Bombay High Court
PRAMOD ALIAS PRADIP DIPCHAND VISHWAKARMAversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
- Disposal
- DISPOSED OFF
- Bench
- RAJNISH R VYAS
Holding
Bail was denied as the court found a prima facie case of murder against the applicant.
Summary
Pramod alias Pradip Dipchand Vishwakarma applied for bail in a murder case (Crime No. 609/2024) under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. The prosecution alleged that the applicant assaulted Ashokkumar with a stone slab, causing fatal head injuries, as corroborated by an eye‑witness, Parmatmaram Sudarshan, and a post‑mortem report indicating multiple depressed skull fractures. The applicant’s counsel argued that the weapon was not clearly described and that there were no prior criminal records, seeking bail. The State contended that the eye‑witness testimony and forensic evidence established a prima facie case of murder, justifying denial of bail. After reviewing the statements and medical report, the court held that sufficient material existed to sustain the charge and consequently rejected the bail application.
Issues considered
- Whether bail should be granted to the accused in a murder case where an eye‑witness and post‑mortem report establish a prima facie case under Section 302 IPC.
Legislation cited
- Indian Penal Code, 1860 — s. 302
Subjects
- bail
- murder
- IPC 302
- eye‑witness testimony
- prima facie case
- post‑mortem report
- criminal procedure
Judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:11800
1 945.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 325 OF 2026
PRAMOD ALIAS PRADIP DIPCHAND VISHWAKARMA
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
...
Advocate for Applicant : Mr. Shete Shankar Govindrao
APP for Respondent : Mr. A.R. Kale
...
CORAM : RAJNISH R. VYAS, J.
DATE : 18TH MARCH, 2026
PER COURT :
1. The sole accused has preferred an application for grant of
bail in connection with Crime No. 609/2024, registered with Kotwali
Police Station, District Ahmednagar, for the offence punishable under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code.
2. In short, it is the case of the prosecution that the reporter by
name Vishwas Dange stated that in agricultural field, several rooms were
constructed, in which, the labourers used to reside. In one of the rooms,
the present applicant was residing. On 21.05.2024, at about 11:48 p.m.,
he received a telephonic call from one Parmatmaram Sudarshanram, who
informed that the applicant had assaulted one Ashokkumar on his head by
means of stone due to which, Ashokkumar had fallen and the blood was
oozing from his ear. The informant then immediately reached to the spot,
2 945.odt
approached the concerned police station. He has also called the private
ambulance.
3. At this juncture, learned counsel Mr. Shete, has contended
that the manner in which the incident has taken place and the weapon of
offence used, if seen would reveal that, prima facie, case is not made out
against the applicant. He submitted that there is no description of the
weapon of crime and, therefore, it is very difficult to arrive at the
conclusion as to whether the injuries sustained were outcome of the
weapon used. He further contended that since chargesheet is already filed
and applicant has no criminal antecedents, he be enlarge on bail.
4. Per Contra, learned APP contended that there is an eye
witness to the incident and the injuries if seen would clearly reveal that
there was intention to commit an offence. He submitted that the final
report clearly makes out a case against the applicant and therefore,
prayed for rejection of bail.
5. With the assistance of both the learned counsels, I have gone
through the record of the case which is annexed along with the bail
application. Incident had occurred on 21 May 2014 at about 11:48 in the
night. Eye witness Parmatmaram Sudarshan, whose statement was
3 945.odt
recorded on 23.05.2024, had category stated that he along with his friend
had been to the hotel for enjoying the food, at which time, the present
applicant came near his table and all of them were enjoying the food.
Since for returning home, there was no vehicle for the applicant,
deceased / Ashokkumar was called by the present applicant. Ashokkumar
then came to the spot of the incident, and at that time, altercation was
going on between the applicant and said Ashokkumar. Ashokkumar was
sitting on his motorcycle and Pramod @ Pradip / the present applicant
was standing in front of him. Thereafter, when quarrel continued, said
Parmatmaram tried to intervene and he came back to his room.
6. Again Paramatmaram, heard the quarrel going on between
the Ashokkumar and the present applicant and he came out of the house,
where he noticed that Ashokkumar was lying in the pool of blood and the
applicant was holding the piece of stone Slab (Farshi) and again assaulted
Ashokkumar on his head by means of said stone. When Parmatmaram
tried to intervene, the applicant also threatened him to kill.
7. Thereafter, the present applicant dropped the weapon on the
spot of the incident, returned to room and, thereafter, went away along
with the bag of clothes. As as said Ashokkumar had died on 22.05.2022,
the postmortem report was conducted on his body. Cause of death in
4 945.odt
postmortem report is head injury due to physical assault. The injuries
sustained are mentioned in column no. 17 of the post mortem report.
Column no. 18 further shows multiple depressed fracture of whole skull
bone. Thus, it is evident that several blows were given on the vital part of
the body. At this stage, commenting something on merit would not be
proper. Considering the fact that the applicant is under the prosecution.
8. Suffice it to say that the eye witness to the incident i.e.
Parmatmaram, prima facie, inspires the confidence. Since, prima facie,
material is available against the applicant, I am not inclined to allow the
present application. Hence, the following order is passed :
ORDER
i. Bail Application is rejected.
ii. At this stage, it is necessary to mention here that Mr.
Govindrao Shete, has argued the matter with full preparation. His
fees be quantified as per the rules.
( RAJNISH R. VYAS, J. )
SPC
Checking your session…