Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Bihar Pension Rules, 1950

38 judgments · newest first · showing 1–38

Rajeshwar DayalversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a former Director and additional Engineer‑in‑Chief of the Water Resources Department, was penalised by a notification dated 11‑04‑2017 that permanently withheld 50% of his pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950. He challenged the punishment, arguing that the …

Ram Sukhit RoyversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a Senior Treasury Officer, was dismissed after a departmental enquiry into alleged withholding of a gratuity payment to Alok Kumar Gupta. The enquiry relied solely on documentary evidence, omitted a list of witnesses, and did not allow the complainant or witnesses to be examined, …

Umesh Chandra SinghversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a former police constable promoted to Assistant Sub‑Inspector, was suspended in 2019 after a viral video alleged police officials at a check‑post were collecting illegal gratification. An initial departmental enquiry dismissed the allegation of receiving money but found he had failed …

Amrendra Kumar MishraversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a former District Programme Officer, was implicated in a case of forged signatures leading to illegal bank withdrawals and faced departmental proceedings. An enquiry report found only the third charge of illegal withdrawals proved, despite no witnesses being examined or documentary …

Govind PrasadversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

The petitioner, Govind Prasad, filed a writ petition challenging a disciplinary proceeding initiated under Section 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950. He sought permission to withdraw the petition because the punishment order was still in force and was also pending challenge in another writ …

Bhagwan DasversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

ALLOWED

The petitioner, Bhagwan Das, was engaged as a daily‑wage worker in 1979 and later regularised in 2008, but the Department refused to count his pre‑2008 service for pension benefits, citing a clause in his appointment letter. The High Court examined the applicability of Rules 56, 58, 59 and 61 of the …

Kalktari Devi @ Kalakatari DeviversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a widow of a deceased government employee, challenged a memo (No. 1400 dated 28‑09‑2022) that demanded recovery of Rs 19,18,073 from her late husband’s death‑cum‑retirement benefits. She argued that no enquiry under the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 was conducted during the employee’s …

Chandrakali DeviversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

Chandrakali Devi, the second wife of a deceased Class‑IV employee of Government Medical College, Bettiah, filed a writ petition seeking the family pension and other retiral benefits that accrued after her husband’s death on 12‑Nov‑2021. She contended that the first wife had died before the employee, …

Anil KumarversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

Anil Kumar, a retired Sub‑Divisional Police Officer, challenged a 10% pension deduction imposed under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, alleging that the departmental proceedings only established partial inefficiency and not grave misconduct or pecuniary loss. He argued that the charges of poor …

Rajendra Prasad RamversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a retired Technical Advisor, was served a show‑cause notice for alleged misconduct dating back to 2009 and subsequently had a 10% deduction imposed on his monthly pension for three years under Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950. He contended that no formal departmental enquiry …

Raj Narayan PoddarversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated lead writ petition (CWJC No.17271 of 2023) and several related petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions were abruptly stopped by the State of Bihar on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The …

Arvind KumarversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated group of writ petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions had been stopped on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The petitioners argued that they had served continuously for decades, received …

Kuwar Munni Devi @ Munni DeviversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated group of civil writ petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions had been stopped by the State of Bihar on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The petitioners argued that they had served continuously, …

Pawan Kumar JhaversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated group of civil writ petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions had been stopped by the State of Bihar on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The petitioners argued that they had served continuously, …

Satyadeo SinghversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated group of civil writ petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions had been stopped by the State of Bihar on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The petitioners argued that they had served continuously, …

Shail DeviversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated lead writ petition (CWJC No.17271 of 2023) and several related petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions were abruptly stopped by the State of Bihar on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The …

Akhileshwar PrasadversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The Patna High Court heard a consolidated group of civil writ petitions filed by retired health‑department employees whose pensions had been stopped by the State of Bihar on the ground that their original appointments were illegal or forged. The petitioners argued that they had served continuously, …

Ashutosh SharanversusThe State of Bihar through the Secretary,

DISPOSED

Ashutosh Sharan, a retired government employee, had his entire pension withheld under Bihar Pension Rule 43(B) following a disciplinary proceeding. The inquiry officer’s report exonerated him, but the disciplinary authority issued a show‑cause notice disagreeing with the report and later passed an …

Ashutosh SharanversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

Ashutosh Sharan, a retired employee, had his entire pension withheld under Bihar Pension Rule 43(B) following a departmental disciplinary proceeding. The inquiry officer’s report exonerated him, but the disciplinary authority disagreed, issued a show‑cause notice and, despite the petitioner’s second …

Yogendra PrasadversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

Yogendra Prasad, a retired statistician, was alleged to have altered his date of birth from 1961 to 1964, thereby drawing salary for three extra years. A departmental proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules was initiated, resulting in an order that stopped two salary increments and …

Shambhu PrasadversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

Shambhu Prasad, a former Assistant Engineer, challenged a departmental order that deducted 20% of his pension for three years despite two inquiry reports finding him not guilty. He argued that the second show‑cause notice and the punishment violated natural justice, the Bihar CCA Rules, 2005, and …

Kaushal Kishore VermaversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

The petitioner, a retired Junior Engineer, challenged an order dated 12 April 2021 that forfeited his pension and salary arrears under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950. He argued that the departmental proceeding did not find him guilty of grave misconduct or pecuniary loss, making the …

BiharversusRamyati Singh

DISPOSED

The State of Bihar appealed against a single judge’s order that upheld a permanent 5% pension deduction imposed on retired Executive Engineer Ramyati Singh for alleged procedural irregularities in a 1998‑99 road repair tender. Singh was charged with executing the agreement without proper …

Bhola Prasad Das @ Bhola DasversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a retired Upper Division Clerk, challenged a 2016 order by the District Magistrate of Madhubani that permanently deducted 10% from his pension under the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950. He alleged that the departmental inquiry that led to the punishment was conducted without serving him …

Rajendra Prasad JaiswalversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

DISMISSED

The petitioner, a retired assistant teacher, filed a writ petition seeking quashing of Memo No. 1592 dated 13-04-2016 which rejected his claim for counting a 17‑month stipend period towards his service continuity and pension benefits, and also sought a mandamus directing his regularisation from …

Bipin KumarversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

Bipin Kumar, a retired government employee, filed a writ petition seeking the release of his full pension, gratuity and other dues which had been withheld on the ground of a pending vigilance case (no charge‑sheet filed). He contended that under the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950, the authorities could …

Girjanandan SharmaversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

Girjanandan Sharma, a retired Assistant Sub‑Inspector of Police, was arrested in 2018 for alleged consumption of prohibited liquor and subsequently dismissed six days before his superannuation. A departmental inquiry found him guilty of gross misconduct and, under the Bihar Pension Rules, ordered a …

Bhola Prasad Choudhary @ Bhola ChoudharyversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

The petitioner, a retired police officer, challenged a charge memo issued on 27 October 2021 that initiated a departmental inquiry into alleged irregularities in a register for the period July 2015 to May 2017. The petitioner argued that he had retired on 31 January 2015, so the alleged misconduct …

Ganesh Prasad YadavversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

Ganesh Prasad Yadav, a former Executive Engineer in the Bihar Public Health Engineering Department, was subjected to departmental charges that were initially found unproved. After his retirement, a second show‑cause notice was issued and the disciplinary authority, disagreeing with the enquiry …

Ganesh Prasad YadavversusThe State of Bihar

ALLOWED

Ganesh Prasad Yadav, a former Executive Engineer in the Bihar Public Health Engineering Department, was subjected to departmental charges that were initially found unproved. After his retirement, a second show‑cause notice was issued and the disciplinary authority, disagreeing with the enquiry …

Shiv Nandan SinghversusThe State of Bihar

DISPOSED

The petitioner, a retired Executive Magistrate, challenged a disciplinary order that deducted 10% of his pension for life under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, alleging that the misconduct cited occurred more than four years before the proceedings and that no proof of wrongdoing existed. He …

THE STATE OF BIHAR & ORS.versusRAJMATI DEVI & ANR.

2022 INSC 615Appeal(s) allowed

The husband of the widow, Rajmati Devi, was an employee of the Bihar Research Society, which was taken over by the Government of Bihar under the Bihar Research Society (Taking Over) Act, 2007. The Old Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 were abolished on 31 August 2005 and replaced by the Bihar Government …

GOPAL PRASADversusBIHAR SCHOOL EXAMINATION BOARD AND OTHERS

2020 INSC 408Matter referred to larger bench

Gopal Prasad, appointed as Calligraphist‑cum‑Assistant of the Bihar School Examination Board in May 1970 at the age of 15½, was retired in May 2012 on the ground that he had completed 42 years of qualifying service, despite the statutory retirement age being 60 years. The Board had earlier resolved …

DR. HIRA LALversusSTATE OF BIHAR & ORS.

2020 INSC 204Appeal(s) allowed

Dr. Hira Lal, a former Touring Veterinary Officer of Bihar, was suspended in 2002 and retired in 2008 while criminal proceedings were pending against him. The State of Bihar, relying on circulars of 1974 and a 1980 government resolution, withheld 10% of his pension and the entire gratuity. The …

PARMESHWAR NANDA ETC.versusTHE STATE OF JHARKHAND THROUGH CHIEF SECRETARY & ORS. ETC.

2020 INSC 149Disposed off

The appellants were employed under a centrally funded Adult Education/Non‑Formal Education Project in the undivided Bihar between 1978‑1990, and after the creation of Jharkhand their services were declared surplus and later absorbed as fresh appointees under a 2007 notification that denied seniority …

RAM DAYAL RAIversusJHARKHAND STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD AND ORS

2005 INSC 125Disposed off

The appellant, a retired foreman of the Jharkhand State Electricity Board, failed to vacate the Board's quarters after retirement and sought extensions from the High Court, which were eventually granted up to 1 November 1999. He finally vacated the premises on 6 January 2000, after which the Board …

ST ATE OF BIHAR AND ORS. ETC. ETC.versusB.S. MATHUR AND ORS. ETC. ETC.

1995 INSC 493Appeal(s) allowed

The respondents were government servants who were deputed to the Rajendra Agricultural University, resigned from government service and were subsequently absorbed as university employees. Upon their retirement, the State of Bihar denied liability for any pension, relying on section 39(20) of the …

DEVAKI NANDAN PRASADversusSTATE OF BIHAR & ORS.

1983 INSC 45Case Allowed

The petitioner, a former member of the Bihar Education Service, sought enforcement of a 1971 Supreme Court mandamus directing the State to compute his pension based on his promotions to Class II and Class I. Despite the Chief Minister’s orders in 1974, the State computed his pension as if he retired …