Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Dhirendra Narayan SinghversusThe Bihar State Power Holding Company Limited

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The orders dated 24‑June‑2014 (punishment) and 29‑January‑2021 (appeal rejection) are set aside as they were passed without considering the petitioner's reply and without recording reasons.

Summary

The petitioner, an unskilled labourer employed by South Bihar Power Distribution Company, challenged a disciplinary order dated 24 June 2014 that stopped one annual increment and withheld salary during suspension, alleging that his detailed reply to the second show‑cause notice was not considered. He also contested the rejection of his appeal by the Chairman‑cum‑Managing Director on 29 January 2021. The High Court examined the departmental proceedings, the applicability of Rule 19(1)(d) of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 2005, and the requirement of reasoned decisions under natural justice. Finding that the disciplinary authority failed to consider the petitioner’s reply and did not record any reasons, the Court held the punishment order unsustainable. Consequently, both the punishment order and the appeal‑rejection order were set aside and the matter remanded for fresh consideration within four months. The writ application was allowed.

Issues considered

  • Whether the disciplinary authority violated Rule 19(1)(d) of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 2005 by not considering the petitioner's reply.
  • Whether the order of punishment is invalid for being unreasoned and contrary to principles of natural justice.
  • Whether withholding salary during suspension for a minor punishment is permissible.
  • Whether the rejection of the petitioner's appeal by the Chairman‑cum‑Managing Director is legally valid.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • departmental proceedings
  • natural justice
  • reasoned order
  • disciplinary action
  • minor punishment
  • salary suspension
  • Bihar Government Servants Rules
  • procedural fairness

Judgment

          IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                       Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.752 of 2022

     ======================================================
     Dhirendra Narayan Singh Son of Late Laxmi Narayan Singh Resident of
     Quarter no.E/8, D.V.C. Colony (Electricity Board Colony) P.O.-Mayaganj
     P.S.-Bararij, District-Bhagalpur.


                                                                   ... ... Petitioner/s
                                         Versus


1.   The Bihar State Power Holding Company Limited through its Chairman
     Cum Chief Managing Director, Vidyut Bhavan, Bailey Road Patna.
2.   The Chairman Cum Managing Director, Bihar State Power Holding
     Company Limited, Vidyut Bhavan, Bailey Road Patna.
3.   The Managing Director, South Bihar Power Distribution Company Limited,
     Vidyut Bhavan, Bailey Road Patna.
4.   The General Manager (HR and Admin), South Bihar Power Distribution
     Company Limited, Vidyut Bhavan, Bailey Road Patna.
5.   The Deputy General Manager (HR and Admin), South Bihar Power
     Distribution Company Limited, Vidyut Bhavan, Bailey Road Patna.


                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s    :      Mr. Bajarangi Lal, Advocate
     For the Respondent/s    :      Mr. Vinay Kirti Singh, Sr. Advocate
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY


                             C.A.V. JUDGMENT


      Date : 30-06-2026

                    Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned

      counsel for the respondents.

                    2. The petitioner has filed the instant application

      praying for quashing the order dated 24.6.2014 (Annexure-6)
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           2/10




         passed under the signature of the Deputy General Manager (HR

         and Admin.), South Bihar Power Distribution Company Limited

         (respondent no.5) whereby the petitioner in a departmental

         proceeding was inflicted with the punishment of stoppage of

         one annual increment with the non-cumulative effect and it was

         further ordered that the petitioner would not be paid any amount

         for the period of suspension except the subsistence allowance

         already paid. The petitioner has also challenged the order dated

         29.1.2021 passed by the Chairman -cum- Managing Director,

         Bihar State Power Holding Company Limited (respondent no.2)

         whereby the appeal preferred by the petitioner was rejected.

                     3. The case of the petitioner in brief is that the

         petitioner who is an unskilled labourer was proceeded against in

         a departmental proceeding by serving a memo of charge on him

         on 7.2.2013. As per the charge, a copy of which has been

         brought on record as annexure to the writ application, the

         petitioner is said to have abused and of having used

         objectionable language against the Assistant Engineer and

         further of having threatened to kill him.

                     4. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner

         that the petitioner was proceeded under clause 29(B) of the

         modified Standing Order. The petitioner submitted his reply on
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           3/10




         which the Conducting Officer after conducting the enquiry

         submitted his enquiry report wherein he found the charges to

         have been proved.

                     5. The petitioner was served with a copy of the

         enquiry report to which he submitted his reply. Thereafter the

         respondents came out with the order of punishment dated

         24.6.2014 ordering for stoppage of one annual increment with

         non-cumulative effect. It was further ordered that the petitioner

         would not be paid any amount for the suspension besides the

         subsistence allowance already paid.

                     6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the

         appeal preferred by the petitioner was rejected by the

         respondent          Chairman-cum-Managing         Director      and

         communicated to him by letter dated 29.1.2021 (Annexure-10).

                     7. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner

         that from perusal of the order of punishment, it would transpire

         that the issues raised by him in his reply to the second show

         cause notice served on him have not been considered by the

         Disciplinary Authority, which is a clear case of violation of Rule

         19(1)(d) of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification,

         Control & Appeal) Rules, 2005, (‘CCA Rules’ in short). In

         support thereof, learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           4/10




         the contents of his reply and more specifically at pages 39 to 42.

         Further with respect to the punishment that the petitioner would

         not be paid any other amount for the period of suspension

         besides the subsistence allowance, it is submitted that as held by

         this Court in the case of Dr. Navin Kumar vs. The State of

         Bihar & Ors. (order dated 16.8.2022) passed in CWJC

         no.11234 of 2015, on the petitioner being inflicted with the

         minor punishment, his remaining salary for the period of

         suspension should not be withheld. Thus the order impugned be

         set aside and the writ application be allowed with all

         consequential benefits.

                     8. The application is opposed by learned counsel for

         the respondents. It is submitted that so far as the judgment in the

         case of Dr. Navin Kumar (supra) is concerned, it would

         transpire that the learned Court therein has relied upon Rule 13

         of the C.C.A. Rules, which deals with treatment of service on

         restatement and admissibility of pay and allowances where

         dismissal, removal and compulsory retirement is set aside by a

         Court of law. It is submitted that the facts of the instant case are

         distinguishable insofar as no such order has been set aside. It is

         further submitted that this Court in several judgments has also

         held that so far as infliction of minor penalty is concerned, even
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           5/10




         a full-fledged enquiry is not required. It is submitted that the

         conduct of the petitioner has been such as to not warrant any

         interference in the order of punishment impugned herein. There

         is no merit in the instant writ application and the same be

         dismissed.

                     9. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused

         the material on record.

                     10. The relevant facts in brief are that the petitioner

         was proceeded against in a departmental proceeding by serving

         upon him the memo of charge on 7.2.2013. He filed his reply to

         the same and the Conducting Officer proceeded with the

         enquiry. An enquiry report was submitted on 24.10.2013 finding

         the charges levelled against the petitioner to have been proved.

                     11. A copy of the enquiry report was provided to the

         petitioner and as directed, he filed his detailed reply on

         9.5.2014, a copy of which has been brought on record as

         Annexure-5 to the writ application. Thereafter the Disciplinary

         Authority proceeded to pass the order of punishment dated

         24.6.2014 ordering stoppage of one annual increment with non-

         cumulative effect and further that the petitioner would not be

         paid any amount for the period of suspension except the

         subsistence allowance already paid.
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           6/10




                     12. Relying upon the judgment in the case of Kranti

         Associates Private Limited and Another vs. Masood Ahmed

         Khan and others; (2010) 9 SCC 496, learned counsel for the

         petitioner submitted that the contentions raised by the petitioner

         in his reply to the second show cause notice and the enquiry

         report has been brushed aside without any consideration by the

         Disciplinary Authority in the order of punishment. The same be

         set aside on this ground alone.

                     13. Having perused the petitioner’s reply to the

         second show cause notice as contained in Annexure-5, this

         Court finds that besides the reply being detailed, substantial

         points have been raised therein by the petitioner which requires

         consideration by the respondents.

                     14. The respondent-Disciplinary Authority came out

         with the order of punishment dated 24.6.2014 stating therein

         that the petitioner’s reply to the second show cause notice and

         the evidence on record was considered by the competent officer

         who vacating the order of suspension has taken a decision to

         inflict the punishment on the petitioner, as stated therein.

                     15. Thus, this Court finds that there is absolutely no

         consideration of the petitioner’s reply to the second show cause

         notice in the order of punishment dated 24.6.2014.
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           7/10




                     16. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Kranti

         Associates Private Limited (supra) held as follows:

                                   “47. Summarising the above discussion, this
                      Court holds:
                                   (a) In India the judicial trend has always
                      been to record reasons, even in administrative
                      decisions, if such decisions affect anyone prejudicially.
                                   (b) A quasi-judicial authority must record
                      reasons in support of its conclusions.
                                   (c) Insistence on recording of reasons is
                      meant to serve the wider principle of justice that justice
                      must not only be done it must also appear to be done as
                      well.
                                   (d) Recording of reasons also operates as a
                      valid restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise of
                      judicial and quasi-judicial or even administrative
                      power.
                                   (e) Reasons reassure that discretion has been
                      exercised by the decision-maker on relevant grounds
                      and by disregarding extraneous considerations.
                                   (f) Reasons have virtually become as
                      indispensable a component of a decision-making
                      process as observing principles of natural justice by
                      judicial, quasi-judicial and even by administrative
                      bodies.
                                   (g) Reasons facilitate the process of judicial
                      review by superior courts.
                                   (h) The ongoing judicial trend in all
                      countries committed to rule of law and constitutional
                      governance is in favour of reasoned decisions based on
                      relevant facts. This is virtually the lifeblood of judicial
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                           8/10




                      decision-making justifying the principle that reason is
                      the soul of justice.
                                   (i) Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions
                      these days can be as different as the judges and
                      authorities who deliver them. All these decisions serve
                      one common purpose which is to demonstrate by reason
                      that the relevant factors have been objectively
                      considered. This is important for sustaining the
                      litigants' faith in the justice delivery system.
                                   (j) Insistence on reason is a requirement for
                      both judicial accountability and transparency.
                                   (k) If a judge or a quasi-judicial authority is
                      not candid enough about his/her decision-making
                      process then it is impossible to know whether the person
                      deciding is faithful to the doctrine of precedent or to
                      principles of incrementalism.
                                   (l) Reasons in support of decisions must be
                      cogent, clear and succinct. A pretence of reasons or
                      "rubber-stamp reasons" is not to be equated with a
                      valid decision-making process.
                                   (m) It cannot be doubted that transparency is
                      the sine qua non of restraint on abuse of judicial
                      powers. Transparency in decision-making not only
                      makes the judges and decision-makers less prone to
                      errors but also makes them subject to broader scrutiny.
                      (See David Shapiro in Defence of Judicial Candor)
                                   (n) Since the requirement to record reasons
                      emanates from the broad doctrine of fairness in
                      decision-making, the said requirement is now virtually a
                      component of human rights and was considered part of
                      Strasbourg Jurisprudence. See Ruiz Torija v. Spain 33
                      EHRR, at 562 para 29 and Anya v. University of Oxford
Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                            9/10




                      34, wherein the Court referred to Article 6 of the
                      European Convention of Human Rights which requires,
                      "adequate and intelligent reasons must be given for
                      judicial decisions".
                                   (0)    In   all    common    law   jurisdictions
                      judgments play a vital role in setting up precedents for
                      the    future.     Therefore,   for   development of    law,
                      requirement of giving reasons for the decision is of the
                      essence and is virtually a part of "due process".
                     17. In view of the facts and circumstances stated

         herein above, the order of punishment dated 24.6.2014 not

         having considered the reply of the petitioner and being

         absolutely devoid of any reason or ground for passing of the

         said order, in the opinion of the Court, is unsustainable.

                     18. As such, the order dated 24.6.2014 (Annexure-6)

         passed under the signature of the Deputy General Manager (HR

         and Admn.), South Bihar Power Distribution Company Limited

         (respondent no.5) as also the order dated 29.1.2021 passed by

         the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Bihar State Power

         Holding Company Limited (respondent no.2) rejecting the

         appeal preferred by the petitioner are both set aside.

                     19. The matter is remanded back to the respondent

         authorities to proceed against the petitioner from the stage the

         petitioner submitted his reply to the second show cause notice

         and to conclude the same within a period of four months from
             Patna High Court CWJC No.752 of 2022 dt.30-06-2026
                                                       10/10




                      the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order.

                                  20. The writ application stands allowed with the

                      above observations and directions.



                                                  (Partha Sarthy, J)

Saurabh/Shiv
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE                  15.05.2026
Uploading Date            30.06.2026
Transmission Date


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.