Created byFuzzy Cloud

Supreme Court of India

NIRZAR S DESAI

453 judgments delivered by benches including this judge — showing 401–453.

SAMATKUMAR PUNJABHAI MAKWANAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Samatkumar Makwana, challenged the State of Gujarat for failing to verify his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as a Lokrakshak Police Constable, Class‑III. He relied on a prior order of the Co‑ordinate Bench dated 26‑July‑2021, affirmed by a Division Bench on 25‑Nov‑2021, which directe…

VISHAL KARMANBHAI KHATANAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Vishal Karmabhai Khatana, challenged the State of Gujarat for not verifying his caste certificate, which delayed his appointment as a Lokrakshak Police Constable. He relied on a prior coordinate‑bench order (26‑07‑2021) and its affirmation by a Division Bench (25‑11‑2021) that directed provisional appoi…

AJAY LAKHMANBHAI VANDAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Ajay Lakhmanbhai Vanda, filed a special civil application challenging the State’s failure to verify his caste certificate, which prevented his provisional appointment as Lokrakshak Jail Sepoy, Class‑III. He relied on a prior order of a Co‑ordinate Bench dated 26‑07‑2021, affirmed by a Division Bench on …

KANABHAI LAXMANBHAI KARAMTAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Kanabhai Laxmanbhai Karamta, challenged the State of Gujarat for failing to verify his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as Lokrakshak Jail Sepoy, Class III. He relied on a prior order of a Co‑ordinate Bench dated 26 July 2021, affirmed by a Division Bench on 25 November 2021, which had…

VIRA SAJANBHAI KATARAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Vira Sajanbhai Katara, challenged the State of Gujarat for not verifying his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as Lokrakshak Police Constable, Class‑III. He relied on a prior order of a Co‑ordinate Bench (Special Civil Application No. 1858 of 2021) and its affirmation by a Division Benc…

DAYABHAI MEHURBHAI KARAMATAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Dayabhai Mehurabhai Karamata, challenged the State of Gujarat for not verifying his caste certificate, which delayed his appointment as a Lokrakshak Police Constable, Class‑III. He relied on a prior order of the Co‑ordinate Bench dated 26 July 2021, affirmed by a Division Bench on 25 November 2021, whic…

KARAN NAJABHAI CHAVDAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Karan Najabhai Chavda, challenged the State's failure to verify his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as a Lokrakshak Police Constable, Class III. He relied on a prior order of the Co‑ordinate Bench (Special Civil Application No.1858 of 2021) and its affirmation by a Division Bench (Let…

RAHUL LAKHABHAI ULAVAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Rahul Lakhabhai Ulava, challenged the State of Gujarat for not verifying his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as a Lokrakshak Police Constable, Class‑III. He relied on a prior order of a coordinate bench dated 26‑07‑2021, affirmed by a division bench on 25‑11‑2021, which had directed p…

KARAN HARESHBHAI CHAVADAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioners, Karan Harshbai Chavada & others, challenged the State of Gujarat for failing to verify their caste certificate, which prevented their appointment as Lokrakshak Police Constables. They relied on a prior order of a coordinate bench dated 26 July 2021, affirmed by a Division Bench on 25 November 2021, whi…

CHAUHAN DINESHBHAI VASTABHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners, Chauhan Dineshbhai Vastabhai & ors., filed a miscellaneous civil application for recall (No.168 of 2026) seeking to withdraw the pending special civil application No.1777/2025 filed against the State of Gujarat & ors. They approached the High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad, through counsel Mr. Utkarsh J. …

DR MANN M PATELversusBHAVNAGAR UNIVERSITY

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Bonus Enterprises Limited filed a Special Civil Application (No. 802 of 2026) and two Tax Appeals (Nos. 772 and 801 of 2026) before the High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad. The matter was heard by Hon’ble Mr. Justice A.S. Supehia and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Pranav Trivedi. The court issued an oral order directing that any off…

DR PIYUSH CHAUHANversusBHAVNAGAR UNIVERSITY

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Dr. Piyush Chauhan filed a Special Civil Application before the Gujarat High Court against Bhavnagar University and others. The petitioner, through Senior Advocate Dhaval D. Vyas and Advocate Vishwas K. Shah, sought the Court's permission to withdraw the petition so that a representation could be made to the competent …

NAREN CHAUDHARYversusBHAVNAGAR UNIVERSITY

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Naren Chaudhary, filed a Special Civil Application seeking permission to withdraw the petition in order to make a representation to the competent authority. Senior Advocate Dhaval D. Vyas, appearing with Advocate Vishwas K. Shah, prayed for such permission. The Hon'ble Justice Nirzar S. Desai granted th…

NEBHABHAI RAJSHIBHAI NANDANIYAversusJAM-KHAMBHALIYA NAGARPALIKA

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Tai King Enterprises Co. filed a Special Civil Application before the Gujarat High Court against the Additional Commissioner of Customs, Surat. The Court, comprising Justices A.S. Supehia and Pranav Trivedi, issued an oral order directing that any objections raised in the proceedings be withdrawn on or before 1 April 2…

MILAN KAKLOTARversusBHAVNAGAR UNIVERSITY

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Milan Kaklotar, sought permission to withdraw his special civil application against Bhavnagar University and others. Senior Advocate Dhaval D. Vyas, appearing with Advocate Vishwas K. Shah, requested the court’s leave to withdraw so that a representation could be made to the competent authority. Justice…

RAMANLAL MOHANLAL PARMARversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Ramanlal Mohanlal Parmar, filed a special civil application seeking relief against the State of Gujarat and others. The grievance of the petitioner was subsequently redressed, and the petitioner’s counsel requested permission to withdraw the petition. The court granted the request, disposing the petitio…

K.M. EDUCATION TRUSTversusDISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER,

47-DISPOSAL IN ANY OTHER MODE FH

The K.M. Education Trust filed a Special Civil Application seeking an amount from the District Education Officer and others. The petitioner claimed that the amount was due to them. During the hearing, the petitioner’s counsel informed the court that the amount had already been received. The court noted that the grievan…

CHAUDHARY MADEVABHAI KARSANBHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

47-DISPOSAL IN ANY OTHER MODE FH

The petitioners, Chaudhary Madevabhai Karsanbhai and others, filed a special civil application before the Gujarat High Court seeking relief against the State of Gujarat and another party. The petition was pending for an extended period. Counsel for the petitioners, Ms. Mamta R. Vyas, submitted that the petition had bec…

PATEL PUNITKUMAR ARVINDBHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners sought enforcement of orders dated 08.01.2026 and 17.01.2026, which granted them full pay scale after the District Primary Education Officer's earlier orders were quashed. The State argued that the earlier show‑cause notice dated 29.11.2021 became redundant in view of the later orders. The Court held th…

KHUSHBUBEN SOMABHAI PATELversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Khushbuben Somabhai Patel, filed a special civil application and, through counsel, sought the Court’s permission to withdraw the petition. The Hon’ble Justice N. S. Desai considered the request and granted permission for withdrawal. Consequently, the petition was disposed of as withdrawn and the notice …

GIRISHKUMAR SHANTILAL PATELversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Girishkumar Shantilal Patel, filed Special Civil Application No. 10811 of 2022 before the High Court of Gujarat. Subsequently, the petitioner, through counsel, sought the Court's permission to withdraw the petition. The Court considered its inherent jurisdiction to allow withdrawal of a pending petition…

ASIAN B.CA COLLEGEversusHEMCHANDRACHARYA NORTH GUJARAT UNIVERSITY

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Asian B.C.A. College filed a Special Civil Application before the Gujarat High Court against Hemchandracharya North Gujarat University and others. The petitioner, through counsel, sought the Court's permission to withdraw the petition in order to pursue an alternative remedy. The Court considered the request and, witho…

JITENDRAKUMAR GANDABHAI MORIversusTHE STATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Jitendrakumar Gandabhai Mori filed Special Civil Application No. 11611 of 2025 against the State of Gujarat and others. The petitioner later joined the case at the transferred place, rendering the petition infructuous. He sought the Court's permission to withdraw the petition. The learned counsel for the petitioner sub…

PATEL DAXABEN NARAYANBHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners sought enforcement of orders dated 08.01.2026 and 17.01.2026, which granted them full pay scale after the District Primary Education Officer's earlier orders were quashed. The State argued that the earlier show‑cause notice dated 29.11.2021 became redundant in view of the later orders. The Court held th…

PRAJAPATI SUNILKUMAR GANPATBHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners sought enforcement of orders dated 08.01.2026 and 17.01.2026, which granted them full pay scale after the District Primary Education Officer's earlier orders were quashed. The State argued that the earlier show‑cause notice dated 29.11.2021 became redundant in view of the later orders. The Court held th…

PATEL MANISHKUMAR JITENDRAKUMARversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners sought enforcement of orders dated 08.01.2026 and 17.01.2026, which granted them full pay scale after the District Primary Education Officer's earlier orders were quashed. The State argued that the earlier show‑cause notice dated 29.11.2021 became redundant in view of the later orders. The Court held th…

RAVAL HARDIK BHAISHANKARversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners sought enforcement of orders dated 08.01.2026 and 17.01.2026, which granted them full pay scale after the District Primary Education Officer's earlier orders were quashed. The State argued that the earlier show‑cause notice dated 29.11.2021 became redundant in view of the later orders. The Court held th…

PATEL PRADIPKUMAR KACHARABHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners sought enforcement of orders dated 08.01.2026 and 17.01.2026, which granted them full pay scale after the District Primary Education Officer's earlier orders were quashed. The State argued that the earlier show‑cause notice dated 29.11.2021 became redundant in view of the later orders. The Court held th…

RAJENDRA GORAKHNATH BAVISKARversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Mrs. Meenaben Paulbhai Khristi filed several special civil applications seeking a higher pay scale. The State Government approved the higher pay scale for each petitioner, and the approval order was placed on record. The petitioner's counsel, Mr. V.K. Joshi, requested that the petitions be withdrawn as the grievance wa…

SURPALSINH ARJUNBHAI MALIVADversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Surpalsinh Arjunbhai Malivad, challenged the State of Gujarat for not verifying his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as a Livestock Inspector (Class‑III) after selection. He relied on a prior order of a coordinate bench (Special Civil Application No.1858 of 2021) and its affirmation by…

VASHRAMBHAI SHANKARBHAI PATEL (SOLANKI)versusDEPUTY DIRECTOR

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Vashrambhai Shankarbhai Patel (Solanki) filed a Special Civil Application before the High Court of Gujarat against the Deputy Director and others. The petitioner, through counsel Mr. Rishin R. Patel, sought permission to withdraw the petition after the legal heirs of the deceased petitioner were recorded. The court con…

MEHULBHAI DINESHBAI CHAUHANversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Petitioner Mehulpbai Dineshbhai Chauhan filed a Special Civil Application seeking redress of a grievance. After the respondents issued an administrative order addressing the grievance, the petitioner moved to withdraw the petition, requesting that Respondent No.3 be directed to implement the order. The Court, after hea…

MAHESH BHARATBHAI GADHVIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

DISPOSED AS INFRUCTUOUS

A large group of special civil applications were filed by various candidates challenging the Gujarat Public Service Commission’s recruitment process. The Court ordered the Commission to produce the examination results in a sealed cover, which revealed that many petitioners either failed, did not appear, or were not per…

MAMTA SHISHUPALSINGH RATHOURversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Mamta Shishupalsingh Rathour, filed a special civil application seeking relief after an administrative order dated 15 January 2026 directed a lump‑sum compensation of Rs.4,00,000 in lieu of a compassionate appointment. The respondent, the Administrative Officer of Nagar Prathmik Shikshan Samiti, Ahmedab…

NIMESHKUMAR KANTILAL BHATTversusTHE STATE OF GUJARAT

58-RULE ISSUED & RULE ABSOLUTE/ALLOWED @FH

The petitioners, appointed as peons before 2006, were placed on a fixed salary that, after the 6th Pay Commission and a 2009 government resolution, resulted in a lower basic pay (Rs.7100) than their juniors who were appointed after 01‑01‑2006 and placed in a higher pay band. Invoking Article 226, they sought to have th…

MAHENDRA VELJIBHAI GARACHversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Mahendra Veljibhai Garach, filed a special civil application seeking redress of grievances related to arrears and other benefits. He later informed the court that his grievances had been fully satisfied as he had received the arrears and benefits to which he was entitled. Consequently, he requested perm…

PATEL NIPURANABEN NATHABHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Petitioner Patel Nipuranaben Nathabhai filed a Special Civil Application before the Gujarat High Court. The petitioner, through her counsel, submitted a communication dated 5 January 2026 requesting to withdraw the petition. The court was asked to grant permission for withdrawal and to vacate the interim relief previou…

VIPULKUMAR PRAMODRAI JOSHIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Vipulkumar Pramodrai Joshi filed a Special Civil Application seeking certain benefits, which had been positively decided in an order dated 9 January 2026, confirming his eligibility. The earlier order also indicated that the benefits required approval from the State Government as per the decision of the Deputy Conserva…

BABUBHAI BHIKHABHAI THAKARDAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

35-ANY OTHER MODE @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners, who have worked for more than five years and over 240 days each year for the State of Gujarat, sought the grant of a benefit under Government Resolutions dated 17‑10‑1988, 15‑09‑2014 and 06‑04‑2016. They contended that, following the Supreme Court’s decision in Workmen of American Express International…

NAVINCHANDRA KANTIBHAI BHANGIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

35-ANY OTHER MODE @ ADM.STAGE

Navinchandra Kantibhai Bhangi filed a special civil application against the State of Gujarat claiming denial of a benefit under Government Resolutions dated 17‑10‑1988, 15‑09‑2014 and 06‑04‑2016, despite having worked more than five years and over 240 days each year. The petitioners argued that, following the Supreme C…

BHARATBHAI RAMABHAI VANKARversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

35-ANY OTHER MODE @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioners, Bharatbhai Ramabhai Vankar & ors., filed a special civil application alleging that they were denied benefits under Gujarat State Government Resolutions dated 17‑10‑1988, 15‑09‑2014 and 06‑04‑2016 despite having worked for more than five years and completing over 240 days each year. They contended that,…

OMDEVSINH PARBATSINH PARMARversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Omdevsinh Parbatsinh Parmar, filed Special Civil Application No. 16731 of 2025 before the High Court of Gujarat. The petitioner, through Advocate Mr. Hem R. Dave, claimed that the grievances raised in the petition had been redressed and therefore sought the Court's permission to withdraw the petition. T…

YOGESHBHAI MANIBHAI PATELversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

The petitioner, Yogeshbhai Manibhai Patel, filed Special Civil Application No. 19924 of 2023 before the High Court of Gujarat. On 7 January 2026, the petitioner communicated a request to withdraw the petition. The petitioner’s counsel, Mr. Kadiwala, sought the court’s permission to effect the withdrawal. The court cons…

PITHABHAI PACHABHAI CHAVDAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

46-ANY OTHER MODE @ FH

The petitioner, Pithabhai Pachabhai Chavda, challenged the State of Gujarat for failing to verify his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as a Primary Teacher (Vidhya Sahayak). He relied on a prior order of the Gujarat High Court's Co‑ordinate Bench (Special Civil Application No. 1858 of 2021) and its co…

MEDGUJ ASSOCIATION OF GUJ MEDICAL COLLEGESversusMEDICAL COUNSELLING COMMITTEE(MCC)

35-ANY OTHER MODE @ ADM.STAGE

The Medguj Association of Gujarat Medical Colleges filed a special civil application seeking a writ of mandamus directing the Medical Counselling Committee (MCC) and the Admission Committee to conduct an additional stray vacancy round to fill three vacant first‑year MBBS seats that became available after three students…

PATEL SURESHKUMAR BHAGWANBHAIversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

27-WITHDRAWN @ ADM.STAGE

Petitioner Patel SureshKumar BhagwanBhai filed a Special Civil Application before the Gujarat High Court. The petitioner, through counsel Mr. Gaurav Chudasama, sought permission to withdraw the petition. The Court, after hearing, granted the request, ordering the petition to stand disposed as withdrawn and discharging …

ST. CYRIL'S SCHOOLversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

40-WITHDRAWN @ FH

The petitioner, St. Cyril's School, challenged orders dated 21‑08‑2023 and 22‑05‑2023 that cancelled its registration for Class 11 English‑Medium. During the pendency of the petition, the school obtained all required permissions, although earlier the lack of such permissions had led to the cancellation of its Class 9 r…

ST CYRILS SCHOOLversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

40-WITHDRAWN @ FH

St. Cyrils School filed a special civil application challenging the order dated 3‑August‑2023 that cancelled its registration for Class 9th English Medium. While the petition was pending, the school obtained all required permissions, which were the basis for the original cancellation. The petitioner’s counsel sought pe…

KARSHAN RAJA MUCHHALversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

58-RULE ISSUED & RULE ABSOLUTE/ALLOWED @FH

The petitioner, Karshan Raja Muchhal, challenged the State of Gujarat for failing to verify his caste certificate, which prevented his appointment as a Vidhya Sahayak (Primary Teacher). He relied on a prior order of the Co‑ordinate Bench dated 26 July 2021, upheld by a Division Bench on 25 November 2021, which directed…

NISHA KARSHANBHAI KARAMTAversusSTATE OF GUJARAT

58-RULE ISSUED & RULE ABSOLUTE/ALLOWED @FH

The petitioner, Nisha Karshanbhai Karamta, a selected candidate for the post of Vidhya Sahayak (Primary Teacher) in Gujarat, challenged the State’s failure to verify her caste certificate, which prevented her appointment. She relied on a prior order of the Co‑ordinate Bench (Special Civil Application No. 1858 of 2021) …

Search Indian case law

Ask in plain English, not just keywords. 25,000 AI words free, no card.

Search by issue, statute, judge or citationSign in to search