspection was carried out behind the back of the petitioner.

         Since the inspection, conducted by the Committee constituted

         by the Mines Commissioner, was conducted behind the back of

         the petitioner, the same stands vitiated for violation of

         principles of natural justice, and therefore, cannot form the

         basis for imposition of penalty upon the petitioner. Once the

         core itself is vitiated, the consequent order of penalty dated

         24.02.2025 can not be sustained to the extent that it is based on

         the inspection report dated 13.12.2024.

                         40.     In view of the above, the imposition of

         penalty upon the petitioner vide order dated 24.02.2025 is set

         aside. The matter is remitted to the Mines Commissioner to

         conduct a fresh inspection, in presence of the petitioner, and
             Patna High Court CWJC No.17509 of 2024 dt.12-03-2026
                                                       30/30




                      after affording a reasonable opportunity of hearing to him, the

                      Mines Commissioner may pass an appropriate order in

                      accordance with law.

                                      41.     With      the     aforesaid    observations   and

                      directions, this writ petition is allowed to the above extent.



                                                                    (Sandeep Kumar, J)


pawan/-
AFR/NAFR                N.A.F.R.
CAV DATE                22.12.2025
Uploading Date          12.03.2026
Transmission Date


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.