Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Rakhi SharmaversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The court held that the FIR does not disclose an overwhelming element of criminality and the matter is essentially civil, warranting mediation and conditional pre‑arrest bail.

Summary

The petitioners – Rakhi Sharma, Akhilesh Kumar Sharma and Rajendra Sharma – were arrested under IPC Section 420 for allegedly cheating a complainant in a land‑sale transaction. The FIR alleged that the complainant paid Rs 4,80,000 to Akhilesh Sharma’s bank account and Rs 8,00,000 in cash to Rajendra Sharma and Akhilesh Sharma, but the sale deed was never executed and the money was not returned. The petitioners contended that they are innocent and that the dispute is purely civil, seeking pre‑arrest bail and an amicable settlement. The High Court, relying on Supreme Court precedents, held that the FIR lacks a clear criminal element and amounts to a civil dispute, directing the matter to mediation under the Mediation Act, 2023 and granting interim pre‑arrest bail subject to compliance. The court ordered the district court to refer the case to a mediator and stipulated that bail will continue if settlement is reached, otherwise the parties may pursue appropriate remedies.

Issues considered

  • The FIR discloses a criminal offence or merely a civil dispute.
  • Whether pre‑arrest bail should be granted in a case that appears to be civil in nature.
  • Whether continuation of criminal proceedings would constitute an abuse of process of law.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • pre‑arrest bail
  • civil dispute
  • mediation
  • Section 420 IPC
  • abuse of process
  • settlement
  • Criminal Procedure Code

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                              CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.7525 of 2026
                  Arising Out of PS. Case No.-315 Year-2022 Thana- SAMASTIPUR COMPLAINT CASE
                                                   District- Samastipur
                 ======================================================
           1.     Rakhi Sharma W/o Akhilesh Kumar Sharma
           2.    Akhilesh Kumar Sharma S/o Deo Narayan Sharma
           3.    Rajendra Sharma S/o Ramakant Sharma
                 All are R/o Village- Rahimapur Angar, P.S - Angarghat, District - Samastipur

                                                                               ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                   Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar
           2.    Md. Tazuddin S/o Late Md. Ali R/o Mohalla - Dharampur, Ward No. 01, P.S
                 - Samastipur (Town), District - Samastipur

                                                        ... ... Opposite Party/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s     :    Mr.Dilip Kumar Roy, Advocate
                 For the Opposite Party/s :    Mr.Jai Narain Thakur, APP
                 For the O.P. No.2        :    Mr. Mazharul Hassan, Advocate
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH
                                       ORAL ORDER

7   12-05-2026                         Heard Mr. Dilip Kumar Roy, learned counsel

                   appearing on behalf of the petitioners; Mr. Jai Narain Thakur,

                   learned APP for the State and Mr. Mazharul Hassan, learned

                   counsel for the O.P. No.2.

                                2. The petitioners seek pre-arrest bail in connection

                   with C.R. No.315 of 2022 registered for the offence(s)

                   punishable under Sections 420 of the Indian Penal Code.

                                3. As per the allegations made in the FIR, the

                   petitioners entered into an agreement to sell their land to the

                   complainant for a consideration amount of Rs.14,00,000/-,
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.7525 of 2026(7) dt.12-05-2026
                                            2/5




          pursuant to which the complainant allegedly transferred

          Rs.4,80,000/- to the bank account of accused Akhilesh Sharma

          (petitioner no.2) and paid Rs.8,00,000/- in cash to accused

          Rajendra Sharma (petitioner no.3) and Akhilesh Sharma, but

          thereafter the petitioners neither executed the sale deed nor

          refunded the amount advanced by the complainant.

                       4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

          petitioners submitted that the petitioners are innocent and have

          falsely been implicated in the present case.          However, on

          instruction, learned counsel submitted that the matter is purely

          civil in nature and to buy peace of mind, petitioners want to

          settle the dispute amicably outside the Court.

                       5. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the O.P.

          No.2 and learned APP appearing on behalf of the State

          submitted that a chance be given to the parties for amicable

          settlement outside the court.

                       6. Counsels for the respective parties on instructions,

          submitted that the petitioner and O.P. No.2 have agreed to

          appear before the learned District Court at 10:30 A.M. on or

          before 19.05.2026.

                       7. Heard the parties

                       8. Considering the nature of allegation made in the
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.7525 of 2026(7) dt.12-05-2026
                                            3/5




          F.I.R. which has a civil flavour and the same prima facie don’t

          disclose an overwhelming element of criminality. In the absence

          of the element of criminality, if both civil and criminal cases are

          allowed to continue, it will definitely amount to abuse of the

          process of law.

                         9. In this regard, I find it apt to refer the observation

          made by the Apex Court in para-12 in case of Paramjeet Batra

          v. State of Uttarakhand, (2013) 11 SCC 673, which is

          reproduced hereinafter::

                                              "12. While exercising its jurisdiction
                                  under Section 482 of the Code the High Court has to
                                  be cautious. This power is to be used sparingly and
                                  only for the purpose of preventing abuse of the
                                  process of any court or otherwise to secure ends of
                                  justice. Whether a complaint discloses a criminal
                                  offence or not depends upon the nature of facts
                                  alleged therein. Whether essential ingredients of
                                  criminal offence are present or not has to be judged
                                  by the High Court. A complaint disclosing civil
                                  transactions may also have a criminal texture. But
                                  the High Court must see whether a dispute which is
                                  essentially of a civil nature is given a cloak of
                                  criminal offence. In such a situation, if a civil
                                  remedy is available and is, in fact, adopted as has
                                  happened in this case, the High Court should not
                                  hesitate to quash the criminal proceedings to
                                  prevent abuse of process of the court."

                       10. In case of Usha Chakraborty v. State of West

          Bengal, (2023) 15 SCC 135, while quashing the FIR therein and

          further proceedings based thereon, the Apex Court observed as

          under: -

                                ‘...the factual position thus would reveal that the
                  genesis as also the purpose of criminal proceedings are nothing but
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.7525 of 2026(7) dt.12-05-2026
                                            4/5




                  the aforesaid incident and further that the dispute involved is
                  essentially of civil nature.’

                       11. The Apex Court has reiterated the aforesaid

          preposition in its recent judgment of S.N. Vijayalakshmi &

          Ors. Vrs. The State of Karnataka and Anr. reported in (2025)

          SCC Online SC 1575.

                       12. Learned District Court is directed to refer the

          matter before the learned Mediator of the District Mediation

          Center under the provision of Mediation Act, 2023 by fixing a

          date for their appearance to give effect to “Mediation for the

          Nation 2.0.”

                       13. Thereafter, learned Mediator of the District

          Mediation Center concerned shall make his/her best efforts to

          settle the dispute amicably and submit his/her report before the

          concerned learned District Court, well within a period of three

          months, till then, no coercive action shall be taken against the

          petitioners in connection with the aforesaid case.

                       14. In case, the parties resolve their dispute amicably

          or arrive at a mutual settlement, in light of the law laid down by

          the Apex Court as referredabove, the petitioners are required to

          be released on pre-arrest bail on such terms and conditions as

          the learned District Court deems it fit and proper.

                       15. In case of failure on the part of the petitioners to
           Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.7525 of 2026(7) dt.12-05-2026
                                                       5/5




                     appear on or before 19.05.2026 before the learned District Court

                     or any date fixed by the learned Mediator, the interim protection

                     granted to the petitioners shall automatically lose its force.

                                  16.     In case, it is deliberate on the part of the

                     complainant to reconcile, then in that case,           the   interim

                     protection granted to the petitioners shall continue and the trial

                     shall proceed in accordance with law.

                                  17. In case, the parties fail to reconcile, then in that

                     case, parties may avail appropriate remedy. Then also,

                     petitioners are directed to be released on pre-arrest bail on such

                     terms and conditions as the learned District Court deems it fit

                     and proper.

                                  18.    With aforesaid direction and observation, the

                     present application stands disposed of.

                                  19. Let a copy of this order be communicated to the

                     Member Secretary, Bihar State Legal Services Authority and the

                     Patna High Court Mediation Centre for the purpose of record.



                                               (Purnendu Singh, J)
Sanjay/-

U      T


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.