Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Kalktari Devi @ Kalakatari DeviversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The court held that the memo demanding recovery of the death‑cum‑retirement benefits from the widow is illegal and set it aside, directing refund of the amount with interest.

Summary

The petitioner, a widow of a deceased government employee, challenged a memo (No. 1400 dated 28‑09‑2022) that demanded recovery of Rs 19,18,073 from her late husband’s death‑cum‑retirement benefits. She argued that no enquiry under the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 was conducted during the employee’s lifetime, making any post‑mortem recovery unlawful. The State contended the petition was untenable and sought adjournment, but the court rejected this. Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (2015 4 SCC 475) and a prior Division Bench judgment (LPA No. 270 of 2021), the court held that excess payments to a deceased employee cannot be recovered from the widow. Consequently, the memo was set aside and the amount was ordered to be refunded with interest within eight weeks. The writ petition was disposed of.

Issues considered

  • Whether recovery of death‑cum‑retirement benefits from the widow is permissible under the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950.
  • Whether the memo demanding such recovery is void and illegal.
  • Whether the petitioner is entitled to a refund of the amount recovered.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • widow
  • death-cum-retirement benefits
  • Bihar Pension Rules
  • pension recovery
  • illegal demand
  • refund
  • writ petition

Judgment

                     IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                                Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6763 of 2023
                 ======================================================
                 Kalktari Devi @ Kalakatari Devi W/o Late Bandelal Ram, R/o Mophalla-
                 Manik Parasi, P.O.- Goprakha Parasi, P.S.- Karakat (Gorai), District- Rohtas.
                                                                             ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                    Versus
           1.     The State of Bihar.
           2.    The Principal Secretary, Panchayat Raj Department, Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
           3.    The Accountant General (A and E), Bihar, Patna.
           4.    The District Magistrate, Rohtas.
           5.    The Panchayat Raj Officer, Rohtas, Sasaram.
           6.    The Block Development Officer, Karaghar Block, Karaghar, Rohtas.
           7.    The District Provident Found Officer, Rohtas.
           8.     The Panchayat Secretary, Gram Panchayat, Araruwan, Karaghar, Rohtas.
                                                                       ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :          Mr. Shashi Shekhar Tiwary,
                 For the Respondent/s   :          Mr.Kameshwar Pd. Gupta (GP10)
                                                   Mr. Virendra Kuar, Adv.
                 For AG, Bihar          :          Mr. Ritika Rani, Adv.
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJIT KUMAR
                                       ORAL ORDER

4   08-05-2026                    Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned

                   counsel for the Respondent-State.

                                 2. The writ petition has been filed for the following

                   relief(s):-

                                                          “(I) Memo no-227dated 19.2.21

                                            issued under the signature of the Block

                                            Development Officer Karahgar, Rohtas as

                                            well     as     the    letter   no.731       dated

                                            23.05.22issued by the same authority may

                                            kindly be quashed and consequential / follow
Patna High Court CWJC No.6763 of 2023(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            2/7




                                  up action over the same may kindly be as

                                  declared as non-est in the eyes of law.

                                                (ii) The orders/action of either

                                  kind,    so     issued   or     proposed   to   be

                                  issued/taken either against the deceased

                                  employee or against the present petitioner

                                  may kindly be declared as alien to 1aw for

                                  a11 practical purposes.

                                                (iii) Rs 19, 18, 073/- said to be

                                  recovered (informed vide memo no 1400

                                  dated 28.09.22) from the Post Retiral/

                                  Death- cum-Terminal dues of the innocent

                                  widow, petitioner, may kindly be directed to

                                  be refunded in her favour with immediate

                                  effect as any kind of order, if passed/ action

                                  taken, against a dead person is a nullity.

                                                (iv) The answering respondents

                                  also may kindly be directed to furnish the

                                  calculation      chart   with    regard    to   the

                                  petitioner’s entitlement and may kindly be

                                  simultaneously directed to pay the surviving

                                  dues including arrears of salary, payable to
Patna High Court CWJC No.6763 of 2023(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            3/7




                                  the employee for of the period of June 2003

                                  to February 2009, (if not paid earlier) at

                                  earliest in the interest of Justice.

                                               (v) Any other relief or reliefs also

                                  may kindly be allowed to the present

                                  petitioner with the statutory / panel interest

                                  on the ground of delayed payment.

                      3. Learned counsel for the petitioner by referring to

          the impugned Memo No. 1400 dated 28.09.2022, submits that

          after death of the petitioner’s husband the liability to the tune of

          Rs. 19,18,073/- has been quantified and the widow petitioner

          has been subjected to make such payment.

                       4. It has next been submitted that in earlier round of

          litigation being CWJC No. 1768/2021, as per the order passed in

          the said writ petition, the entire amount of death-cum-retiral

          dues are said to have been paid and the arrears of salary were

          also deposited in the account of the petitioner but the amount to

          the tune or Rs. 19,18,073/- which is being shown as arrears

          upon the petitioner’s husband vide impugned Memo No. 1400

          dated 28.09.2022, was not brought to the notice of the Hon’ble

          Court for unexplained reasons.

                      5.     It is further submitted that while the said writ
Patna High Court CWJC No.6763 of 2023(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            4/7




          petition was being disposed, the State Counsel had never

          brought on record the factum of such withholding of amount in

          the said proceeding, in which, the adjudication of such liability

          could have been carried out by this petitioner and since this

          liability so created was communicated after disposal of the said

          writ petition, therefore, this petitioner has been coerced to file

          another writ petition challenging the said demand, which is

          sought to be made by the authorities from the death-cum-retiral

          benefits of the petitioner, having been sanctioned in pursuance

          of the order passed by this Court in the aforesaid writ petition.

                      6. It has next been submitted by the learned counsel

          for the petitioner that from the order impugned itself, it is quite

          evident that no proceedings were ever drawn, which is provided

          under Bihar Pension Rules, 1950, to quantify the liability in

          accordance with law and since no such proceedings were drawn

          during the life time of the deceased employee, such liability

          could not have been fastened against the widow-petitioner in

          terms of provision of Bihar Pension Rules, much less without

          any proceeding known to law.

                      7. At this stage, learned counsel for the State submits

          that this matter may be adjourned to take appropriate

          instructions in the matter and file appropriate affidavit. The
Patna High Court CWJC No.6763 of 2023(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            5/7




          prayer made by the learned counsel for the State is being

          rejected on the ground that the writ petition is of the year 2023

          is legally unsustainable and despite there being specific

          averment made by the writ petitioner that no recovery can be

          made after the death of the deceased-employee much less from

          the death-cum-retiral benefits of the widow petitioner and to

          such statement made in the writ petition, no plausible reasons

          have been put forth for consideration by the State authority in

          the counter affidavit filed by the State.

                      8. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits

          that in the matter of recovery after the death of the deceased

          employee from the family pension, such act of the authority

          have been deprecated and is impermissible in reference to the

          provisions of Bihar Pension Rules, 1950, and the adjudication

          made by this Court on the similar issues may be referred from

          the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Division Bench passed

          in LPA No.270 of 2021, wherein by relying upon the judgment

          of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of State of Punjab & Ors v.

          Rafiq Masih & Ors reported in (2015) 4 SCC 475, it has been

          categorically mentioned that “excess payment made in favour

          of the deceased-Rama Nand Prasad cannot be recovered from

          his wife, respondent-Akhileshwari Devi.”
Patna High Court CWJC No.6763 of 2023(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                            6/7




                      9. Considering the fact that the impugned order itself

          sufficiently indicates that no enquiry was conducted during the

          life time of the deceased employee as the opening line of the

          order impugned speaks that quantification was done after the

          death of the deceased employee, which the authorities were

          well aware that the demand which was being made from the

          widow-petitioner was impermissible in law, still on the strength

          of such orders as contained in Memo No. 1400 dated

          28.09.2022, an amount to the tune of Rs. 19,18,073/- has been

          withheld by them.

                      10.      Since the provisions of Bihar Pension Rules,

          1950 have not been resorted during the lifetime of the deceased

          employee to fasten the liability, which finds place in the

          impugned Memo No. 1400 dated 28.09.2022, and since, the

          statutory provision does not permit such recovery to be made

          from the death-cum-retiral benefits from the widow-petitioner,

          in such background, this Court has got no option but to set aside

          the Memo No. 1400 dated 28.09.2022 and accordingly, the

          amount to the tune of Rs. 19,18,073/- is directed to be refunded

          in favour of the petitioner with applicable bank interest, within

          eight weeks from the date of production/receipt of this order.

                      11. The writ petition stands disposed of.
         Patna High Court CWJC No.6763 of 2023(4) dt.08-05-2026
                                                     7/7




                               12. Interlocutory application, if any, shall also be

                   deemed to be disposed of.



                                                           (Ajit Kumar, J)
    perwez

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.