Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Dr. Arun Kumar Singh,versusBrajesh Mehrotra, Chief Secretary,

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The Court held that the order under contempt had been complied with, and therefore the present application was disposed of.

Summary

The petitioner, Dr. Arun Kumar Singh, filed an application alleging that the State Government had failed to comply with the directions of a 30‑April‑2013 order of this Court in CWJC No. 683 of 2007, which declared Plus‑two lecturers appointed under Advertisement No. 1/87 to be members of the Subordinate Educational Service (SES) and entitled to all associated benefits. The order also quashed the 23‑June‑2009 notification that attempted to encadre these lecturers under a different service. The respondents filed a show‑cause statement asserting that all statutory benefits, including the differential amount arising from the merger into the Bihar Education Service, had already been paid to the petitioner. After examining the show‑cause statement, the Court found that the earlier order had been fully complied with and that no further relief was warranted. Consequently, the Court disposed of the present application without issuing any new order. The petitioner was advised that any further grievance could be pursued through a fresh application in accordance with law.

Issues considered

  • Whether the State Government has complied with the directions of the 30‑April‑2013 order in CWJC No. 683 of 2007.
  • Whether the petitioner is entitled to any further relief or benefit beyond what has already been paid.
  • Whether the Court should pass any additional order in the present application.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • Subordinate Educational Service
  • Plus‑two lecturers
  • Service benefits
  • Compliance of court order
  • Contempt
  • Education law
  • Bihar

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                               Miscellaneous Jurisdiction Case No.1549 of 2024
                                                       In
                                  Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.683 of 2007
                 ======================================================
                 Dr. Arun Kumar Singh, Late Krishna Nandan Singh, Resident of-
                 Rameshthalaya, new Mithila Colony, Nasriganj, opposite of Mobile Tower,
                 ahead of Ganga Nursery, Danapur, P.O.- Danapur, Police Station- Danapur,
                 District- Patna.

                                                                                ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                   Versus
           1.    Brajesh Mehrotra, Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna
           2.    Arvind Kumar Choudhary, Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Finance
                 Department, Government of Bihar, Patna now Designated as Additional
                 Chief Secretary, Finance.
           3.    K.K. Pathak, Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Education, Government of
                 Bihar, Patna, now Designated as Additional Chief Secretary, Education,
                 Government of Bihar, Patna.
           4.    Kanhaiya Prasad Srivastav, Director of Secondary Education, Human
                 Resource Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.

                                                        ... ... Opposite Party/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s     :    Mr. Sanjay Kumar, Advocate
                 For the Opposite Party/s :    Mr. Venkatesh Kirti, AC to GA2
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH
                         and
                         HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SHAILENDRA SINGH
                                       ORAL ORDER

                 (Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH)

7   07-05-2026                      The present application has been preferred by the

                   petitioner     alleging    non-compliance      of   the       order     dated

                   30.04.2013 passed by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in

                   CWJC No. 683 of 2007 and other analogous cases, wherein

                   following directions have been issued :

                                             "For the aforesaid reasons, we hold
                                   that the Plus two lecturers in the Government
                                   and the Nationalized (Taken Over) Secondary
Patna High Court MJC No.1549 of 2024(7) dt.07-05-2026
                                            2/4




                          Schools appointed pursuant to Advertisement
                          No. 1/87 and selected by the Board were
                          always part of the Subordinate Educational
                          Service and that they are entitled to the
                          benefits as the members of the Subordinate
                          Educational Service. The encadrement of the
                          Plus two lecturers with the teachers in the
                          Nationalized Schools under Notification dated
                          23rd June 2009 is bad and illegal. The
                          Notification dated 23rd June 2009 has been
                          issued without application of mind and
                          without considering Article 790 of the Bihar
                          Education Code, the Government decision
                          dated 7th July 1985 and the Advertisement
                          No. 1/87. The impugned order dated 16th
                          October 2006 and the Notification dated 23rd
                          June 2009 are quashed and set aside.
                                     The petitioners and other Plus two
                          lecturers appointed pursuant to the
                          Advertisement No. 1/87 are indeed the
                          members of the Subordinate Educational
                          Service. The petitioners are entitled to the
                          service benefits as the members of the
                          Subordinate Educational Service. The State
                          Government will treat the petitioners and the
                          other Plus two lecturers appointed pursuant to
                          the Advertisement No. 1/87 as the members of
                          the Subordinate Educational Service and will
                          extend the service benefits as the members of
                          the Subordinate Educational Service.
                                     All other legal consequences shall
                          follow.
                                     The State Government will make
                          orders, as may be required to comply with the
                          above directions, within one year from today.
                                     The petitions are allowed in the
                          above terms."

                       2. A show cause has been filed on behalf of opposite
Patna High Court MJC No.1549 of 2024(7) dt.07-05-2026
                                            3/4




          party No. 4, wherein following statements have been made in

          paragraph Nos. 5 & 6 :

                                     "5. That at the outset, it is humbly
                          submitted that in compliance of the order of
                          this Hon'ble Court under reference, all legally
                          admissible benefits/consequential benefits
                          have already been extended to the petitioner
                          consequent to merger into SES to BES and the
                          differential amount consequent to merger in
                          BES as well as A.C.P./ M.A.C.P. has already
                          been extended to Sri Arun Kumar Singh
                          (Petitioner) like Dr. Karunesh Kumar
                          (Petitioner No.1 in CWJC No.683 of 2007).
                                     6. That it is further humbly
                          submitted that consequent to merger in BES,
                          the admissible differential amount of the
                          petitioner based on authority slip of the
                          Accountant General Bihar has already been
                          made to him by the concerned authority i.e.
                          D.P.O. (Establishment), Patna-cum-D.D.O.,
                          which is being shown in tabular form for its
                          perusal.
                          Petitioner Name         Differential amount    Status
                          Dr. Arun Kumar          Total Rs 24,77,349/-   Paid

                       3. Considering the statements as referred above, this

          court is of the view that no further order is required to be passed

          in the present matter as the order under contempt has already

          been complied with.

                       4. Accordingly, the present application stands

          disposed of.

                       5. If so advised, the petitioner, if aggrieved by the
          Patna High Court MJC No.1549 of 2024(7) dt.07-05-2026
                                                      4/4




                    decision of the authority, shall be at liberty to challenge the

                    same by way of filing an appropriate application in accordance

                    with law.

                                 6. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand

                    disposed of.



                                                (Sudhir Singh, J)


                                              ( Shailendra Singh, J)
annu/Rajesh

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.