Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Phulendra Prasad RoyversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The Court held that the original disciplinary order and the appellate order are set aside due to bias and lack of merit, and the writ petition is allowed.

Summary

The petitioner, a Junior Engineer in the Bihar Rural Works Department, was exonerated by the conducting officer’s report in a disciplinary enquiry but was later issued a show‑cause notice and a punitive order reducing his pay under Rule‑14(vii) of the Government Servants (Classification, Control and Appeal) (Amendment) Rules, 2007. He appealed, but the appellate authority dismissed the appeal on the ground of limitation. The petitioner contended that the Engineer‑in‑Chief who conducted the enquiry also acted as the disciplinary authority, creating bias and violating natural justice, and that the penalty was unwarranted. The State argued there was no violation of law or natural justice. The High Court found that a person cannot be a judge in his own cause, held the original order and the appellate order biased and unsustainable, set both aside, and allowed the writ petition, directing the State to re‑issue a fresh show‑cause notice within three months.

Issues considered

  • Whether the Engineer‑in‑Chief acting as both enquiring officer and disciplinary authority violates the principles of natural justice and creates bias.
  • Whether the reduction in pay imposed under Rule‑14(vii) of the Government Servants (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 2007 is valid in view of the exoneration in the enquiry report.
  • Whether the appellate authority’s dismissal of the appeal on limitation grounds is maintainable.
  • Whether the original disciplinary order and the subsequent appellate order should be set aside.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • disciplinary proceedings
  • bias
  • natural justice
  • limitation period
  • government service rules
  • writ petition
  • reduction in pay
  • show‑cause notice

Judgment

                     IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                               Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.9345 of 2024
                 ======================================================
                 Phulendra Prasad Roy Son of Late Radha Roy, Resident of Poonam Mansion,
                 Cant Road, Mustafa, P.S.-Khagaul, District-Patna Pin Code 801105.
                                                                            .. ... Petitioner/s
                                                   Versus
           1.     The State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Rural Work Department,
                  Government of Bihar, Patna.
           2.    The Special Secretary, Rural Work Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           3.    The Engineer-in-Chief, Rural Work Department, Government of Bihar,
                 Patna.
           4.    Chief Engineer-4 Cum Conducting Officer, Rural Work Department,
                 Government of Bihar, Patna.
           5.    Special Work Officer, Rural Work Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           6.     Superintending Engineer, Rural Work Department, work Circle Nalanda..
                                                                        ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :       Mr. Raj Nandan Prasad, Adv.
                 For the Respondent/s   :       Mrs. Archana Meenakshee, GP6
                                                Mr. Rana Veer Prawar, AC to GP6
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DR. ANSHUMAN
                                       ORAL ORDER

2   12-02-2026                     Heard Learned Counsel for the petitioner and

                   Learned Counsel for the State.

                               2. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that the

                   present writ petition has been filed with the following reliefs:-

                                               “That this application is being filed for
                                  issuance of appropriate writ, order or orders, direction
                                  quashing the order dated 09.08.2021 passed by Special
                                  Secretary,   Rural   Works    Department,       Bihar,   Patna
                                  respondent no.2 issued under memo No. 1033 dated
                                  09.08.2021 whereby and where under appeal application
                                  dated 15.02.2021 filed by the petitioner has been rejected
                                  only on the ground of limitation in delay filing of appeal
                                  application. And also quashing the order dated 15.01.2020
                                  passed by Praween Kumar Thakur Engineer-in-Chief,
                                  Rural Work Department, respondent no.3 issued under
                                  memo no. 336, dated 16.01.2020, whereby, punishment of
Patna High Court CWJC No.9345 of 2024(2) dt.12-02-2026
                                            2/4




                          reduction in time Scale pay to three stages lower till
                          retirement and not giving increment during this period has
                          been imposed as a major penalty classified under Rule-
                          14(vii) of the Government Servants (Classification, Control
                          and Appeal) (Amendment) Rule 2007, although in the
                          enquiry report submitted by conducting officer, it has been
                          said that no any Charge has been proved against the
                          petitioner.”
                      3. Counsel for the petitioner further submits that the

          petitioner was a Junior Engineer in Rural Works Department,

          Government of Bihar and the Department had started inspection

          for his work. After five years of inspection, Prapatra- Ka has

          been issued against him and upon receiving charge-sheet, the

          petitioner had submitted his reply and appeared before the

          Conducting Officer, who vide report dated 25.06.2018 &

          27.06.2018, the petitioner has been exonerated from all the

          charges levelled against him. Thereafter, the matter was referred

          before the Disciplinary Authority, who upon differing from the

          report, issued show-cause against him.

                      4. Counsel further submits that the said show-cause

          has been issued in gross violation of Rules 18(2) and 18(3) of

          the Bihar CCA Rules, 2005. He further submits that the reply to

          the second show-cause has been filed upon receiving the same

          and final order of punishment has been imposed vide Memo

          No.336 dated 16.01.2020.
Patna High Court CWJC No.9345 of 2024(2) dt.12-02-2026
                                            3/4




                      5. Counsel further submits that he became very much

          surprised to see the final order that the then Conducting Officer,

          Mr. Praween Kumar Thakur, being an Executive Engineer had

          conducted the enquiry and subsequently, the same Praween

          Kumar Thakur, being the Engineer-in-Chief, had passed the

          final order against the petitioner. He further submits that the said

          discrepancies, he has challenged before the Appellate Authority,

          but the Appellate Authority had rejected the appeal on the

          ground that it has been filed beyond 45 days of limit.

                      6. Counsel for the State raised preliminary objection

          and submits that there is neither violation of natural justice nor

          violation of any provision of law under the Bihar CCA Rules,

          2005 nor punishment is exonerated. Therefore, there is no need

          of any interference in the said orders.

                      7. Upon hearing the parties, it transpires to this Court

          that the said Praween Kumar Thakur had conducted an enquiry

          against the present petitioner and submitted a report and

          subsequently, he has again tested the said report being the

          Disciplinary Authority by virtue of his promotion. As such, it is

          a case of bias in the opinion of the Court. A person cannot be a

          judge in his own cause. Here in the present case, this is apparent

          from the record, particularly, Annexure-6 and Annexure-10 of
          Patna High Court CWJC No.9345 of 2024(2) dt.12-02-2026
                                                      4/4




                    the writ petition. It is due to this reason mentioned above, the

                    present proceeding is bad in law and the order passed by the

                    Original Authority i.e., Memo No.336 dated 16.01.2010 passed

                    by Engineer-in-chief, Rural Work Department (annexure-10) is

                    hereby set aside and when annexure-10 is set aside then the

                    Appellate order i.e., vide memo No.1022 dated 09.08.2021

                    passed by Special Secretary, Rural Works Department, Bihar,

                    shall also be set aside due to two reasons. Firstly, the original

                    order is not sustainable and the appellate order has not been

                    decided on merit. Therefore, it is hereby directed that both the

                    orders be set aside and hence, the present writ petition is hereby

                    allowed.

                                8. However, liberty is hereby granted to the State to

                    proceed from the stage of second show-cause afresh, but

                    everything should be completed within three months from the

                    date of production of this order.

                                9. With the aforesaid directions and observations, the

                    present writ application stands disposed of.



                                                             (Dr. Anshuman, J)
Prakashmani/-

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.