Bombay High Court

THE STATE OF MAH THR. COLLECTOR LATUR AND ORSversusCHANDBEE ABDUL SHAIKH

Disposal: DISPOSED OFF
Bench: NEERAJ P DHOTE

Holding

All the civil applications stand disposed as no matter survives after the first appeals were disposed.

Summary

The State of Maharashtra, through the Collector of Latur, filed several civil applications (Nos. 3687‑3697 of 2012) and corresponding first appeals (Nos. 1413‑1419 of 2018) against Narsing Pandurang Alange. The matters were listed before this Court and were argued by Shri V. M. Chate (AGP) for the State and Shri Shashikiran N. Patil for the respondent. The Court observed that the first appeals had already been disposed of, leaving no pending issues in the civil applications. Consequently, the Court ordered that the civil applications stand disposed. No substantive factual or legal dispute remained for adjudication.

Issues considered

Whether any relief remains pending in the civil applications after the disposal of the first appeals

Subjects

civil procedure
first appeal
disposal
applications
high court

Judgment

2026:BHC-AUG:23293
                                             1


                        IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
                                  BENCH AT AURANGABAD.

                               CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3695 OF 2012
                                               IN
                                  FIRST APPEAL NO.1413 OF 2018

               The State of Maharashtra
               Through Collector, Latur and Ors                       … Applicants
                     Versus
               Narsing Pandurang Alange                               … Respondent
                                               …..
                                              AND
                               CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3693 OF 2012
                                               IN
                                  FIRST APPEAL NO.1414 OF 2018
                                               …..
                                              AND
                               CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3697 OF 2012
                                               IN
                                  FIRST APPEAL NO.1415 OF 2018
                                               …..
                                              AND
                               CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3689 OF 2012
                                               IN
                                  FIRST APPEAL NO.1417 OF 2018
                                               …..
                                              AND
                               CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3691 OF 2012
                                               IN
                                  FIRST APPEAL NO.1418 OF 2018

                                                  AND
                               CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3687 OF 2012
                                                  IN
                                  FIRST APPEAL NO.1419 OF 2018
                                                  …..
                                         In all the matters :
                         Shri. V. M. Chate, AGP for the Applicants – State.
                      Shri. Shashikiran N. Patil, Advocate for the Respondents
                                                  …..
                               2

                              CORAM :      NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J.
                              Dated    :   JUNE 12, 2026

PER COURT :-

.     In view of disposal of the First Appeals, nothing survives in the
Civil Applications and the same stand disposed of.




                                             ( NEERAJ P. DHOTE, J. )

GGP

Continue reading with your account

Checking your session…