Created by Fuzzy Cloud

TARUN CHATTERJEE

280 judgments · newest first · showing 201–280

NEW OKHLA INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY & ANR.versusARVIND SONEKAR

2008 INSC 480Case Allowed

The New Okhla Industrial Development Authority (the Noida authorities) appealed against an order of the MRTP Commission directing it to refund the excess amount paid by Arvind Sonekar for a plot allotment. The respondent had earlier received a 1993 offer letter stating a rate of Rs.2750 per sq.mtr, …

U.P.C.U.E.F. LTD.versusCANE COMMISSIONER AND R.C.C.S. AND ORS.

2008 INSC 481Case Allowed

The appellant, a trade union of seasonal workers employed by a cooperative cane development union, challenged an order by the Cane Commissioner that redefined "crushing season" and thereby altered the period for which wages were payable. The amendment changed the definition from a fixed calendar …

THE HARYANA STATE AGRICULTURAL MARKETING BOARD AND ORS.versusSADHU RAM

2008 INSC 466Appeal(s) allowed

The Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board conducted an open auction of shop and booth plots under the Punjab Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1961, but did not disclose the reserve price in the public notice. The respondents were declared highest bidders, deposited 25% of the bid amount, yet …

MANAGEMENT OF AUROFOOD PVT. LTD.versusS. RAJULU

2008 INSC 451Dismissed

The respondent, S. Rajulu, was employed as a packer by Aurofood Pvt. Ltd. and was suspended in 1981 for alleged misconduct, including insolent and filthy language towards superiors and a lady supervisor. A domestic enquiry found him guilty on two charges and the employer dismissed him after an …

ZOLBAversusKESHAO AND ORS.

2008 INSC 440Case Allowed

The appellant, a defendant in a partition suit, failed to file his written statement within the 30‑day period and beyond the 90‑day limit prescribed by Order 8 Rule 1 of the CPC because his counsel advised him to wait for the outcome of a pending appeal and the case files were not available. Both …

HONNAMMA & ORS.versusNANJUNDAIAH SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS. & ORS.

2008 INSC 432Case Allowed

The appellants filed a Form‑7 under the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961 claiming occupancy rights over certain survey numbers and later sought to amend the form to correct mis‑descriptions, adding land in two villages. The Land Tribunal rejected the claim, but the Land Reforms Appellate Authority …

MADAN MOHAN ABBOTversusSTATE OF PUNJAB

2008 INSC 410Case Allowed

An FIR (No.155/2001) was lodged under Sections 379, 406, 409, 418 and 506/34 IPC arising from a business dispute between the complainant and the accused. The parties executed a compromise deed on 25 January 2002, settling all differences. The complainant applied to the High Court for quashing the …

RAMACHANDRA KRISHNA BHATTAversusSTATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR.

2008 INSC 365Dismissed

The appellant, Ramachandra Krishna Bhatta, claimed occupancy rights over agricultural lands owned by the Gopal Krishna Devaru Temple, asserting that he was a tenant under the Karnataka Land Reforms Act, 1961. The Land Tribunal granted him occupancy rights, but the Land Reforms Appellate Authority …

HINDALCO INDUSTRIES LTD.versusASSOCIATION OF ENGINEERING WORKERS

2008 INSC 369Dismissed

The Association of Engineering Workers filed a complaint under Item 9 of Schedule IV of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, 1971, alleging that Hindalco Industries treated its canteen staff as contract workers to avoid granting permanency and …

RAMA DEVIversusDILIP SINGH

2008 INSC 385Dismissed

Rama Devi executed a deed on 15 May 1974 purportedly as a conditional mortgage for a loan of Rs.13,000, stipulating reconveyance of the land if repaid within five years. She sought reconveyance within the period, but the respondent refused; later, under local pressure, he returned possession in 1984 …

M/S. MEDICAMEN BIOTECH LTD. AND ANR.versusRUBINA BOSE, DRUG INSPECTOR

2008 INSC 359Case Allowed

The Drugs Inspector collected a sample of Enalapril Maleate tablets manufactured by M/s. Medicamen Biotech Ltd., divided it into four parts and sent one part to the Government Analyst, whose report declared the drug sub‑standard. The appellant disputed the report, sent two written notices within 28 …

M/S. GIRIAS INVESTMENT PVT. LTD. & ANR.versusSTATE OF KARNATAKA & ORS.

2008 INSC 360Dismissed

The Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board (KIADB) initially notified acquisition of land for a trumpet interchange and access road to Bangalore Airport under the Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board Act, 1966. Later, the Karnataka State Industrial Investment and Development Corporation …

MAHANT RAM KHILAWAN DASversusSTATE OF M.P.

2008 INSC 329Case Allowed

Mahant Ram Khilawan Das, a temple manager, claimed title to a temple and adjoining agricultural lands bequeathed by his guru and filed a suit for declaration of title and permanent injunction against the State of Madhya Pradesh. The trial court dismissed the suit, but the Additional District Judge …

SITA RAM GUPTAversusPUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ORS.

2008 INSC 334Dismissed

The appellant, Sita Ram Gupta, had executed a guarantee with Punjab National Bank for loans advanced to certain borrowers. The guarantee expressly stated it was a "continuing guarantee" that would remain in force for all subsequent transactions, irrespective of the account status. Gupta later sent a …

P.B. KRISHNANKUTTY NAIRversusTHE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, ESI CORPN. & ANR.

2008 INSC 320Dismissed

P.B. Krishnankutty Nair, a former employee covered under the Employees State Insurance (ESI) scheme, suffered an accident on 15 June 1990 and claimed disability benefit. He had ceased to be an employee on 1 October 1989 because his salary exceeded the cut‑off wage, but his contribution period as an …

PURAN RAMversusBHAGURAM AND ANR.

2008 INSC 277Case Partly allowed

Puran Ram purchased agricultural land from Bhaguram but the sale deed was never executed. The agreement mistakenly described the land as Chak No. 3 SSM instead of Chak No. 3 SLM. In the suit for specific performance, the plaintiff sought to amend both the plaint and the agreement to correct this …

VAISHAKHI RAM AND ORS.versusSANJEEV KUMAR BHATIANI

2008 INSC 248Dismissed

The appellants, led by Vaisakhi Ram, were tenants of a shop in Delhi since 1956. They allowed three relatives (appellants Nos.2‑4) to conduct independent businesses in a portion of the shop without obtaining the landlord's written consent. The present landlord, Sanjeev Kumar Bhatiani, purchased the …

SUMITOMO CORPORATIONversusCDC FINANCIAL SERVICES (MAURITIUS) LTD. & ORS.

2008 INSC 245Dismissed

Sumitomo Corporation, Punjab Tractors Pvt. Ltd. and Swaraj Mazda Ltd. entered into a joint venture agreement that later gave rise to disputes over shareholding and management. The respondents filed a company petition before the Company Law Board (CLB) under Sections 397, 398 and 402 of the Companies …

MUNDRIKA DUBEY AND ORS.versusSTATE OF BIHAR AND ORS.

2008 INSC 232Dismissed

The appellants, Class IV employees of Bihar Rajya Shakari Bhumi Vikas Bank, were compulsorily retired under the Bank's Rules 232 and 235. They challenged the retirement, arguing that only Rule 232, which requires inefficiency, could be used for compulsory retirement, and that Rule 235 merely dealt …

SHRI V.S. KRISHNAN AND ORS.versusM/S. WESTFORT HI-TECH HOSPITAL LTD. AND ORS.

2008 INSC 235Dismissed

The appellants, directors and shareholders of Westfort Hi‑Tech Hospital Ltd., claimed that they were denied proper notice of the eleventh Annual General Meeting (AGM), were illegally removed from directorships despite a promise of permanent appointment, and that the issuance of right shares and …

UNION OF INDIA & ORSversusSHAKTI LPG LTD. & ANR

2008 INSC 209Appeal(s) allowed

Shakti LPG Ltd. imported steel plates in 1996 and warehoused them under the Customs Act, 1962. The initial one‑year warehousing period was repeatedly extended until January 2001, after which the importer surrendered the goods in December 2004. When an auction was scheduled for September 2005, the …

B.K. MUNIRAJUversusSTATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS.

2008 INSC 208Dismissed

The appellant, B.K. Muniraju, sought cancellation of a sale deed and restoration of land that had been transferred to respondents 4 and 5, invoking the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act, 1978. The Assistant Commissioner and the Deputy …

JAGADEESH & ANR.versusSTATE OF KARNATAKA & ORS.

2008 INSC 175Dismissed

The appellants, Jagadeesh and others, claimed tenancy and occupancy rights over a scheduled agricultural land and filed Form‑7 before the Karnataka Land Tribunal. The Tribunal and the Appellate Authority granted occupancy rights, but the High Court, exercising revisional jurisdiction under Section …

BOKKA SUBBA RAOversusKUKKALA BALAKRISHNA & ORS.

2008 INSC 176Case Partly allowed

The plaintiffs‑respondents filed a suit seeking a declaration of ownership of a specific property and a perpetual injunction. The trial court dismissed the suit and the decision was upheld on appeal. The High Court, however, in a second appeal, reversed the lower courts and decreed in favour of the …

BABU LALversusHARYANA STATE AGRICULTURAL MKT. BOARD

2008 INSC 165Dismissed

Babu Lal, a former employee of the Haryana State Agricultural Market Board, filed a suit seeking salary arrears from 2 November 1995 to 30 March 2001, claiming he was promoted to Executive Officer‑cum‑Secretary in November 1995. The trial court dismissed the suit, but the first appellate court …

DHARMA NAIKAversusRAMA NAIKA AND ANR.

[2008] 2 S.C.R. 451Dismissed

The case concerned a 2‑acre land granted by the Government of Karnataka to a Scheduled Caste grantee with a condition that it not be alienated for fifteen years. After the restriction period, an agreement to sell was executed on 5 July 1976, but the sale deed was executed and registered on 13 …

VENTURE GLOBAL ENGINEERINGversusSATYAM COMPUTER SERVICES LTD. AND ANR.

2008 INSC 36Case Allowed

Venture Global Engineering (VGE) and Satyam Computer Services Ltd. (SCSL) entered into a joint venture and shareholders agreement that provided for arbitration of disputes. A dispute arose and SCSL obtained an award from the London Court of International Arbitration directing VGE to transfer its …

M/S. SIFY LTD.versusM/S. FIRST FLIGHT COURIERS LTD.

2008 INSC 24Case Partly allowed

Sify Ltd., a network services provider, filed a summary suit under Order 37 Rule 2 of the CPC to recover unpaid dues from First Flight Couriers Ltd. The respondent sought unconditional leave to defend, but the Single Judge of the Bombay High Court granted conditional leave, requiring a deposit of Rs …

NIRLEX SPARES PVT. LTD.versusCOMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE

2008 INSC 4Case Allowed

Nirlex Spares Pvt. Ltd., a small‑scale manufacturer of steel heads, printed a hexagonal artistic design on its corrugated boxes alongside its own brand names. The tax authorities held that the design was a monogram belonging to its marketing agent, L.M.S. Marketing Co., and therefore denied the …

M/S NOPANY INVESTMENTS (P) LTD.versusSANTOKH SINGH (HUF)

2007 INSC 1255

M/S NOPANY INVESTMENTS (P) Ltd., the landlord, sought eviction of SANTOKH SINGH (HUF) tenant. The junior HUF member, Jasraj Singh, filed the suit claiming to be the Karta despite the senior brother being alive but residing abroad and having executed a power of attorney. The Supreme Court held that …

K.N. ANANTHARAJA GUPTAversusSMT. D.V. USHA VIJAY KUMAR

2007 INSC 1211

The respondent, a widow and co‑owner of a residential flat in Bangalore, filed an eviction petition under Section 27(2)(r) read with Section 31 of the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999, claiming the premises were dilapidated and needed demolition and reconstruction for her and her children’s use. The Small …

STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESHversusABDUL KHUDDUS (DEAD) BY LRS. & ORS.

2007 INSC 1206Disposed off

The State of Andhra Pradesh filed an application under the Andhra Pradesh Land Grabbing (Prohibition) Act, 1982 alleging illegal occupation of certain parcels of land (the Schedule Land) by Abdul Khuddus and others. The Special Court examined oral and documentary evidence and held that the …

UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.versusAMAR SINGH

2007 INSC 1183Appeal(s) allowed

Amar Singh, a constable in the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), was found after 29 years of service to have entered the force using a fictitious school leaving certificate. A departmental enquiry confirmed the fraud, leading to his dismissal under Section 11(1) of the CRPF Act, 1949 and Rule 27 …

DADAN RAM AND ORS.versusSTATE OF BIHAR AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1184Case Partly allowed

The case concerned surplus land declared under the Bihar Land Reforms (Fixation of Ceiling Area and Acquisition of Surplus Land) Act, 1961. Respondent No.8's 4.64 acres were declared surplus, notified and allotted to eight downtrodden persons (parcha holders). Later the District Collector, invoking …

TAMIL NADU WAKF BOARDversusLARABSHA DARGA PANRUTI

2007 INSC 1185Dismissed

The dispute concerned whether the Larabsha Darga and its associated lands constitute a private Wakf (Wakf‑alal‑aulad) or a public Wakf. The property, originally part of a larger Wakf, had passed through successive settlements (hibbas) and was managed by Safia Bi, who claimed it was her private …

STATE OF PUNJAB AND ORS.versusHARBHAJAN SINGH AND ANR.

2007 INSC 1113Appeal(s) allowed

Harbhajan Singh, a former Indian Army soldier who retired in 1987 and was drawing a defence pension, was re‑employed as a JBT teacher in the Punjab Education Department from 1994 to 2002. He applied for a civil‑service pension, arguing that his army service should be counted towards the ten‑year …

STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.versusNAVNEET VERMA

2007 INSC 1114Appeal(s) allowed

Navneet Verma was appointed as an Accounts Executive on a temporary post in the Haryana Bureau of Public Enterprises (HBPE) in July 1993. In December 1994 his services were terminated on the ground that the post had been abolished. Verma contended that the abolition was a pretext to remove him due …

BHARAT PETROLEUM CORPORATION LTD.versusTHE GREAT EASTERN SHIPPING CO. LTD.

2007 INSC 1048Dismissed

Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (appellant) and Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. (respondent) entered into a time charter party on 6 May 1997, which was extended to 31 August 1998. After the extension expired, the parties continued to use the vessel without a new written charter, and the respondent …

STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR.versusARAVALI KHANIJ UDYOG AND ANR.

2007 INSC 1053Disposed off

The State of Haryana granted a 20‑year mining lease for silica sand to Aravali Khanij Udyog, which expired on 17 February 2000. The respondent claimed that due to departmental delays it was unable to mine for 850 days and sought an extension of the lease, which the State rejected; the Punjab & …

KANWARJIT SINGH DHILLONversusHARDYAL SINGH DHILLON AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1072Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, Kanwarjit Singh Dhillon, filed a civil suit seeking a declaration that certain immovable and movable properties left by his father, the late S. Kirpal Singh, were joint Hindu family assets and an injunction restraining the respondent from alienating them. The respondent had obtained …

M.D., U.P. STATE AGRO-INDUSTRIAL CORPN. LTD.versusMAHENDRA KUMAR MISHRA AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1079Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, M.D., U.P. State Agro‑Industrial Corp. Ltd., appealed against the Allahabad High Court’s order that reinstated the respondent, Mahendra Kumar Mishra, after his dismissal from service. The High Court had set aside the dismissal order dated 11‑12‑2000 and directed reinstatement with all …

BCPP MAZDOOR SANGH AND ANR.versusN.T.P.C. AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1037Appeal(s) allowed

The case concerned the transfer of 236 non‑executive employees recruited by NTPC for the BALCO Captive Power Plant (BCPP) to BALCO after BALCO was disinvested and became a private concern. The employees argued that they were appointed by NTPC, not BALCO, and that the 1990 NTPC‑BALCO agreement and …

TRIVEDI HIMANSHU GHANSHYAMBHAIversusAHMEDABAD MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1031Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, an X‑ray technician employed by Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation since 1988, also performed clerical and administrative duties. He applied for the post of Assistant Manager, which required ten years of administrative experience, and his application was endorsed by the Medical Officer …

N.R. CONSTRUCTIONS PVT. LTD.versusSRI RAM BADAN SINGH AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1017Dismissed

The appellant, a partner in a construction firm, entered into arbitration with the respondents over a partnership dispute, resulting in two awards dated 19 April 1997 and 25 November 2000. The appellant sought adjustment of the cross‑award under Order XXI Rules 18 and 19 of the CPC, arguing that the …

RAM PRAKASH GUPTAversusRAJIV KUMAR GUPTA AND ORS.

2007 INSC 1000Appeal(s) allowed

Ram Prakash Gupta, a handicapped plaintiff, filed a suit in 1990 seeking declaration of ownership of his house and nullity of two decrees obtained fraudulently by his brothers' sons in 1976. He discovered the fraudulent decree only in 1986 when an interpleader suit disclosed it. After 15 years of …

V ALSALA KUMARI DEVI M.versusDIRECTOR, HIGHER SECONDARY EDUCATION AND ORS.,.

2007 INSC 974Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a High School Assistant (HSA) appointed in 1990, applied for promotion to the post of Higher Secondary School Teacher (HSST) when a vacancy arose. Although she was senior and possessed the required second‑class M.A. and B.Ed. qualifications, the Selection Committee appointed a junior …

M.P. STATE COOP. BANK LTD., BHOPALversusNANURAM YADAV AND ORS.

2007 INSC 975Case Partly allowed

The Madhya Pradesh State Cooperative Bank appointed 60 clerks‑cum‑typists on an ad‑hoc basis, later regularising them after written exams, interviews, probation and a security bond, in accordance with the Staff Service Rules. The Bank later terminated 58 of them on 27‑Oct‑1997, relying on a Lokayukt …

BRIJBHUSHAN YADAV AND ORS.versusUNION OF INDIA AND ANR.

2007 INSC 915Disposed off

Workmen were initially engaged as security guards through an agency on 1 Oct 1996. After the agency contract expired on 1 Oct 1997, they continued to work for the Telecom Department until 31 May 1999. Claiming that they had rendered continuous service of more than 240 days, they sought reinstatement …

MARKFED VANASPATI & ALLIED INDUSTRIESversusUNION OF INDIA

2007 INSC 922Dismissed

The appellant, Markfed Vanaspati & Allied Industries, entered into a contract with the Union of India to supply rapeseed oil but failed to meet the delivery schedule, leading to contract cancellation. The appellant invoked a force majeure clause, claiming that a government ban on the use of rapeseed …

M.D. UNIVERSITY, ROHTAKversusAJIT SINGH NANDAL AND ANR.

2007 INSC 911Dismissed

Ajit Singh Nandal, a university employee, challenged a university notification that declared his post vacant, alleging it amounted to an illegal removal without the required inquiry under the service rules. The trial court dismissed his suit, but the appellate court set aside that decision, holding …

COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE, MUMBAI-IVversusM/S. DAMNET CHEMICALS PVT. LTD. ETC.

2007 INSC 903Dismissed

Damnet Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. manufactured two products, ‘CRC 2-26’ and ‘CRC Acryform’, and claimed exemption from central excise duty under Notification No. 120/84‑CE (blended lubricating oil) and Notification No. 175/86‑CE (SSI) respectively. The Central Excise Department issued a show‑cause notice …

RAM NAYAKversusU.P. STATE SUGAR CORPORATION

2007 INSC 888Disposed off

Ram Nayak, a workman of Ratna Sugar Mills, claimed that he was employed by the undertaking on the "appointed day" (24 April 1989) when the mill was vested in U.P. State Sugar Corporation under the U.P. Sugar Undertaking Acquisition Act, 1971. He was terminated by an oral order on 1 June 1990. The …

HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATIONversusM/S CORK MANUFACTURING CO.

2007 INSC 874Disposed off

The appellant, Haryana State Industrial Development Corporation, resumed an industrial plot allotted to the respondent, Cork Manufacturing Co., alleging breach of a contractual construction deadline. The respondent filed a suit for permanent injunction, claiming the resumption order was illegal, …

SAROJAversusCHINNUSAMY (DEAD) BY LRS. AND ANR.

2007 INSC 859Dismissed

Saroja purchased a property from her husband Kuppusamy while a suit filed by her against Kuppusamy for title was pending. The earlier suit was decided ex parte in favour of the respondents, and the decree attained finality. Saroja then filed a separate suit asserting ownership of the same property, …

STATE OF GUJARATversusNARENDRA K. AMIN

2007 INSC 828Case Allowed

In a murder case, the Sessions Court granted anticipatory bail under Section 438 of the CrPC to Deputy Superintendent of Police Narendra K. Amin. The State of Gujarat appealed, contending that the court failed to consider the prosecution’s apprehension that the accused could influence or coerce …

HIMADRI CHEMICALS INDUSTRIES LTD.versusCOAL TAR REFINING COMPANY

2007 INSC 816Dismissed

Himadri Chemicals Industries Ltd entered into a contract with Coal Tar Refining Co. for supply of extra‑hard pitch coal, with payment to be made by an irrevocable Letter of Credit (LC) opened by the appellant. The appellant’s bank found discrepancies in the documents and, after the appellant waived …

SONIAversusORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. AND ORS.

2007 INSC 817Appeal(s) allowed

The Oriental Insurance Company advertised five Assistant Administrative Officer vacancies on 30 October 2003, reserving one for Scheduled Tribes (ST) but allowing exchange of reservations between Scheduled Castes (SC) and ST where no eligible candidate existed. Sonia, an SC employee, applied, …

CENTRAL BANK OF INDIAversusSIRIGUPPA SUGARS & CHEMICALS LTD. & ORS.

2007 INSC 818Appeal(s) allowed

The Central Bank of India had advanced a loan to Siriguppa Sugars & Chemicals Ltd. secured by a pledge of the company's sugar stock. The company defaulted, and the Recovery Authority seized the pledged sugar without the bank's consent, leading to its sale. The High Court, pending a writ appeal, …

MAHATMA GANDHI SAHAKRA SAKKARE KARKHANEversusNATIONAL HEAVY ENGG. COOP. LTD. AND ANR.

2007 INSC 747Appeal(s) allowed

The appellant, a Karnataka co‑operative sugar society, contracted a respondent to design, supply, erect and commission a sugar plant, with the respondent furnishing a bank guarantee. The guarantee stipulated that the bank would pay the appellant on demand without demur, and the appellant alone would …

RAM SUNDER RAMversusUNION OF INDIA & ORS.

2007 INSC 748Dismissed

Ram Sunder Ram, a Petrol, Oil and Lubricants clerk in the Indian Army, was alleged to have received illegal money for the clandestine sale of gas. A court of inquiry found him guilty of a prejudicial act, after which he was shown cause; his reply was deemed unsatisfactory and he was discharged from …

KISHOR KIRTILAL MEHTA AND ORS.versusLILAVATI KIRTILAL MEHTA MEDICAL TRUST AND ORS.

2007 INSC 736Disposed off

The Supreme Court considered appeals arising from a suit concerning the administration of the Lilavati Kirtilal Mehta Medical Trust under the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950. The trial court had struck out portions of the written statements of defendants 11‑13 and parts of the plaintiff's affidavit, …

STATE OF U.P. & ORS.versusDEEPAK FERTILIZERS & PETROCHEMICAL CORPORATION LTD.

2007 INSC 569Dismissed

The State of Uttar Pradesh had issued a notification on 2 November 1994 exempting the sale of the NPK 23:23:0 fertilizer from trade tax for the period 1 November 1994 to 31 March 1995. Two later notifications dated 10 April 1995 and 15 May 1995 withdrew that exemption retrospectively for NPK 23:23:0 …

PUNJAB STATE & ORS.versusDINA NATH

2007 INSC 570Dismissed

The Punjab State issued a work order containing a clause that any dispute between the department and the contractor would be referred to the Superintending Engineer, whose decision would be final and binding. After the contractor completed the work, a dispute arose over final bills and measurements, …

UNION OF INDIAversusA.S. GANGOLI AND ORS.

2007 INSC 473Appeal(s) allowed

The case concerned Air Force officers who voluntarily retired under a scheme to join the public sector undertaking Vayudoot Ltd. The Government issued a circular on 30 Oct 1987 granting a service‑weightage for pension calculation, but a note excluded officers who retired prematurely for permanent …

MAHARSHI DAYANAND UNIVERSITY & ANR.versusANAND COOP. L/C SOCIETY LTD. & ANR.

2007 INSC 463Dismissed

Maharshi Dayanand University invited tenders for construction of sheds. The respondent submitted a tender containing a clause (25A) providing for arbitration and the university accepted the tender, stipulating that work would commence from the date of acceptance but that no payment would be made …

N. RANGACHARIversusBHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LTD.

2007 INSC 438Dismissed

Data Access (India) Ltd issued two cheques to Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd which were dishonoured for insufficiency of funds. A complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was filed against the company and its directors, including the appellant N. Rangachari. The appellant claimed he …

USHA BALASAHEB SWAMI AND ORS.versusKIRAN APPASO SWAMI AND ORS.

2007 INSC 436Appeal(s) allowed

The suit concerned partition of ancestral property where the plaintiff claimed a half‑share. The defendants, in their written statement, admitted the plaintiff’s entitlement but later sought to amend the statement to allege that the plaintiff and certain co‑defendants were illegitimate children and …

MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, JABALPUR AND ORS.versusM/S. RAJESH CONSTRUCTIONS CO.

2007 INSC 418Disposed off

The Municipal Corporation of Jabalpur awarded a road‑construction contract to M/s Rajesh Constructions, which contained Clause 29 stipulating that any arbitration could only be initiated after the contractor furnished a security deposit and the corporation then constituted an Arbitration Board. A …

BEGUM SAHIBA SULTANversusNAWAB MOHD. MANSUR ALI KHAN AND ORS.

2007 INSC 411Dismissed

Begum Sahiba Sultan, the daughter of the deceased, filed a suit in the Delhi High Court seeking a declaration that an alleged oral will made by her mother was never made, a declaration that a sale deed was void, and a decree of partition of immovable properties situated in Village Pataudi, Gurgaon, …

DIRECTORATE OF FILM FESTIVALS AND ORS.versusGAURAV ASHWIN JAIN AND ORS.

2007 INSC 410Case Partly allowed

Documentary filmmakers sought to enter non‑feature films for the National Film Awards, challenging regulations that required certification by the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) and release on film format. They argued that entry did not constitute public exhibition, making certification …

FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIAversusM/S. CHANDU CONSTRUCTION AND ANR.

2007 INSC 406Appeal(s) allowed

The Food Corporation of India (FCI) entered into a construction contract with Chandu Construction for godowns, which required the rate to include both labour and material as per CPWD specifications. After termination of the contract, the claimants sought arbitration and were awarded Rs 8,23,101 for …

SARDAR KHAN AND ORS.versusSYED NAJMUL HASAN (SETH) AND ORS.

2007 INSC 234Disposed off

The Supreme Court examined whether the Wakf Act, 1995 barred civil courts from hearing a suit and its appeal that were filed before the Act came into force on 1 January 1996. The appellant Sardar Khan had filed a suit in 1976, which was dismissed in 1996, and the respondents appealed to the High …

FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA AND ANR.versusRAM KESH YADAV AND ANR

2007 INSC 221Dismissed

The Food Corporation of India (FCI) introduced a compassionate appointment scheme that allows dependants of workers who voluntarily retire on medical grounds to be appointed, provided the employee is below 55 years of age. The second respondent, a departmental worker, submitted a composite …

M/S. TRANSPORT CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD.versusM/S. VELJAN HYDRAIR LTD.

2007 INSC 189Dismissed

The Transport Corporation of India Ltd, a common carrier, was entrusted by Veljan Hydra Ltd with a hydraulic cylinder consignment in 1996. The carrier repeatedly assured the consignee that it was locating the goods but never informed them of any loss, and the consignment was never delivered. Veljan …

CHHEDI LAL MISRA (DEAD) THROUGH LRS.versusCIVIL JUDGE, LUCKNOW AND ORS.

2007 INSC 137Dismissed

The appellant obtained the disputed property through a conveyance from the Wakif and his Mutwalli after a collusive suit in 1958, despite the property having been declared a Wakf in 1926, registered under Section 38 of the U.P. Muslim Wakfs Act, 1936 and notified in the Official Gazette in 1954. The …

PEERLESS GENERAL FINANCE & INVESTMENT CO. LTD.versusPODDAR PROJECTS LTD. & ANR.

2007 INSC 138Disposed off

Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd. (appellant) held shares of Poddar Udyog Ltd. Under a court‑sanctioned scheme of arrangement, a portion of the business was transferred to Poddar Projects Ltd. (respondent No.1), which subsequently sold the shares to Vijaya Finance Corp. Ltd. (respondent …

UTTRARANCHAL FOREST RANGERS' ASSON.versusSTATE OF U.P. AND ORS.

2006 INSC 654Appeal(s) allowed

The appellants, directly recruited Forest Rangers in Uttar Pradesh (now Uttaranchal), challenged a High Court order that gave seniority to promotee Forest Rangers who had been elevated beyond the statutory promotion quota. The Court examined the U.P. Government Servants Seniority Rules, 1991, …

STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANR.versusMEWA SINGH

2006 INSC 166Appeal(s) allowed

The State of Punjab acquired land for urban development in SAS Nagar and framed a 1974 scheme to allot residential plots to persons whose land was taken. Mewa Singh, claiming a one‑fourth share in 66 kanals 9 marlas, applied in 1980 for a plot, asserting sole entitlement. Earlier writ proceedings …