Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Rajeshwar DayalversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The notification imposing permanent withholding of 50% of the petitioner's pension is set aside as it was passed without complying with mandatory procedural safeguards and without sufficient evidence.

Summary

The petitioner, a former Director and additional Engineer‑in‑Chief of the Water Resources Department, was penalised by a notification dated 11‑04‑2017 that permanently withheld 50% of his pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950. He challenged the punishment, arguing that the departmental proceeding did not follow the mandatory procedure applicable to dismissal cases and that the charge‑sheet omitted a list of witnesses, rendering the enquiry report unsustainable. The court found that no oral evidence was taken, the memorandum of charges was deficient, and the disciplinary authority had exceeded its jurisdiction by attributing a loss of Rs 8.99 crore not framed in the charges. Citing Supreme Court precedents that documentary evidence alone is insufficient in disciplinary matters involving major penalties, the court held that the findings of the enquiry officer could not be sustained. Consequently, the notification imposing the pension withholding was set aside and the writ petition was allowed. The respondents were directed to grant the petitioner all admissible consequential benefits within ten weeks.

Issues considered

  • Whether the departmental proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 required compliance with the procedure applicable to dismissal proceedings.
  • Whether the absence of a witness list and lack of oral evidence in the charge‑sheet invalidates the enquiry report.
  • Whether the disciplinary authority exceeded its jurisdiction by attributing a financial loss not framed in the charge‑sheet.
  • Whether the rejection of the review application has any bearing on the writ petition.
  • Whether the punishment of permanent withholding of 50% of pension is legally valid.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • departmental disciplinary proceeding
  • pension withholding
  • Rule 43(b)
  • procedural fairness
  • evidence requirement
  • charge‑sheet deficiency
  • quasi‑judicial enquiry
  • administrative law

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                  Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7702 of 2020
     ======================================================
     Rajeshwar Dayal Son of Late Tetar Ram, Resident of Flat No. 102, Space
     Shiva Apartment, Post Office Road, P.S. Shastri Nagar, District, Patna, Bihar.

                                                               ... ... Petitioner/s
                                       Versus
1.   The State of Bihar through the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.   The Principal Secretary, Water Resources Department, Government of Bihar,
     Patna.
3.   The Departmental Enquiry Commissioner, Government of Bihar, Patna.
4.   The Deputy Secretary, Water Resources Department, Government of Bihar,
     Patna.
5.   The Bihar Public Service Commission, through its Chairman.

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s   :      Mr. Prabhat Ranjan, Adv.
     For the Respondent/s   :      Mr. Sudhanshu Bhushan, AC to GP-7
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH KUMAR
     ORAL JUDGMENT
      Date : 09-07-2026

                  Heard Mr. Prabhat Ranjan, learned Advocate for the

      petitioner and Mr. Sudhanshu Bhushan, learned AC to GP-7.

                  2. The petitioner is aggrieved with the Notification

      bearing Memo No. 506 dated 11.04.2017, whereby he has been

      inflicted with the punishment of withholding 50% of his pension

      permanently under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950

      (hereinafter referred to as "the Rules, 1950"). The petitioner has

      also challenged Notification No. 766 dated 19.03.2018, whereby

      the review application preferred against the order of punishment

      has been rejected. He has further questioned the enquiry report
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           2/10




         dated 22.02.2016 submitted by the Departmental Enquiry

         Commissioner in Departmental Proceeding No. 54 of 2015.

                     3. The brief facts leading to the filing of the present

         writ petition are that while the petitioner was working as

         Director, WALMI, he was entrusted with the additional charge

         of the post of Engineer-in-Chief, Water Resources Department,

         Government of Bihar, Patna, w.e.f. 29.06.2009. During the

         period he was holding the additional charge, certain allegations

         surfaced in relation to the execution of the Nepal Hitkari

         Scheme under the Gandak Project, 2009, wherein excess

         payments under the head of transportation were allegedly made.

                     4. While the matter was under scrutiny at the

         departmental level, the petitioner superannuated from service on

         30.09.2014. Upon completion of the preliminary enquiry, the

         Department resolved to initiate a departmental proceeding

         against the petitioner and, accordingly, vide Resolution bearing

         Memo No. 2018 dated 08.09.2015, a proceeding under Rule

         43(b) of the Rules, 1950 was instituted. A Departmental Enquiry

         Commissioner was appointed as the Enquiry Officer, whereas

         the    Deputy       Director-I,     Water    Sciences   and   Planning

         Organization, Patna, was nominated as the Presenting Officer to

         represent the State.
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           3/10




                     5. Along with the said resolution, the petitioner was

         served with a memorandum of charges with the statement of

         imputations and the list of documents. The petitioner entered

         appearance and submitted an elaborate written statement of

         defence controverting the allegations levelled against him. Upon

         conclusion of the enquiry, the Enquiry Officer submitted his

         report vide Letter No. 85 dated 22.02.2016 holding both the

         charges to be proved.

                     6. Thereafter, a second show-cause notice along with

         a copy of the enquiry report was served upon the petitioner, to

         which he submitted his reply. However, finding the explanation

         unsatisfactory, the disciplinary authority passed the impugned

         Notification bearing Memo No. 506 dated 11.04.2017 imposing

         the punishment of permanent withholding of 50% of the

         petitioner's pension.

                     7. Assailing the impugned order, learned Advocate for

         the petitioner primarily contended that in view of the second

         proviso to Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950, the respondents were

         required to conduct the departmental proceeding in accordance

         with the procedure applicable to a proceeding in which an order

         of dismissal from service may be passed. According to him, the

         mandatory procedure prescribed therein has not been followed.
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           4/10




         It is further submitted that the memorandum of charges does not

         contain the list of witnesses by whom the articles of charge were

         proposed to be proved.

                     8. It is contended that in the absence of any witness,

         the contents of the documents and reports relied upon by the

         Department could not have been proved merely by producing

         the documents. Consequently, the findings recorded by the

         Enquiry Officer are unsustainable. In support of the said

         submission, reliance has been placed upon the judgment of the

         Hon'ble Supreme Court in Satyendra Singh v. State of Uttar

         Pradesh & Anr., (2024) INSC 873. It is further argued that the

         petitioner, while holding the additional charge of Engineer-in-

         Chief, was assigned only administrative responsibilities and had

         no direct role in supervising the execution of the project, which

         responsibility vested with the Executive Engineer and the Chief

         Engineer concerned.

                     9. It is further submitted that although the petitioner

         submitted a detailed reply to the second show-cause notice, the

         disciplinary authority has neither considered nor dealt with the

         specific defence raised therein. The impugned order merely

         reproduces the findings of the Enquiry Officer and proceeds to

         impose punishment without assigning any independent reasons.
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           5/10




                     10. Learned Advocate further submitted that while

         imposing the punishment, the disciplinary authority has

         travelled beyond the scope of the charges contained in the

         memorandum of charges. According to him, throughout the

         enquiry there was no allegation, much less any evidence,

         establishing that the petitioner was personally responsible for

         causing any financial loss to the Government. Nevertheless,

         while imposing punishment, the disciplinary authority has

         attributed a loss of Rs. 8.99 crore to the petitioner, although such

         allegation never formed part of the charge-sheet.

                     11. Per contra, learned Advocate appearing for the

         State, submitted that while exercising the power of judicial

         review, this Court cannot sit in appeal over the findings recorded

         in a departmental proceeding or reappreciate the evidence on

         record. It is submitted that the enquiry has been conducted

         strictly in accordance with the prescribed procedure. Referring

         to Clause 15 of the Bihar Public Works Department Code, it is

         contended that the Engineer-in-Chief, being the administrative

         head of the Department, was responsible for ensuring proper

         supervision and monitoring of the project. According to the

         State, had the petitioner discharged his duties with due

         diligence, the State exchequer would not have suffered the
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           6/10




         alleged loss of more than Rs. 8.99 crore.

                     12. Having considered the rival submissions and upon

         perusal of the materials available on record, this Court finds that

         the memorandum of charges does not contain the list of

         witnesses by whom the charges were proposed to be established.

         Admittedly, no witness was examined during the enquiry to

         prove either the documents or the reports relied upon by the

         Department. In the absence of oral evidence proving the

         contents of the documentary materials, the findings recorded by

         the Enquiry Officer cannot, prima facie, be sustained.

                     13. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has consistently held

         that where a disciplinary proceeding may culminate in a major

         penalty, recording of evidence is mandatory and mere

         production of documents is insufficient, unless the charge is

         based on impeccable documentary evidence, undisputed by

         delinquent. In Roop Singh Negi Vs. Punjab National Bank &

         Ors., (2009) 2 SCC 570, the Supreme Court categorically held

         that production of documents by itself does not amount to proof

         of their contents and that documentary evidence must be proved

         through competent witnesses. The same principle has recently

         been reiterated in Satyendra Singh (supra).

                     14. At this stage, it would be apposite to reproduce
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           7/10




         paragraphs 14 and 19 of the judgment in Roop Singh Negi

         (supra), which succinctly reiterate the aforesaid legal position.

                                “14. Indisputably, a departmental
                         proceeding is a quasi-judicial proceeding. The
                         enquiry officer performs a quasi-judicial
                         function. The charges levelled against the
                         delinquent officer must be found to have been
                         proved. The enquiry officer has a duty to arrive
                         at a finding upon taking into consideration the
                         materials brought on record by the parties. The
                         purported       evidence       collected      during
                         investigation by the investigating officer against
                         all the accused by itself could not be treated to
                         be evidence in the disciplinary proceeding. No
                         witness was examined to prove the said
                         documents. The management witnesses merely
                         tendered the documents and did not prove the
                         contents thereof. Reliance, inter alia, was placed
                         by the enquiry officer on the FIR which could
                         not have been treated as evidence.
                                    19. The judgment and decree passed
                         against the respondent in Narinder Mohan Arya
                         case [(2006) 4 SCC 713 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 840]
                         had attained finality. In the said suit, the enquiry
                         report in the disciplinary proceeding was
                         considered, the same was held to have been
                         based on no evidence. The appellant therein in
                         the aforementioned situation filed a writ petition
                         questioning the validity of the disciplinary
                         proceeding, the same was dismissed. This Court
                         held that when a crucial finding like forgery was
                         arrived at on an evidence which is non est in the
                         eye of the law, the civil court would have
                         jurisdiction to interfere in the matter. This Court
                         emphasised that a finding can be arrived at by
                         the enquiry officer if there is some evidence on
                         record. It was furthermore found that the order
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           8/10




                           of the appellate authority suffered from non-
                           application of mind.”

                     15. This Court also finds that the enquiry report fails

         to explain the precise nature of the duties entrusted to the

         petitioner as Engineer-in-Chief which he is alleged to have

         failed to discharge. Though the Bihar Public Works Department

         Code describes the Engineer-in-Chief as the administrative head

         of the Department responsible for its efficient functioning, the

         enquiry report does not disclose how such administrative

         responsibility had any direct nexus with the alleged excess

         payments made in the execution of the project. The materials on

         record indicate that the execution of the work, recording of

         measurements, quality control and release of payments were

         undertaken by the Executive Engineer on the basis of the

         Measurement Book and Quality Control Reports, upon getting

         the order of concerned Chief Engineer.

                     16. Equally significant is the fact that while dealing

         with the petitioner's reply to the second show-cause notice, the

         disciplinary authority has merely reproduced the defence taken

         by the petitioner without examining or discussing the same.

         Instead      of     independently        considering   the   petitioner's

         explanation, the disciplinary authority has mechanically

         accepted the findings of the Enquiry Officer. Moreover, it has
Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                           9/10




         travelled beyond the scope of the memorandum of charges by

         recording that the petitioner's conduct resulted in a financial loss

         of Rs. 8.99 crore to the Government, although no such charge

         was ever framed against him.

                      17. This Court further finds that neither the enquiry

         report nor the impugned order of punishment discloses any

         cogent material establishing a nexus between the petitioner's

         alleged omission and the irregularities detected in the execution

         of the project. There is no connecting link demonstrating that

         the alleged loss suffered by the State was attributable to any

         misconduct or negligence on the part of the petitioner. In the

         absence of such evidence, the finding of guilt cannot be

         sustained.

                      18. So far as the order passed in the review

         application is concerned, learned Advocate for the petitioner has

         fairly submitted that the review petition itself was misconceived

         since the original order of punishment had been passed by the

         State Government. Consequently, the order rejecting the review

         petition has no independent bearing on the adjudication of the

         present writ petition.

                      19. In view of the aforesaid facts and the settled legal

         position, this Court is of the considered opinion that Notification
             Patna High Court CWJC No.7702 of 2020 dt.09-07-2026
                                                       10/10




                      bearing Memo No. 506 dated 11.04.2017, as contained in

                      Annexure-5 to the writ petition, cannot be sustained in law and

                      is, accordingly, set aside.

                                  20. The writ petition stands allowed.

                                  21. The respondents are directed to extend all

                      admissible consequential benefits to the petitioner within a

                      period of ten weeks from the date of receipt/production of a

                      copy of this order.




                                                  (Harish Kumar, J)
rohit/-
AFR/NAFR                NAFR
CAV DATE                NA
Uploading Date          13-07-2026
Transmission Date


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.