Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Chandrakali DeviversusThe State of Bihar

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The petitioner, as the only surviving widow at the employee’s death, is entitled to the family pension and the authorities must adjudicate her claim within two months.

Summary

Chandrakali Devi, the second wife of a deceased Class‑IV employee of Government Medical College, Bettiah, filed a writ petition seeking the family pension and other retiral benefits that accrued after her husband’s death on 12‑Nov‑2021. She contended that the first wife had died before the employee, making her the sole surviving widow entitled to the full pension, and cited a prior judgment (LPA No.72 of 2018) interpreting the Bihar pension scheme. The State argued that the pension scheme allowed equal sharing among multiple widows and that a compromise had already allocated a lump‑sum to the petitioner. The Court examined the relevant Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 and the Finance Department resolutions of 1990 and 1996, concluding that the petitioner, being the only surviving widow, was entitled to the family pension. It directed the department to summon all legitimate claimants, adjudicate the petitioner’s claim within two months, and ordered the District Magistrate to decide on a compassionate appointment for the dependents. The writ petition was disposed of with these directions.

Issues considered

  • Whether a second wife, whose husband’s first wife predeceased him, is entitled to the full family pension under Bihar pension rules.
  • Whether the prior compromise and allocation of a lump‑sum amount affect the petitioner’s right to family pension.
  • Procedural steps the department must follow to adjudicate the pension claim and arrange compassionate appointment.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • family pension
  • second wife
  • widow entitlement
  • Bihar Pension Rules
  • government employee benefits
  • compassionate appointment
  • writ petition

Judgment

                     IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                                Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.10753 of 2022
                 ======================================================
                 Chandrakali Devi Wife of Late Pramod Prasad Patel, Resident of Village-
                 Bhitahan, P.O. Bhitahan, P.S. Bairiya, District- West Champaran.

                                                                          ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                  Versus
           1.    The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of Health,
                 Government of Bihar, Patna.
           2.    The Principal Secretary, Department of Health, Government of Bihar, Patna.
           3.    The Superintendent, Government Medical College, Bettiah, District- West
                 Champaran.

                                                           ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :        Mr.Alka Singh, Adv.
                 For the Respondent/s   :        Mr.Binod Kr. Yadav (SC18)
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJIT KUMAR
                                       ORAL ORDER

5   08-05-2026                 Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and the

                   Respondents-State.

                               2. The instant writ petition has been preferred for the

                   following relief(s):-

                                                      “(i) To issue an appropriate writ
                                            preferably in the nature of Mandamus
                                            Commanding        upon      the    Respondent
                                            authorities to pay to the petitioner entire
                                            retiral benefits including Family Pension
                                            accrued in her favour after death of her
                                            husband namely Pramod Prasad Patel who
                                            died in harness on 12.11.2021 while serving
                                            Government Medical College, Bettiah as
                                            Class IV employee.
                                                      (ii) To award suitable interest on
Patna High Court CWJC No.10753 of 2022(5) dt.08-05-2026
                                           2/6




                                  the delayed payment of retiral-cum-death
                                  benefits of her late husband.
                                               (iii) To grant any other relief(s),
                                  for which the Petitioner may be found
                                  entitled to in the facts and circumstances of
                                  the case.”
                      3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that on

          the basis of the compromise arrived with the legitimate children

          of first wife and this petitioner, who is said to have married with

          the deceased employee after the death of the first wife, the

          present petitioner claiming to be the second wife submits that

          the pensionary benefits got divided between them and the

          petitioner is said to have received an amount of Rs. 6,27,914/-

          as against GPF and rest other benefits were extended in favour

          of the legitimate children of the first wife.

                      4. In the present writ petition, the petitioner who is

          the second wife claims family pension after the death of her

          husband on 12.11.2021. It is the case of the petitioner that

          during life time of the first wife, the petitioner had not

          contracted any marriage whereas the said marriage had taken

          place only after the death of the first wife and, therefore, she is

          legally wedded wife and sole surviving wife to receive family

          pension.

                      5. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the
Patna High Court CWJC No.10753 of 2022(5) dt.08-05-2026
                                           3/6




          judgment of Hon’ble Division Bench rendered in L.P.A. No.72

          of 2018, (Sumitra Kunwar @ Sunaina Devi @ Sumitra Devi v.

          The State of Bihar and Others) which is being reproduced

          hereunder :-

                                              "5. In order to understand the

                                  controversy, we may point out that the

                                  Family Pension Scheme as was promulgated

                                  and revised by the State Government from

                                  time to time earlier contained a provision

                                  that where an employee survived by more

                                  than one widow, the pension will be paid to

                                  them in equal share. This is evident from the

                                  extract of the revised provisions contained in

                                  the Finance Department's Resolution dated

                                  19th of April, 1990 in respect of the Family

                                  Pension Scheme promulgated with effect

                                  from 1964.

                                              …………..

                                              7. A perusal of the same would

                                  indicate that the earlier resolution was taken

                                  notice of and an amendment was made that

                                  even if an employee consummates a second
Patna High Court CWJC No.10753 of 2022(5) dt.08-05-2026
                                           4/6




                                  marriage during the subsistence of the first

                                  marriage and the first wife is surviving, then

                                  in that event the second wife will not get

                                  family pension but her illegitimate children

                                  would be entitled to the same.

                                              8. In the instant case, the peculiar

                                  fact is that even though there appears to

                                  have been a second marriage, but the first

                                  wife had already died before the death of the

                                  employee himself. Thus, the second wife was

                                  the only widow surviving as on the date of

                                  the death of the employee and there was

                                  nobody else to claim the family pension as

                                  the first wife had no children. In the given

                                  circumstances therefore, this peculiar case

                                  required         and    different     treatment

                                  interpretation in the light of the Resolution

                                  dated 6th of September, 1996, quoted herein

                                  above, and since the appellant was only

                                  surviving widow and wife as on the date of

                                  the death of the employee, there is no other

                                  prejudice being caused to the Government
Patna High Court CWJC No.10753 of 2022(5) dt.08-05-2026
                                           5/6




                                  nor there being a violation of the Resolution

                                  dated 06th of September, 1996, the appellant

                                  ought to have been extended the said benefit.

                                  We do not find any such consideration

                                  having been made by the learned single

                                  Judge in the impugned judgment dated 06th

                                  December, 2017."

                      6. Be that as it may, in order to allow the authorities

          to adjudicate the claim of family pension, it is required that the

          concerned authorities of the department would secure

          attendance of all legitimate claimants including this petitioner

          and after securing their presence and with the aid of supportive

          materials and the benefits which is said to have been extended

          in favour of this petitioner as per compromise arrived, the

          entitlement with regard to family pension shall be adjudicated

          and once it is found that the petitioner’s grievance is genuine,

          then there should not be any hesitation in extending the family

          pension for which she is legally entitled as per the dictum of

          Hon’ble Division Bench and as also the provisions of Bihar

          Pension Rules, 1950.

                      7. Insofar the issues of compassionate appointment

          which is required to be extended to the dependents of the
             Patna High Court CWJC No.10753 of 2022(5) dt.08-05-2026
                                                        6/6




                       deceased employee, as would be evident from the counter

                       affidavit, the issues are pending before the District Magistrate,

                       Bettiah, West Champaran, it is accordingly, directed that the

                       District Magistrate would take a final decision by ensuring the

                       same to be placed before the appropriate Committee, which is

                       constituted under the Compassionate Appointment Guidelines,

                       issued by the State Government. Once such matter is placed

                       before the Committee, the same shall also be adjudicated and

                       the persons in whose favour the mandate is given for

                       appointment on compassionate ground, the same shall also be

                       accordingly, directed in accordance with law. With regard to the

                       adjudication of family pension, all the exercise shall be

                       completed within a period of two months from the date of first

                       appearance and appropriate representation made in her behalf.

                                   8. The writ petition stands disposed of.

                                   9.    Interlocutory Application, if any, shall also be

                       deemed to be disposed of.



                                                    (Ajit Kumar, J)
    perwez

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.