Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Amrendra Kumar MishraversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The order dated 20‑09‑2021 imposing a permanent 50% pension deduction is unsustainable and is hereby quashed.

Summary

The petitioner, a former District Programme Officer, was implicated in a case of forged signatures leading to illegal bank withdrawals and faced departmental proceedings. An enquiry report found only the third charge of illegal withdrawals proved, despite no witnesses being examined or documentary evidence substantiating the allegation. Consequently, a notification dated 20‑09‑2021 under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 deducted 50% of his pension, and a later letter declared his appeal against the punishment non‑maintainable. The petitioner challenged both the punishment and the denial of appeal, arguing violation of the principles of a quasi‑judicial departmental inquiry and lack of evidence. The Court, relying on Supreme Court precedents that require proof beyond suspicion in disciplinary inquiries, held that the enquiry officer erred and that there was no evidence to sustain the charge. The order imposing the pension deduction was quashed and the petitioner was directed to receive the deducted pension within three months.

Issues considered

  • Whether the order deducting 50% of the petitioner’s pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 is valid in the absence of evidentiary proof.
  • Whether the departmental inquiry complied with the requirements of a quasi‑judicial proceeding, particularly the need for witness examination and proof of the charge.
  • Whether an appeal against the punishment order is maintainable under the Bihar Civil Servants (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 2005.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • pension deduction
  • departmental inquiry
  • no evidence
  • quasi‑judicial proceeding
  • Rule 43(b)
  • Bihar Pension Rules
  • appeal maintainability
  • Civil Servants Rules

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.13078 of 2023
     ======================================================
     Amrendra Kumar Mishra Son of late Birendra Kumar Mishra, Resident of
     House No. 2259, Sector-8A. Street No.-11, Bokaro Steel City, Bokaro,
     Jharkhand.

                                                              ... ... Petitioner/s
                                      Versus
1.   The State of Bihar Through the Principal Secretary, Education Department,
     Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.   The Principal Secretary, Education Department, Government of Bihar,
     Patna.
3.   The Director (Administration)-cum-Additional         Secretary,     Education
     Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s   :      Mr. Vaidehi Raman Prasad Singh, Advocate
     For the Respondent/s   :      Mr. Kameshwar Kumar, GP-17
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY
     CAV JUDGMENT

     Date : 23-06-2026

                     Heard Mr. Vaidehi Raman Prasad Singh, learned

      counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Kameshwar Kumar, learned

      Government Pleader for the respondents.

                     2. The petitioner has filed the instant application for

      the following reliefs:

                                                  “i.    For    grant    of   an
                                   appropriate writ for quashing the
                                   Notification under          Memo No.428
                                   dated 20.9.2021 issued under the
                                   signature        of         the      Director
                                   (Administration)-cum-Additional
                                   Secretary,     Education          Department,
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           2/12




                                         Government of Bihar withholding
                                         50% of pension admissible to the
                                         petitioner under Rule 43(b) of Bihar
                                         Pension Rules, 1950 on the ground
                                         that there was a grave administrative
                                         failure on the part of the petitioner
                                         which         had     resulted     in      illegal
                                         withdrawal          of     huge    government
                                         money (Annexure-6).
                                                         ii.      For    grant   of     an
                                         appropriate writ for quashing the
                                         Letter No.346 dated 11.7.2023 of the
                                         Director                 (Administration)-cum-
                                         Additional          Secretary,       Education
                                         Department informing the petitioner
                                         that no appeal is admissible against
                                         the order of the Government under the
                                         provision of Bihar Civil Servants
                                         (Classification, Control and Appeal)
                                         Rules, 2005 and as such the appeal
                                         filed by him is not maintainable
                                         (Annexure-8).
                                                         iii. For grant of an
                                         appropriate writ for a direction to the
                                         respondents           to       exonerate      the
                                         petitioner from the charges leveled
                                         against him and to make order for
                                         grant of full pension to the petitioner
                                         with consequential benefits.”

                        3. The case of the petitioner in brief is that at the
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           3/12




         relevant time when the petitioner was posted as District

         Programme Officer, Planning and Accounts, Saran, Chapra, he

         received information about a cheque for Rs.9,56,500/- having

         been presented to the bank for withdrawal. On reaching the

         bank and obtaining the details, it transpired that between

         14.8.2012 and 4.10.2012 using forged signature of the

         petitioner, a sum of Rs.54,55,800/- had been withdrawn from

         the bank. The petitioner got an FIR being Bhagwan Bazar P.S.

         Case no.193 of 2012 registered in the jurisdictional police

         station.

                        4. By order dated 28.11.2012, the petitioner was

         placed under suspension in contemplation of a disciplinary

         proceeding. A departmental proceeding was initiated against

         him with the service of the memo of charge on 28.11.2012.

                        5. The petitioner was asked to submit his reply

         which he filed on 19.6.2015.

                        6. The Conducting Officer submitted the enquiry

         report on 27.7.2015 finding charge nos.1 and 2 not to have been

         proved while charge no.3 was found to be proved.

                        7. The petitioner was served with a copy of the

         enquiry report with a direction to file his response thereto which

         he filed on 5.12.2015.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           4/12




                        8. The respondents came out with the order of

         punishment contained in memo no.428 dated 20.9.2021 issued

         under the signature of the Director (Administration)-cum-

         Additional Secretary, Education Department, Government of

         Bihar imposing the punishment of permanent deduction of 50%

         of the petitioner’s pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar

         Pension Rules, 1950.

                        9. The petitioner filed an appeal before the

         Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department, Bihar,

         however he was communicated with letter dated 11.7.2023 of

         the      Director     (Administration)-cum-Additional   Secretary,

         Education Department that appeal is not maintainable against

         the order of punishment, though a review application can be

         filed.

                        10. By way of the instant writ application, the

         petitioner has challenged the order of punishment dated

         20.9.2021 deducting 50% of the petitioner’s pension under Rule

         43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 as also the letter dated

         11.7.2023 communicating to the petitioner that the appeal filed

         by him is not maintainable.

                        11. It is submitted by learned counsel for the

         petitioner that he was not given opportunity to examine
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           5/12




         witnesses in his defence, the Conducting Officer found the

         petitioner guilty of the charge not framed against him, he was

         not given second show cause notice against the proposed

         punishment and the Disciplinary Officer has passed the

         impugned order without considering the defence of the

         petitioner. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits

         that no witness having been examined by the respondents nor

         any document exhibited or proved in support of the charges

         levelled against the petitioner, this is a case of no evidence

         against the petitioner. Reliance has been placed by learned

         counsel for the petitioner on the judgment in the case of Roop

         Singh Negi vs. Punjab National Bank & Ors.; (2009) 2 SCC

         570.

                        12. The application is opposed by learned counsel

         appearing for the respondents. It is submitted that though the

         proceedings was started against the petitioner under the Bihar

         Government Servants (Classification, Control and Appeal)

         Rules, 2005 (‘CCA Rules’ in short), the petitioner having

         superannuated from service during pendency of the proceedings

         on 31.10.2019, the proceedings were converted into one under

         Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules. The petitioner was given

         opportunity at each stage of the proceedings and in the enquiry
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           6/12




         conducted, the Conducting Officer found charge no.3 to be

         proved against the petitioner. Enclosing a copy of the enquiry

         report dated 27.7.2015, the petitioner was asked to submit his

         response thereto which he filed on 5.12.2015 requesting that he

         be completely exonerated. Thereafter taking into consideration

         the material on record including the memo of charge, the reply

         filed by the petitioner, the enquiry report submitted by the

         Conducting Officer, the contents of the second show cause

         notice and the reply thereto filed by the petitioner, the order of

         punishment dated 20.9.2021 was passed against the petitioner

         which is impugned herein. It was finally submitted that the

         order of punishment having been passed by the Government (on

         the orders of the Governor, Bihar) no appeal against the same

         was maintainable under the CCA Rules. The petitioner not

         having been able to show any illegality or irregularity in the

         conduct of the proceedings, the writ application be dismissed.

                        13. Heard learned counsel for the parties and

         perused the material on record.

                        14. The relevant facts in brief are that on the

         petitioner having received information about a cheque for

         Rs.9,56,500/- having been received for payment in the bank, the

         petitioner reached the bank and made enquiries. The payment
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           7/12




         was stopped. On enquiry, it transpired that a total sum of

         Rs.54,55,800/- was withdrawn from the bank between

         14.8.2012 and 4.10.2012 by different persons including some

         fake persons using forged signature of the petitioner.

                        15. The petitioner accordingly lodged an FIR which

         was registered as Bhagwan Bazar P.S. Case no.193 of 2012 on

         6.10.2012 under sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120B of the

         Indian Penal Code.

                        16. The petitioner was thereafter placed under

         suspension in contemplation of a departmental proceeding

         which was initiated with the service of the memo of charge on

         the petitioner on 28.11.2012.

                        17. The three charges against the petitioner was:

                        (i) Up to date cash register relating to projects were

         not presented on demand for its critical study,

                        (ii) Report relating to projects were not produced

         for its critical study, and

                        (iii) Illegal withdrawals were made from bank

         account no.106510400003651 relating to accounts and planning

         of District Education Programme Officer which showed his

         wrong intention.

                        18. The petitioner submitted his reply to the memo
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           8/12




         of charge and the proceedings started wherein the Conducting

         Officer submitted his enquiry report dated 27.7.2015. As per the

         report, while charge nos.1 and 2 were not found to have been

         proved, charge no.3 was found to be proved.

                        19. A perusal of the enquiry report, a copy of which

         has been brought on record as Annexure-4 to the writ

         application would show that there is no mention therein of any

         witness having been examined in support of the charges against

         the petitioner. Though by way of documentary evidence with

         respect to charge no.3, there is mention of letter no.818 dated

         12.10.2012 of the Regional Deputy Director of Education, Saran

         Division, Chapra, however it is not in dispute that no witness

         having been examined, neither the said letter nor the contents

         thereof has been proved in course of the departmental

         proceeding.

                        20. On further perusal of the reasoning/opinion

         given by the Enquiry Officer with respect to charge no.3, it

         transpires that the Enquiry Officer notes that no strong evidence

         has been produced by the Presenting Officer showing the

         intention or involvement of the petitioner in the illegal

         withdrawal. However as the withdrawals have taken place by

         cheques, the Conducting Officer concludes that the petitioner
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                           9/12




         miserably failed in financial management as a result of which

         the Government suffered financial loss and thus the charge no.3

         is proved.

                        21. At this stage itself, it would be relevant to

         observe that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its judgment in the

         case of Roop Singh Negi (supra) held as follows:

                                                       “14.       Indisputably,    a
                                         departmental proceeding is a quasi-
                                         judicial      proceeding.     The   enquiry
                                         officer       performs    a   quasi-judicial
                                         function. The charges levelled against
                                         the delinquent officer must be found to
                                         have been proved. The enquiry officer
                                         has a duty to arrive at a finding upon
                                         taking        into   consideration       the
                                         materials brought on record by the
                                         parties.       The   purported      evidence
                                         collected during investigation by the
                                         investigating officer against all the
                                         accused by itself could not be treated
                                         to be evidence in the disciplinary
                                         proceeding. No witness was examined
                                         to prove the said documents. The
                                         management           witnesses       merely
                                         tendered the documents and did not
                                         prove the contents thereof. Reliance,
                                         inter alia, was placed by the enquiry
                                         officer on the FIR which could not
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                          10/12




                                         have been treated as evidence.”

                        22. A Division Bench of this Court in the case of

         Devendra Prasad vs. The State of Bihar and Ors. (judgment

         dated 19.10.2023 passed in L.P.A. no. 1302 of 2017), following

         Roop Singh Negi (supra) observed as follows:

                                                       “7. As has been held in Roop
                                         Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank
                                         and others; (2009) 2 SCC 570, the
                                         documents           produced         in         a
                                         departmental inquiry has to be proved
                                         by examining witnesses. Even an
                                         F.I.R. was held to be not evidence by
                                         itself without actual proof of facts
                                         stated therein. The Hon’ble Supreme
                                         Court had also held that even an
                                         admission or confession to the police
                                         itself is not sufficient to find the
                                         delinquent employee guilty in a
                                         departmental        proceeding        if       no
                                         evidence is brought on record to prove
                                         the offence or misconduct alleged.
                                         Departmental inquiry was held to be a
                                         quasi-judicial proceeding and the
                                         Inquiry Officer functions in the status
                                         of a quasi-judicial authority. Not only
                                         should        evidence   be    led        in   a
                                         departmental inquiry, the conclusions
                                         arrived at should be based on
Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                          11/12




                                         evidence      which   brings   forth   a
                                         probability that the delinquent has
                                         committed the misconduct alleged and
                                         charged against him. No Inquiry
                                         Report based on conjectures and
                                         surmises can be sustained and even in
                                         a departmental inquiry, the standard
                                         of proof is not a mere suspicion.
                                         However high the degree of suspicion
                                         is, it cannot be a substitute for legal
                                         proof.”

                        23. Taking into consideration the facts and

         circumstances of the case, no witness having been examined on

         behalf of the respondents in course of the enquiry in the

         departmental proceeding, it is a case of no evidence against the

         petitioner. Further on perusal of the conclusion of the enquiry

         report where the finding with respect to charge no.3 having been

         proved is given, it transpires that the Conducting Officer himself

         observes that in course of enquiry the Presenting Officer did not

         produce any evidence of the petitioner having any ill intention

         or being involved directly or indirectly in the withdrawal of any

         amount.

                        24. In the above circumstances, the Conducting

         Officer seriously erred in coming to the conclusion that charge

         no.3 was proved against the petitioner.
             Patna High Court CWJC No.13078 of 2023 dt.23-06-2026
                                                       12/12




                                     25. In view of the facts and circumstances of the

                      case, from the contents of the enquiry report, the Court has no

                      hesitation in holding that it is a case of no evidence against the

                      petitioner. As such, the order of punishment dated 20.9.2021

                      (Annexure-6) issued under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension

                      Rules permanently deducting 50% of the petitioner’s pension is

                      not sustainable.

                                     26. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the

                      order/notification of punishment contained in Memo no.428

                      dated 20.9.2021 issued on the orders of the Governor, Bihar

                      under the signature of the Director (Administration)-cum-

                      Additional Secretary, Education Department, Government of

                      Bihar being unsustainable is hereby quashed and set aside.

                                     27. The writ application is allowed.

                                     28. Any pension deducted consequent to the order

                      of the punishment passed, impugned herein, shall be paid to the

                      petitioner within a period of three months from the date of

                      receipt/production of a copy of this order.



                                                  (Partha Sarthy, J)
sauravkrsinha/-
AFR/NAFR                NAFR
CAV DATE                14.5.2026
Uploading Date          23.6.2026
Transmission Date       NA


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.