Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Ram Lakhan Yadav @ RamlakhanversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The court held that, given the settlement and lack of evidence of an attempt to murder, the petitioners are entitled to provisional bail.

Summary

Ram Lakhan Yadav and his son Amit Kumar applied for pre‑arrest bail in a case registered under several sections of the Bihar Non‑Compulsory Act, alleging they assaulted the informant's father with intent to kill. The petitioners asserted that the dispute had been settled through a village Panchayat and that a joint compromise petition would be filed in the District Court. The State opposed bail but acknowledged the compromise. Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Naushey Ali v. State of Uttar Pradesh, the court examined the nature of the injuries and the weapon used, concluding that the facts did not satisfy the criteria for an attempt to murder under IPC 307. Consequently, the court granted provisional bail, subject to conditions, and ordered that the bail become absolute if no further complaint is made within six months.

Issues considered

  • Whether pre‑arrest bail can be granted in offences involving alleged attempt to murder when the parties have reached a settlement.
  • Whether the nature of injuries and weapon used disqualify the offence from falling under IPC 307 (attempt to murder) or IPC 149 (common object).
  • Effect of a settlement/compromise on the continuance of criminal proceedings.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • pre‑arrest bail
  • settlement
  • compromise petition
  • attempt to murder
  • IPC 307
  • criminal procedure
  • Bihar law

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

                              CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.30384 of 2026
                        Arising Out of PS. Case No.-36 Year-2025 Thana- Beladi District- Madhepura

                 ======================================================
           1.     Ram Lakhan Yadav @ Ramlakhan, aged about 48 years (wrongly mentioned
                 in impugned order as 60 years), S/O Late Bindeshwari Yadav
           2.    Amit Kumar, aged about 25 years, Male, S/O Ram Lakhan Yadav
                 Both are Resident of Village- Parihari, Ward No.- 13, P.S- Belari
                 (Kumarkhand), District- Madhepura.

                                                                                     ... ... Petitioner/s

                                                         Versus
                 The State of Bihar

                                                                               ... ... Opposite Party/s

                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s     :        Mr.Barun Kumar Singh, Advocate
                 For the Opposite Party/s :        Mr.Ram Naresh Ray, APP
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH

                                                    ORAL ORDER

2   13-05-2026                       Heard Mr. Barun Kumar Singh, learned counsel

                   appearing on behalf of the petitioners and Mr. Ram Naresh Ray,

                   learned APP for the State.

                                 2. The petitioners seek pre-arrest bail in connection

                   with Belari P.S. Case No. 36 of 2025 registered for the

                   offence(s)       punishable        under       Sections       115(2),       126(2),

                   109(1),352,351(2),3(5) of the BNS.

                                 3. As per the allegation made in the FIR, the accused

                   persons named therein including the petitioners assaulted the
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.30384 of 2026(2) dt.13-05-2026
                                            2/6




          father of the informant, with an intention to kill, causing

          injuries.

                        4. At the outset, learned counsel appearing on behalf

          of the petitioner submitted that specific statement has been

          made in paragraph no.11 of the bail petition that the matter has

          been compromised between the parties in presence of local

          village Panchayat. The compromise petition has been brought

          on record by way of Annexure-4. It has further been informed

          that the parties have agreed to file a joint compromise petition

          before the learned District Court concerned.

                        5. Learned APP for the State vehemently opposed the

          prayer for grant of pre-arrest bail, however, supports the factum

          of compromise.

                       6. Considering the aforesaid information given by the

          petitioner, I find it apt to reproduce the observations made by

          the Apex Court in para-11 to 20 in case of Naushey Ali & Ors.

          Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. reported in (2025) 4 SCC 78,

          which are as under:

                                                “11. Before we apply this judgment to
                                  the facts, it will be worthwhile to recall the
                                  observations of Sikri, J. in Narinder Singh
                                  (supra):-
                                  "26. Having said so, we would hasten to add that
                                  though it is a serious offence as the accused
                                  person(s) attempted to take the life of another
                                  person/victim, at the same time the court cannot be
                                  oblivious to hard realities that many times whenever
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.30384 of 2026(2) dt.13-05-2026
                                            3/6




                                  there is a quarrel between the parties leading to
                                  physical commotion and sustaining of injury by
                                  either or both the parties, there is a tendency to give
                                  it a slant of an offence under Section 307 IPC as
                                  well..."
                                                                   (Emphasis supplied)
                                  12. Coming back to Laxmi Narayan (supra), this
                                  Court has held that mere mention of Section 307
                                  IPC in the FIR or the charge-sheet should not be the
                                  basis for adopting a hands-off approach. It has
                                  further held that it would be open for the court to
                                  examine as to whether incorporation of Section 307
                                  IPC is there for the sake of it or whether there is
                                  evidence to back it. It has been held that the courts
                                  may go by the nature of injuries sustained; as to
                                  whether the injuries are inflicted on the vital/
                                  delicate parts of the body and the nature of weapon
                                  used. It has also been clarified that such an exercise
                                  would be permissible after investigation and filing
                                  of chargesheet/framing of charges or during the
                                  trial. [See 15.4 of Laxmi Narayan (supra)].
                                  13. Coming to the facts of the case, admittedly, there
                                  is a settlement between the parties. The case filed by
                                  the appellants' party which was prior in point of
                                  time and that too on the same day of occurrence,
                                  has been settled.
                                  14. It should be recalled that, at the outset, after
                                  investigation, the police actually closed the case in
                                  its final report of 07.09.1991. It was the trial Court,
                                  which by its order of 05.09.1992, refused to accept
                                  the same and summoned the appellants. The
                                  incident is of 11.08.1991, i.e. about 33½ years back.
                                  No doubt, there is a reference to the firing in the FIR
                                  but admittedly there was no injury. The allegation is
                                  that firing was done by Abdul Waris. He is since
                                  deceased. The facts, assuming to be true, also do not
                                  make out a case of common object for the appellants
                                  under Section 149 IPC insofar as the offence of
                                  Section 307 is concerned.
                                  15. The role attributed to the seven members,
                                  including the five appellants is not specific. General
                                  allegation was that they abused in filthy language
                                  and assaulted Mahmood with lathi and iron bars.
                                  The specific individual role was only attributed to
                                  Adbul Waris, who is since deceased.
                                  16. In any event, the police who investigated
                                  disbelieved the entire story. No recoveries have been
                                  made of any pellets. What engaged the attention of
                                  the High Court was only the fracture of the head of
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.30384 of 2026(2) dt.13-05-2026
                                            4/6




                                  the distal phalanx of left finger of respondent No.2.
                                  17. We have seen the injuries sustained by
                                  Mahmood (R-2) from the medical evidence
                                  collected. From the injury report, it is clear that
                                  while the first four injuries were contusions and
                                  abrasions, injury Nos. 5, 6 and 7 pertained to
                                  incised lacerated wound and swelling on the middle
                                  finger of the left hand. We have also seen the x-ray
                                  report which shows that in the left hand there was a
                                  fracture of the head of distal phalanx of left ring
                                  finger. Assuming that this was the result of injury
                                  with lathis or iron bar, applying the test in Laxmi
                                  Narayan (supra), considering the injury and the
                                  nature of the weapon used, certainly no offence
                                  under Section 307 IPC is made out.
                                  18. Section 307 of IPC reads as under:-
                                  "307. Attempt to murder.-
                                  Whoever does any act with such intention or
                                  knowledge, and under such circumstances that, if he
                                  by that act caused death, he would be guilty of
                                  murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of
                                  either description for a term which may extend to
                                  ten years, and shall also be liable to fine; and if hurt
                                  is caused to any person by such act, the offender
                                  shall be liable either to imprisonment for life, or to
                                  such punishment as is hereinbefore mentioned.
                                  Attempts by life convicts.- When any person
                                  offending under this section is under sentence of
                                  imprisonment for life, he may, if hurt is caused, be
                                  punished with death."
                                  19. Keeping in mind the surrounding circumstances,
                                  the nature of the weapon and the nature of the
                                  injury, on facts, we are inclined to conclude that the
                                  overt act attributed to the appellants does not bring
                                  the case within the four corners of the Section 307
                                  of IPC, either on a stand-alone basis or as held
                                  above with the aid of Section 149 of IPC.
                                  20. We are also inclined to conclude that
                                  considering the overall circumstances, the nature of
                                  the weapon and the nature of the injury (fracture of
                                  the head of distal phalanx of left ring finger), the
                                  offence alleged, on facts, does not fall in that
                                  category of cases where the court should deny relief
                                  in the event of a settlement. At the highest, the
                                  offence alleged could be one under Section 326 of
                                  IPC. It could not be said, on facts, considering all
                                  the circumstances that this is a crime which has
                                  such an harmful effect on the public and that it has
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.30384 of 2026(2) dt.13-05-2026
                                            5/6




                                  the effect of seriously threatening the well-being of
                                  the society. We make it clear that we are saying so
                                  on the facts of the present case. We are also firmly of
                                  the opinion that proceeding with the trial, when
                                  parties have amicably resolved the dispute in the
                                  present case, would be futile and the ends of justice
                                  require that the settlement be given effect to by
                                  quashing the proceedings. It would be a grave abuse
                                  of process to let this trial remain pending under the
                                  above circumstances, particularly when the dispute
                                  is settled and resolved.”



                       7. In light of the law laid down by the Apex Court as

          referred above and considering that the parties have already

          settled the dispute and they are                 willing to file      a joint

          compromise petition before the learned District Court, the

          petitioners, named above, are directed to be released on

          provisional bail on such terms and conditions as the learned

          District Court deems it fit and proper.

                       8. In the event a joint compromise petition is filed by

          both parties and no further complaint is made by either side for

          a further period of six months, thereafter, the provisional bail

          granted to the petitioners shall be made absolute by the learned

          District Court on such terms and conditions as the learned

          District Court deems it fit and proper.

                       9.    In     case      of    failure    on     part    of     the

          informant/complainant, the learned District Court is directed to

          make the provisional bail absolute, or it is, otherwise, on the
           Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.30384 of 2026(2) dt.13-05-2026
                                                       6/6




                     part of the petitioner then the interim relief granted to the

                     petitioner shall lose its force and the learned trial Court may

                     proceed with trial in accordance with law.

                                  10. The bail applications stand disposed of.



                                               (Purnendu Singh, J)
Sanjay/-

U      T


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.