Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Rinky KumariversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The ex‑parte order is set aside pending determination by the Municipal Building Tribunal, and a stay of coercive steps is granted for three months from the Tribunal’s functional date or until a stay application is decided.

Summary

Rinky Kumari, widow of the deceased Ranjit Kumar, filed a writ petition challenging an ex‑parte order dated 14‑01‑2023 issued by the Municipal Commissioner, Patna, which directed demolition of her late husband’s building for alleged violation of Bihar Bye‑Laws. She contended that the order was passed without notice, violating the principle of audi alteram partem, and that it had never been properly served. The petition also sought to quash subsequent letters dated 18‑04‑2026 and 22‑04‑2026 and to obtain a stay of any coercive action. The High Court observed that the matter is pending before the Municipal Building Tribunal, which is currently non‑functional, and directed that the appeal (Misc. Appeal No. 8N of 2026) be decided by the Tribunal at the earliest. The Court further ordered that no coercive steps be taken against the petitioner for three months from the date the Tribunal becomes functional or until a stay application, if filed, is decided, and disposed of the writ petition.

Issues considered

  • Whether the ex‑parte order dated 14‑01‑2023 is violative of the audi alteram partem principle.
  • Whether the order and subsequent letters can be quashed by certiorari and mandamus.
  • Whether the petitioner is entitled to a stay of coercive action pending determination by the Municipal Building Tribunal.

Legislation cited

  • Bihar Bye‑Laws, 2014 (as amended 2022)
  • Bihar Municipal Act, 2007 — s. 323, 323(7)
  • Patna Municipal Corporation Tax and Non‑Tax Revenue Recovery Regulation, 2013

Subjects

  • writ jurisdiction
  • certiorari
  • mandamus
  • audi alteram partem
  • ex‑parte order
  • municipal law
  • stay of execution
  • building tribunal

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                               Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6782 of 2026
                 ======================================================
                 Rinky Kumari Wife of Late Ranjit Kumar, Resident of Kurji Bujurg Digha,
                 Sadaquat Asharam, P.O.- Sadaqat Ashram, P.S.- Digha, District- Patna, Bihar,
                 Pin Code- 800010.

                                                                            ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                   Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, the Department of Urban
                 Development and Housing, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           2.    The Principal Secretary, the Department of Urban Development and
                 Housing, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           3.    The Municipal Commissioner, Patna Municipal Corporation, Patna.
           4.    The Additional Municipal Commissioner, Patna Municipal Corporation,
                 Patna.
           5.    The Additional Town Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Patna.
           6.    The Vigilance Officer, Municipal Corporation, Patna.
           7.    Executive Engineer, New Capital Division (North), Patna Municipal
                 Corporation, Patna.
           8.    The Municipal Corporation, Patna through the Municipal Commissioner,
                 Patna Municipal Corporation.

                                                           ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :      Mr. Shekhar Singh, Sr. Advocate
                                               Mr. Siddharth Shankar Pandey, Advocate
                                               Mr. Sandeep Kumar Singh, Advocate
                                               Ms. Shambhavi Singh, Advocate
                 For the State          :      Mr. Gautam Kumar Yadav, AC to GP-26
                 For the PMC            :      Mr. Prasoon Sinha, Sr. Advocate
                                               Mr. Prabhat Kumar, Advocate
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY
                                       ORAL ORDER

4   08-05-2026                    Heard Mr. Shekhar Singh, learned Senior counsel for

                   the petitioner and Mr. Prasoon Sinha, learned Senior Counsel

                   for the Patna Municipal Corporation.

                                 2. The petitioner has filed the instant application for
Patna High Court CWJC No.6782 of 2026(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            2/6




          the following reliefs :-

                                         “That the Petitioner above named has
                             preferred instant writ application for the
                             issuance of appropriate writ/writs, order/orders,
                             direction/directions in the nature of certiorari to
                             quash the unlawful, illegal and not sustainable
                             ex-parte order dt. 14.01.2023 passed by the
                             Municipal Commissioner, Patna in a case
                             bearing Vigilance Case No. 248A/2015, which
                             has been passed in utmost and flagrant violation
                             of the well settled principles of audi alteram
                             Partem vide which the said authority was
                             pleased to illegally and wrongfully observe
                             therein that opposite party (the deceased
                             husband of the writ petitioner) had not obtained
                             no objection from the concerned Department and
                             also not get the map sanctioned for the
                             construction of the Building. Hence opposite
                             party was directed to remove the Construction
                             made in the violation of Bihar Bye Laws 2014
                             (as amended in the year 2022) within 30 days. It
                             was further observed therein that in case the
                             opposite party not complies the order within the
                             given time frame in that event the entire
                             unauthorized construction made by the Opposite
                             Party shall be considered as unauthorized and
                             accordingly may be removed by the Municipal
                             Corporation in terms of provision contained
                             under Section 323 of Bihar Municipal Act, 2007
                             and entire expenses of such removal shall be
                             recovered from the opposite party as per the
                             provisions contained in Section 323 (7) of Bihar
Patna High Court CWJC No.6782 of 2026(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                             3/6




                             Municipal Act, 2007 under the provision of
                             Patna Municipal Corporation Tax and Non Tax
                             Revenue      Recovery        Regulation,         2013.   The
                             aforesaid order dt. 14.01.2023 has never been
                             communicated to the Petitioner or served upon
                             the petitioner validly in accordance with law.
                             The Petitioner obtained the aforesaid order on
                             dt. 27.04.2026 after applying for the same on dt.
                             27.04.2026. The writ petitioner also prays for
                             issuance of appropriate writ/writs, order/orders,
                             direction /directions in the nature of mandamus
                             to stay the operation of the impugned order dt.
                             14.01.2023        passed        by       the      Municipal
                             Commissioner, Patna in a case bearing Vigilance
                             Case No. 248A/2015. The writ petitioner also
                             prays before this Hon'ble Court for the issuance
                             of     appropriate          writ/writs,         order/orders,
                             direction/directions in the nature of certiorari to
                             quash the Letter No. 6773 dt. 18.04.2026 vide
                             which     the     Vigilance          Officer,     Municipal
                             Corporation, Patna asked the deceased husband
                             of writ Petitioner to submit explanation within 3
                             days as to why proceeding of removal be not
                             initiated on account of non-submission of
                             compliance Report of the order dt. 14.01.2023
                             passed in Vigilance Case No. 248A/2015 in view
                             of the stipulation contained in Clause 8 of the
                             aforesaid order. Apart from that writ petitioner
                             also prays for issuance of the appropriate
                             writ/writs, order/orders, direction/directions in
                             the nature of mandamus to stay the operation of
                             Letter No. 6773 dt. 18.04.2026. Moreover the
Patna High Court CWJC No.6782 of 2026(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            4/6




                             writ petitioner also prays before this Hon'ble
                             court for the issuance of the appropriate
                             writ/writs order/orders, direction/directions in
                             the nature of certiorari to quash the order
                             contained in the Letter No. 7060 dt. 22.04.2026
                             vide which Team for the marking and removal of
                             unauthorized construction at Kurji Digha, Gate
                             No. 82 towards north of the Ganga Protection
                             Dam/Bandh was constituted/formed by the
                             Municipal Commissioner, Patna and said team
                             has been directed by the said authority to
                             conclude the process of the marking and removal
                             of unauthorized construction within time frame
                             of 5 days from dt. 24.04.2026. The writ petitioner
                             further prays before this Hon'ble Court for the
                             issuance      of     the    appropriate   writ/writs,
                             order/orders, direction/direction in the nature of
                             mandamus to stay the operation of the order
                             contained in Letter No. 7060 dt. 22.04.2026.”

                      3. The relevant facts in brief are that the Patna

          Municipal Corporation proceeded against the petitioner’s

          husband by filing Vigilance Case no.248A of 2015 (Patna

          Municipal Corporation vs. Ranjit Yadav) wherein order dated

          14.1.2023 (Annexure-P8) was passed by the Municipal

          Commissioner, Patna Municipal Corporation.

                      4. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner

          that the husband of the petitioner having died on 27.5.2023, the

          petitioner had no information/knowledge about the passing of
Patna High Court CWJC No.6782 of 2026(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            5/6




          the order in Vigilance Case no.248A of 2015 and having come

          to know about the same on the respondent Corporation taking

          steps in the matter, an appeal bearing Misc. Appeal no.8N of

          2026 (Rinky Kumari vs. Patna Municipal Corporation) has been

          filed by the petitioner before the Municipal Building Tribunal,

          Patna.

                      5. It is stated at the Bar that the Municipal Building

          Tribunal, Patna is not functional in view of the absence of the

          members.

                      6. Mr. Prasoon Sinha, learned Senior Counsel

          appearing for the Patna Municipal Corporation submits that the

          Tribunal is expected to become functional soon.

                      7. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case,

          the writ application is disposed of with the following

          observations and directions :-

                                   (i) The Misc. Appeal no.8N of 2026

                      (Rinky Kumari vs. Patna Municipal Corporation)

                      shall be decided by the Municipal Building

                      Tribunal, Patna at the earliest.

                                   (ii) The petitioner will be at liberty to

                      file an application for stay of coercive steps being

                      taken by the authorities of the Patna Municipal
           Patna High Court CWJC No.6782 of 2026(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                                       6/6




                                 Corporation pursuant to the order dated 14.1.2023

                                 passed in Vigilance Case no.248A of 2015 (Patna

                                 Municipal Corporation vs. Ranjit Yadav).

                                              (iii) No coercive steps shall be taken

                                 against the petitioner starting today for a period of

                                 three months after the Municipal Building

                                 Tribunal, Patna becomes functional or the petition

                                 for stay, if filed by the petitioner, is decided,

                                 whichever is later.



                                                (Partha Sarthy, J)
sauravkrsinha/-

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.