Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Dr. Amrendra Kumar AmanversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The punishment orders dated 8 December 2016 and 2 May 2017 are set aside as they were passed without any evidence, violating natural justice.

Summary

Dr. Amrendra Kumar Aman, a District Malaria Officer, was punished in a departmental proceeding for alleged unauthorised absence, carelessness and non‑attendance at a meeting. An earlier punishment order of 2003 was quashed in 2010, with the department given liberty to conduct a fresh enquiry. A fresh enquiry under the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 2005 led to a punishment order on 8 December 2016 and a modified order on 2 May 2017, but the enquiry report showed that no witnesses were examined or documents produced. The petitioner contended that the orders violated principles of natural justice. The Patna High Court, relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank, held that an order passed without any evidence is unsustainable and set aside both punishment orders, directing the respondents to pay the petitioner’s salary and benefits within three months.

Issues considered

  • Whether a departmental punishment order passed without any evidence or witness testimony violates principles of natural justice.
  • Whether the fresh enquiry initiated after the earlier order was valid despite procedural deficiencies.
  • Whether the modified punishment order of 2 May 2017 can be sustained.
  • Whether the petitioner is entitled to salary and consequential benefits pending the quashing of the orders.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • departmental inquiry
  • natural justice
  • punishment order
  • quashing
  • salary benefits
  • Bihar health department
  • CCA Rules
  • evidence
  • writ petition

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                                Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.5734 of 2017
                 ======================================================
                 Dr. Amrendra Kumar Aman Son of Late Lal Chand Ram, Resident of Village-
                 Barawa, P.S.- Asaw, District- Siwan.

                                                                           ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                   Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar through the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           2.    The Principal Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           3.    The Joint Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.

                                                           ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :       Mr. Dinu Kumar, Advocate
                                                Mr. Vardaan Mangalam, Advocate
                                                Mrs. Ritika Rani, Advocate
                 For the Respondent/s   :       Mr. Rajeshwar Singh- GA10
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY
                                       ORAL ORDER

5   16-02-2026                   Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned

                   counsel for the respondents.

                                 2. The petitioner has filed the instant application for

                   the following relief(s):

                                            “A. For quashing the office order vide memo
                                 no.1307 (9) dated 8.12.2016 issued under the signature
                                 of under Secretary to the Government by the order of
                                 the Hon'ble Governor as contained in Annexure-17 by
                                 which petitioner has been punished in departmental
                                 proceeding as follows-(i) three increments have been
                                 withheld with cumulative effect and (ii) petitioner shall
                                 not be paid anything save and except the subsistence
                                 allowance for the period of suspension.
                                            B. Also for commanding the respondents to
                                 make payment of salary and other consequential
                                 benefits which has not been paid after punishment order
Patna High Court CWJC No.5734 of 2017(5) dt.16-02-2026
                                             2/5




                       passed on 8.12.2016 and earlier punishment order
                       passed on 4.7.2003 as contained in Annexure-5 to the
                       writ petition which was also affirmed by the appellate
                       authority on 1.12.2007 as contained in Annexure-7 to
                       the writ petition even after setting aside the punishment
                       order passed by the Hon'ble High Court Patna in
                       CWJC No.9283 of 2004 on 2.12.2010 as contained in
                       Annexure-12.
                                    C. And also for any other relief or reliefs for
                       which the petitioner is found entitled in the eye of law.
                                    D. For quashing the office order vide memo
                       no. 452 dated 02.05.2017 issued under the signature of
                       the Secretary to the Government Health Department,
                       Government of Bihar by the order of Governor Health
                       Department       by     which     punishment   order   dated
                       08.12.2016 as contained in Annexure-17 has been
                       amended to the extent punishment of censor has also
                       been included the besides to punishment which was also
                       corporate in the Annexure-17.
                                    E. Also for directing to the respondents to not
                       give order dated 02.05.2017 as contained in Annexure-
                       18.
                                    F. And also for necessary relief/reliefs
                       order/orders direction/directions in which the petitioner
                       is entitled in the eye of law.”
                      3. The case of the petitioner in brief is that the

          petitioner who was posted as the District Malaria Officer in

          Gaya was proceeded against in a departmental proceeding for

          his unauthorised absence from duty, carelessness and not

          participating in the monthly meeting. The proceeding ended in
Patna High Court CWJC No.5734 of 2017(5) dt.16-02-2026
                                            3/5




          an order of punishment being passed against the petitioner on

          4.7.2003 which the petitioner challenged by filing CWJC

          no.9283 of 2004. The writ application (CWJC no.9283 of 2004)

          was allowed by order dated 2.12.2010 quashing Annexure-5 and

          Annexure-11, orders impugned therein. The department was

          granted the liberty to initiate fresh proceedings from the stage of

          holding a fresh enquiry into the matter if it thinks fit and proper,

          keeping in mind that the occurrence took place in the year 1999

          and charges were framed in the year 2001.

                      4. It is submitted by learned counsel appearing for the

          petitioner that though liberty was granted to the respondents to

          proceed afresh from the stage of holding a fresh enquiry

          nevertheless the respondents came out with a resolution dated

          20.1.2012, proceeding afresh against the petitioner under the

          Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control and

          Appeal) Rules, 2005 (‘CCA Rules’ in short). A memo of charge

          which has been brought on record at page 70 was served on the

          petitioner, perusal of which would show that the charges related

          to the year 1999. The enquiry proceeded and the Conducting

          Officer submitted an enquiry report dated 30.6.2015, a copy of

          which was provided to the petitioner on 13.11.2015. The

          petitioner filed a reply to the same on which the respondents
Patna High Court CWJC No.5734 of 2017(5) dt.16-02-2026
                                            4/5




          came out with an order of punishment dated 8.12.2016.

          Subsequently, the respondents came out with a modified order

          of punishment dated 2.5.2017 imposing the punishment of (i)

          censure (ii) stoppage of three increments with non-cumulative

          effect and (iii) no other amount would be payable for the period

          of suspension except the subsistence allowance.

                      5. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner

          that a perusal of the enquiry report which is Annexure-15 to the

          writ application would show that not a single witness was

          examined on behalf of the respondents in support of the charges

          and consequently neither any document was exhibited nor

          proved in course of the proceedings, no witness having been

          examined. This fact of no witness having been examined

          besides being borne out from the contents of the enquiry report

          is not contested by learned counsel for the respondents.

                      6. Submissions have been made on behalf of the

          respondents on the merits of the case with prayer of dismissing

          the instant writ application.

                      7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and

          taking into consideration the submissions made on behalf of the

          petitioner specially no witness having been examined nor any

          document having been exhibited or proved in course of enquiry,
            Patna High Court CWJC No.5734 of 2017(5) dt.16-02-2026
                                                        5/5




                      the proceeding itself is in teeth of the judgment of the Hon’ble

                      Supreme Court in the case of Roop Singh Negi vs. Punjab

                      National Bank; (2009) 2 SCC 570.

                                  8. Consequently, the order of punishment passed on

                      such an enquiry report is not sustainable. Similarly the order

                      passed rejecting the appeal preferred by the petitioner is also fit

                      to be set aside on this ground alone.

                                  9.     Taking     into      consideration    the    facts   and

                      circumstances of the case, both the orders of punishment

                      contained in Memo no.1307(9) dated 8.2.2016 under the

                      signature     of    the     Under       Secretary,   Health    Department,

                      Government of Bihar as also the modified order of punishment

                      contained in Memo no.452(9) dated 2.5.2017 issued under the

                      signature     of    the     Under       Secretary,   Health    Department,

                      Government of Bihar are both set aside.

                                  10. The writ application is allowed with all

                      consequential benefits which shall be paid by the respondents

                      within a period of three months from the date of

                      receipt/production of a copy of this order.


                                                  (Partha Sarthy, J)
Saurabh/-
U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.