Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Parvati DeviversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISMISSED

Holding

The petition is barred by the statutory two‑year limitation and the extensive delay, so the relief sought is denied.

Summary

The petitioner, Parvati Devi, sought restoration of a PDS licence originally held by her father‑in‑law, invoking compassionate grounds under the Bihar Trade Article (License Unification) Order, 1984. The State argued that the petition was filed after an inordinate delay, breaching the two‑year limitation prescribed in Section 10 of the Bihar Targeted Public Distribution System (Control) Order, 2016. The petitioner contended that earlier writs (CWJC No. 7579 of 1999 and CWJC No. 7736 of 2010) had restored licences for similarly situated dealers, and therefore her claim should be allowed. The Court observed that the petitioner was not a party to those earlier proceedings and that the statutory provision expressly requires an application within two years of the licence holder’s death. Considering the eighteen‑year lapse, the Court found the claim barred by the limitation and laches, and dismissed the writ petition.

Issues considered

  • Whether an application for restoration of a PDS licence on compassionate grounds filed after the two‑year period prescribed in Section 10 of the Bihar Targeted Public Distribution System (Control) Order, 2016 is barred.
  • Whether the petitioner can avail the benefit of earlier judgments restoring licences to other dealers despite not being a party to those cases.
  • Whether the eighteen‑year delay amounts to laches warranting dismissal of the writ petition.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • compassionate licence
  • PDS licence
  • statutory limitation
  • delay
  • laches
  • Bihar law
  • writ petition
  • license restoration

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.9845 of 2019
     ======================================================
     Parvati Devi Wife of Dinesh Prasad Yadav R/o Village and Post-Chakki
     Mayurva, P.S. Sonbarsa, District Sitamarhi

                                                             ... ... Petitioner/s
                                       Versus
1.   The State of Bihar through its Principal Secretary, Food and Consumer
     Protection Department, Govt. of Bihar
2.   The Collector cum District Magistrate Sitamarhi
3.   The Sub Divisional Officer Sadar, Sitamarhi

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s    :     Mr. Raja Ram Mishra, Advocate
     For the Respondent/s    :     Mr. S. Raza Ahmad, AAG 5
     ======================================================
        CORAM: HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. G. ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY

                                 ORAL JUDGMENT
                                 Date : 23-06-2026

                  1. The petitioner has filed the instant

      application for the following relief(s):

                      “(i)       For     a     direction       upon       the
                      Respondents to restore the license in
                      the name of the petitioner which was
                      granted          under    Bihar      Trade      Article
                      (License Unification) Order, 1984 in the
                      name of Father-in-law of the petitioner
                      in the year 1989 having license no.
                      26/89 on compassionate ground as
                      father-in-law of the petitioner died on
                      27.01.2001 and the petitioner is only
                      claimant of the license in her family.
                      (ii) To issue direction upon Respondent
                      no. 1 to 3 for restoration of license in
Patna High Court CWJC No.9845 of 2019 dt.23-06-2026
                                           2/6




                          the name of the petitioner.
                          (iii)       To         issue      other        proper
                          Writ/order/direction/orders to the ends
                          of justice.”



                     2. At the outset, the Learned counsel

         appearing on behalf of the State has drawn the

         attention of this Court to paragraph 5(iv) of the

         counter affidavit and submitted that the Writ

         petition deserves to be dismissed on the ground of

         inordinate delay and laches. Paragraph 5(iv) of the

         counter affidavit reads as follows:

                                   "5(iv) That the petitioner filed a

                      petition before the licensing authority for

                      issuance of PDS License on compassionate

                      ground on 01.08.2018, approximate, 18

                      years after the death of the PDS License

                      which was found not in accordance with

                      law as per provision of Section 10 of Bihar

                      Targeted           Public        Distribution   System

                      (Control) Order 2016, i.e., the application

                      compassionate                   ground     shall      be

                      entertained, if submitted within two years
Patna High Court CWJC No.9845 of 2019 dt.23-06-2026
                                           3/6




                      from the death of the licensee by his

                      dependent."

                     3. In response, Learned counsel for the

         petitioner submitted that a similarly situated PDS

         dealer, whose licence had been cancelled by the

         same        order,       had       challenged     the     order   of

         cancellation by filing CWJC No. 7579 of 1999. The

         said Writ petition was allowed, as would appear

         from        Annexure-2,             whereby      the     order    of

         cancellation was quashed. It has further been

         submitted that, pursuant thereto, the licences of

         several similarly situated dealers were restored.

         However, owing to the death of the petitioner's

         father-in-law on 27.01.2001, the licence standing in

         his name was not restored.

                     4. The Learned counsel for the petitioner

         further submitted that other similarly situated PDS

         dealers had also challenged the cancellation of

         their dealerships by filing CWJC No. 7736 of 2010

         and      other      analogous           cases.   By    order   dated

         14.10.2011, this Court was pleased to condone the

         delay and allow the said Writ petitions, whereby
Patna High Court CWJC No.9845 of 2019 dt.23-06-2026
                                           4/6




         the cancellation              order dated 28.05.1999 was

         quashed, as would appear from Annexure-5.

                     5.      Having         considered           the     aforesaid

         submissions, this Court finds that neither the

         petitioner nor her father-in-law was a party to the

         proceedings culminating in the orders contained in

         Annexure-2 and Annexure-5. The benefits flowing

         from the said judgments were granted to the

         respective            petitioners            therein,         who    had

         approached this Court seeking redressal of their

         grievances.

                     6. Upon consideration of the facts and

         circumstances of the case and the materials

         available on record, this Court finds no reason to

         grant       the      reliefs      sought       by   the        petitioner.

         Admittedly, the petitioner's father-in-law died on

         27.01.2001, whereas the petitioner approached

         the Licensing Authority for grant/restoration of a

         PDS licence on compassionate grounds only on

         01.08.2018, i.e., after a lapse of about eighteen

         years.

                     7. The provisions contained in the Bihar
Patna High Court CWJC No.9845 of 2019 dt.23-06-2026
                                           5/6




         Targeted         Public       Distribution       System        (Control)

         Order, 2016 specifically provide that an application

         seeking compassionate consideration is required to

         be submitted within two years from the date of

         death of the licence holder by his dependent. The

         petitioner's         application         was,    therefore,      clearly

         beyond the period prescribed under the relevant

         statutory provisions.

                     8. This Court also finds substance in the

         objection raised on behalf of the State that the

         petitioner        has      slept        over    her   rights    for   an

         inordinately long period. The law relating to

         compassionate              appointment           or   compassionate

         grant of licence is well settled that such claims are

         required to be raised within a reasonable time and

         are intended to provide immediate succour to the

         family upon the death of the licence holder. A claim

         raised after nearly eighteen years defeats the very

         object underlying such a provision.

                     9. Moreover, it is pertinent to note that

         since the cancellation order dated 28.05.1999, the

         statutory framework governing the grant and
             Patna High Court CWJC No.9845 of 2019 dt.23-06-2026
                                                        6/6




                      regulation          of     PDS       licences       has   undergone

                      substantial          changes.           In   such    circumstances,

                      entertaining the present Writ petition at this

                      belated stage would serve no useful purpose and

                      may also result in administrative complications.

                                  10. In view of the discussions made

                      hereinabove, this Court finds no merit in the

                      present Writ petition.

                                  11. Accordingly, the Writ petition stands

                      dismissed.

                                  12. Interlocutory Application(s), if any,

                      shall stand disposed of.




                                         (G. Anupama Chakravarthy, J)
Spd/-
AFR/NAFR                NAFR
CAV DATE                NA
Uploading Date          23.06.2026
Transmission Date


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.