Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Binoy Krishna Jha and OrsversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISMISSED

Holding

The court held that the petitioners are not entitled to pension benefits as they did not complete the statutory ten years of service and no provision for notional service was contained in their appointment letters.

Summary

The petitioners, former Census Department employees retrenched in the 1980s, were eventually appointed as Lower Division Clerks on 31‑12‑2002 after prolonged delays. They argued that because of the delay they could not complete the ten‑year qualifying service required under the Bihar Pension Rules for a minimum pension, and sought notional credit of service from an earlier date when similarly situated employees were appointed. The State contended that the petitioners retired without the requisite ten years and that no provision in their appointment letters allowed retroactive service credit. The Court examined the factual timeline, the absence of any clause granting notional service in the appointment orders, and distinguished prior judgments that involved explicit retroactive service provisions. Concluding that the petitioners did not satisfy the statutory ten‑year requirement and no express provision existed to count prior service, the Court dismissed the writ petition.

Issues considered

  • Whether delay in issuance of appointment letters by the respondents entitles the petitioners to notional credit of service for pension eligibility.
  • Whether the Bihar Pension Rules permit counting of prior service not reflected in the appointment order.
  • Whether precedents granting notional service benefits are applicable to the present facts.
  • Whether the respondents are obligated to treat the petitioners as employees entitled to minimum pension under the Bihar Pension Rules.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • pension
  • minimum service
  • retrenched employees
  • notional service
  • Bihar Pension Rules
  • writ petition
  • civil service
  • delay
  • laches

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                   Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.20512 of 2013
     ======================================================
1.    Binoy Krishna Jha, Son Of Late Jai Krishna Jha Resident of Village And
      Post Kharahra, Police Station - Barahat, District - Banka
2.1. Smt. Meena Devi Wife of Late Dharnidhar Jha, Resident of Village -
     Dayalpur, P.O. Jhandapur, Police Station - Bihpur, District- Bhagalpur.
3.   Daya Nand Singh Son Of Late Adhik Lal Singh Resident Of Village -
     Dayalpur, Police Station Bihpur, District - Bhagalpur
4.   Ashwani Kumar Singh Son Of Late Yamuna Prasad Singh Resident Of
     Village - Sujal Korama, Police Station, Rajaun, District - Banka
                                                                  ... ... Petitioner/s
                                        Versus
1.   The State Of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of Revenue
     and Land Reforms, Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
2.   The Commissioner - Cum - Secretary, Department Of Revenue And Land
     Reforms, Govt. Of Bihar, Patna
3.   The Deputy Secretary, Department Of Revenue And Land Reforms, Govt.
     Of Bihar, Patna
4.   The Divisional Commissioner, Bhagalpur Division, Bhagalpur
5.   The Collector - Cum - District Magistrate, Bhagalpur

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s   :        Mr. Kundan Kumar Sinha
     For the Respondent/s   :        Mr. Manoj Kumar Singh, AC to SC-19
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RITESH KUMAR
     ORAL JUDGMENT
      Date : 22-06-2026
                 Heard the parties.

                 2. The present writ petition has been filed for the

     following reliefs:-

                                “A. The respondents be directed to treat these
                                    petitioners under the category of those
                                    employees who are entitled to the benefit of
                                    minimum pension under Bihar Pension Rules
                                    since all the petitioners, because of the delay
                                    in issuance of appointment letter/order could
                                    not be able to complete minimum 10 years of
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           2/11




                                        service as a Government employee under the
                                        jurisdiction of Bhagalpur Collectoriate.
                                  B.    And further be pleased to direct the
                                        respondents to calculate the pensionary
                                        benefits treating them notionally qualified the
                                        minimum 10 years of service as required
                                        under Bihar Pension Rules because all these
                                        petitioners have been the member of pension
                                        fund and there has been normal deduction of
                                        amount from the salary of these petitioners
                                        under the general provident fund head.”


                    3. The brief facts, which are essential for proper

       adjudication of the present writ petition are that the petitioners

       were employed in the Census Department under the Directorate of

       Census Operation, Bihar in the year 1981-82. Vide resolution of

       the State Government dated 05.05.1987, it was decided to absorb

       the retrenched employee of the Census Directorate in different

       departments of the State Government. Certain conditions were

       there for absorption of only those employees, who had completed

       a minimum of six months of service in the Census Department and

       the decision of the State Government was communicated to the

       head of all the Government Departments, including the Divisional

       Commissioner and the District Magistrate. Subsequently, vide

       memo no. 615 dated 05.05.1987, a list of district wise retrenched

       employees was sent to all the concerned districts with a direction
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           3/11




       to take decision on the absorption of the retrenched employees on

       priority basis. Since, no decision was being taken by the concerned

       authorities, with respect to appointment/absorption of the

       retrenched employees, some of the retrenched employees filed a

       writ petition before this Hon’ble Court. The writ petition was

       numbered as CWJC No. 4908 of 1988 and the same was disposed

       of vide order dated 21.07.1988, with a direction to the respondent

       authorities to fill up the vacant post as early as possible by issuing

       the appointment letters in favour of the retrenched employees of

       the Census Department. When the order was not being complied

       with by the State authorities, a contempt petition bearing MJC No.

       1197 of 1992 was filed by similarly situated persons and vide

       order dated 19.08.1993, a direction was issued to the State

       Government to treat all the retrenched employees on similar

       footing, to those persons, who have approached this Hon’ble Court

       by filing different writ petitions. The contempt petition was

       subsequently disposed of vide order dated 19.08.1993.

                    4. It is the case of the petitioners that vide memo no. 159

       dated 06.06.2000, the District Magistrate, Bhagalpur issued an

       order, whereby 25 retrenched employees of Census Department

       were appointed against the vacancies of Class III posts. The order

       of the appointment was issued in flagrant violation of seniority
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           4/11




       position of the retrenched employees and even though, the

       petitioners being senior to the persons, who were appointed vide

       order dated 06.06.2000, their cases were not considered.

       Subsequently, another list of retrenched employees was issued on

       24.03.2001, wherein the name of the petitioner no. 4 figures at

       serial no. 7 and some of the persons named therein were

       appointed, however the petitioner no. 4 was not appointed. Finally,

       vide order dated 31.12.2002, the District Magistrate, Bhagalpur

       issued appointment letter in favour of all the four petitioners and

       they were appointed as Lower Division Clerk in the Pay Scale of

       Rs. 3050-4590/-. Accordingly, the petitioners gave their respective

       joining, which was accepted w.e.f. the dates indicated in the order

       dated 13.02.2003.

                    5. It is further case of the petitioners that due to laches

       on the part of the respondent authorities, the petitioners could not

       complete the required ten years of service, for being eligible to the

       minimum pension, as per the provisions contained under Bihar

       Pension Rules and which also affected their respective Pay Scales.

       The persons, who were appointed earlier to the petitioners, were

       given the pay scale of Rs. 4000-6000/-. The details of the length of

       the service of the petitioners have been mentioned in paragraph no.

       16 of the writ petition, which is quoted hereinbelow:-
           Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                                      5/11




Date of Joining      Date of                  Total Service                 Shortage
                    Retirement
Petitioner no.1     31.08.2011         8 years 7 Months 21 days                  1-4-9
  10.01.2023
Petitioner no.2     31.08.2012         9Years 7 months 21 days                   0-4-9
 10.01.2023
Petitioner no.3     31.07.2011         8 years 6 months 23 days                  1-5-7
  08.01.2003
Petitioner no.4     31.01.2012               9 years 23 days                    0-11-07
 08.01.2003


                                   6. It is the case of the petitioners that if the petitioners

                  would have been appointed along with the persons, whose names

                  have been indicated in memo no. 159 dated 06.06.2000, they could

                  have also completed ten years of service, for being entitled for

                  grant of pension, in terms of the Bihar Pension Rules. The

                  petitioners, after their respective joining, kept on requesting the

                  respondent authorities to at least shift their date of appointment,

                  notionally from 06.06.2000, to entitle them to claim benefits of

                  pension and other pensionary benefits, however no decision was

                  taken by the respondent authorities.

                                   7. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that

                  the petitioners, being eligible, should have been appointed on

                  06.06.2000, when similarly situated employees/persons were given

                  appointment letter by the District Magistrate, Bhagalpur, however

                  due to latches on the part of the respondent authorities, the

                  petitioners were denied appointment and finally, they were
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           6/11




       appointed vide order dated 31.12.2010. She submits that on

       account of the delay caused by the respondent authorities in taking

       decision on the case of the petitioners, they have been denied the

       benefit of pension and pensionary benefits, since they have not

       completed the maximum ten years of continuous service, for being

       entitled for grant of pension, in terms of the provisions contained

       in Bihar Pension Rules. She submits that the case of the petitioners

       deserves sympathetic consideration in view of the fact that they

       were not at fault for non-issuance of the appointment letter in their

       favour and the same has to be attributed upon the respondent

       authorities, due to which the petitioners        have been forced to

       suffer.

                        8. The learned counsel for the petitioners relies upon

       a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in

       (2020) 12 SCC 131 (Parmeshwar Nanda & Ors. versus The State

       of Jharkhand through Chief Secretary & Ors). While referring to

       paragraph nos. 4, 16 and 23 of the aforementioned judgment, the

       learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioners are

       entitled for counting their respective services from the date, when

       similarly situated employees were appointed/absorbed for treating

       their respective service for grant of pension and pensionary

       benefits.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           7/11




                        9. The learned counsel for the petitioner further refers

       to and relies upon a judgment of the learned Single Judge dated

       08.01.2024 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 182 of 2022 (Ujjwal Kant

       versus the State of Bihar & Ors.), wherein the learned Single

       Judge, while considering the case of the petitioner therein for grant

       of notional benefits, for counting the services rendered by the

       petitioner therein, prior to his regularisation, for giving benefits of

       ACP/MACP, went on to record that the petitioner therein is

       entitled for grant of said benefit after considering his past services

       notionally.

                        10. The learned counsel for the petitioners further

       refers to and relies upon a judgment of the learned Coordinate

       Bench of this Court dated 24.10.2024 passed in C.W.J.C. No.

       1937 of 2019 (Mahendra Jha versus the State of Bihar & Ors.),

       wherein the learned Single Judge, while referring to the

       appointment letter issued in favour of the petitioner therein, has

       granted the benefit of counting his previous service, rendered,

       prior to regularisation, notionally for grant of benefits of ACP and

       MACP.

                        11. The learned counsel for the petitioners further

       refers to and relies upon a judgment of the Hon’ble Calcutta High

       Court dated 17.04.2025 passed in W.P.S.T. 210 of 2024 (Dr.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           8/11




       Satinath Samanta versus the State of West Bengal & Ors.),

       wherein the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court

       proceeded to allow the writ petition with a direction to the

       respondent authorities to count his past service as a qualifying

       service by adding the same in his service, till his superannuation

       for consideration of his claim for grant of pension and pensionary

       benefits.

                        12. Per contra, the learned counsel for the State

       opposes the prayer made by the petitioners and submits that the

       petitioners retired from service before completing the minimum

       ten years of qualifying service, for grant of pension and pensionary

       benefits. He submits that as per Rule 145 of the Bihar Pension

       Rules, persons who does not complete the service of ten years, is

       not entitled for the benefits of pension, since their full service

       length does not cover the minimum service length of ten years. He

       submits that there is no delay, attributable on the respondent

       authorities for making appointment of the petitioners, since the

       administrative decisions takes time and the same was dependent

       upon the vacancies available at the relevant time. The petitioners

       were duly appointed after following all the process available under

       law.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                           9/11




                        13. The learned counsel for the State further submits

       that in terms of the order passed by this Hon’ble Court in MJC No.

       1157 of 1992, the petitioners submitted their representations on

       05.02.2001 and 17.04.2001, for consideration of their cases for

       being appointed/absorbed and pursuant thereto, a decision was

       taken to appoint the petitioners on 31.12.2002, therefore there is

       no delay on the part of the respondent authorities in giving

       appointment to the petitioners and therefore, the petitioners are not

       entitled for the benefits, for which the present writ petition has

       been filed.

                         CONSIDERATION

                    14. Having heard the rival contentions and after going

       through the records, it appears that the petitioners were retrenched

       employees of the Census Department of the State of Bihar and

       pursuant to the directions given by this Hon’ble Court in C.W.J.C.

       No. 4908 of 1998 and MJC No. 1157 of 1992, the petitioners were

       appointed vide order dated 31.12.2002. They retired from their

       respective service, on completion of their age of superannuation,

       however they did not complete the minimum qualifying service of

       10 years, which is required under Bihar Pension Rules for giving

       the benefit of pension and pensionary benefits. It is not in dispute

       that the petitioners gave their applications before the respondent
Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                          10/11




       authorities, for consideration of their cases on 05.02.2001 and

       17.04.2001 and in terms thereof, the cases of the petitioners was

       considered and subsequently, appointment letter were issued in

       their favour on 31.12.2002. So far the judgment relied upon by the

       learned counsel for the petitioners are concerned, the same are not

       applicable in the facts of the present case, since in those cases, the

       petitioners therein were appointed after having rendered services

       either as a regular employee or as a temporary employee and in

       their appointment letter, it was written that the past services will be

       counted notionally for grant of service related benefits. In the

       present case, no such condition was there. So far the judgment

       relied upon by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

       petitioner of the Calcutta High Court is concerned, in the said case,

       the case of the petitioner therein was crystallized for being

       appointed on 22.02.2005 but the respondent authorities therein

       took 5 years in issuing the order of appointment and further, in the

       earlier round of litigation, he was given liberty to claim for

       retrospectivity and consequential benefits and further similarly

       situated employees were granted the same benefits, which was at

       par with the petitioner. Therefore, the judgments relied upon by the

       petitioners herein are not applicable in the facts and circumstances

       of the present case.
             Patna High Court CWJC No.20512 of 2013 dt.22-06-2026
                                                       11/11




                                      15. Considering the above-mentioned facts, this

                    Court does not find any reason to grant benefits to the petitioners,

                    in absence of any express provision in the appointment letter and

                    in the fact that even prior to their retrenchment, the petitioners had

                    worked for a very short period, as a casual/daily wage employee.

                                      16. Having considered the same, this Court does not

                    find any merit in the writ petition and the same is dismissed

                    accordingly.

                                      17. Pending application, if any, shall also stands

                    disposed of.




                                                  (Ritesh Kumar, J)
AjayMishra/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE                  NA
Uploading Date           24.06.2026
Transmission Date         NA


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.