Created by Fuzzy Cloud

M B SHAH

198 judgments · newest first · showing 1–198

VIJAY LAKSHMIversusPUNJAB UNIVERSITY AND ORS.

2003 INSC 505Appeal(s) allowed

The Punjab University Calendar contained Rules 5, 8 and 10 reserving certain posts in women’s colleges – principal, teacher and hostel superintendent – for women only. A writ petition challenged these provisions as violative of Articles 14, 15(3) and 16 of the Constitution. The Punjab and Haryana …

NAWAL SINGHversusSTATE OF U.P. AND ANR.

2003 INSC 506Dismissed

The appellants, senior judicial officers of Uttar Pradesh, were ordered by the Allahabad High Court to retire compulsorily at age 58 after a screening committee found them unsuitable to continue in service. They challenged the order, contending that Rule 2 of the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Officers …

P.C. KESAVAN KUTTYNAYAR ETC. ETCversusHARISH BHALLA AND ORS.

2003 INSC 507

The Supreme Court examined whether the Central Government could grant permission to increase student intake or renew permission for medical colleges in contravention of Sections 10‑A and 10‑B of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and the regulations framed by the Medical Council of India (MCI). …

P.C. KESAVAN KUTTYNAYAR ETC. ETCversusHARSH BHALLA AND ORS.

2003 INSC 508

The Supreme Court examined whether the Central Government could grant permission to increase student intake or renew admission permissions for medical colleges without the colleges complying with the requirements of Sections 10‑A and 10‑B of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and the regulations …

M.C. MEHTAversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS. ON BEHALF OF MONITORING COMMITTEE

2003 INSC 495

The Supreme Court, hearing a writ petition under Article 32 filed by environmental activist M.C. Mehta on behalf of a Monitoring Committee, examined the Taj Heritage Corridor project undertaken near the Taj Mahal. The Court found that construction and river‑bed reclamation work had commenced without …

SANTOSH KUMAR AND ORS.versusG.R. CHAWLA AND ORS.

2003 INSC 466Dismissed

The appellants, who were initially appointed as ad‑hoc Inspectors of Drugs, sought regularisation under the U.P. Regularisation of Ad hoc Appointments Rules, 1979 and claimed seniority over directly recruited inspectors appointed by the State Public Service Commission under the U.P. Inspector of …

BAITARANI GRAMIYA BANKversusPALLAB KUMAR AND ORS.

2003 INSC 467Appeal(s) allowed

Baitarani Gramiya Bank submitted an original recruitment indent to the Banking Service Recruitment Board (BSRB) for Officers and Field Supervisors, but later pruned the indent due to a financial crisis and communicated the revised numbers before the examination results were declared. The BSRB …

BHAVSINGH (DEAD) BY LRS.versusKESHAR SINGH AND ORS.

2003 INSC 469Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, the estate of the deceased Bhavsingh, claimed that a 1960 sale deed of agricultural land was a mortgage transaction for a loan and sought declaration of nullity under the Madhya Pradesh Samaj Ke Kamjor Vargon Ke Krishi‑Bhumi Dharkon Ka Udhar Dene Walon Ke Bhumi Hadapane Sambandhi …

OM PRAKASH SOODversusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2003 INSC 423Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a Technical Assistant with a superannuation age of 60, was offered promotion to Key Board Operator (KBO) on the condition that he could revert to his original post and retire at 60. The department neither accepted nor rejected this condition and later superannuated him at 58, the KBO …

M/S. WIDIA (INDIA) LTD. AND ORS.versusTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS.

2003 INSC 410Dismissed

The case concerned the Karnataka Tax on Entry of Goods Act, 1979 and its amendment in 1993 which inserted the words "retrospectively or prospectively" in Section 3(1). The petitioners challenged the validity of the amendment for lack of the President's assent under Article 304(b) of the …

V. DANDAPANI CHETTIARversusBALASUBRAMANIAN CHETTIAR (DEAD) BY LRS AND ORS.

2003 INSC 380Appeal(s) allowed

Rajathiammal, a female Hindu, acquired suit property from her maternal grandmother through a court‑sanctioned compromise decree. She died intestate and without issue on 1 July 1972. The appellant, V. Dandapani Chettiar, son of Rajathiammal's father, claimed that the property should devolve on the …

T.K. RANGARAJANversusGOVERNMENT OF TAMIL NADU & ORS.

2003 INSC 371Disposed off

The Tamil Nadu Government dismissed about two lakh employees who went on strike, prompting the employees to file writ petitions under Articles 226/227 challenging the dismissals and the validity of the Tamil Nadu Essential Services Maintenance Act, 2002 and Tamil Nadu Ordinance No.3 of 2003. The …

BIHAR PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION AND ANR.versusVINOY KUMAR SINGH AND ANR.

2003 INSC 365Appeal(s) allowed

The Bihar Public Service Commission (BPSC) conducted a competitive examination in 1983, declared the results in 1985 and later, after a two‑year gap, issued a show‑cause notice to Vinoy Kumar Singh alleging unfair means in the General Knowledge paper. The Commission cancelled his answer‑sheet and …

DAVID JUDEversusHANNAH GRACE JUDE AND ORS.

2003 INSC 348Disposed off

The husband filed a contempt petition against his wife and her mother for violating an unconditional undertaking given to the Supreme Court that the child would be brought back to India and that they would appear before the Family Court when required. Despite multiple notices and adjournments, the …

SAFIYAversusGOVERNMENT OF KERALA

2003 INSC 338Dismissed

The appellant Safiya, wife of T.P. Moideen Koya, challenged his preventive detention under Section 3(1)(iv) of the COFEPOSA Act on grounds that the Advisory Board’s opinion revoking the detention of another accused in the same smuggling case was not considered, that there was an inordinate delay in …

STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH AND ANR.versusMARRI VENKAIAH AND ORS.

2003 INSC 339Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court examined whether an application under Section 28‑A of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 must be filed within three months of the civil court’s award or from the date the applicant actually learns of the award. The land in question was acquired by a common notification, an award was …

OFFICERS AND SUPERVISORS OF I.D.P.L.versusCHAIRMAN AND M.D.I.D.P.L. AND ORS.

2003 INSC 330Dismissed

The petitioners, officers and supervisors of Indian Drugs and Pharmaceuticals Ltd (IDPL), a public sector undertaking declared a sick unit by the BIFR, sought direction to revise their pay scales and to receive three instalments of interim relief as recommended by the Fifth Pay Commission and …

COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS, KOLKATTAversusM/S. GRAND PRIME LIMITED AND ORS.

2003 INSC 305Appeal(s) allowed

M/s. Grand Prime Ltd. imported raw silk and other silk products into Kolkata using an advance licence that was later found to be forged and was subject to a condition of re‑export. The importer failed to comply with the re‑export condition, did not appear before customs, and did not file a bill of …

M/S. OM PRAKASH BHATIAversusCOMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS, DELHI

2003 INSC 306Dismissed

The appellant, O.P. Bhatia, exported ladies' skirts and declared a value far above the domestic market price, subsequently claiming a large drawback. The Customs Commissioner found that the export value was deliberately over‑invoiced, treated the goods as prohibited, confiscated them and imposed a …

M/S. N.S. NAYAK AND SONSversusSTATE OF GOA

2003 INSC 286Dismissed

The appellant, N.S. Nayak & Sons, challenged the High Court's dismissal of its appeals under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, arguing that the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 should govern the appeals because the arbitration agreement referred to "the provisions of the Arbitration …

COLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, 'BANGALOREversusM/S. ESCORTS MAHLE LTD.

2003 INSC 280Dismissed

The Collector of Central Excise challenged the claim of MODVAT credit by Mis. Escorts Mahle Ltd. for chemicals—Ramming Mass, Fibre Glass and Filter Mesh—used in the manufacture of steel pistons. The assessees argued that these chemicals are essential to neutralise acidic vapours generated during …

THE STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AND ORS.versusYASH PAL GARG (DEAD) BY LRS. AND ORS.

2003 INSC 270Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Himachal Pradesh enacted the Himachal Pradesh Taxation (On Certain Goods Carried by Road) Act, 1976 to levy a tax on goods transported by road. The Himachal Pradesh High Court declared the Act unconstitutional as a restriction on inter‑state trade under Article 301 and for lacking …

AMINAversusHASSN KOYA

2003 INSC 264Appeal(s) allowed

Amina married Hassn Koya on 28 December 1972 while she was five months pregnant. The husband later claimed that the pregnancy had been concealed, rendering the Muslim marriage void and absolving him of maintenance liability under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The trial magistrate held …

DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION LTD.versusROSE ADVERTISING

2003 INSC 239Dismissed

The Delhi Transport Corporation (DTC) entered into a 1993 agreement with Rose Advertising containing an arbitration clause. A dispute arose and the contractor sought appointment of an arbitrator in early 1996; the arbitrator was appointed on 4 July 1996, after the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, …

NARENDERA NATH KHAWAREversusPARASNATH KHAWARE AND ORS.

2003 INSC 240Disposed off

The complainant, Narendra Nath Khaware, filed a Special Leave Petition under Article 136 of the Constitution challenging the High Court's dismissal of the State's appeal against the acquittal of seven accused in the murder of his son, Diwakar Khaware. The Supreme Court held that a private person may …

OIL & NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD.versusSAW PIPES LTD.

2003 INSC 241Appeal(s) allowed

ONGC entered into a contract with Saw Pipes Ltd for supply of casing pipes, making timely delivery essential and providing for liquidated damages of 1% per week (up to 10%) for delay. Saw Pipes failed to deliver on time due to a strike, sought an extension, and ONGC granted it on the condition that …

SUKANYA HOLDINGS PVT. LTDversusJAYESH H. PANDYA AND ANR.

2003 INSC 230Dismissed

Sukanya Holdings Pvt. Ltd. and J.H. Pandya entered into a partnership agreement that contained an arbitration clause. After the partnership fell into dispute, the respondent filed a suit for dissolution, accounts and other reliefs, including claims against purchasers of flats who were not parties to …

M/S. POLYGAS ACRYLIC MFG. CO. LTD.versusCOMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS, VISHAKHAPATNAM

2003 INSC 197Appeal(s) allowed

Mis. Polygas Acrylic Mfg. Co. Ltd. imported Methyl Methacrylate Monomer (MMM) described in the invoice as "regenerated second grade". The Customs Department rejected this description, issued a show‑cause notice alleging misdeclaration and claimed the goods were of prime quality, leading to …

M/S. SUNNY INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD.versusCOLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, CALCUTTA

2003 INSC 183Dismissed

M/s Sunny Industries Pvt. Ltd. manufactured an Ad‑vitamin Massage Oil Forte and claimed it to be a patent or proprietary medicine, seeking classification under tariff heading 30.03 (medicaments). The Assistant Collector and the Collector (Appeals) classified it as a cosmetic product under heading …

PEOPLE'S UNION FOR CIVIL LIBERTIES (PUCL) AND ANR.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2003 INSC 176Disposed off

The Supreme Court examined the constitutionality of Section 33B (also called Section 338) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, inserted by the 3rd Amendment Act, 2002, which barred candidates from disclosing any information not expressly required by the Act despite Supreme Court …

GOAPLAST PVT. LTD.versusSHRI CHICO URSULA DSOUZA AND ANR.

2003 INSC 153Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Goaplast Pvt. Ltd., issued post‑dated cheques to the respondent and later instructed the drawee bank to stop payment before the dates on which the cheques became payable. The respondent filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, which was dismissed by …

STATE OF MADHYA PRADESHversusM/S. K.C.T. DRINKS LTD.

2003 INSC 135Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Madhya Pradesh granted a D‑2 licence, in the form of a lease, to Mis. K.C.T. Drinks Ltd for manufacturing Indian Made Foreign Liquor. The licence contained a condition that the licensee pay the full cost of excise supervisory staff posted at its factory. The High Court struck down this …

M/S. HINDUSTAN METAL PRESSING WORKSversusCOMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE, PUNE

2003 INSC 126Appeal(s) allowed

Hindustan Metal Pressing Works removed excisable goods at the prevailing duty rate while awaiting classification list approval to claim exemption under Notification No.175/86-CE. After the classification list was approved in June 1988, the Revenue granted a refund of excise duty for April‑August …

M/S. AMCO BATTERIES LTD., BANGALOREversusCOLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, BANGALORE

2003 INSC 120Case Partly allowed

Amco Batteries Ltd., a manufacturer of lead‑acid batteries, obtained lead ingots from various sources, including job workers who reclaimed lead from waste and scrap sent by Amco. The waste and scrap were claimed to be exempt from excise duty under Notification 186/84‑CE (as amended by 246/87‑CE). …

FORBES GOKAK LTD.versusCOLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, AURANGABAD

2003 INSC 121Disposed off

Forbes Gokak Ltd. manufactured glass moulds with plastic gaskets for making ophthalmic lenses. The Central Excise authority classified the product under heading 70.15 of the Central Excise Tariff Act as "other articles of glass" and levied duty, while the assessee claimed classification under …

COLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, MADRAS ETC.versusM/S. I.T.C. LTD., BIHAR ETC.

2003 INSC 69Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court examined whether a printed cigarette packet falls under “other packing containers” or “boxes” in Tariff Item No.17 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, and consequently whether Exemption Notification No.66/82 (dated 28‑Feb‑1982) applies. The Revenue argued that the packet is a …

FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIAversusSURENDRA, DEVENDRA AND MAHENDRA TRANSPORT CO.

2003 INSC 58Case Partly allowed

The Food Corporation of India (FCI) entered into a contract with Sure... Transport Co. containing an arbitration clause (Clause XX) that referred all disputes to an arbitrator except matters whose decision was expressly provided for in the contract. Clause XII specifically excluded claims relating …

N. KHADERVALI SAHEB (DEAD) BY LRS. AND ANR.versusN. GURUSAHIB (DEAD) AND ORS.

2003 INSC 59Appeal(s) allowed

A partnership of four family members was dissolved and the partners' residual assets were allocated by an arbitration award dated 2 October 1972. Some partners objected to the award under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, contending that the award needed to be registered under Section 17 of …

COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, BOMBAYversusM/S. ELEPHANTA OIL AND INDUSTRIES LTD., BOMBAY

2003 INSC 53Appeal(s) allowed

The Collector of Customs imposed a penalty on M/s Elephant Oil and Industries Ltd. for importing beef tallow, which was deemed a canalised item under the Import Policy. The importer argued that the Open General Licence (OGL) permitted the import and that the penalty was unwarranted after the goods …

STATE OF GUJARAT AND ORS.versusSAURASHTRA CEMENT AND CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES

2003 INSC 47Appeal(s) allowed

Saurashtra Cement and Chemical Industries set up a new kiln in a new building on the same premises, using existing crushers, cranes, and other plant, and applied for exemption from electricity duty under the Bombay Electricity Duty Act, 1958. The statutory authority rejected the application, but the …

U. DHAR AND ANR.versusTHE STATE OF JHARKHAND AND ANR.

2003 INSC 23Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants, senior officials of Tata Construction & Projects Ltd, were sued criminally by Singh Construction Co. for allegedly misappropriating payment received from Bokaro Steel Plant for contract work. The complaint invoked IPC sections 403, 406, 420 and 1208, alleging dishonest conversion of …

RAM NARAIN POPLIversusCENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

2003 INSC 10Disposed off

The case involved five financial transactions between Maruti Udyog Ltd (MUL), a government company, and Harshad S. Mehta (A5), a broker, routed through banks. The CBI alleged that the accused conspired to divert MUL's surplus funds to A5 through fraudulent transactions. The Special Court convicted …

M/S. ALPINE INDUSTRIESversusCOLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, NEW DELHI.

2003 INSC 11Dismissed

Alpine Industries manufactured a product called "Lip Salve" and supplied it exclusively to the Defence Department for use by military personnel at high altitude. The company claimed that the product was a medicament and should be classified under Heading 30.03 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, …

KEDIA AGGLOMERATED MARBLES LTD.versusCOLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE

2003 INSC 12Appeal(s) allowed

Kedia Agglomerated Marbles Ltd. manufactures floor tiles marketed under the trade names “Marbella Agglomerated Marble” and “Marbellam Tiles” and classifies them under tariff heading 68.07. Notification No. 59/91‑CE dated 20‑Mar‑1990 exempts “mosaic tiles, i.e., tiles known commercially as mosaic …

M/S. EASLAND COMBINES, COIMBATOREversusTHE COLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, COIMBATORE

2003 INSC 9Disposed off

Easland Combines, a small‑scale manufacturer, had its classification list approved and claimed exemption under a notification. The Central Excise authorities later issued a show‑cause notice demanding differential duty, alleging a willful misstatement regarding its SSI registration. The Tribunal …

FLASH LABORATORIES LTD.versusCOLLECTOR OF CENTRAL EXCISE, NEW DELHI.

2002 INSC 568Dismissed

Flash Laboratories Ltd, a toothpaste manufacturer, sold 60% of its output to its holding company Parle Products Ltd and the remaining 40% to another subsidiary, Parle Biscuits Ltd. The Central Excise authorities issued show‑cause notices alleging that the three entities were "related persons" under …

STATE OF UTTAR PRADESHversusRAM SEWAK AND ORS.

2002 INSC 556Disposed off

The State of Uttar Pradesh appealed the Allahabad High Court's acquittal of five accused in a murder case arising from a factional clash. The deceased had given a dying declaration naming Ram Sewak as the shooter, which was corroborated by a promptly lodged FIR and eyewitness testimony. The trial …

DEVENDER PAL SINGHversusSTATE N.C.T. OF DELHI AND ANR.

2002 INSC 544Dismissed

The petitioners filed review applications under Article 137 of the Constitution seeking to set aside death sentences imposed by the Supreme Court in three criminal appeals. They argued that because one of the three judges on the bench had either acquitted the accused or suggested life imprisonment, …

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAXversusM/S. HINDUSTAN BULK CARRIERS

2002 INSC 545Case Partly allowed

The dispute arose over the period for which interest under Section 234B (and related sections 234A, 234C) could be levied by the Income Tax Settlement Commission after an assessee disclosed previously undisclosed income under Section 245C. The revenue argued that interest should be limited to the …

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, MUMBAIversusM/S. DAMANI BROTHERS

2002 INSC 546Appeal(s) allowed

The Revenue appealed against an order of the Income Tax Settlement Commission concerning Daman! Brothers' settlement application. The Supreme Court examined whether the Commission could waive or reduce interest under Section 220(2) while exercising powers under Section 245(4), whether assessment …

MANSAB ALIversusLRSAN AND ANR.

2002 INSC 538Disposed off

The complainant challenged a High Court order that granted bail to one co‑accused (Irsan) in a murder‑related case, alleging that the order was laconic and failed to state reasons. The Supreme Court reiterated that the discretion to grant or refuse bail under the Criminal Procedure Code must be …

MAHESH CHANDversusB. JANARDHAN AND ANR.

2002 INSC 514Disposed off

Mahesh Chand filed an FIR alleging forged sale deeds and trespass. The police investigation concluded the matter was a civil dispute and filed a case‑disposal report, which the magistrate accepted, leading to the dismissal of Chand's criminal complaint. After a protest petition was also dismissed, …

NAGAPPAversusGURUDAYAL SINGH AND ORS.

2002 INSC 504Appeal(s) allowed

Nagappa, a poor agriculturist who lost his right leg in a road accident, claimed compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The Claims Tribunal awarded a modest sum, which the Karnataka High Court later enhanced and also ordered payment for an artificial leg. Nagappa then sought to amend his …

COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE, SHILLONGversusNORTH-EASTERN TOBACCO CO. LTD.

2002 INSC 499Dismissed

The North‑Eastern Tobacco Co. Ltd, after closing its earlier cigarette unit at Bangagarh under a disinvestment agreement, set up a new manufacturing unit at the Export Promotion Industrial Park in Amingaon in 1999 and sought exemption from central excise duty under the Exemption Notification dated …

SOHAN LALversusBABU GANDHI AND ORS.

2002 INSC 490Disposed off

An election for the post of Sarpanch of a Gram Panchayat was held. The appellant was orally told he had won, but the official result declared the respondent as the winner. The Sub‑Divisional Officer, on an ex‑parte order, recounted the votes and corrected a clerical error, declaring the appellant …

MAHENDER PRATAPversusKRISHAN PAL AND ORS.

2002 INSC 492Dismissed

Mahender Pratap, who lost a Legislative Assembly election by 161 votes, filed an election petition seeking a recount of votes on the ground of alleged irregularities in electronic voting machine counting and non‑compliance with Conduct of Election Rules 56A and 63. He claimed that his application …

A.P. STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD AND ORS.versusJ. VENKATESHWARA RAO AND ORS.

2002 INSC 478Disposed off

The Andhra Pradesh State Electricity Board issued a 1985 memorandum promising appointment of eligible ex‑casual labourers to vacant posts, a right later affirmed by the High Court in a writ petition. In 1997 the Board issued another memorandum limiting such appointments to 50% of vacancies, and some …

SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL DESAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

2002 INSC 475Disposed off

The Supreme Court considered the procedure for custody and disposal of property seized by police under Sections 451 and 452 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The petitioners sought further directions on how seized items should be handled when the accused denies involvement and no physical …

VENKATRAO ANANTDEO JOSHI AND ORS.versusSAU MALATHIBAI AND ORS

2002 INSC 461Appeal(s) allowed

Venkatrao Joshi and his mother filed a partition suit against the father and his wife, alleging an illegal transfer of joint family land. The trial court issued a preliminary decree granting the appellants a two‑thirds share and held the transfer void; the decree became final after the father and …

K. PREMA S. RAO AND ANR.versusYADLA SRINIVASA RAO AND ORS.

2002 INSC 443Disposed off

The husband forced his wife to relinquish land given as stridhana, concealed her family’s mail, and, together with his parents, drove her out of the matrimonial home, leading her to commit suicide. The trial court convicted the husband under Section 498A IPC for cruelty and acquitted all accused of …

RAM EKBAK MISSIRversusRAM NIWASH PANDEY@ SRI NIWASH PANDEY AND ORS.

2002 INSC 430Leave granted

An FIR under Section 302 IPC was lodged in 1979, but the case was not listed before the magistrate for over ten years due to administrative lapses. The accused filed a writ petition seeking quashal of the prosecution, relying on the A.R. Antulay v. R.S. Nayak decision that prolonged delay could …

JUSTICE K.P. MOHAPATRAversusSRI RAM CHANDRA NAYAK AND ORS.

2002 INSC 431Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court examined the meaning of "consultation" under Section 3(1) of the Orissa Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 1995, which requires the Governor to appoint a Lokpal after consulting the Chief Justice of the Orissa High Court and, if any, the Leader of the Opposition. The Chief Minister had …

RAJESHEKAR BASAVARAJ PATILversusSUBASH KALLUR AND ORS.

2002 INSC 429Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant challenged the election of Subash Kallur, alleging that he was disqualified under Section 9A of the Representation of People Act, 1951 because a contract with the Karnataka Irrigation Department subsisted on the date of election (5 September 1999). Kallur contended that he had …

SUNDERBHAI AMBALAL DESAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

2002 INSC 418

The Supreme Court considered two special leave petitions filed by police inspectors seeking directions on the custody and disposal of seized property such as valuable articles, vehicles, liquor and narcotic drugs. The petitioners argued that the prosecution could not seek remand of accused for …

GOVT. OF ANDHRA PRADESH AND ORS. ETC. ETC.versusP. VENKU REDDY

2002 INSC 404Appeal(s) allowed

The Government of Andhra Pradesh and a District Co-operative Central Bank appealed a High Court order that had quashed a criminal case against P. Venku Reddy for alleged acceptance of a bribe under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The High Court had held that Reddy was not a "public servant" …

URBAN IMPROVEMENT TRUST, UDAIPURversusBHERU LAL AND ORS.

2002 INSC 402Disposed off

The Urban Improvement Trust, Udaipur sought to acquire land for a housing scheme under the Rajasthan Urban Development Act. The State of Rajasthan issued a notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, first published in newspapers in 1990 and later in the official gazette on 4 …

SRI S.K. SARMAversusMAHESH KUMAR VERMA

2002 INSC 393Appeal(s) allowed

Mahesh Kumar Verma, a former railway employee, was allotted official accommodation while in service but failed to vacate after his retirement in 1984. The railway administration invoked Section 138 of the Indian Railways Act, 1890 to recover possession, but the Calcutta High Court set aside the …

MS. ARUNA ROY AND OTHERSversusUNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS

2002 INSC 380Dismissed

The Supreme Court dismissed a public‑interest writ petition challenging the National Curriculum Framework for School Education (NCFSE) 2000 on the grounds that it was framed without consulting the Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE) and that it violated secularism and Article 28. The Court …

K.G. PREMSHANKERversusINSPECTOR OF POLICE AND ANR.

2002 INSC 381Dismissed

The appellant, K.G. Premshanker, sought to quash criminal prosecution on the ground that a civil suit for damages against him had been dismissed, and he argued that the civil judgment should prevail over the criminal case. The High Court rejected this plea and the matter reached the Supreme Court. …

BINDESHWARI PRASAD SINGHversusSTATE OF BIHAR

2002 INSC 332Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants were acquitted by a Sessions Court of murder charges under Sections 302 and 302/114 IPC. The State's appeal against the acquittal was dismissed by the High Court on a limitation ground, after which the informant filed a criminal revision under Section 401 of the CrPC. The High Court …

DR. J.J. MERCHANT AND ORS.versusSHRINATH CHATURVEDI

2002 INSC 330Disposed off

The doctors filed a petition before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) alleging that a complaint of medical negligence against them should be dismissed or stayed, arguing that the case involved complicated questions of law and fact and that a nine‑year delay in disposal …

VIKASversusSTA TE OF RAJAS THAN

2002 INSC 324Dismissed

The appellant Vikas, his parents and sisters were charged with dowry harassment, torture and murder of Vikas's wife Neeta. The prosecution alleged that Neeta was taken from a relative's house on a motorbike, later found dead in a river, and that ornaments worn by her were recovered from Vikas's …

PRAKASH KHANDREversusDR. VIJAY KUMAR KHANDRE AND ORS.

2002 INSC 272Case Partly allowed

In the Karnataka Legislative Assembly election for the Bhalki constituency, Prakash Khandre was declared elected. Dr. Vijay Kumar Khandre challenged the result, alleging that Prakash Khandre was disqualified under Section 9A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 because of subsisting …

UNION OF INDIAversusASSOCIATION FOR DEMOCRATIC REFORMS AND ANR.

2002 INSC 253Case Partly allowed

The Supreme Court examined whether the Election Commission could be directed to require candidates to disclose criminal cases, assets, liabilities and educational qualifications, as ordered by the Delhi High Court, despite the absence of a specific provision in the Representation of the People Act, …

SANJU @ SANJA Y SINGH SENGARversusSTATE OF M.P.

2002 INSC 250Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, brother of the deceased's wife, was charged under Section 306 IPC for allegedly abetting the suicide of his brother‑in‑law, Chander Bhushan, by allegedly telling him to "go and die" during a quarrel on 25 July 1998. The deceased was found hanged on 27 July 1998 and left a suicide note …

GOVERNMENT OF ORISSAversusM/S. ASHOK TRANSPORT AGENCY AND ORS.

2002 INSC 249Matter referred to larger bench

The plaintiff obtained an ex‑parte decree against the Charge Chrome Division of Orissa Mining Corporation before the division was taken over by the State of Orissa under the 1991 Ordinance. The State, not being impleaded, objected to execution of the decree on the ground that the decree was not …

SUBASH PARBAT SONVANEversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

2002 INSC 221Case Partly allowed

Subash Parbat Sonvane, a public servant, was convicted by a Special Judge in Ahmedabad under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 for taking money from a complainant. The Gujarat High Court upheld both convictions. On appeal before the Supreme Court, the appellant …

UNION OF INDIA AND ANR.versusVENKATESHAN S. AND ANR.

2002 INSC 216Appeal(s) allowed

The Union of India detained B. Sankar under Section 3 of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA) for alleged hawala transactions involving Rs. 42.9 lakh. The Karnataka High Court set aside the detention, holding that the underlying offence …

BIHARI MANJHI AND ORS.versusSTATE OF BIHAR

2002 INSC 200Appeal(s) allowed

In a case of gruesome carnage in Bihar that left 35 dead, the Designated Court convicted several accused under the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (TADA) and the Indian Penal Code based solely on a confessional statement of Bihari Manjhi recorded by a police inspector. The …

KRISHNA MOCHI AND ORS.versusSTATE OF BIHAR ETC.

2002 INSC 199Dismissed

The case concerned a mass‑caste massacre in Bihar in which 35 members of a community were killed and many others injured. Thirteen persons were charged under the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (TADA) and the Indian Penal Code; four were acquitted and the remaining nine …

MOTI LALversusCENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION AND ANR.

2002 INSC 188Dismissed

Motilal was arrested for possessing skins of protected wildlife under several provisions of the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972. The Central Government, invoking the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, issued a notification and, with the consent of the Uttar Pradesh Government, transferred the …

CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATIONversusR.S. PAI AND ANR.

2002 INSC 178Appeal(s) allowed

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) filed a charge sheet in a fraud case and later sought the Special Court's permission to produce additional documents that were gathered during the investigation but not submitted with the charge sheet. The Special Court rejected the application, prompting …

GEORGEversusSTATE OF KERALA

2002 INSC 179Appeal(s) allowed

The deceased, a farm worker, disappeared after leaving for work and his body was later found drowned in a river. The accused, George, was found in possession of the deceased's watch and two gold rings, which he had pledged to others shortly after the disappearance. The prosecution relied on …

DEVENDER PAL SINGHversusSTATE N.C.T. OF DELHI AND ANR.

2002 INSC 168Case Partly allowed

The appellant Devender Pal Singh was arrested after being deported from Germany and recorded a confessional statement under Section 15 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act (TADA). The Designated Court convicted him of offences under TADA and the IPC, including criminal …

SUBHASH CHANDER AND ANR.versusSTATE TRANSPORT APPELLATE TRIBUNAL AND ORS.

2002 INSC 163Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants applied for mini‑bus permits on the Dasuya‑Jalalpur via Miani route under the liberalised scheme of Section 80 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Their applications were rejected by the State Transport Commissioner, but the State Transport Appellate Tribunal (STAT) allowed the appeals …

M.C. MEHTAversusKAMAL NATH AND ORS.

2002 INSC 144Disposed off

The Supreme Court examined the liability of Span Motels Pvt. Ltd. (SMPL) for constructing walls and bunds on the banks and bed of the River Beas, which interfered with the river's natural flow and caused environmental degradation. The Court affirmed earlier findings that SMPL's actions violated the …

CHOWDARAPU RAGHUNANDANversusSTATE OF TAMIL NADU AND ORS.

2002 INSC 145Appeal(s) allowed

The petitioner was detained under Section 3(1)(i) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 after customs seized a large quantity of dutiable cell‑phones from his baggage at Chennai Airport. He claimed the goods were not his, that the customs statement …

AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF INDIAversusSATYAGOPAL ROY AND ORS.

2002 INSC 143Dismissed

The Airports Authority of India appealed a Gauhati High Court order that awarded compensation for cutting trees on its land using a multiplier of 18 years' yield. The appellant argued that the multiplier violated the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Haryana v. Gurcharan Singh, which limits the …

MAHENDRA PALversusSHRI RAM DASS MALANGER AND ORS.

2002 INSC 115Dismissed

In a Himachal Pradesh assembly election, Mahendra Pal (appellant) lost to Ram Dass Malanger (respondent) by three votes. The appellant claimed a discrepancy of eight votes between the total ballots recorded in Form 20‑A (35,310) and the round‑wise count (35,318) and sought a recount under Section …

RAM NATH SAO @ RAM NATH SAHU & ORS.versusGOBARADHAN SAO AND ORS.

2002 INSC 106Appeal(s) allowed

The case arose from a partition suit involving 116 acres of land where, during the pendency of a first appeal, several appellants died. Substitution applications were filed after delays of 130 days, three years, and five years. The Patna High Court refused to condone the delay and set aside the …

S.R EJAZversusTAMIL NADU HANDLOOM WEAVERS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD.

2002 INSC 100Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a long‑time tenant, was forcibly evicted by the respondent landlord while an eviction suit was pending. The appellant filed a criminal complaint and, within six months, instituted a suit for restoration of possession under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. The trial court …

INDER SAIN MITTALversusHOUSING BOARD HARYANA AND ORS.

2002 INSC 96Appeal(s) allowed

The Housing Board filed civil suits against contractor I.S. Mittal, and the court appointed a Superintending Engineer as arbitrator. The arbitrator was transferred during the proceedings but continued the arbitration and issued an award. The Board objected under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, …

KARNATAKA ELECTRICITY BOARDversusTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS.

2002 INSC 87Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court examined a dispute where Karnataka Electricity Board (KEB) entered into a written agreement with landowners to acquire 21 acres 14 guntas for a power station, agreeing to pay Rs 14,250 per gunta for two‑thirds of the land and to pay solatium fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer …

IN RE: DEA TH OF 25 CHAINED INMATES IN ASYLUM FIRE IN TAMIL NADUversus.

2002 INSC 63Disposed off

A tragic fire at a mental asylum in Ervadi, Tamil Nadu, killed 25 chained patients, prompting the Supreme Court to take suo motu action under Article 32. The Court examined the failure of the Central and State governments to implement the Mental Health Act, 1987 and related disability statutes, …

RAGHURAM RAO AND ORS.versusERIC P. MATHIAS AND ORS.

2002 INSC 58Appeal(s) allowed

The case concerned a permanent mulgeni lease of about 40 cents of land granted in 1903 with an express clause prohibiting the lessee from alienating the whole leasehold property, but without any clause restricting partial alienation. After the lessee's death, the leasehold was partitioned among …

LEHNAversusSTATE OF HARYANA

2002 INSC 39Appeal(s) allowed

Lehna was convicted of murder (Sec. 302 IPC), attempt to murder (Sec. 324 IPC) and assault (Sec. 458 IPC) for killing his mother, brother and sister‑in‑law and injuring his father and nephew during a family land dispute. The trial court sentenced him to death, which the High Court confirmed. On …

STATE OF KARNATAKAversusM. DEVENDRAPPA AND ANR.

2002 INSC 28Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Karnataka charged M. Devendarappa and another with forging bank guarantees and impersonating a bank manager, invoking IPC sections 465, 468, 471, 420 and 120‑B. The Karnataka High Court, exercising its inherent power under Section 482 of the CrPC, quashed the proceedings on the ground …

DAVINDER PAL SEHGAL AND ANR.versusM/S PARTAP STEEL ROLLING MILLS PVT. LTD. AND ORS.

2001 INSC 607Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants, settled abroad, filed a suit for declaration and possession but their advocate could not appear on the scheduled date due to a family emergency, and no notice of the next hearing was received. The trial court dismissed the suit for non‑prosecution and later dismissed two restoration …

PRAKASH DHAWAL KHAIRNAR (PATIL)versusSTATE OF MAHARASHTRA

2001 INSC 606Disposed off

The case involved a dispute over agricultural land that led Prakash Dhawal Khairnar (Patil) to murder his brother, mother, sister‑in‑law and five other relatives. The prosecution relied on strong circumstantial evidence—motive, blood‑stained clothing, a shoulder injury, eyewitness identification, …

HARJEET SINGH @ SEETAversusSTATE OF PUNJAB AND ANR.

2001 INSC 598Appeal(s) allowed

Harjeet Singh, charged under Sections 302/34 and 307/34 of the IPC, applied for bail which was denied by the trial court but granted by a Single Judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The State filed a separate application before another High Court judge seeking cancellation of the bail on the …

SHAILENDRA KUMARversusSTATE OF BIHAR AND ORS.

2001 INSC 583Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant alleged that his mother was murdered and the accused were charged under Sections 148, 149, 323, 449 and 302 of the IPC. The Sessions Judge closed the prosecution evidence because the appellant did not request further examination of witnesses. After the case was transferred, a new …

STATE OF RAJASTHAN AND ANR.versusM/S. NAV BHARAT CONSTRUCTION CO.

2001 INSC 582Disposed off

The State of Rajasthan appealed against an arbitration award that granted the contractor, M/s Nav Bharat Construction Co., interest of 18% on delayed payments. The contractor had also obtained a district court award of 15% interest, both of which were confirmed by the Rajasthan High Court. The …

STATE OF BIHAR AND ORS.versusJAIN PLASTICS AND CHEMICALS LTD.

2001 INSC 577Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Bihar and others entered into a contract with Jain Plastics & Chemicals Ltd. for the supply of PVC pipes and fittings, but the company delayed delivery, leading the appellants to terminate the contract and procure the fittings at a higher price. The appellants deducted the additional …

MADANLALversusSHYAMLAL

2001 INSC 570Dismissed

The respondent filed a suit for specific performance of a land sale agreement. After the plaintiff's evidence was closed, the defendant (appellant) applied under Order 13 Rule 2 of the CPC for production of a land acquisition award, electricity bills, and a registered sale deed. The trial court …

OUSEPH MATHAI AND ORS.versusM. ABDUL KHADIR

2001 INSC 555Appeal(s) allowed

The landlord Joseph Mathai filed an eviction petition under the Kerala Building (Lease & Rent Control) Act, 1965 on grounds of arrears of rent and bona‑fide need for reconstruction. The Rent Control Court initially dismissed the arrears claim but later allowed eviction on reconstruction; the tenant …

S.N. KAPOOR (DEAD) BY HIS LRS.versusBASANT LAL KHATRI AND ORS.

2001 INSC 556Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a widow of the original landlord S.N. Kapoor, sought eviction of the tenant under Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, claiming a bona‑fide need for the premises. The Rent Controller held the claim not bona‑fide, and the Delhi High Court dismissed both the revision …

JAYAWANT DATTATRAY SURYARAOversusSTATE OF MAHARASHTRA

2001 INSC 558Dismissed

The case involved a shoot‑out at J.J. Hospital in Mumbai on 12 September 1992, resulting in the murder of a prisoner and two police constables and injuries to several others. The accused – A‑2 (Jayawant Dattatray Suryarao), A‑6 (Subhashsingh Thakur) and A‑7 (Shamkishore Garikapatti) – were convicted …

MURLI S. DEORAversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2001 INSC 551Directions issued

The petitioners sought a direction under Article 32 of the Constitution to prohibit smoking in public places, arguing that passive smoking infringes the fundamental right to life under Article 21. The Court examined the harmful health effects of tobacco smoke, both for smokers and non‑smokers, and …

KAMALADEVI AGARWALversusSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

2001 INSC 517Appeal(s) allowed

Kamala Devi Agarwal, a partner in a firm, complained that a deed of dissolution of the partnership had been forged, causing her son mental shock and the closure of his shop. She filed a criminal complaint under IPC sections 465, 467, 468, 471 and 120‑B. The trial magistrate found a prima facie case …

BANTU @ NARESH GIRIversusSTATE OF M.P.

2001 INSC 518Case Partly allowed

The appellant, Bantu (also known as Naresh Giri), was convicted under Sections 302 and 376 of the Indian Penal Code for the rape and murder of a six‑year‑old girl, Jyoti. The trial court and the Madhya Pradesh High Court sentenced him to death, holding that he had abducted the child, raped her, and …

T.N. LAKSHMAIAHversusSTATE OF KARNATAKA

2001 INSC 513Dismissed

The appellant, a government servant, was convicted of murdering his wife and son at a picnic spot and sentenced to life imprisonment. He appealed to the Supreme Court claiming exemption under Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code, asserting that he was suffering from mental illness (moderate …

MAHENDRA LAL DASversusSTATE OF BIHAR AND ORS.

2001 INSC 506Appeal(s) allowed

Mahendra Lal Das, an executive engineer, was charged under Sections 5(2) and 5(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 for possessing disproportionate assets of Rs. 50,600. An FIR was lodged in 1988, but the investigating agency failed to obtain sanction for prosecution for more than 12 …

M. KRISHNANversusVIJAY SINGH AND ANR.

2001 INSC 499Leave Granted & Allowed

The appellant alleged that the respondents forged documents to withdraw large sums from a bank, invoking several sections of the Indian Penal Code. A magistrate took cognizance and issued process, but the respondents filed a petition under Section 482 of the CrPC seeking to quash the criminal …

JAGDIP SINGHversusJAGIR CHAND AND ANR.

2001 INSC 496Leave Granted & Allowed

The State Transport Appellate Tribunal granted permits to certain applicants to operate mini‑buses on specific routes in Punjab. Existing private permit‑holders challenged the grant, and the Punjab and Haryana High Court set aside the tribunal’s order. On appeal, the Supreme Court examined whether …

PUNJAB STATE ELECTRICLTY BOARDversusNATIONAL THERMAL POWER CORPORATION LTD. AND ORS.

2001 INSC 498Appeal(s) allowed

The Punjab State Electricity Board and other state electricity boards appealed to the Supreme Court against an interim order of the Delhi High Court that virtually stayed the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission's (CERC) norms for hydro‑generation and inter‑state transmission tariffs. The …

DR. KIRPA RAM MATHURversusSTATE OF U.P. AND ORS.

2001 INSC 489Dismissed

Dr. Kirpa Ram Mathur, appointed as Lecturer in Pathology in 1984, challenged a seniority list that placed him below Respondent No.4, claiming he had higher merit. After an initial government order in 1993 placed him senior, the High Court set aside that order and directed a fresh seniority …

GHULAM QADIRversusSPECIAL TRIBUNAL AND ORS.

2001 INSC 480Dismissed

The case concerned Ghulam Qadir's claim to a property that had been declared evacuee property and vested in the Custodian under the Jammu Kashmir State Evacuees (Administration of Property) Act, 1949. The original claimant, Sardar Begum, had filed a claim under Section 8, executed a will in favour …

DINESH DUIT JOSHIversusTHE STATE OF RAJASTHAN AND ANR.

2001 INSC 475Disposed off

The appellant, Dinesh Dutt Joshi, was accused of demanding a bribe for providing an electric connection. The trial court discharged him, but the Rajasthan High Court, invoking its inherent power under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, set aside the discharge and ordered that charges be …

KALYAN AND ORS.versusSTATE OF U.P.

2001 INSC 472Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants were charged with murder and related offences under Sections 302, 307, 147, 148, 149 and 1208 of the IPC for an incident alleged to have occurred on 27 June 1977 in Badayun, Uttar Pradesh. The trial court acquitted all accused, holding that the prosecution failed to prove its case …

THE BRAHMA VART SANATANversusKANHYALAL BAGLA AND OTHERS

2001 INSC 458Appeal(s) allowed

Durga Prasad Bagla executed a 1917 Will bequeathing all his estate to his third wife, Mst. Durgi, using the term "puree malik" indicating absolute ownership. After Durga's death, Durgi adopted Kanhaiya Lal, whose later suit sought possession of the property and declared Durgi's subsequent Will and …

GURDIAL SINGHversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2001 INSC 459Appeal(s) allowed

Gurial Singh applied for a Freedom Fighters Pension under the 1972 scheme on 13 March 1973, providing various documents to prove his service in the Indian National Army. His claim was initially rejected, later a provisional pension was granted in 1998 by both the State of Punjab and the Central …

RAJINDER PRASADversusBASHIR AND ORS.

2001 INSC 452Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant Rajinder Prasad filed applications before a Judicial Magistrate to add offence under Section 395 IPC and to implead four additional accused. The magistrate, invoking Chapter XIV of the Cr.P.C., allowed the applications and committed the case to the Sessions Court, which framed charges …

SUBRATA SEN AND ORS.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2001 INSC 449Disposed off

The petitioners, former officers of Indian Oil Corporation (Assam Oil Division) who retired before 1 December 1994, challenged a government notification dated 10 March 1995 that revised the pension formula only for officers retiring on or after that date. They argued that the cut‑off date was …

STATE OF MADHYA PRADESHversusKAJAD

2001 INSC 430Appeal(s) allowed

The respondent, KAJAD, was arrested under Section 50 of the NDPS Act with 7 kg of opium and charged under Section 18, an offence punishable with imprisonment of ten to twenty years. His bail applications were rejected by the trial court and initially by the High Court, but a later High Court order …

UNION OF INDIAversusMAMTA ANURAG SHARMA AND ANR.

2001 INSC 428Appeal(s) allowed

Mamta Anurag Sharma, an IPS officer of the West Bengal cadre, married an IPS officer of the Andhra Pradesh cadre and sought inter‑cadre transfer to her home state. The request was denied under the 1995 Government guidelines which forbid transfers to the spouse's home state on the ground of marriage. …

M/S. SWIL LTD.versusSTATE OF DELHI AND ANR.

2001 INSC 367Appeal(s) allowed

Mis. Swil Ltd., a public limited company, filed an FIR alleging cheating and misappropriation by respondent No.2, J. Rajmohan Pillai. Although Pillai's name appeared only in column 2 of the charge‑sheet (for persons not sent for trial), the Metropolitan Magistrate issued summons to him along with …

STATE OF U.PversusJHINKOO NAI

2001 INSC 340Directions issued

The accused, armed with knives, entered a Harijan household at night intending to rape an 18‑year‑old girl. When she resisted, one accused (Tahir) stabbed her, causing her death, while the others inflicted knife injuries on her parents. The trial court convicted Jhinkoo Nai and Deep Chand under …

THE MEGHALAYA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD AND ANR.versusSHRI JAGADINDRA ARJUN

2001 INSC 336Appeal(s) allowed

The Meghalaya State Electricity Board (MSEB) adopted a Government of Meghalaya memorandum on premature retirement of employees under Fundamental Rule 57(b) by passing Resolution No. 6 on 10 May 1989 and later issued an order compulsorily retiring Jagadindra Arjun. The employee challenged the order, …

N.R. NARAYAN SWAMYversusB. FRANCIS JAGAN

2001 INSC 326Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a landlord, initially filed an eviction suit under the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 on the ground of bona fide requirement, which he later withdrew after the tenant promised to vacate. When the tenant died and his son continued occupying the premises, the landlord filed a second …

GOPI NATH @ JHALLARversusSTATE OF U.P.

2001 INSC 328Dismissed

The appellant Gopi Nath was convicted of murder under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code for the killing of Ram Chandra, who was attacked by three accused armed with weapons. The appellant argued that he only inflicted a simple injury and should be liable only under Section …

STATE OF MADHYA PRADESHversusSARDAR

2001 INSC 314

The State of Madhya Pradesh appealed the acquittal of Sardar, who had been convicted of murder under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC. The High Court had set aside the conviction on the ground that, because two other accused had been given the benefit of doubt, Sardar should also receive …

RAKESH AND ANR.versusSTATE OF HARYANA

2001 INSC 313Dismissed

The father of a minor girl lodged an FIR alleging that three men, including the appellants, had abducted her for rape. Police investigation found only one of the alleged persons, Prem Chand, involved and framed charges against him. During the trial, after the prosecutrix’s cross‑examination began, …

SHRI BHAGWANversusSTATE OF RAJASTHAN

2001 INSC 274Disposed off

Shri Bhagwan, a 20‑year‑old apprentice goldsmith, was convicted of murdering five members of Shiv Pratap's family and committing robbery and dacoity. The conviction was based on circumstantial evidence: he was seen with one of the deceased, sustained injuries, possessed blood‑stained clothing and …

BIBHACHHAversusSTATE OF ORISSA

2001 INSC 262Dismissed

The appellant was convicted of murder under Section 302 IPC after the dead body of the deceased was found near the Hati River. The prosecution relied solely on circumstantial evidence, such as the last sighting of the accused and the deceased together, recovery of blood‑stained clothing, the missing …

RAJEEV CHAUDHARYversusSTATE (N.C.T.) OF DELHI

2001 INSC 257

The appellant, Rajeev Chaudhary, was arrested for offences under IPC sections 386, 506 and 120B and was released on bail by a Metropolitan Magistrate under Section 167(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code because the charge‑sheet was not filed within 60 days. The Additional Sessions Judge set aside the …

RAJAN WORLIKAR ETC. ETC.versusSTATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS.

2001 INSC 258Dismissed

The appellants, who were operating a factory manufacturing Mandrax tablets, were detained under the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs & Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988. They challenged the detention on two grounds: that the order failed to inform them of their right to make a …

PURAN ETC. ETC.versusRAMBILAS AND ANR. ETC. ETC.

2001 INSC 251Dismissed

The appellants were charged under Sections 498‑A and 304‑B of the IPC for a dowry‑death. The Additional Sessions Judge granted them bail on 13 November 2000 without recording any reasons, prompting the father of the deceased to move the High Court, which cancelled the bail on the ground that the …

RAJUversusSTATE OF HARYANA

2001 INSC 247Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Raju, was accused of enticing an 11‑year‑old girl, Rinku, with toffees, raping her and subsequently striking her with two bricks when she threatened to disclose the crime, resulting in her death. The prosecution relied on eyewitness testimony, the appellant's extra‑judicial confession …

THE DENTAL COUNCIL OF INDIAversusSUBHARTI K.K.B. CHARITABLE TRUST AND ANR.

2001 INSC 226Case Partly allowed

The Subharti K.K.B. Charitable Trust sought to establish a dental college with an annual intake of 100 students, but the Dental Council of India (DCI) recommended only 60 seats, which the Central Government accepted. The Allahabad High Court issued a mandamus directing the DCI and the Central …

STATE OF ORISSA AND ORS.versusK. SRINIVASA RAO (DEAD) THROUGH LRS.

2001 INSC 216Case Partly allowed

The Supreme Court examined the meaning of "family" under the Orissa Land Reforms Act, 1960 (as amended by President's Act 17 of 1973) in two contexts. It held that a married woman is an individual whose family consists of herself, her husband and their children, and therefore she is not a member of …

M/S. SOMAIYA ORGANICS (INDIA) LTD.versusSTATE OF UTT AR PRADESH AND ANR.

2001 INSC 211Case Partly allowed

The appellant, Mis. Somaiya Organics (India) Ltd., manufactured industrial alcohol and was initially exempt from a vend fee under the U.P. Excise Act, 1910. The exemption was withdrawn in 1979 and the company filed writ petitions; the High Court ordered it to give a bank guarantee and/or deposit …

NARSINGH PRASAD SINGHversusRAJ KUMAR @ PAPPU AND ORS.

2001 INSC 191Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Narsingh Prasad Singh, filed a criminal appeal after his daughter was brutally beaten with a burning wooden stick by the respondents, Raj Kumar and others, for alleged dowry demand. The trial court convicted the respondents under Section 498-A of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced …

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.versusRAKESH KUMAR

2001 INSC 188Appeal(s) allowed

The respondent, a former constable of the Border Security Force (BSF), resigned after 12 years and 8 months of service under Rule 19 of the BSF Rules, 1969. The Government of India, relying on a 1995 Government Order, granted him full pensionary benefits, which were not released, leading to a writ …

DAYA SINGHversusSTATE OF HARYANA

2001 INSC 96Dismissed

In 1988 a terrorist attack on Dr. Harnam Singh's house in Kurukshetra resulted in four deaths and several injuries. Fourteen accused, including Daya Singh, were tried under the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act and the IPC for murder and attempted murder. The trial court convicted …

THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU AND ANR.versusBASKAR

2001 INSC 98Disposed off

The State of Tamil Nadu appealed against a Madras High Court order that had quashed a preventive detention order issued on 2 August 1999 against Baskar and three others. The High Court had held the detention order vague because it allegedly did not specify the exact overt act attributable to each …

THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU AND ANR.versusBALASUBRAMANIAM

2001 INSC 99Disposed off

The State of Tamil Nadu issued a preventive detention order against Balasubramaniam in 1999. The Madras High Court, hearing a habeas corpus petition under Articles 226 and 21 of the Constitution, quashed the order on the ground that the sponsoring authority’s affidavit mentioned six cases while the …

MAHENDRA KUMARversusLALCHAND AND ANR.

2001 INSC 73Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant Mahendra Kumar filed a suit for partition of property with his mother, which resulted in a preliminary decree granting equal shares to mother and son, and a final decree after a document alleged the son had relinquished his share, giving equal shares to the mother and respondent No.1. …

GURBAX SINGHversusSTATE OF HARYANA

2001 INSC 74Appeal(s) allowed

Gurbax Singh was seized carrying 7 kg of poppy straw in a polythene bag at a railway platform. A 100‑gram sample was taken and sealed in the presence of a witness, but the seal was later claimed to be wooden by the witness and brass by the investigating officer, and it remained with the witness for …

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.versusMANAGER, M/S JAIN AND ASSOCIATES

2001 INSC 75Appeal(s) allowed

The Union of India and others appealed against a decree passed by the High Court under Section 17 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 after an arbitrator's award, where the appellants had not filed objections within the prescribed 30‑day period. The High Court had held that such a decree was not an …

INTELLIGENCE OFFICER NARCOTICS CONTROL BUREAUversusSAMBHU SONKARAND ANR.

2001 INSC 66Appeal(s) allowed

The Intelligence Officer of the Narcotics Control Bureau recovered 18.7 kg of ganja from Shambhu Sonkar and charged him under Section 20(b)(i) of the NDPS Act. The trial court denied bail, but the Calcutta High Court granted bail, holding that Section 37 of the NDPS Act did not apply because the …

LAL SINGH ETC. ETCversusSTATE OF GUJARAT AND ANR.

2001 INSC 13Case Partly allowed

The Supreme Court examined the convictions of five appellants under Section 3(3) of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act (TADA) for alleged conspiracy to commit terrorist acts, the recovery of large quantities of arms, ammunition and explosives, and related offences under the …

HAR KIRAN COMMARversusDELHI ADMN. AND ORS.

2000 INSC 537Dismissed

Mrs. Har Kiran Commar filed a review petition under Section 48 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, seeking de‑acquisition of land on the ground that the acquisition proceedings against her were quashed, similar to the relief granted to her brother, Gurdip Singh Uban. The Court examined a letter dated …

G.M. BHARAT COKING COAL LTD., WEST BENGALversusSHIB KUMAR DUSHAD AND ORS.

2000 INSC 501Appeal(s) allowed

The employee, Shib Kumar Dushad, claimed that his date of birth recorded by his employer, G.M. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd., was incorrect and sought correction to extend his superannuation. The employer had referred the matter to its Medical Board, which, following the company's service rules and …

FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA, HYDERABAD AND ORS.versusA. PRAHALADA RAO AND ANR.

2000 INSC 500Appeal(s) allowed

The Food Corporation of India (FCI) imposed a minor penalty on two employees for alleged dereliction of duty that caused loss to the corporation. The employees denied the charges and challenged the penalty before the High Court, which held that a full departmental enquiry, as required for major …

B.S. KHURANA AND ORS.versusMUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI AND ORS.

2000 INSC 456Dismissed

The Delhi Municipal Corporation repeatedly passed resolutions from 1970 to 1989 to transfer or sell municipal quarters to its employees, but each time the Municipal Commissioner objected. The Corporation was superseded three times, and eventually the Administrator, on the Lt. Governor’s direction, …

R. BALAKRISHNA PILLAIversusSTATE OF KERALA

2000 INSC 425Dismissed

R. Balakrishna Pillai, a former Kerala minister, was convicted under Sections 5(1)(d) and 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 for abusing his office to supply electricity to a private firm in Karnataka. He filed a criminal appeal before the Kerala High Court and subsequently moved a …

HANUMAN VITAMIN FOODS PVT. LTD. AND ORS.versusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR.

2000 INSC 344Dismissed

The appellants, members of a co‑operative society, transferred five shares to other members via an instrument dated 31 March 1986. The Superintendent of Stamps treated the instrument as a conveyance of property and demanded stamp duty under Article 25(b)(i) of the Bombay Stamp Act, 1958. The Bombay …

RISHABH AGRO INDUSTRIES LTD.versusP.N.B. CAPITAL SERVICES LTD.

2000 INSC 309Appeal(s) allowed

Rishabh Agro Industries Ltd., ordered to be wound up by a High Court Single Judge for defaulting on a bank loan, obtained a stay of that order from the Division Bench. The company then filed a reference under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 before the …

JAI MANGAL ORAONversusSMT. MIRA NAYAK AND ORS. ETC.

2000 INSC 295Dismissed

The appellant, a member of a Scheduled Tribe, claimed title to land that had been surrendered by his predecessor Nanda Oraon in 1942 to a landlord. He alleged that he was the adopted son of Sukhi Oraon and therefore succeeded to the land, filing a complaint that led the Special Officer under the …

RAJASTHAN HOUSING BOARDversusSMT. PARVATI DEVI ETC.

2000 INSC 279Disposed off

The Rajasthan Housing Board (RHB) was alleged by several homebuyers, including Parvati Devi, to have delayed construction, demanded additional payments and failed to hand over possession of allotted houses. The complainants filed a petition before the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices …

T.N. GODAVARMAN THIRUMULPADversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2000 INSC 270Disposed off

The Supreme Court had constituted a High Power Committee (HPC) to fix recovery norms for veneer extraction from timber and to levy penalties on units exceeding those norms. Units were required to submit their production records by 15 January 1998, but questions arose whether the HPC could impose a …

UNION BANK OF INDIAversusOFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR H.C. OF CALCUTTA AND ORS .

2000 INSC 259Disposed off

The Supreme Court examined the sale of assets of Kolay Biscuits Co. Ltd., a company under liquidation, where the Company Judge ordered an auction as a going concern based largely on oral statements about 1,200 workers and a valuation report that was not disclosed to the secured creditor, Union Bank …

ROOP SINGH (DEAD) THROUGH LRSversusRAM SINGH (DEAD) THROUGH LRS.

2000 INSC 158Appeal(s) allowed

Roop Singh, the plaintiff, owned 15.32 acres of agricultural land and sued Ram Singh for illegal possession. The defendant claimed he had purchased the land 14 years earlier, sought protection under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, and alleged title by adverse possession. The trial court …

KARAMCHARI UNION, AGRAversusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

2000 INSC 113Case Partly allowed

The Supreme Court examined whether Dearness Allowance (DA), City Compensatory Allowance (CCA) and House Rent Allowance (HRA) paid to government employees fall within the definition of "salary" under Section 17 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and are therefore taxable. The appellants argued that these …

ALMITRA H. PATEL AND ANR.versusUNION OF INDIA

2000 INSC 68

The Supreme Court entertained a writ petition under Article 32 seeking effective solid waste management in Delhi, noting that earlier directions in Dr. B.L. Wadhera v. Union of India had not been implemented. The Court observed that no landfill sites had been identified, compost plants were not …

M.N. ABDUL PAWOOFversusPICHAMUTHU AND ORS.

2000 INSC 62Appeal(s) allowed

The respondents had executed a usufructuary mortgage in favour of the appellant and later claimed to be "debtors" under the Tamil Nadu Debt Relief Act, 1979. The dispute turned on the meaning of the expression "not less than Rs. 1200" in the proviso to Section 3(3) of the Act, which exempts persons …

STATE OF HLMACHAL PRADESHversusSURINDER MOHAN AND ORS.

2000 INSC 53

The State prosecuted Surinder Mohan and others for murder and related offences. An accomplice, Sandeep Kumar, was granted pardon by the Chief Judicial Magistrate and his statement was recorded before the case was committed to the Sessions Court, but the accused were not cross‑examined at that stage. …

SPRINT R.P.G. INDIA LTD.versusCOMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS-I, DELHI

2000 INSC 26Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant imported seven hard disk drives pre‑loaded with computer software. Customs classified the consignment under heading 84.71 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, attracting a 25% duty, whereas the appellant contended that the goods should fall under heading 85.24, attracting only 10% duty as …

ROSY AND ANR.versusSTATE OF KERALA AND ORS.

2000 INSC 12Appeal(s) allowed

The Excise Inspector filed a complaint under the Kerala Abkari Act before a Judicial Magistrate, who, without examining any of the ten listed witnesses, committed the case to the Sessions Court because the offences were exclusively triable there. The accused later raised, during arguments, an …

LAL CHAND AND ANR.versusDISTRICT JUDGE AGRA AND ORS.

1999 INSC 419Dismissed

The landlord filed an eviction suit in 1976 after a shop was reconstructed in 1970. The tenant, Gian Chand, claimed he remained a statutory tenant under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947, and argued that the exemption period of ten years under the U.P. Urban …

K.R. PATEL (DEAD) THROUGH L.RS.versusCOMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX

1999 INSC 360Dismissed

The deceased K.R. Patel and B.G. Amin were appointed executors and trustees under a 1962 will that directed payment of debts, conveyance of specific legacies, conversion of remaining assets into cash and donation to charitable purposes. The will created a public trust, which was registered in …

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, DELHIversusBHARAT CARBON AND RIBBON MFG. CO. (P) LTD.

1999 INSC 334Dismissed

Bharat Carbon and Ribbon Manufacturing Co. manufactured carbon paper, which was later classified as coated paper under Item 17(2) of the Central Excise Tariff, leading to a demand for excise duty for the years 1976-77, 1978-79 and 1979-80. The company challenged the levy by filing a writ petition …

BHAGWAN RAMA SHINDE GOSAI AND ORS.versusSTATE OF GUJARAT

1999 INSC 246Disposed off

The appellants were convicted by a trial court under Section 392 read with Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and sentenced to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment. They appealed to the Gujarat High Court, seeking suspension of the sentence, which was denied, and later also sought an …

HYDERABAD INDUSTRIES LTD. AND ANR.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

1999 INSC 234Disposed off

Hyderabad Industries Ltd. and another imported asbestos fibre before 1986 and were demanded additional customs duty under Section 3(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975. The appellants argued that the fibre, obtained by merely separating it from the parent rock, was not a manufactured article and …

STATE OF M.P. AND ANR.versusSMT. ABHA SETHI ETC.

1999 INSC 208Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Madhya Pradesh appealed against a Madhya Pradesh High Court order that held video games in video parlours were not liable to entertainment tax under the MP Entertainments Duty and Advertisement Tax Act, 1936. The High Court had relied on the decision in Harrish Wilson v. State of MP, …

STATE THROUGH SUPDTT. CENTRAL JAIL, NEW DELHIversusCHARULATA JOSHI AND ANR.

1999 INSC 180Disposed off

A news magazine sought permission from the Additional Sessions Judge to interview an under‑trial prisoner, Babloo Srivastava, in Tihar Jail. The Sessions Judge granted a blanket permission, which the High Court modified by imposing conditions that the prisoner must consent and the interview must not …

MAKTOOL SINGHversusSTATE OF PUNJAB

1999 INSC 111Disposed off

The appellant, Maktool Singh, challenged the conviction and sentence imposed under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, 1985, seeking suspension of the sentence pending appeal. The High Court refused suspension, prompting an appeal to the Supreme Court. The Court examined …

GURMEJ SINGH AND ANR.versusSTATE OF PUNJAB AND ORS.

1999 INSC 100Dismissed

The appellants purchased a portion of land from Smt. Charanjit Kaur after the PEPSU Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1955 had been amended in 1956. The landowner held more than the permissible limit of 30 standard acres (equivalent to 60 ordinary acres) and had not applied for reservation of land …

STATE OF U.P.versusRANJIT SINGH

1999 INSC 72Appeal(s) allowed

Ranjit Singh, a stenographer of a High Court judge, forged a bail order that was never signed by the judge to obtain bail for an accused. He was convicted under IPC Sections 466 and 468 for making a false document and for forgery of a court record, while the Sessions Court granted him probation …

M/S. MARSHALL SONS AND CO. (I) LTD.versusM/S SAHI ORETANS (P) LTD. AND ANR.

1999 INSC 29Disposed off

Marshall Sons & Co. (I) Ltd., the landlord, obtained a decree for eviction against four defendants for non‑payment of rent and unlawful sub‑letting. The decree was not executed, and the respondents continued to occupy the premises. The respondents later filed a declaratory suit claiming tenancy …

RAM LAL AND ANR.versusSTATE OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR

1999 INSC 22Disposed off

The appeal involved two convicted persons: the first under Section 326 of the IPC (a non‑compoundable offence) and the second under Section 324 IPC (compoundable with court permission). Both parties sought to compound the offences after reaching a settlement. The Supreme Court held that Section …

GANESH NAGARAO RAUT DUDHAGAONKARversusRAJANI SHANKARRAO SATAV AND ORS.

1998 INSC 467Dismissed

In a municipal council election with 424 voters, the quota for election was 213 votes. No candidate reached the quota, leading to successive rounds of elimination under the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961. The appellant, G.N.R. Dudhagaonkar, contended that 71 ballot papers, which were declared …