Created by Fuzzy Cloud

M M SATHAYE

72 judgments · newest first · showing 1–72

RADHIKA BANDU RAUT AND ORS.versusLIBERTY GENERAL INSURANCE LTD.

Disposed Off

The claimants, who are the wife, children and parents of a deceased agricultural worker, applied to the High Court for permission to withdraw half of the amount deposited by Liberty General Insurance Ltd. before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Solapur. The insurance company opposed, arguing that …

GAURI JAYANT SAWANT AND ORS.versusLIBERTY GENERAL INSURANCE LTD.

Disposed Off

The applicants, dependents of a deceased agriculturist who also ran a small hotel, sought to withdraw half of the amount deposited by Liberty General Insurance Ltd. with the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, arguing their financial dependence on the deceased. The insurer contended that the deceased's …

NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.versusSMT. KANTABAI SHIVAJI RUPNAVAR AND ORS.

Disposed Off

National Insurance Co. Ltd. filed an application seeking an interim stay of a judgment and award dated 3 July 2013. The company claimed to have deposited the amount as per the office note and asserted that the writ had been duly received. The court examined whether the deposit and receipt of the …

SAYAJI DNYANDEO LONDHE AND ORSversusSHRI. SATISH RAGHUNATH LONDHE AND ORS

Dismissed

The applicants filed a civil revision challenging an order dated 15 March 2012 issued under section 5 of the Mamlatdar’s Court Act, 1906, which had been allowed in favour of the respondents. The revision was previously rejected by the Sub‑Divisional Officer on 30 November 2015, confirming the …

RAMESH GENU SONAWANE AND ORSversusBAHIRU BHANUDAS GAVALI AND ANR.

Disposed Off

The applicants, Ramesh Genu Sonawane and others, filed a civil revision application before the Bombay High Court, Kolhapur Circuit Bench. During the proceedings, counsel for the applicants submitted that the revision application had become infructuous. The bench, after considering the submission, …

GO DIGIT GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., PUNEversusDRAUPADA NAMDEV PATIL AND ORS.

Disposed Off

The appellant, Go Digit General Insurance Co., appealed a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal award concerning a motor accident claim by Draupada Namdev Patil and others. The appellant had previously deposited Rs.37,41,487 with the Tribunal, of which the claimants had withdrawn Rs.24,31,966. The insurer, …

SHRI. RAJU @ DEVAPPA ANNA SHETTIversusMAJOR PRAKASH RAJGONDA PATIL (RETIRED)

Disposed Off

The applicant, Shri Raju @ Devappa Anna Shetti, filed a civil revision application before the Bombay High Court. Subsequently, the applicant's counsel instructed the court to withdraw the revision application. The court considered the request and, without further hearing, disposed of the application …

TEJAL YASH BOHARAversusYASH ANIL BOHARA

Disposed Off

The wife (applicant) filed a miscellaneous civil application seeking transfer of the divorce petition filed by her husband from the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Ichalkaranji to the Family Court at Ahmednagar, invoking her severe medical condition (heterozygous pathogenic variants in GNC gene …

AMRUTA VIJAY KHORATversusVIJAY SHRAVAN KHORAT

Disposed Off

The wife (Applicant) sought transfer of a divorce petition filed by her husband (Respondent) from the Civil Judge Senior Division Court at Gadhinglaj to the Court at Karad, citing the distance of 136 km and her residence with her mother and minor son in Karad. Mediation between the parties was …

Aishwarya Shrikant KadamversusShrikant Dattatray Kadam

Disposed Off

The applicant, Aishwarya Shrikant Kadam, filed a miscellaneous civil application seeking transfer of a marriage petition. The respondent, Shrikant Dattatray Kadam, subsequently withdrew the marriage petition. The applicant's counsel informed the court that the underlying petition was withdrawn, …

NETRA DYANESHWAR GIRMEversusDYANESHWAR ANKUSH GIRME

Allowed

The wife, Netra Dyaneshwar Girme, filed a miscellaneous civil application seeking transfer of the divorce petition filed by her husband, Dyaneshwar Ankush Girme, from the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Satara to the Family Court at Pune. She argued that she resides in Pune with two school‑going …

UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO.LTD,versusMINAKSHEE PRAMOD SHELAKE AND ORS.,

Disposed Off

The applicant, United India Insurance Co. Ltd, filed an interim application seeking restoration of its first appeal (No. 1932 of 2010) which had been dismissed for default on 15-12-2025. The application was filed immediately thereafter, within the prescribed time. The court examined the averments …

BALASAHEB KRISHNA MALIversusASST. REGISTRAR CO-OP. SOC. AND ORS

Disposed Off

The petitioner, Balasaheb Krishna Mali, filed a writ petition but repeatedly failed to supply required copies of documents and did not appear for hearings despite multiple extensions. Notices to the respondents could not be issued, and the petition was already dismissed against two respondents. On …

DHANASHRI SANTOSH RUPNARversusANNASAHEB KALLAPPA UPADHYE

Disposed Off

The applicants, Dhanashri Santosh Rupnar and others, filed a Civil Revision Application No. 345 of 2023 before the Bombay High Court, Kolhapur Circuit Bench, challenging a lower court order. During the hearing, counsel for the applicants informed the Court that they had instructions to withdraw the …

VIJAY BHUPAL PATILversusSANDHYA VIJAY PATIL (NEE MS. SANDHYA NAIR)

Disposed Off

The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging the proceedings of P.E. No. 111/2021, which was instituted by the respondent under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The petitioner’s counsel submitted that the Section 125 proceeding had been withdrawn, attaching copies of the …

ISMILE ABBAS TETVILKAR AND ORS.versusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Disposed Off

The applicants Navnath Waghmare, Ismile Abbas Tetvilkar and Hasan Abbas Tetvilkar filed a criminal application for leave to appeal before the Bombay High Court. During the hearing, counsel for the applicants informed the court that Applicants No.1 and No.2 wished to withdraw their applications. The …

SUNIL TUKARAM BORHADEversusCOLLECTOR, PUNE AND ORS.

Dismissed

Sunil Tukaram Borhade filed a writ petition challenging his disqualification under section 14 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act, 1958, seeking interim relief. The Collector had found him disqualified, an order confirmed by the Additional Commissioner. The petitioner applied for interim relief, …

MRS.JYOTI AMRISH BARKULEversusDNYANESHWAR MOTIRAM TALVEKAR and ORS.

Disposed Off

The petitioners challenged an order dated 2 March 2001 of the Assistant Charity Commissioner, Thane Region, which had granted permission under Section 51 of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 to the respondents to file a suit for possession of Survey No. 59‑B, Thane. The petitioners claimed to be …

SUNIL VISHNU DESAIversusSAKSHI SUNIL DESAI AND ANR

Disposed Off

The petitioner, a 63‑year‑old consultant, challenged a Family Court order dated 18‑03‑2021 that directed him to pay Rs.15,000 per month to his wife and Rs.8,000 per month to his 15‑year‑old daughter under Section 125 of the CrPC. He argued that he had resigned from his former job, earned only …

SHIRISH RATNAKAR KULKARNIversusTHE PRINCIPAL, B.N.N.COLLEGE, THANE AND ORS.

Dismissed

The petitioner, Shirish Ratnakar Kulkarni, filed a writ petition challenging an order of the Grievance Committee that dismissed his appeal against an oral termination on the ground of lack of jurisdiction. The petition was admitted in August 2006 but no interim relief was granted. During the hearing …

RADHESHYAM SEETALAPRASAD GUPTAversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA and ORS.

Dismissed

The petitioner, Radheshyam Seetalaprasad Gupta, challenged a 2004 order allocating ration shops, alleging the order was not implemented. The High Court directed the petitioner's counsel to contact the petitioner by registered post and report back. No response or evidence of communication was …

Swati Dhirajkumar SapkaleversusDhirajkumar Ramesh Sapkale

Disposed Off

The parties, Swati Dhirajkumar Sapkale and Dhirajkumar Ramesh Sapkale, had filed a petition for divorce by mutual consent in the Family Court at Nashik. Subsequently, the applicant filed an application for leave to appeal (Pvt.) No. 84 of 2025 before the Bombay High Court. The applicant's counsel …

UNION OF INDIAversusKISHOR BHIKAJI INGLE AND ANR.

Allowed

The State (Union of India) filed an application seeking leave to appeal a 2018 judgment of the Special (CBI) Judge in Pune that acquitted Sub‑Inspector Kishor Bhikaji Ingle, who was charged under Sections 7 and 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 for demanding a bribe from a …

SHIVRAM APPA GOVINDAPPA SAKHARE (DESD) LRS.versusBABULAL GANPAT PAGARE

Disposed Off

The petitioners sought a writ directing the respondent to deliver possession of a suit property. The respondent informed the court that vacant possession had already been handed over to the petitioners. The court scheduled a verification on 22 June 2026, but the petitioner's counsel could not …

PUNE HOUSING AND AREA DEVELOPMENT BOARDversusVITHAL SHRIPATI LADKAT

Allowed

The Pune Housing and Area Development Board (the Board) sought a writ under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution to set aside an order of the Appellate Officer that dismissed the Board's appeal and allowed the respondent's appeal, thereby staying an eviction order. The dispute concerned a flat …

SHARIQUE AHMAD MOHAMMAD WARIS MOMINversusSTATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS

Dismissed

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 seeking to quash a Criminal Miscellaneous Application under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C. filed by his wife and daughter for maintenance. The petitioner claimed that a Khula and a mutual‑consent divorce dated 25‑08‑2020 and 07‑09‑2020 respectively …

MORESHWAR HARI BHIDE DECD THR LHRSversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS

Disposed Off

The petitioners, heirs of the deceased petitioner, filed an interim application seeking a declaration that they had complied with the order dated 09.04.2026 directing them to take steps concerning the deceased petitioner. The petitioners argued that they had already been brought on record as legal …

ANAND PRAVINCHANDRA SHAHversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Allowed

The applicant, Anand Pravinchandra Shah, sought cancellation of a bailable warrant issued on 24.03.2026 after he failed to appear in a criminal revision proceeding. The court noted that the applicant was present in the courtroom and had a documented heart ailment that required hospitalization in …

M/S. VORA AND CO. AND ORSversusLILABEN MANIBHAI PATEL AND ORS

Disposed Off

The applicants filed a civil revision seeking correction of a bona fide mistake in the High Court's order dated 8 May 2026. The order had been reserved on 23 December 2025, but this reservation date was omitted from the pronouncement. The Court, acting suo motu, examined whether such a clerical …

MSTC LIMITEDversusShri Ishar Alloy Steels Limited

Allowed

MSTC Limited, a government company, filed an application to restore its earlier leave to appeal (ST) No. 639 of 2019 and a related delay‑condonation application (No. 1410 of 2019) which had been dismissed for default on 9 January 2026. The restoration application was filed 15 days late, and the …

PRAVIN JOSEPH PATHE AND ANR.versusM/S. KOTHARI ASSOCIATES AND ORS.

Dismissed

The appellant, Pravin Joseph Pathe & Anr., filed a criminal appeal challenging an acquittal under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. A fresh notice was issued in March 2026, but when police attempted service, the appellants could not be found at the address. No party appeared …

ANANDA ABAJI SHELARversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

Dismissed

Ananda Abaji Shelar filed a criminal revision application challenging an order of acquittal. The applicant failed to appear despite service of notice, and fresh notices were issued on 13.01.2026. Several respondents, including accused and villagers, were reported dead, with death certificates …

PRAKASH E. NIPHADKARversusVASANT SOMA CHAUDHARI

Disposed Off

The writ petition filed by Prakash E. Niphadkar in 2002 sought relief against Vasant Soma Chaudhari. A rule was granted in September 2002, but the petitioner's advocate was discharged in 2010. Subsequent court notices could not be served as the petitioner did not reside at the recorded address, and …

NAUTAM DAMJI SHAHversusARVIND ENGINEERING COMPANY AND ORS.

Allowed

The High Court examined a dispute arising under the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 concerning Godown No. 16 and the land beneath it. The plaintiffs, heirs of the deceased Damji Gelabhai Shah, claimed ownership of both the land and the godown based on a conveyance deed dated 12‑December‑2002, …

VISHWANATH SAKHARAM CHURIversusARVIND ENGINEERING COMPANY AND ORS.

Allowed

The dispute concerned Godown No. 16 and the land beneath it in Lower Parel, Mumbai, governed by the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999. The original owners, New Sun Mills Co., had let the premises to Arvind Engineering Company in 1956 and later agreed to sell the godown for Rs 20,000 in 1981, while …

M/S K.A. SHAH AND CO.versusINDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT BANK OF INDIA LTD.

Disposed Off

M/s K.A. Shah & Co. filed an interim application in a civil revision proceeding against IDBI Ltd., seeking an early date of hearing. The applicant’s counsel indicated that the prayer for the respondent to deposit money in court would be postponed to the final hearing. The court noted that all …

SMT. CHANDADEVI CHOUDHARYversusM/S. STATE TRADING CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

Disposed Off

The High Court considered a group of civil revision applications filed by several landlords against State Trading Corporation of India Ltd. (STC) seeking higher mesne profits for premises on the 6th floor of Maker Chamber No. IV, Nariman Point. The trial court had awarded Rs 12 per sq ft per month, …

M/S. ANNAPURNA PROPERTIESversusM/S. STATE TRADING CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

Disposed Off

The High Court considered a group of civil revision applications filed by several landlords against State Trading Corporation of India Ltd. (STC) seeking higher mesne profits for premises on the 6th floor of Maker Chamber No. IV, Nariman Point. The trial court had awarded Rs 12 per sq ft per month, …

SMT.LALITA DEVI JAJODIAversusM/S. STATE TRADING CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.

Disposed Off

The High Court considered a group of civil revision applications filed by several landlords against State Trading Corporation of India Ltd. (STC) seeking higher mesne profits for premises on the 6th floor of Maker Chamber No. IV, Nariman Point. The trial court had awarded Rs 12 per sq ft per month, …

VISHWAS BHIKAJI REDKAR (SINCE DECD.) THROUGH LRS.versusNARAYAN GOPINATH PATIL

Disposed Off

The petitioners filed an application to bring on record the legal heirs of deceased petitioner No.3, who died a bachelor. The application was filed after a delay, and the petitioners sought condonation of that delay. The court examined the circumstances, noting that petitioners Nos.2a to 2c were …

SMT. AMIRA AMAR MISHRA AND ORS.versusFUTURE GENERALI INDIA INS. CO. LTD.,MUMBAI

Dismissed

Future Generali India Insurance Co. appealed against an order that held it and the vehicle owner jointly liable to pay compensation to six claimants under the Employee's Compensation Act, 1923. The insurer argued that a private‑investigator statement (Exhibit C‑12) showed the owner denied any …

FUTURE GENERALI INDIA INS. CO. LTD.,MUMBAIversusSMT. AMIRA AMAR MISHRA AND ORS.

Dismissed

Future Generali India Insurance Co. appealed against an order that held it and the vehicle owner jointly liable to pay compensation to six claimants under the Employee's Compensation Act, 1923. The insurer argued that a private‑investigator statement (Exhibit C‑12) showed the owner denied any …

FUTURE GENERALI INDIA INS. CO. LTD.,MUMBAIversusSMT. AMIRA AMAR MISHRA AND ORS.

Disposed Off

Future Generali India Insurance Co. appealed against an order that held it and the vehicle owner jointly liable to pay compensation to six claimants under the Employee's Compensation Act, 1923. The insurer argued that a private‑investigator statement (Exhibit C‑12) showed the owner denied any …