Created by Fuzzy Cloud

M Y EQBAL

134 judgments · newest first · showing 1–134

TEKAN ALIAS TEKRAMversusSTATE OF MADHYA PRADESH (NOW CHHATTISGARH)

2016 INSC 157Dismissed

The appellant, Tekan alias Tekram, was convicted under Section 376 IPC for raping a blind, illiterate girl after promising marriage. The trial and High Court upheld the conviction, finding the prosecution proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The appellant appealed, challenging both the conviction …

HAMANT YASHWANT DHAGEversusSTATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS

2016 INSC 153Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Hamant Yashwant Dhage, filed a complaint and sought registration of an FIR for a cognizable offence. The Judicial Magistrate refused to register the FIR, prompting the appellant to approach the High Court via a writ petition, which also declined to direct registration. The Supreme …

THE STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION & ANR.versusTHE STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION & ANR.

2016 INSC 136Case Partly allowed

The Kerala Public Service Commission (PSC) was approached by examinees seeking, under the Right to Information Act, scanned copies of their answer sheets, the tabulation sheet containing interview marks, and the names of the examiners who evaluated their papers. The State Public Information Officer …

STATE OF U.P. & ORS.versusRAVINDRA KUMAR SHARMA & ORS.

2016 INSC 129Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants obtained disability certificates from a Medical Board under the Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Rules, 1996 and were selected for a BTC training course reserved for physically handicapped candidates. A complaint by the …

VIPINCHANDRA VADILAL BAVISHI (D) BY LRS. AND ANOTHERversusSTATE OF GUJARAT AND OTHERS

2016 INSC 102Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants, land‑holders of plots 36‑43 in Survey No. 71, challenged the State of Gujarat's claim that their land had vested in the State under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976, on the basis of a handwritten corrigendum and a panchnama. The Supreme Court examined whether such a …

STATE OF RAJASTHANversusRAM KAILASH ALIAS RAM VILAS

2016 INSC 100Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Rajasthan prosecuted Ram Kailash alias Ram Vilas for shooting Mangla Ram, who later died from his injuries. The trial court convicted the accused under Section 302 IPC (murder) and sections of the Arms Act, imposing life imprisonment and additional terms. On appeal, the Rajasthan High …

BIHAR STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD & ORS.versusMIS. BHOLA RAM STEEL PVT. LTD. & ORS.

2016 INSC 101Appeal(s) allowed

The Bihar State Electricity Board (BSEB) sought to recover minimum guarantee charges from Mis. Bhola Ram Steel Pvt. Ltd., an industrial unit that had been granted exemption under the 1995 Industrial Policy for a connected load of up to 500 KVA. The Board argued that the consumer’s Maximum Demand …

SATISH KUMARversusKARAN SINGH AND ANOTHER

2016 INSC 84Appeal(s) allowed

The Delhi Development Authority allotted a lease‑hold plot to the defendant with a condition that the plot could not be transferred for ten years. The defendant executed a receipt‑agreement to sell his rights in the plot to the plaintiff for Rs 4.60 lakh, receiving an initial payment of Rs 2.30 …

RESERVE BANK OF INDIAversusJAYANTILAL N. MISTRY

2015 INSC 942Dismissed

The Supreme Court examined whether the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) could refuse to disclose information obtained from banks under the Right to Information (RTI) Act on the grounds of fiduciary relationship, economic interest, or commercial confidence. The Court held that RBI does not have a …

LAL SHAH BABA DARGAH TRUSTversusMAGNUM DEVELOPERS AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 925Case Partly allowed

The Lal Shah Baba Dargah Trust filed a suit before the single‑member Maharashtra Waqf Tribunal seeking injunction against alleged illegal development of waqf property. The respondents obtained a civil revision, arguing that the 2013 Wakf (Amendment) Act, which mandates a three‑member tribunal, …

PARIVARTAN KENDRAversusUNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 893Disposed off

The Supreme Court entertained a public‑interest writ under Article 32 on behalf of two Dalit sisters who were victims of a brutal acid attack in Bihar. The petitioners argued that the compensation of Rs 3 lakhs per victim prescribed in the earlier Laxmi judgment was grossly inadequate given the …

VENNANGOT ANURADHA SAMIRversusVENNANGOT MOHANDAS SAMIR

2015 INSC 884Appeal(s) allowed

The husband filed a petition for divorce on the ground of cruelty and sought transfer of the case from Bombay to Hyderabad. The parties entered into a settlement agreement where the husband promised to pay Rs.12.5 lakh as full and final alimony at the time of a mutual consent divorce decree. The …

STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AND OTHERSversusASHWANI KUMAR AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 866Appeal(s) allowed

The case concerned the interpretation of the Himachal Pradesh Ceiling on Land Holdings Act, 1972, specifically the calculation of permissible area for a family consisting of a husband, wife, an adult son and three minor children. The predecessor-in-interest, Dev Raj, held 2400 kanals of land and was …

STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND OTHERSversusUNITED BANK OF INDIA AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 867Disposed off

The State of Uttar Pradesh leased a Nazul (government) property at 19 Clive Road, Allahabad to a private company, which later mortgaged its leasehold interest to United Bank of India without obtaining prior State sanction. The Bank obtained a mortgage decree and later sought conversion of the …

K. S. SOUNDARARAJAN AND ORS.versusCOMMISSIONER OF H.R. & C.E.AND ORS.

2015 INSC 853Dismissed

Sundararaja Naidu's 1949 will bequeathed certain properties and directed his brother's son to manage them and perform specific charitable rites. Five members of the testator's community applied under Section 64 of the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959 to have a scheme …

BRIJ BIHARI SINGHversusBIHAR STATE FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 847Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, an Assistant General Manager of Bihar State Financial Corporation, was suspended and subjected to disciplinary proceedings on multiple charges of financial misconduct. The enquiry was conducted by an officer who examined only the files without hearing the appellant or presenting any …

RAKESH MOHINDRAversusANITA BERI AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 836Appeal(s) allowed

The plaintiffs filed a suit under the Specific Relief Act seeking a declaration of title over a property. The defendant sought to prove a disclaimer letter by secondary evidence because the original was allegedly misplaced in the custody of the DEO, Ambala, and submitted a photocopy along with a …

JUPUDYPARDHASARATHYversusPENTAPATI RAMA KRISHNA AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 834Dismissed

The case concerned a property bequeathed by P. Venkata Subba Rao in 1920 to his third wife Veeraghavamma for her lifetime as maintenance. After the husband's death, Veeraghavamma occupied the house, and the question arose whether her limited life interest under the Will became an absolute right …

GURUDASSING NAWOOSING PANJWANIversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRAAND OTHERS

2015 INSC 833Dismissed

Gurudassing Nawoosing Panjwani, a displaced person, was allotted land under the Displaced Persons Act but later faced competing mutation entries arising from a series of revenue proceedings. Multiple revisions and appeals were filed under the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966, culminating in a …

ASHOK RANGNTH NAGARversusSHRIKANT GOVINDRAO SANGVIKAR

2015 INSC 806Matter referred to larger bench

The respondents filed a suit for perpetual injunction which was dismissed by the trial court; the first appeal to the District Judge also dismissed the suit. The respondents then filed a second appeal before the Bombay High Court. The High Court reversed both the trial court and the first appellate …

N. SUNKANNAversusSTATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH

2015 INSC 769Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a Deputy Tahsildar, was alleged to have demanded a bribe of Rs.300 from a fair‑price shop owner and was caught in a trap where tainted currency notes were recovered from his possession. The complainant later turned hostile, and no other witness testified to the demand. The trial and …

RAZIAAMIRALI SHROFF AND OTHERSversusM/S NISHUVI CORPORATION AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 762Disposed off

The petitioners filed a Notice of Motion (No.3616 of 2010) in the Bombay High Court seeking interim reliefs during the pendency of a suit. The Single Judge declined to grant any ad‑interim order, directing the parties to file affidavits and setting a hearing date. The petitioners appealed, but the …

DULU DEVIversusSTATE OF ASSAM AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 759Appeal(s) allowed

Oulu Devi, a teacher appointed in 1976 and regularised in 1989, served continuously for over 25 years. After a period of non-payment of salary, a High Court order directed the authorities to release her salary and investigate regularisation, which they complied with. Later, the authorities stopped …

KANACHUR ISLAMIC EDUCATION TRUST(R)versusUNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER

2015 INSC 722Dismissed

The Kanachur Islamic Education Trust applied to the Government of India for permission to start a new MBBS college for 2015‑16. After obtaining state‑level clearances, the Medical Council of India (MCI) inspected the college and reported numerous deficiencies in faculty, infrastructure and clinical …

SARASWATI MEDICAL COLLEGEversusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2015 INSC 723Disposed off

Saraswati Medical College sought a Letter of Permission to start a new MBBS programme with 150 seats for the 2015‑16 academic year. The Medical Council of India (MCI) inspected the college, identified deficiencies, and after a second inspection raised further deficiencies, leading the Union of India …

SONI KUMARIversusDEEPAK KUMAR

2015 INSC 669Appeal(s) allowed

Soni Kumari and Deepak Kumar, married in 2009, lived separately from 2014 due to irreconcilable differences and filed a joint petition for divorce by mutual consent under Section 13‑8(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act. The Family Court allowed the first motion but refused to waive the statutory six‑month …

MASTER SATYAM GANDHIversusUNION TERRITORY, CHANDIGARH AND ORS.

2015 INSC 668Dismissed

The appellant, a student who had passed Class X, applied for admission to the medical stream in Class XI at St. Jones School, a private unaided minority institution affiliated to the CBSE. The school rejected his request on the basis of his pre‑board marks and an aptitude test, offering him a seat …

SANDU (D) BY LRS.versusGU LAB (D) BY LRS. AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 639Appeal(s) allowed

The case concerned land originally owned by a tribal person that had been sold to a non‑tribal transferee. The Assistant Collector initially dropped restoration proceedings under Section 4 of the Maharashtra Restoration of Lands to Scheduled Tribes Act, 1974, because the tribal transferor was …

KSH. LAKSHAHEB SINGH AND OTHERS.versusSTATE OF MANIPURAND OTHERS

2015 INSC 629Disposed off

The appellants, Section Officers Grade‑I in Manipur's Public Health Engineering Department, sought promotion to Assistant Engineer under the 60% promotion quota, contending that the recruitment rules apply to vacancies, not to the total cadre strength. The State had previously imposed a ban on …

U.V. MAHADKARversusSUBHASH ANAND CHAVAN AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 628Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, U.V. Mahadkar, was selected as Head of the Department of Agronomy by a committee constituted under Statute 41 of the Maharashtra Agricultural Universities Statutes, 1990. Respondent Subhash Anand Chavan challenged the selection, and the Bombay High Court set it aside, directing a …

K. NANJAPPA (DEAD) BY LRS.versusR.A. HAMEED ALIAS AMEERSAB (DEAD) BY LRS. AND ANOTHER

2015 INSC 625Appeal(s) allowed

The appeal arose from a suit for specific performance of a sale agreement dated 2 September 1967 concerning immovable property. The agreement was written on a quarter‑sheet of paper and was produced in a criminal proceeding, leading the High Court to decree specific performance in favour of the …

DR. TAPAS KUMAR MAN DAL AND OTHERS & ETC.versusSTATE OF WEST BENGALAND OTHERS

2015 INSC 624Dismissed

The appellants, in‑service doctors who had completed postgraduate diplomas between 2012 and 2014, applied for government‑sponsored seats in the 2015 West Bengal Post‑Graduate Medical Admission Test and were initially placed on the select list. Subsequently, the Government issued a notification …

GURDAS SINGH AND OTHERS ETC.versusSTATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 622Appeal(s) allowed

The petitioners, teachers originally appointed in the school cadre, had been transferred to two Sanskrit institutes that were treated as colleges and had been teaching there for more than 25 years. They claimed parity of pay with college lecturers, arguing that they performed the same duties and …

PADMASHREE DR. D.Y. PATIL MEDICAL COLLEGEversusMEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA & ANR.

2015 INSC 621Dismissed

Padmashree Dr. D.Y. Patil Medical College applied to the Central Government for an increase in MBBS seats for the 2015-16 academic session but failed to attach the mandatory essentiality certificate, resulting in the application’s rejection. The college sought condonation of the delay and a …

HANUMAPPA CHANNAPPA HULLUR (D) BY LRS.versusSHIVAMARUTHAPPA PARAPPA KALLI & ORS.

2015 INSC 592Disposed off

The plaintiff sought specific performance of a sale agreement executed by the father (vendor) who claimed to sell an entire joint family property, although he owned only a one‑third share. The High Court dismissed the suit, holding the agreement invalid without the consent of the other co‑owners. …

K.K.GOHILversusSTATE OF GUJARAT AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 569Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a government employee, completed nine years of service and was granted a higher grade pay scale under the 1994 Government Resolution. The departmental examination required for confirming the promotion was never conducted, yet the higher pay scale was later withdrawn on the ground of …

CHIEF CONTROLLING REVENUE AUTHORITYversusCOSTAL GUJARAT POWER LTD. AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 563Appeal(s) allowed

Coastal Gujarat Power Ltd obtained loans from thirteen financial institutions which formed a consortium and appointed State Bank of India as a security trustee. The borrower executed a single mortgage deed (Indenture of Mortgage) with the trustee, paying Rs 4.21 lakh stamp duty. The Gujarat revenue …

A.N. SACHDEVA (DEAD) BY LRS. & ORS.versusMAHARSHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY, ROHTAK &ANR.

2015 INSC 555Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants, former employees of Punjab University and Kurukshetra University who later joined Maharshi Dayanand University (MDU), claimed that their uninterrupted service in the earlier universities should be counted as qualifying service for pension under MDU's 1997 pension scheme. The …

RAJESHWAR BABURAO BONEversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER

2015 INSC 531Dismissed

The appellant, Rajeshwar Baburao Bone, claimed membership in the Kali Mahadev scheduled tribe to obtain a post reserved for Scheduled Tribes in the Zilla Parishad, Beed, and was issued a tribe validity certificate after a Scrutiny Committee verification in 2010. After it emerged that his brother's …

DHARAM CHANDversusCHAIRMAN, NEW DELHI MUNICIPAL COUNCIL AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 533Dismissed

Dharm Chand, a hawker who had been allotted a Tehbazari kiosk opposite the Supreme Court, was ordered by the New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) to relocate his stall to a site near Baroda House on security grounds following a bomb blast near the Delhi High Court in 2011. He challenged the order, …

DM WAYANAD INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCESversusUNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER

2015 INSC 515Dismissed

The DM Wayanad Institute of Medical Sciences and another institute filed writ petitions under Article 32 challenging the Medical Council of India's (MCI) refusal to recommend renewal of permission for MBBS admissions for the 2015‑16 session and the Union Government's consequent denial of that …

N.K. RAJENDRA MOHANversusTHIRVAMADI RUBBER CO. LTD. & ORS.

2015 INSC 471Dismissed

In 1918 the plaintiffs leased 963.75 acres of land to Mr. Campbell Hunt for 36 years, allowing the lessee to cultivate any crop and clear forests. The lease later passed to Thiruvamadi Rubber Co., which continued possession after the lease expired, paying rent until 1978 and establishing a rubber …

BILASPUR RAIPUR KSHETRIYAGRAMIN BANKANDANRversusMADANLAL TANDON

2015 INSC 429Dismissed

The respondent, a former field supervisor of a bank, was subjected to two departmental inquiries resulting in removal from service. He challenged the second inquiry, arguing that the charge-sheet was not accompanied by the list of documents or the documents themselves, depriving him of a fair …

MAHILA RAMKALI DEVI AND OTHERSversusNANDRAM (D) THR. LRS. AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 412Case Partly allowed

The plaintiff filed a suit in 1964 seeking declaration of title and possession of agricultural land based on a will executed by Ajuddhibai. The trial court upheld the will, rejected alleged sale deeds and granted possession to the plaintiff. The defendants appealed, and the High Court reversed the …

UNION OF INDIA & ORS.versusMANJEET SINGH

2015 INSC 402Dismissed

Manjeet Singh joined the Indian Army in 1999 and was later diagnosed with generalized tonic‑clonic seizures and neurotic depression, leading to his invalidation in 2002 with a composite disability of 20%. The Medical Board denied him a disability pension, concluding the ailments were constitutional …

UNION OF INDIA & ORS.versusSHRI HANUMAN INDUSTRIES & ANR.

2015 INSC 394Appeal(s) allowed

The Union of India and the North Eastern Council (NEC) implemented the Scheme of Promotion of Industries in North East (SPINE) to provide financial assistance to new industries. Several applicants obtained a court order in 2007 directing the authorities to process their applications, a decision …

RAMGARH FARMS AND INDUSTRIES LTD.versusSTATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 340Dismissed

Ramgarh Farms and Industries Ltd. held land under a lease dated 25 January 1951, which was later deemed invalid as a tenure holder under the Uttar Pradesh Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950. The Uttar Pradesh Imposition of Ceiling on Land Holdings Act, 1960 initially declared 5,446 acres …

MONOJ LAL SEAL AND OTHERSversusOCTAVIOUS TEAAND INDUSTRIES LTD.

2015 INSC 342Dismissed

The landlords filed an eviction suit against Octavious Tea & Industries Ltd for non-payment of rent. The tenant filed applications under Sections 7(1) and 7(2) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997. The trial court allowed the Section 7(1) application but directed the tenant to deposit …

DHANUULALAND OTHERSversusGANESHRAMANDANOTHER

2015 INSC 295Dismissed

The dispute concerned a property inherited by Phoolbasa Bai after her husband's death and a subsequent sale of a portion of that property to Mukesh Kumar Chourasia. The plaintiff, Ganeshram, challenged both the validity of a 1977 will favouring Phoolbasa Bai's brothers and the 1987 sale deed, …

DR. AMBICA PRASADversusMD. ALAM AND ANOTHER

2015 INSC 299Appeal(s) allowed

Dr. Ambica Prasad filed an eviction suit against Abdul Karim, claiming ownership of the tenanted premises through exchange deeds executed with his brother, the original owner. The trial court held that the appellant was not the landlord, but the appellate court reversed this, finding him to be the …

BALASAHEB ARJUN TORBOLE & ORS.versusTHE ADMINISTRATOR & DIVISIONAL COMMISSIONER

2015 INSC 280Dismissed

The appellants, residents of slums on privately owned plots in Kurla, challenged the approval of a slum rehabilitation scheme that treated their private plots together with adjoining municipal plots as a single slum area. They argued that the authorities wrongly clubbed the lands, that consent of …

MANMEET SINGH ALIAS GOLDIEversusSTATE OF PUNJAB

2015 INSC 253Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant Manmeet Singh (alias Goldie) was convicted under Section 396 of the Indian Penal Code for dacoity with murder, based on an alleged robbery of a large sum of money and the killing of Mohinder Singh. The prosecution alleged that five or more persons participated in the dacoity, but only …

SHYAM LALversusDEEPA DASS CHELA RAM CHELA GARIB DASS

2016 INSC 496Matter referred to larger bench

Shyam Lal, the appellant, claimed continuous possession of agricultural land in Faridabad for about 27 years under a lease that expired in May 2005, asserting that he became a statutory tenant protected by the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953. The respondent, Deepa Dass Chela Ram Chela …

M/S. SHERALI KHAN MOHAMED MANEKIAversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 177Dismissed

The appellant purchased an evacuee property and filed a suit in 1980 seeking specific performance of the sale, possession and the appointment of a court receiver. The trial court denied the receiver, but the High Court on appeal appointed one to take possession, collect rent and account for profits. …

RAVINDRAversusSTATE OF MADHYA PRADESH

2015 INSC 170Disposed off

Ravindra was convicted under Section 376(1) IPC for raping Narmadabai in 1994 and sentenced to ten years' rigorous imprisonment. The appellant challenged the conviction on grounds of lack of physical injury, insufficient semen evidence, contradictions in the victim's testimony, and the absence of …

AMRUTLAL LILADHARBHAI KOTAK & ORS.versusSTATE OF GUJARAT

2015 INSC 167Dismissed

The deceased, Truptiben, married in 1996 and allegedly faced repeated dowry demands and mental harassment by her husband and his relatives, leading her to commit suicide by hanging in 2000, within seven years of marriage. A criminal complaint was filed under Sections 498A, 304B, 306 and 114 of the …

SUNIL HARIBHAU KALEversusAVINASH GULABRAO MARDIKAR AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 144Dismissed

In the Amravati Municipal Corporation election of 2012, 23 councillors formed an "aghadi" (group) and elected Avinash Gulabrao Mardikar as its leader. In 2014, the General Secretary of the Nationalist Congress Party sought to replace Mardikar with Sunil Haribhau Kale, and the Divisional Commissioner …

M/S. SUNDARAM FINANCE LIMITED AND ANOTHERversusT. THANKAM

2015 INSC 141Disposed off

Sundaram Finance Ltd. filed a suit for injunction to restrain the repossession of a vehicle financed to T. Thankam. The loan agreement contained an arbitration clause (clause 22) and a repossession clause (clause 14.6). The respondent filed the injunction suit in a civil court; the appellant moved …

M/S. BHANDARI UDYOG LIMITEDversusINDUSTRIAL FACILITATION COUNCIL AND ANR.

2015 INSC 140Appeal(s) allowed

M/s. Bhandari Udyog Ltd., a cotton ginning business in Raichur, Karnataka, sold 750 bales of cotton to Respondent No.2, a spinning mill in Latur, Maharashtra. A dispute over the unpaid balance was referred to arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and an award was made …

RASHMI BEHLversusSTATE OF U.P. & ORS.

2015 INSC 130

The petitioner, a 22‑year‑old woman from Uttar Pradesh, filed a writ petition under Article 32 alleging that she was abducted, repeatedly assaulted and raped by her father and his accomplices, and that the police failed to record her statement under Section 164 CrPC or conduct a medical examination …

PETROMARINE PRODUCTS LTD.versusOCEAN MARINE SERVICES COMPANY LTD. & ORS.

2015 INSC 124Dismissed

Petromarine Products Ltd. filed an admiralty suit in the Bombay High Court seeking a decree and attachment of sale proceeds of the vessel MV Eleni, which was already arrested and placed under the jurisdiction of the Madras High Court where a suit by another creditor had been filed. The Madras Court, …

RAVEESH CHAND JAINversusRAJ RANI JAIN

2015 INSC 111Dismissed

The mother (respondent) sued her son (appellant) for possession of a property she claimed to have purchased with her own funds and for damages. The son contended the property was a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) asset bought with ancestral money. An earlier partition suit filed by the son was …

BHIM SINGH AND ANR.versusSTATE OF UTIARAKHAND

2015 INSC 107Dismissed

The Supreme Court examined the death of Prema Devi, who died within five months of marriage with extensive burn injuries and traces of poison. The prosecution alleged that she was subjected to cruelty and harassment by her husband Bhim Singh and his brothers in connection with dowry demands, …

DASIN BAI@ SHANTI BAIversusSTATE OF CHHATTISGARH

2015 INSC 105Dismissed

The appellant, Dasin Bai, was convicted of murder under Section 302 IPC for setting the deceased, Raju Rajak, on fire after pouring kerosene on him. The prosecution relied on the victim's oral dying declaration recorded in hospital, which was corroborated by two eyewitnesses present at the time. The …

EXECUTIVE OFFICER, ANTIYUR TOWN PANCHAYATversusG. ARUMUGAM (D) BY LRS.

2015 INSC 49Appeal(s) allowed

The Executive Officer of Antiyur Town Panchayat appealed against a High Court order that refused to condone a 1373‑day delay in filing a second appeal against a decree granting possession of land to G. Arumugam. The original suit was dismissed, the first appeal was allowed, but the Panchayat took no …

STATE OF PUNJABversusBAWA SINGH

2015 INSC 45Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Punjab appealed against the High Court’s order reducing Bawa Singh’s sentence for assault with a gandasa (IPC s.326) to the period already served. The trial court had convicted Singh and his wife under sections 326, 323 and 34 IPC, imposing rigorous imprisonment of three years and one …

M/S. PEPSICO INDIA HOLDING PVT. LTD.versusKRISHNA KANT PANDEY

2015 INSC 9Appeal(s) allowed

Krishna Kant Pandey, employed by Pepsico India Holding Pvt. Ltd., was terminated after serving in various supervisory roles, most recently as Fleet Executive. He claimed that he was a "workman" under Section 2(z) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and that his termination violated …

INDER SINGH & ORS.versusSTATE OF RAJASTHAN

2015 INSC 7Disposed off

Four villagers were killed and an informant seriously injured in a violent clash in Dhodi village, Rajasthan, leading to the charge of murder and grievous hurt against 29 co‑villagers. The trial court convicted 24 of them under Sections 302, 307 and 149 of the IPC, while five were acquitted; …

NARGIS JAL HARADHVALAversusSTATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS

2015 INSC 6Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Nargis Jal Haradhvala, obtained a Section 20 exemption under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 for a parcel of land in Mumbai, with an initial condition to surrender 30% of the permissible floor space to government‑nominated allottees. A 1990 government corrigendum …

M/S. RAM BARAI SINGH & CO.versusSTATE OF BIHAR & ORS.

2014 INSC 881Appeal(s) allowed

M/s. Ram Bara Singh & Co. appealed against a Division Bench order that set aside a Patna High Court judgment allowing its writ petition under Art. 226. The respondents argued that an arbitration clause in the 1989 contract made the writ petition non‑maintainable, even though the contract had been …

S. SESHACHALAM & ORS. ETC.versusCHAIRMAN, BAR COUNCIL OF TAMIL NADU & ORS.

2014 INSC 869Dismissed

The petitioners, retired government employees who later enrolled as advocates, challenged the proviso in Section 16 Explanation II (5) of the Tamil Nadu Advocates' Welfare Fund Act, 1987 that denied a lump‑sum payment of Rs 2 lakh to the nominees of advocates already receiving pension or other …

M/S. GOVIND RUBBER LTD.versusM/S. LOUIDS DREYFUS COMMODITIES ASIA PVT. LTD.

2014 INSC 1042Dismissed

The appeal concerned a dispute between Govind Rubber Ltd. (appellant) and Louids Dreyfus Commodities Asia Pvt. Ltd. (respondent) over two sales contracts for natural rubber that contained an arbitration clause referring disputes to the Singapore Commodity Exchange. The appellant argued that no valid …

SRI PRABIN RAM PHUKAN &ANR.versusSTATE OF ASSAM & ORS.

2014 INSC 860Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants, co‑landholders of a 59‑bigha estate in Assam, failed to pay Rs 731.70 land revenue, leading the Deputy Commissioner to auction the land under Section 70 of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886. No proper notice of demand or sale was served on the appellants, and the auction …

K.K. SINGHAL & ORS.versusSTEEL STRIPS LTD.

2014 INSC 845Dismissed

The appellants K.K. Singhal & Ors. issued 33 cheques that were dishonoured, leading the respondent Steel Strips Ltd. to file 26 complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The parties later entered into a settlement at Chandigarh, where the respondent agreed to withdraw the …

DISTRICT MAGISTRATE, HARIDWAR AND ANR.versusHARISH MALHOTRA

2014 INSC 851Dismissed

The respondent, a cable television network operator registered under the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995, began transmitting two private video channels and was directed by the District Magistrate of Haridwar to pay a license fee of Rs.11,88,500 under Rule 17(2) of the Uttar Pradesh …

KANCHANBEN PURSHOTTAMBHAI BHANDERIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

2014 INSC 839Dismissed

The case involved the suicide of Hina, a daughter‑in‑law, who allegedly faced mental and physical harassment and dowry demands from her mother‑in‑law, Kanchanben. The trial court convicted Kanchanben under IPC sections 3048 (dowry death) and 498A (cruelty) and under sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry …

KAREDLA PARTHASARADHIversusGANGULA RAMANAMMA (D) THROUGH L.RS & ORS.

2014 INSC 835Directions issued

The deceased K. Satyanarayna died intestate, and his brother Karedla Parthasaradhi claimed inheritance of the suit house. Defendant Gangula Ramanamma (defendant No.1) asserted that she was the deceased's legally married wife, having lived with him for over three decades, and thus claimed ownership …

UNION OF INDIA ETC. REP. THROUGH SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICEversusT. NATHAMUNI

2014 INSC 824Appeal(s) allowed

A complaint of bribery was lodged against T. Nathamuni, an Income Tax Inspector, leading to a CBI case under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The investigating officer, initially an Inspector of Police, was replaced by Sub‑Inspector G.A. Suriya Kumar after a petition under Section 17 of the …

GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AND ANOTHERversusK. VARALAKSHMIAND OTHERS

2014 INSC 813Dismissed

The case concerned a 5‑acre parcel of land originally assigned to a landless poor woman, Sagiraju Bangaramma, who sold it in 1970 to another landless poor person, Durga Ramalingeswara Rao, before the Andhra Pradesh Assigned Lands (Prohibition of Transfers) Act, 1977 came into force. After Rao’s …

ARCHANA GIRISH SABNISversusBAR COUNCIL OF INDIA AND OTHERS

2014 INSC 811Dismissed

Archana Girish Sabnis, who held a Licentiate of the Court of Examiners in Homoeopathy (LCEH), was admitted to an LLB programme at the University of Mumbai, completed her law degrees and applied for enrollment as an advocate. The Bar Council of Maharashtra and Goa, and subsequently the Bar Council of …

STATE OF MADHYA PRADESHversusSURENDRA SINGH

2014 INSC 774Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant State of Madhya Pradesh appealed against a High Court order that reduced the sentence of Surendra Singh, who was convicted for causing death by rash and negligent driving of a jeep. The trial court had sentenced him under IPC sections 279, 337 and 304‑A to six months and two years of …

EMBASSY HOTELS PVT.LTD.versusMIS. GAJARAJ & CO. & ORS.

2014 INSC 1026Appeal(s) allowed

Embassy Hotels Pvt. Ltd. filed a suit for specific performance of a 1978 agreement for sale of land that had been mortgaged by the vendor, M/s. Gajaraj & Co., to Srinivasa Perumal Financing Corporation. The mortgaged land was sold by court auction to the appellant, who obtained a sale certificate …

INBASEGARAM AND ANOTHERversusS. NATARAJAN (DEAD) THR. LRS.

2014 INSC 748Disposed off

The plaintiff (Inbasegaran) filed two suits against the defendant (S. Natarajan) – one for a permanent injunction to prevent forcible dispossession of a constructed building, and a later suit for specific performance of a sale agreement. The defendant contended that the second suit was barred by …

ZARINA SIDDIQUIversusA. RAMALINGAMALIAS R.AMARNATHAN

2014 INSC 752Appeal(s) allowed

The plaintiff sought specific performance of a 1979 agreement whereby the first defendant, owner of a one‑third undivided share in a Bangalore property, through his brother (the second defendant) who held a registered power of attorney, agreed to sell the share for Rs 40,000. The plaintiff paid the …

KULDEEP KAURversusSTATE OF UTIARAKHAND

2014 INSC 737Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Kuldeep Kaur, the mother‑in‑law of Jagpreet Kaur, was convicted under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code for abetment of suicide after the bride died by hanging within four months of marriage. The prosecution alleged dowry demands and harassment, but the trial court found no …

PRADEEP KUMAR MASKARA AND OTHERSversusSTATE OF WEST BENGAL AND OTHERS

2014 INSC 733Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants owned agricultural land that was transferred from Bihar to West Bengal under the Bihar and West Bengal (Transferred Territories) Act, 1956, and the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 was extended to the transferred territories. The Calcutta High Court, in a 1984 writ petition, quashed …

AK DEVAIAHversusSTATE OF KARNATAKA

2014 INSC 715Dismissed

The Supreme Court examined the appeal of A.K. Devaiah, convicted under Sections 3, 4, 6 of the Dowry Prohibition Act and Sections 498‑A and 304‑B of the IPC for the death of his wife, who committed suicide by self‑immolation within a year of marriage. The prosecution proved that the husband demanded …

P.S. MEHERHOMJIversusK.T. VIJAY KUMAR & ORS.

2014 INSC 710Dismissed

The appellant, a company secretary of Rallis India Ltd., was accused in a private complaint of defamation under Sections 499 and 500 IPC for a letter allegedly sent to Ashika Capital Ltd. that contained false allegations against the complainants. The trial court took cognizance of the complaint and …

R. N. AGARWALversusR. C. BANSAL & ORS.

2014 INSC 720Appeal(s) allowed

The CBI filed a charge‑sheet in a Special Court under the Prevention of Corruption Act against six persons for conspiracy, forgery and corruption. The Special Judge, exercising powers under Section 5 of the Act and the Code of Criminal Procedure, summoned three additional persons who had been listed …

PATEL MAHESHBHAI RANCHODBHAI AND OTHERSversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

2014 INSC 687Dismissed

The case involved the suicide of Renukaben Patel, a married woman, who alleged severe physical and mental cruelty by her husband and in‑laws before setting herself on fire in her matrimonial home. The trial court, after a hurried nine‑day trial, acquitted all accused except the husband (convicted …

LIYAKAT AND ANOTHERversusSTATE OF RAJASTHAN

2014 INSC 689Disposed off

The case arose from the alleged murder of Jumila in a dowry dispute, for which Liyakat, Ajeem Khan and others were convicted under Sections 302, 498A and 201 of the IPC. The High Court set aside the conviction, holding that material incriminating the accused had not been put to them under Section …

PREM KUMAR GULATIversusSTATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER

2014 INSC 668Disposed off

The deceased Rajni died from severe burns after kerosene oil was poured on her and she was set alight. Her dying declaration named her husband Mahender Singh, her brother‑in‑law Prem Kumar Gulati and his wife Simla as participants, but did not specify who actually poured the oil or lit the fire. The …

SWAN GOLD MINING LTD.versusHINDUSTAN COPPER LTD.

2014 INSC 661Dismissed

Swan Gold Mining Ltd, an Australian company, entered into a contract with Hindustan Copper Ltd for the operation of a mine, agreeing that the successful bidder would be liable for taxes as per the Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) and subsequent Work Order. After completing work, the appellant sought …

K.PRAKASHversusB.R. SAMPATH KUMAR

2014 INSC 659Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, K. Prakash, sued B.R. Sampath Kumar for specific performance of a 2003 agreement to sell a Bangalore property for Rs.16.10 lakh, having paid Rs.5.45 lakh as advance. The respondent contended the agreement was signed under mental pressure and that the price was far below market value, …

STATE OF U.P.versusNAREN.DRA & ORS.

2014 INSC 657Dismissed

The case involves a brutal murder of Dr. Rajveer Singh, his sons, and his brother over a land dispute, for which six accused were tried. The trial court convicted them under various IPC sections and sentenced five of them to death. On appeal, the Allahabad High Court held that the case did not fall …

TEJPALversusSTATE OF U.P.

2014 INSC 658Dismissed

The case involves Tej Pal, who was convicted of murder under IPC sections 302 and 149 arising from a land dispute, and sentenced to life imprisonment. Tej Pal appealed the conviction before the Supreme Court, while a separate Special Leave Petition (SLP) filed by co-accused Narendra had already been …

SRI CHAND AND ANOTHERversusSTATE OF PUNJAB

2014 INSC 653Dismissed

The deceased Harpal Kaur was burnt to death in her matrimonial home within months of her marriage. Her father and a panchayat member found her body and reported the incident, leading to the arrest of her husband, his parents (Sri Chand and Darshan Kaur) and brother. The trial court convicted all …

TANUA RABIDASversusSTATE OF ASSAM

2014 INSC 600Dismissed

The appellant, Tanua Rabidas, was convicted of murder under section 302 IPC for allegedly pouring kerosene on his wife and setting her ablaze, leading to her death. The prosecution relied on two dying declarations: one recorded orally by a doctor and a nurse at the hospital, and another made in the …

STATE OF NCT OF DELHIversusSANJAY

2014 INSC 602Disposed off

The Supreme Court examined whether the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act) bars prosecution under the Indian Penal Code (IPC) for theft of sand and gravels from riverbeds. The Court held that offences under Section 21 of the MMDR Act (contravention of mining lease …

NARINDER SINGH.versusNEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LTD. & ORS.

2014 INSC 605Dismissed

The complainant insured a Mahindra Pick‑up vehicle whose temporary registration expired on 11‑January‑2006, yet the vehicle was involved in an accident on 2‑February‑2006 while being driven without any valid registration. The insurer denied the claim, leading to proceedings before the District …

VIRESHWAR SINGH & ORS.versusMUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF DELHI & ORS.

2014 INSC 586

The case concerned General Duty Medical Officers (GDMOs) appointed on an ad‑hoc basis in two phases (Phase‑I: 1982‑86; Phase‑II: 1986‑89) by a specially constituted selection committee, contrary to the Delhi Municipal Corporation Health Service Recruitment Regulations, 1982 which required UPSC …

KUSHA LAXMAN WAGHMAREversusSTATE OF MAHARASHTRA

2014 INSC 583Case Partly allowed

The appellant, Kusha Laxman Waghmare, was accused of killing his wife Anusuya by beating her with a wooden stick. No eye‑witness was present, but the appellant made extra‑judicial confessions to two persons (PW‑1 and PW‑2) and no defence was offered under Section 313 of the CrPC. The post‑mortem …

M/S. NAVODAYA MASS ENTERTAINMENT LTD.versusM/S. J.M. COMBINES

2014 INSC 564Dismissed

The parties entered into an agreement for the installation and operation of an amusement ride, with revenue sharing and guaranteed minimum collections. The appellant defaulted on payments, leading the respondent to invoke the arbitration clause. An arbitrator awarded the respondent Rs.13,94,240 with …

STATE OF MADHYA PRADESHversusBABLU

2014 INSC 996Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Madhya Pradesh appealed a High Court order that reduced the six‑month rigorous imprisonment awarded to Bablu for offences under Sections 323 and 354 IPC to the 21 days he had already served, on the ground that he was a first‑time offender. The Supreme Court held that sentencing must …

ATUL TRIPATHIversusSTATE OF UP. & ANR.

2014 INSC 499Appeal(s) allowed

The Supreme Court examined appeals filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh challenging the High Court's grant of bail to several convicts who had been sentenced to life imprisonment for serious offences under the IPC and the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013. The central issue was whether, at the …

SHYAM NARAIN PANDEYversusSTATE OF U.P.

2014 INSC 500Dismissed

Shyam Narain Pandey, a school principal, was convicted under IPC sections 147, 148, 302/144 read with 120B and sentenced to life imprisonment. He applied for a stay of his conviction under Section 389(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, arguing that the conviction would deprive him of his …

UNION OF INDIA & ORS.versusCHATRO DEVI & ORS.

2014 INSC 368Dismissed

The appeals filed by the Union of India and other respondents challenged the validity of acquisition proceedings that had been initiated after tenure‑holders raised objections under Section 5‑A of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The petitioners contended that the objections were maintainable and …

KUSHALBHAI RATANBHAI ROHIT & ORS.versusTHE STATE OF GUJARAT

2014 INSC 366Dismissed

An FIR under the NDPS Act led to the arrest of a accused who escaped while being escorted by police constables. The constables were charged under IPC Section 222 and convicted, prompting them to file a criminal appeal. The Gujarat High Court, after dictating an acquitting order in open court but …

R. SUBRAMANIAMversusMURUGAPPA GOUNDER AND ORS.

2014 INSC 917Appeal(s) allowed

In a contempt proceeding before the Madras High Court, Respondents tendered an unconditional apology in the form of an affidavit, which the Single Judge accepted. Despite this acceptance, the Judge directed the Principal Secretary & Commissioner of Land Administration to initiate appropriate action …

SANJAY KUMARversusTHE STATE OF BIHAR & ANR.

2014 INSC 60Dismissed

The petitioner, Sanjay Kumar, alleged that he was appointed as a senior lecturer in a purportedly fake dental college, received post‑dated cheques for salary which later bounced, and consequently filed a criminal complaint under various IPC sections and Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. …

UNION OF INDIAversusFACULTY ASSOCIATION OF ALLMS

[2014] 14 S.C.R. 1651Disposed off

The Supreme Court entertained review petitions filed by the Union of India challenging its earlier decision on reservation in faculty posts at AIIMS. The issue centered on whether Articles 15, 16 and 335 of the Constitution permit reservation in super‑specialty faculty positions. The Court clarified …

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, GUJARATversusGUJARAT FLUORO CHEMICALS

2013 INSC 633Matter referred to larger bench

The petitioner, Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat, challenged the claim of the respondent, Gujarat Fluoro Chemicals, that the Revenue should pay interest when the total of advance tax and TDS installments paid exceeds the assessed tax. The issue centered on whether the Revenue is liable to pay …

VIKASversusSTATE OF RAJASTHAN

2013 INSC 540Disposed off

The appellant, Vikash, was implicated in an abduction case where a girl was allegedly kidnapped by several accused. The trial court, after taking cognizance under sections 363, 366(A), 1208 and 376 of the IPC, issued a non‑bailable warrant to secure his attendance under section 319 of the CrPC. …

MOHIT ALIAS SONU AND ANOTHERversusSTATE OF U.P. AND ANOTHER

2013 INSC 399Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Mohit alias Sonu, and another were not summoned under an application filed by the complainant under Section 319 CrPC, and the Sessions Court rejected the application twice. The complainant challenged the rejection in the High Court by invoking the inherent power under Section 482 …

CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATIONversusV. VIJAY SAI REDDY

2013 INSC 333Appeal(s) allowed

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) filed an appeal seeking cancellation of bail granted to V. Vijay Sai Reddy (A‑2) in a case involving alleged conspiracy, fraud and corruption under the IPC and the Prevention of Corruption Act. The Special Court had granted bail, and the High Court affirmed …

LITTA SINGH & ANR.versusSTATE OF RAJASTHAN

2013 INSC 285Disposed off

The appellants Litta Singh and Kalla Singh, along with their father Boga Singh, were charged with the murder of Hansraj Singh after assaulting him with a lathi and a gandasi following a prior quarrel. The victim died the next day, leading the trial court to convict the two appellants under Section …

POURNIMA SURYAKANT PAWARversusSTATE OF MAHARAHTRA AND OTHERS

2013 INSC 140

The petitioners, two cousins, claimed membership in the Thakar Scheduled Tribe and sought a caste certificate, which was rejected by the Scheduled Tribe Certificate Scrutiny Committee. The Committee, after examining documentary evidence and a vigilance enquiry, found that the family’s historical …

SACHIN GUPTA AND ANOTHERversusK.S. FORGE METAL PRIVATE LIMITED

2013 INSC 132

The appellants challenged an arbitral award that had been set aside by the Delhi High Court. The High Court held the award invalid for lack of notice and hearing to the respondent, invoking Section 34(2)(a)(iii) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and also made extensive remarks on the …

STATE OF ASSAMversusRIPA SARMA

2013 INSC 114Dismissed

The State of Assam filed a Special Leave Petition (SLP) under Article 136 of the Constitution challenging only the Gauhati High Court's order dismissing its review petition, without challenging the original judgment of the Writ Appeal dated 20 November 2007. The Court examined whether an SLP can be …