Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Parmanand BhagatversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The order dismissing the arbitration case for alleged continuous absence of the petitioner is quashed as the order sheet does not substantiate the claim, and the matter is remanded for fresh hearing.

Summary

Petitioner Parmanand Bhagat filed a writ petition under Section 3(G)(5) of the National Highway Act, 1956, seeking mandamus to restore Arbitration Case No. 225 of 2023, which had been dismissed for alleged continuous absence. The High Court examined the order sheets and found inconsistencies, noting that the petitioner had appeared on several dates and that the arbitrator’s claim of default was unsupported. Consequently, the Court quashed the dismissal order dated 01.10.2024 and remanded the arbitration matter for a fresh, reasoned decision. The Court directed the petitioner to attend all future hearings and stipulated that the case be concluded within three months. The writ petition was disposed with these observations.

Issues considered

  • Whether the arbitrator/divisional commissioner correctly dismissed the arbitration case on the ground of the petitioner's alleged continuous absence.
  • Whether the order dated 01.10.2024 is valid in view of the inconsistencies in the order sheet.
  • Whether a writ of mandamus can be issued under Section 3(G)(5) of the National Highway Act to restore the arbitration proceedings.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • arbitration
  • default dismissal
  • mandamus
  • National Highway Act
  • order sheet
  • procedural fairness
  • land acquisition

Judgment

                     IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                                Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.2985 of 2026
                 ======================================================
                 Parmanand Bhagat Son of Late Raj Chand Bhagat, Resident of Village-Siswa,
                 Rajhat, P.S.-Banmankhi, District-Purnea.

                                                                       ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Revenue and Land
                 Reforms Dept. Bihar, Patna.
           2.    The Divisional Commissioner, Purnea cum Arbitrator (Appointed under
                 section 3(G) 5 N.H. Act, 1956).
           3.    The Collector, Purnea.
           4.    The Competent Authority cum District Land Acquisition Officer, Purnea.
           5.    Project Director National Highway Authority of India-1 (Project
                 Implementation Unit Purnea) Purnea Head Office, Sikandar Singh Ex-MLA,
                 Sahaban Hata, Janta Chowk, Purnea.

                                                           ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :        Mr. Sandeep Jha, Advocate
                 For the Respondent/s   :        Mr. Dhurjati Kr. Prasad, GP-14
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV ROY
                                       ORAL ORDER

4   30-06-2026                 Heard Mrs. Pratima Kumari, learned counsel for the

                   petitioner and Mr. Dhurjati Kumar Prasad, learned GP-14.

                               2. The present petition has been preferred for the

                   following relief(s):

                                               “for    issuance      of    an     appropriate

                                  writ/writs, order/orders, direction/directions in

                                  the       nature    of    Mandamus          directing   the

                                  Respondent no. 2 (The Divisional Commissioner,

                                  Purnea cum Arbitrator (Appointed under section

                                  3(G)5 N.H. Act, 1956) to restore the Arbitration
Patna High Court CWJC No.2985 of 2026(4) dt.30-06-2026
                                            2/6




                          Case No.225 of 2023 filed by the petitioner

                          before him U/Sec- 3(G)(5) of the N.Η. Act 1956

                          in No.37 dated 09/10/2023 issued by competent

                          authority cum DLA Officer Purnea passed in

                          Land Acquisition Case No. 10-30/2021-22, who

                          has twice dismissed the Restoration Petition of

                          the petitioner.

                                      Further the Respondent no.2 (The

                          Divisional Commissioner, Purnea cum Arbitrator

                          (Appointed under section 3(G)5 N.H. Act, 1956)

                          may be directed after restoration of the

                          Arbitration Case No.225 of 2023 be heard on its

                          merit and disposed of within a stipulated period

                          in accordance with law.

                                      And/or pass such other order or orders

                          as your Lordships may deem fit and proper.”

                      3. The matter relates to the award/compensation for

          the land the petitioner owned and aggrieved by the Award,

          preferred Arbitration Case No. 225 of 2023 (Parmanand

          Bhagat vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.) before the

          respondent no. 2, the Divisional Commissioner, Purnea-cum-

          Arbitrator. It came to be dismissed on 25.03.2025 and the
Patna High Court CWJC No.2985 of 2026(4) dt.30-06-2026
                                            3/6




          learned Divisional Commissioner, Purnea recorded that from

          27.08.2024, the petitioner has repeatedly absented himself

          and it seems that he has lost interest in the case.

                      4. Aggrieved, the present petition.

                      5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that

          contrary to the observation made in the order sheet, the

          petitioner was diligently appearing in the matter and further

          after 27.08.2024, when he failed to appear, the petitioner

          appeared on the next appointed date, 01.10.2024 but

          recording that he absented himself regularly, it was

          accordingly dismissed on 01.10.2024 itself.

                      6. This Court, in view of the contention of the

          petitioner that despite request, the complete order sheets were

          never provided by the respondents directed the State-

          respondents to file the entire order sheets alongwith the

          counter-affidavit.

                      7. Pursuant thereto, the counter affidavit containing

          the order sheet, has come. On perusal of the said order sheet,

          it would manifest that the case was adjourned on 05.03.2024

          when the petitioner was absent. It was taken up next on

          09.04.2024 when time petition was preferred by the petitioner

          and the matter was adjourned for 18.06.2024.
Patna High Court CWJC No.2985 of 2026(4) dt.30-06-2026
                                            4/6




                      8. The order dated 18.06.2024 clearly shows that

          though the petitioner was present, it was the Arbitrator who

          was attending the programme of the Hon’ble the Chief

          Minister of Bihar through video conferencing and as such, it

          was adjourned for 27.08.2024 when the petitioner was found

          absent.

                      9. The order dated 01.10.2024 clearly records that

          the petitioner is present whereafter in a different handwriting

          it has been recorded that the petitioner was absent. Thereafter,

          the word 'absent' has been struck off and now it reads that the

          petitioner was ‘absent on call’. This follows the order in

          english that: petitioner is continuously absent on several

          dates, it seems to be uninterested in his case, hence dismissed

          for default.

                      10. This Court fails to understand that when an

          order dated 01.10.2024 duly signed by the Arbitrator -cum-

          Divisional Commissioner, Purnea is on record what prompted

          him to record another order on 01.10.2024. Further, the

          handwriting of the entire order sheet vis a vis the order

          recorded on 01.10.2024 are quite different.

                      11. This Court has further taken note of the fact that

          the petitioner preferred a time petition on 09.04.2024. On the
Patna High Court CWJC No.2985 of 2026(4) dt.30-06-2026
                                            5/6




          next date, i.e. on 18.06.2024, when the petitioner was present,

          the Arbitrator was busy and as such, the matter was

          adjourned. Though on 27.08.2024, the petitioner was absent,

          on 01.10.2024, his presence has been recorded. Later, after

          recording that he failed to appear on call and has

          continuously absented himself, the petition was dismissed for

          default. In the opinion of this Court, the order sheet do not

          justify the observation made by the Arbitrator that the

          petitioner continuously absented himself.

                      12. In that background, the order dated 01.10.2024

          in Arbitration Case No. 225 of 2023 (Parmanand Bhagat vs.

          The State of Bihar & Ors.) passed by the respondent no. 2,

          the Arbitrator-cum the Divisional Commissioner, Purnea

          stands quashed and the matter is remanded back for deciding

          the matter afresh by a comprehensive and reasoned order.

                      13. The petitioner is directed to remain vigilant and

          present himself on each and every date so that the matter is

          taken to its logical conclusion at an earliest, preferably within

          a period of three months.

                      14. So far as the order sheet which has been

          provided      with      the    counter-affidavit   the   order   dated

          01.10.2024 recording the presence and absence of the
          Patna High Court CWJC No.2985 of 2026(4) dt.30-06-2026
                                                      6/6




                    petitioner creates doubt. The Divisional Commissioner,

                    Purnea is required to look into the matter and satisfy

                    himself/herself in this case.

                                15. The writ petition stands disposed of with the

                    aforesaid observation.



                                                  (Rajiv Roy, J)
Adnan/-

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.