Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Bhagwan DasversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
ALLOWED

Holding

The Court held that the petitioner’s service from 1979 must be counted for pension benefits and the exclusion clause in the appointment letter is void.

Summary

The petitioner, Bhagwan Das, was engaged as a daily‑wage worker in 1979 and later regularised in 2008, but the Department refused to count his pre‑2008 service for pension benefits, citing a clause in his appointment letter. The High Court examined the applicability of Rules 56, 58, 59 and 61 of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950, and relevant precedents on counting continuous service of temporary employees. It held that the petitioner’s uninterrupted service from 1979 qualifies as pensionable under Rule 59 and that the clause excluding prior service is ultra vires. Consequently, the order dated 05‑12‑2012 rejecting his claim was quashed and the respondents were directed to pay pension benefits accruing from 1979 within three months. The petition was allowed.

Issues considered

  • The applicability of Rules 58 and 59 of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 to count service rendered as a daily‑wage employee for pension benefits.
  • Whether the clause in the 2008 appointment letter that excludes prior service can be set aside.
  • Whether the petitioner’s delay in filing the writ petition bars relief on the ground of laches.
  • Whether the order dated 05‑12‑2012 rejecting the claim to count past service is legally valid.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • pension
  • regularisation
  • daily‑wage employee
  • service count
  • delay and laches
  • Bihar Pension Rules
  • quashing order
  • mandamus

Judgment

         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                   Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.18407 of 2013
     ======================================================
     Bhagwan Das Son Of Late Ram Keshwar Ram Resident Of Mohalla - Chattar
     Darwaja, Nai Sahar Daudnagar, P.S. Daudnagar, District - Aurangabad

                                                                       ... ... Petitioner/s
                                             Versus
1.   The State of Bihar
2.   The Principal Secretary, Water Resources Development Department,
     Government Of Bihar, Patna
3.   The Chief Engineer, Water                Resources    Development      Department,
     Government Of Bihar, Patna
4.   The Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur
5.   The Executive Engineer, Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur

                                               ... ... Respondent/s
     ======================================================
     Appearance :
     For the Petitioner/s      :        Mr. Amrendra Kumar Sinha No.-1, Advocate
     For the Respondent/s      :        Mr. Anuj Kumar Sinha, AC to SC-12
     ======================================================
     CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RITESH KUMAR
     CAV JUDGMENT
      Date : 16-06-2026
               Heard the parties.

                 2. The present writ petition has been filed for the

     following reliefs:-

                          “A) For quashing the order contained in Letter No.
                                   3314 dated 05.12.2012 issued under signature of
                                   Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department,
                                   Muzaffarpur where by and where under rejected
                                   the claim of the petitioner for calculate/count the
                                   service period prior to his regularisation.
                          B)       For issuance of writ in nature of mandamum
                                   commanding the respondents to calculate/count
                                   the previous service rendered by the Petitioner as
                                   daily wager and also from the date when he got
                                   temporary status by him minimum pay of the scale
                                   alongwith all other allowances by the order of this
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         2/50




                                  Hon’ble Court dated 16.01.1998 passed in
                                  C.W.J.C. No. 11255 of 1995.
                            C)    For issuance of a direction to the Respondents to
                                  count the period of continuous service under the
                                  department and grant him to benefit of          old
                                  pension       scheme   granting   him   to   regular
                                  employee before year 2005.”
                    3. An interlocutory application bearing I.A. No. 1 of

       2014 (974 of 2014) was filed, seeking amendment in the prayer

       portion of the main writ petition and vide order dated 02.09.2025,

       the interlocutory application was allowed. The petitioner was

       directed to file a fresh typed copy of paragraph no. 1 of the writ

       application, incorporating the additional prayer, which was

       allowed by the order passed in I.A. No. 1 of 2014, which is being

       reproduced hereinbelow:-

                                  “d. For issuance of writ in the nature of
                                        Certiorari quashing the Paragraph 2 of the
                                        appointment letter contained in Annexure 2
                                        of the writ petition whereby and where
                                        under it is stated that “Purb Ki Karyat
                                        Awadhi ki Ganana Seva Awadhi ki liya
                                        manya nahi hai” (Pass service will not be
                                        counted in Present Service).”
                                 BRIEF FACTS

                    4. The brief facts, which are necessary to be taken into

       consideration for adjudication of the writ petition, are that the

       petitioner was initially engaged as a daily wager in the year 1979
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         3/50




       to perform the duties of a class-IV post in the Punpun Flood

       Division, Karbigahiya, Patna under the Irrigation Department of

       the State of Bihar. The petitioner was being paid the remuneration

       for his work by the respondent-authorities. After completion of

       about 19 years of service, the petitioner, along with some others

       filed a writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No. 11255 of 1995

       (Kapileshwar Singh & Ors. versus the State of Bihar & Ors.),

       before this Hon’ble Court for issuance of a direction upon the

       respondent-authorities to regularise their services and to pay them

       equal pay for equal work. The writ petition filed by the petitioner

       and others was disposed of vide judgment dated 16.01.1998, with

       a direction to the respondent-authorities, including the District

       Magistrate, Patna to advertise the posts, prepare and finalise the

       panel for appointment, against the Class-IV posts in accordance

       with the guidelines mentioned in the order. It was directed that

       the weightage as stipulated therein in favour of the daily wage

       employees, age relaxation is to be given over outsiders. The panel

       has to be scrutinized by the District Magistrate concerned within

       a period of three months from the date of receipt/production of a

       copy of the judgment. It was further directed that during

       finalization of the panel, the District Magistrate, Patna will

       ascertain from different Mufassil Offices of all the department of
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         4/50




       the State, which are situated in the district of Patna, the total

       number of Class-IV vacancies, existing in one or other offices.

       The Secretary of the Water Resources, Irrigation Department/

       concerned Chief Engineer/Executive Engineer of the Division

       were also directed to intimate the District Magistrate, Patna the

       total number of existing candidates of all Class-IV posts within a

       period of three months from the date of receipt/production of a

       copy of the judgment. Thereafter, the District Magistrate, Patna

       was to make recommendation of the persons, whose names will

       appear in the panel, on the basis of their position in the merit list.

       Class IV vacancies of all the Mufassil offices of the district of

       Patna, was to be filled up on regular basis within one year from

       the date of approval of such panel. This process was to be

       followed by the District Magistrate, Patna in the subsequent

       years, till the guidelines framed by the State exists. So far as, the

       payment of wages on the principle of equal pay for equal work is

       concerned, the Hon’ble Court directed that the petitioners may

       move before the Chief Engineer concerned, who will find out as

       to what is the minimum pay scale prescribed for the post against

       which, one or other petitioners were functioning and then the

       petitioners would be paid minimum pay of the post against which

       the petitioners were performing duty, along with the admissible
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         5/50




       allowances for the month from January, 1998 till the petitioners

       are regularised in service or provided with regular appointments.

       In compliance of the order dated 16.01.1998, passed in C.W.J.C.

       No. 11255 of 1995, final panel of Class-IV employees was

       prepared, department wise and the name of the petitioner was

       shown at serial no. 14 of the list. In the meantime, a office order

       was issued by the respondent-Chief Engineer, Water Resources

       Development Department, Government of Bihar, Patna by giving

       minimum scale of pay to the petitioner and several other similarly

       situated persons w.e.f. January 1998. Subsequently, vide order

       contained in Memo No. 1159 dated 30.06.2001 was issued, by

       which the petitioner and others similarly situated persons of the

       division and other divisions, were shifted from their place of

       posting to another place, only with a view to frustrate the right of

       the petitioner and others, which accrued on account of order dated

       16.01.1998 passed by this Hon’ble Court. The petitioner was

       shifted to Tirhut Circle under the control of the Chief Engineer,

       Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur and thereafter, was

       posted at the office of the Executed Engineer, Tirhut Canal

       Division, Muzaffarpur. The petitioner kept on working on the

       post, however temporary status was granted to the petitioner and

       other similarly situated employees after 1998, when minimum
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         6/50




       scale of the post was granted and petitioner started getting salary

       from the State Government. Vide office order contained in Memo

       No. 2867 dated 14.08.2008, issued under the signature of the

       Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur, the

       petitioner      was     appointed        on      the   sanctioned   post   of

       Peon/Chaukidar in view of roster clearance given by the

       Commissioner, Tirhut Division vide his letter No. 3807 dated

       06.08.2008 and in view of the directions contained in letter dated

       16.03.2006 and 01.04.2006, issued from the Personal and

       Administrative Reforms Department, Government of Bihar,

       Patna. The petitioner was appointed as a Peon in the pay scale of

       Rs. 2500-3200/- with all the applicable allowances with

       immediate effect and was posted in Tirhut Canal Division No. 1,

       Muzaffarpur. Pursuant to issuance of Memo dated 14.08.2008,

       vide letter No. 3644 dated 15.10.2008, issued under the signature

       of    the    Chief      Engineer,        Water     Resources   Development

       Department, Government of Bihar, Patna, the services of the

       petitioner and similarly situated employees was confirmed w.e.f.

       14.08.2008.

                    5. It is the case of the petitioner that he continuously

       worked in the services of the State Government for more than 25

       years, prior to his regularisation, but his initial service was not
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         7/50




       counted by the respondent-authorities for granting the benefits of

       services rendered prior to regularisation/appointment. The

       petitioner filed his representation before the authorities concerned

       for counting his past service for the purposes of pension in terms

       of Old Pension Scheme. It is the case of the petitioner that he is

       entitled for counting his services from 1979. When no action was

       being taken by the respondent-authorities on the representation

       filed by the petitioner, he was again constrained to file a writ

       petition filed bearing C.W.J.C. No. 5882 of 2012, before this

       Hon’ble Court with a prayer to count his service from his initial

       date of appointment/engagement for giving pensionary and other

       benefits. The writ petition filed by the petitioner was disposed of

       vide order dated 19.04.2012 by a learned Single Judge of this

       Court with a direction to the respondent to consider the

       representation of the petitioner in accordance with law and to

       dispose it of by a reasoned and speaking order, preferably within

       a maximum period of three months from the date of receipt/

       production of a copy of the order. In compliance thereof, the

       petitioner filed a representation on 30.04.2012 and 01.08.2012,

       alongwith the copy of the order dated 19.04.2012, wherein it was

       stated that he was engaged as a Daily Wager in 1979 and

       continuously worked under the department from one place to
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         8/50




       another place with full satisfaction of the authorities concerned.

       He further submitted that on the directions of this Hon’ble Court,

       he started getting time scale of the post and the panel was

       prepared, wherein his name was mentioned as serial no. 14, but

       the respondent did not consider that aspect and regularised the

       service in the year 2008, therefore the petitioner is entitled for

       grant of pensionary benefits, counting his services from 1979.

       Finally, vide letter no. 3314 dated 05.12.2012, issued under the

       signature of the Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department,

       Muzaffarpur, the claim of the petitioner for counting his past

       services and shifting the date of regularisation, only for the

       limited purpose of counting pensionary benefits and other

       benefits was rejected.

             SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER

                    6. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that

       the respondent authorities knowingly and willingly, with mala

       fide intention did not act on the panel in 1999 and not regularised

       the services of the petitioner, before implementation of the New

       Pension Scheme, which came to effect from 01.09.2005. The

       entire process of empanelment was completed in the year 1994

       and an averment to that effect was made by the respondent

       authorities before the Hon’ble Patna High Court in a contempt
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         9/50




       proceeding, filed by the petitioner against non-compliance of the

       order dated 16.01.1998 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 11255 of 1995.

                    7. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in

       a similar matter vide order dated 06.12.1993, learned Single

       Judge of this Court directed the respondent-State to issue sanction

       order within three months from the date of receipt/ production of

       a copy of the order and forwarded the same to Accountant

       General and the Accountant General was directed to issue

       authority slip on receipt of such sanction letter. Simultaneously,

       the respondent State was directed to serve statement showing

       amount sanctioned under different heads and if the petitioner will

       not be satisfied, it will be open to file a representation, which will

       be disposed of by the competent authority within three months

       after giving personal hearing to the petitioner, if anything is found

       to be due. Pursuant thereto, fresh sanction order will be issued

       and the Accountant General will issue authority slip within two

       weeks.

                    8. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that

       the case of the petitioner is similar to the petitioner of C.W.J.C.

       no. 8626 of 1992, in as much as that he was working in the

       department for more than 38 years and filed a writ petition vide

       C.W.J.C. No.          1065 of 1990, which was disposed of with
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         10/50




       direction to the respondent to consider the case of regularisation

       of the services of the petitioner. In-spite of the direction, the

       respondent sat over the matter and did not take any step.

                    9. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that

       the services of the petitioner and others was regularised on the

       verge of the retirement, only to deny the benefits, which they

       were entitled prior to coming into force the New Pension Scheme

       w.e.f. 2005. He further submits that the services of the petitioner

       was regularised w.e.f. his joining with a condition that his prior

       services will not be counted for giving benefit of service, which is

       arbitrary and against the service jurisprudence.

                    10. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that

       as per Rule 58 of the Bihar Pension Rules, which states that the

       service must be under Government, employment must be

       substantial and permanent and the services must be paid by the

       Government. In the case of the petitioner, all the conditions have

       already been fulfilled by the petitioner, prior to his

       appointment/regularisation in the service, therefore Rule 58 of

       the Bihar Pension Rule is fully applicable in the present case.

       He submits that respondents did not take into consideration the

       fact that the petitioner rendered his services, without any break
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         11/50




       since 1979 and received daily wages payment and minimum

       scale for the post, alongwith other admissible allowances.

                    CASE OF THE RESPONDENTS

                    11. A counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the

       respondent nos. 3 to 5, wherein it has been pointed out that the

       petitioner was initially engaged as a daily wage employee, as per

       the requirement of the work in the department concerned. The

       petitioner was appointed as a regular Government Servant on

       14.08.2008, against the sanctioned and vacant post, which clearly

       mentioned that the past services rendered as daily wager, will not

       be counted for services. The petitioner superannuated in the year

       2013, and therefore, he only worked in regular establishment for

       5 years. He submits that New Pension Scheme came into effect in

       the year 2005, and therefore, the petitioner is covered under the

       New Pension Scheme. The petitioner alongwith others filed

       C.W.J.C. no 5887 of 2012 before this Court and vide order dated

       19.04.2012, direction was given to the department concerned to

       consider the representation of the petitioner. The Chief Engineer,

       Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur had considered the

       same and passed reasoned and speaking order contained in Letter

       No. 3314 dated 05.12.2012.
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         12/50




           SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS

                    12. The learned counsel for the State-respondents

       submits that the services of the regular Government Servant will

       be governed by the Bihar Service Code and the Bihar Pension

       Rules. The provisions contained in Rule 56, Rule 58 and Rule 61

       of Bihar Pension Rules prescribes that ‘unless it be otherwise

       provided by special rule or contract, the services of every

       government servant qualifies from the date on which he takes

       charges of the posts to which he is first appointed’. Further Rule

       58 provides that ‘the services of a government servant does not

       qualify for pension unless it conforms to the following three

       conditions (i) The services must be under Government (ii) The

       employment must be substantive and permanent, (iii) The

       services must be paid by the Government’. Further Rule 61

       provides that ‘Service does not qualify unless the Government

       servant holds substantively a post on a permanent establishment’.

       He submits that the petitioner was appointed as a regular

       Government servant on 14.08.2008 and from perusal of the

       provisions contained in Rules 56 and 58 of the Bihar Pension

       Rules, it is clear that the past services of the petitioner rendered as

       a daily wager cannot be added for the retiral or pensionary
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         13/50




       benefits, as the petitioner became the Government servant only

       after his appointment in the year 2008.

                    13. A reply, to the interlocutory application filed on

       behalf of the petitioner has been filed, wherein it has been stated

       that since the petitioner was appointed in the year 2008 and

       superannuated in the 2013, therefore the petitioner had rendered

       only five years of continuous service. It has further been stated

       that at the time of appointment, the petitioner accepted all the

       terms and conditions mentioned in the appointment letter, he

       submitted his joining, he superannuated in the year 2013 and now

       after almost 17 years, the petitioner is challenging the averments

       made in paragraph no. 2 of the appointment letter, which is

       impermissible in law. It is stated therein that the petitioner cannot

       approbate and reprobate simultaneously.

                    14. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

       State-respondents submits that the doctrine of delay and laches

       rests on the foundation of greater public interest on the ground

       that the log dormant claims have more of cruelty than justice. The

       defendant looses the evidence and finally persons with good

       cause of action has to pursue the case with diligence. The doctrine

       of laches has been taken as equivalent to doctrine of waiver.

        CASE LAW RELIED ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         14/50




                    15. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

       petitioner refers to and relies on a judgment of the Hon’ble

       Division of this Court dated 26.06.2023 passed in L.P.A. no. 198

       of 2016 (The Registrar General, Patna High Court versus Ram

       Vyas Dubey & Others.), wherein in paragraph nos. 10, 11, 12 and

       13 it has been held as follows:-

                            “10. It is the categorical case of respondent no. 2-
                                  appellant that a minimum of 10 years of service
                                  as a regular employee is required to qualify for
                                  pension and the same has been fixed by the
                                  Government of Bihar. At this stage Rule 58 of the
                                  Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 which deals with the
                                  conditions of the service of a Government
                                  servant to qualify for pension may be referred to
                                  and the same is quoted hereinbelow:
                                  “58. The service of a Government servant does
                                  not qualify for pension unless it conforms to the
                                  following three conditions :-
                                  First- The service must be under Government.
                                  Second -The employment must be substantive
                                  and permanent.
                                  Third -The service must be paid by Government.
                                  These three conditions are fully explained in the
                                  following sub-sections.
                            11. Rule 59 of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950 provides
                                  that in certain cases even though the conditions
                                  are not fulfilled, the Government may provide
                                  that the service rendered by a Government
                                  servant shall count for pension. Under this
                                  provision the Government came out with Memo
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         15/50




                                  No. Pen1024/69/11779 F., dated 12.8.1969 which
                                  is quoted hereinbelow for ready reference:
                                  “Regarding:-Declaration of temporary service of
                                  a Government servant who is not confirmed as
                                  pensionable.
                                  Under       the       existing   pension   rules,   a
                                  temporaryGovernment servant if not confirmed
                                  in any post, is not entitled to pension unless his
                                  services are declared pensionable under rule 59
                                  of the Bihar Pension Rules.
                                  2. There are a large number of temporary
                                  Government servants employed under different
                                  schemes which are in existence for the last 15-20
                                  years and it will cause hardship to them, if they
                                  are not allowed pension after their retirement.
                                  3.    The      State     Government    after   careful
                                  consideration have, therefore, been pleased to
                                  decide that, if the service of the temporary or
                                  officiating Government servant who is not
                                  confirmed in any post is continuous and is more
                                  than 15 years, it will be considered as
                                  pensionable under rule 59 of the Bihar Pension
                                  Rules.
                                  4. These orders will be applicable to Government
                                  servants retiring on or after 12 August, 1969.
                                  [*Vide Memo No. Pen 1024/69/11779 F., dated
                                  12-8-1969.]”
                            12.   Reading of the above provisions clearly provide
                                  that even if a person has worked in a temporary
                                  capacity and has not been confirmed, if his
                                  service on any post is continuous and is for more
                                  than 15 years, then it may be considered as
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         16/50




                                  pensionable under Rule 59 of the Bihar Pension
                                  Rules, 1950.
                            13.   Taking into consideration the material on record,
                                  Rules 58 and 59 of the Bihar Pension Rules,
                                  1950 and the Memo dated 12.8.1969 which has
                                  also been extracted in full by the learned Single
                                  Judge in the order impugned, the learned Single
                                  Judge was rightly pleased to allow the prayer
                                  sought for in the writ application.”
                    16. The learned counsel for the petitioner further refers

       to and relies on a judgment dated 07.08.2019 passed by a learned

       Single Judge of this Court in C.W.J.C. no. 12833 of 2017 (Savita

       Devi versus the State of Bihar & Others), wherein in paragraph

       nos. 2, 4 and 5 it has been held as follows:-

                               “2. The learned counsel for the petitioner has
                                      relied upon a judgment rendered by a co-
                                      ordinate Bench of this Court dated
                                      21.05.2010 passed in CWJC No. 14717
                                      of 2009 (Parmeshwar Paswan vs. The
                                      State of Bihar & Ors.) to contend that
                                      the past services for the period 1.4.1977
                                      onward       are     also     required   to   be
                                      considered         for      the   purposes    of
                                      computation of the pension/ family
                                      pension amount in terms of Rule 59 of
                                      the Bihar Pension Rules. It would be
                                      relevant to reproduce paragraphs no. 8
                                      to 14 of the aforesaid judgment rendered
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                           17/50




                                      in the case of Parmeshwar Paswan
                                      (supra) herein below:-
                                      8.     Considering the rival submissions of
                                             the parties and their respective
                                             pleadings, it would appear that the
                                             basic      facts    with        respect      to
                                             appointment, allowing regular pay
                                             scale, gratuity, additional allowance
                                             and meeting the expenditure from
                                             general     revenue        of    the      State
                                             Government under the different
                                             head as indicated in Annexures -3
                                             and 4. It is also not in dispute that
                                             the petitioner also got declared as
                                             Class – IV employee of State
                                             Government vide Annexure -5. It
                                             would be appropriate to refer Rules
                                             58 and 59 in connection with
                                             entitlement of pension under the
                                             Bihar Pension Rules which are
                                             quoted below :-
                                             Rule :- 58 the services of a
                                             Government         servant       does      not
                                             qualify     for    pension       unless      it
                                             conforms to the following three
                                             conditions :-
                                             First – The Service must be under
                                             Government.
                                             Second – the employment must be
                                             substantive and permanent.
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                           18/50




                                             Third - the service must be paid by
                                             Government.
                                             These three conditions are fully
                                             explained in the following sub-
                                             sections.
                                             Rule       :-   59         The      provincial
                                             Government may, however, in the
                                             case of service paid from general
                                             revenues, even though either or both
                                             of conditions (1) and (2) are not
                                             fulfilled.
                                      (1) declare that any specified kind of
                                             service rendered in a non- gazetted
                                             capacity shall qualify for pension.
                                      (2) In individual cases, and subject to
                                             such conditions as it may think fit to
                                             impose in each case, direct that
                                             service rendered by a Government
                                             servant shall count for pension
                                      9.     On     perusal        of     the     aforesaid
                                             provision it would appear that Rule
                                             58     prescribes          three     necessary
                                             conditions      to     be        fulfilled   for
                                             qualifying      for    pension         by    the
                                             Government             servants.             The
                                             conditions are that the service must
                                             be     under          Government,            the
                                             employment must be substantive and
                                             permanent and the service must be
                                             paid by the government. The Rule
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         19/50




                                            59 empowers the State Government
                                            declare even though the person
                                            claiming pension may not fulfill the
                                            above conditions no. 1 and 2 to
                                            direct that the service rendered by
                                            the Government servant shall count
                                            for     pension       considering      the
                                            individual cases with respect to any
                                            specific kind of service rendered in
                                            non-gazetted capacity having the
                                            paramount consideration for service
                                            of    such   individual       cases    that
                                            services must have been paid from
                                            the general revenue of the State
                                            Government.
                                      10. The case of the petitioner that after
                                            initial appointment on the post of
                                            Chowkidar the regular pay scale
                                            revisions of pay scale as also the
                                            allowances and extending other
                                            benefits like payment of gratuity and
                                            exgratia     amount     to     the    legal
                                            representatives of the Chowkidar in
                                            case of his death even prior to
                                            01.01.1990     were      allowed.      The
                                            expenditure on account of such
                                            payments were made from the public
                                            exchequer under the specific police
                                            heads mentioned in Annexure- 3 and
                                            4     even   before     the     petitioner
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         20/50




                                            alongwith other village Chowkidars
                                            were declared as Class – IV
                                            Employee. These facts are not in
                                            dispute.
                                      11. The only reason for disallowing the
                                            benefit of pension is that in case,
                                            pension is allowed to the petitioner,
                                            the Government may be face more
                                            similar individual cases causing
                                            problem for the government in
                                            future. The stand is not justified in
                                            law in view of the provisions of
                                            rules 58 and 59 of the Bihar
                                            Pension Rules. Moreover, this court
                                            as per the order dated 29.04.2008 in
                                            C.W.J.C. No. 13634 of 2006 as
                                            contained         in     Annexure-      6
                                            specifically           directed        for
                                            consideration            by         “State
                                            Government” to consider the case
                                            of the petitioner in terms of Rule 59
                                            of the Bihar Pension Rules for
                                            considering the service rendered by
                                            him in between 01.01.1977 to
                                            01.01.1990. The impugned order
                                            does        not   indicate    any    such
                                            consideration.
                                      12. Learned counsel for the State is not
                                            in a position to controvert the
                                            submissions of the petitioner that
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         21/50




                                            such considerations were made in
                                            the         impugned      order       dated
                                            18.06.2009         as     contained      in
                                            annexure- 8.
                                      13. In the above circumstances and in
                                            view of the discussions made in the
                                            forgoing paragraphs, this court is
                                            unableto uphold the decision as
                                            contained in impugned order dated
                                            18.06.2009                 (Annexure-8),
                                            accordingly, the same is quashed
                                            with        direction   that   the    State
                                            Government should take conscious
                                            decision for counting the previous
                                            service of the petitioner between
                                            01.01.1977         to   01.01.1990      for
                                            qualifying service for pension in
                                            light of the relevant consideration
                                            required to be taken under Rule 58
                                            and 59 of Bihar Pension Rules in
                                            the individual cases. Such decision
                                            be taken after considering the entire
                                            facts and circumstances of the case
                                            in respect of the petitioner as also
                                            directed by the Court on the
                                            previous writ application filed by
                                            the petitioner Vide Annexure -6
                                            within a period of six months on
                                            receipt/production of certified copy
                                            of the present order
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         22/50




                                      14. The writ application stands disposed
                                            of          with         the           above
                                            observations/directions”.
                               4.     Having      regard       to   the    facts    and
                                      circumstances of the case, I deem it fit
                                      and proper to quash the order dated
                                      21.4.2017 passed by the Secretary of
                                      Home (Police Department), Government
                                      of Bihar, Patna and remand the matter
                                      back to the State authorities to consider
                                      the case of the husband of the petitioner/
                                      petitioner herein for grant of pension/
                                      family pension and take a decision under
                                      Rules 58 and 59 of the Bihar Pension
                                      Rules.
                               5.     In the facts and circumstances of the
                                      case, considering the aforesaid judgment
                                      rendered in the case of Parmeshwar
                                      Paswan (supra), the writ petition stands
                                      allowed to the aforesaid extent.”
    CASE LAW RELIED ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS

                    17. Per contra, the learned counsel for the State refers

       to and relies on a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of

       India reported in 2002 SCC OnLine SC 295 (State of Bihar

       versus S.A. Hassan & Anr.), wherein in paragraph no.12 it has

       been held as follows:-

                                    “12. Rule 58 is clear that a government servant
                                        does not qualify for pension unless he
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         23/50




                                        conforms to three conditions viz. (1) his
                                        service must be under the Government, (2)
                                        the employment must be substantive and
                                        permanent, and (3) service must be paid by
                                        the Government. In view of this Rule the
                                        respondents cannot claim the period of their
                                        service before the College was taken over
                                        as they were neither under the employment
                                        of the Government nor were their salaries
                                        paid by the Government. Under the specific
                                        Rule 58 the past service rendered by the
                                        respondents in the College while it was
                                        under the private management cannot be
                                        counted.”
                    18. The learned counsel for the State further refers to

       and relies on a judgment of the Hon’ble Full Bench of this

       Court reported in 2014 (4) P.L.J.R. 229 (The State of Bihar &

       Anr. versus Bhagwan Singh), wherein Hon’ble Full Bench of

       this Court has held as follows:-

                                         “We shall first consider the relevant
                                         provisions of the Pension Rules, 1950. Rule
                                         56 of the Pension Rules provides that
                                         ‘unless it be otherwise provided by special
                                         rule or contract, the service of every
                                         government servant qualifies from the
                                         date he takes the charge of the post to
                                         which he is first appointed'. Rule 58
                                         thereof provides that the service of a
                                         Government servant does not qualify for
                                         pension unless it conforms to the following
                                         three conditions:-
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         24/50




                                         (i) The service must be under Government.

                                         (ii) The employment must be substantive
                                         and permanent.

                                         (iii)   The    service   must    be        paid   by
                                         Government.

                                         Rule 61 thereof provides, ‘service does not
                                         qualify unless the Government servant
                                         holds substantively a post on a permanent
                                         establishment’.

                                         Rule 45 thereof expressly excludes certain
                                         service for computation of pension. Clause
                                         (a) thereof reads, ‘when a government
                                         servant is appointed for a limited time
                                         only, or for a specified duty, on the
                                         completion      of   which      he    is     to   be
                                         discharged’. Clause (b) thereof reads,
                                         ‘when a person is employed temporarily
                                         on monthly wages without specified limit
                                         of time or duty’.

                                         It is apparent that the above-referred
                                         provisions were not brought to the notice of
                                         the learned single Judge or before the
                                         Division Bench in the matter of State of
                                         Bihar v. Chandrika Rai (Letters Patent
                                         Appeal No. 1343 of 1998).

                                         Keeping in view the above provisions, we
                                         are of the opinion that the service rendered
                                         by the petitioner as daily wage Choukidar
                                         under the Executive Engineer, Tubewell
                                         Division, Gaya cannot be said to be a
                                         service for which the petitioner was paid
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         25/50




                                         from the general revenue of the State
                                         Government or the service rendered on a
                                         substantive         post   in      a    permanent
                                         establishment. Such service, although was
                                         followed       by     absorption       on   regular
                                         establishment, will not qualify for pension.
                                         Therefore, the service rendered by the
                                         petitioner, as daily wage employee from
                                         April 1973 to December 1978, was not a
                                         pensionable service or did not qualify for
                                         pension. On his retirement from service or
                                         his superannuation from service, he would
                                         be entitled to pension for the service

                                         rendered on a substantive post from 1 st
                                         January 1979 till the date he retired from
                                         service.”

                    19. The learned counsel for the State further refers to

       and relies on a judgment of a learned Single Judge of this

       Hon’ble Court in the case of Ram Naresh Jha versus the State of

       Bihar & Others passed in C.W.J.C. no. 1109 of 2015, wherein it

       has been held as follows:-

                                  “5. The issue raised in the present case is no
                                         more res integra. In The State of Bihar &
                                         Anr. vs. Bhagwan Singh (since dead)
                                         [2014(4) PLJR 229], a Full-Bench of this
                                         Court had an occasion to consider the issue
                                         raised in the present writ petition. The
                                         Bench after taking into consideration the
                                         relevant provisions of Bihar Pension Rules,
                                         1950, i.e., Rules 56, 58 and 61 held that the
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         26/50




                                         service rendered by a person as daily wage
                                         employee cannot be said to be a service for
                                         which the petitioner was paid from the
                                         general revenue of the State Government or
                                         the service rendered on a substantive post
                                         in a permanent establishment. It held that
                                         such service, even if it is followed by
                                         absorption on regular establishment, will
                                         not qualify for pension.
                                  6.     In view of the above binding precedent of
                                         this Court, the prayer of the petitioner
                                         cannot    be    allowed.   It   is     dismissed,
                                         accordingly.”
                    20. The learned counsel for the State further refers to

       and relies on a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India

       reported in 2022 (2) SCC 25 (Union of India & Others versus N.

       Murugesan & Others), wherein it has been held as follows:-

                                  “25. Acquiescence would mean a tacit or passive
                                         acceptance. It is implied and reluctant
                                         consent to an act. In other words, such an
                                         action would qualify a passive assent.
                                         Thus, when acquiescence takes place, it
                                         presupposes       knowledge          against   a
                                         particular act. From the knowledge comes
                                         passive acceptance, therefore instead of
                                         taking any action against any alleged
                                         refusal to perform the original contract,
                                         despite adequate knowledge of its terms,
                                         and instead being allowed to continue by
                                         consciously ignoring it and thereafter
                                         proceeding further, acquiescence does take
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         27/50




                                         place. As a consequence, it reintroduces a
                                         new implied agreement between the parties.
                                         Once such a situation arises, it is not open
                                         to the party that acquiesced itself to insist
                                         upon the compliance of the original terms.
                                         Hence, what is essential, is the conduct of
                                         the parties. We only dealt with the
                                         distinction involving a mere acquiescence.
                                         When acquiescence is followed by delay, it
                                         may become laches. Here again, we are
                                         inclined to hold that the concept of
                                         acquiescence is to be seen on a case-to-
                                         case basis.
                                         Approbate and reprobate
                                  26. These phrases are borrowed from the Scots
                                         law. They would only mean that no party
                                         can be allowed to accept and reject the
                                         same thing, and thus one cannot blow hot
                                         and cold. The principle behind the doctrine
                                         of election is inbuilt in the concept of
                                         approbate and reprobate. Once again, it is
                                         a principle of equity coming under the
                                         contours of common law. Therefore, he who
                                         knows that if he objects to an instrument,
                                         he will not get the benefit he wants cannot
                                         be allowed to do so while enjoying the
                                         fruits. One cannot take advantage of one
                                         part while rejecting the rest. A person
                                         cannot be allowed to have the benefit of an
                                         instrument while questioning the same.
                                         Such a party either has to affirm or
                                         disaffirm the transaction. This principle
                                         has to be applied with more vigour as a
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         28/50




                                         common law principle, if such a party
                                         actually enjoys the one part fully and on
                                         near completion of the said enjoyment,
                                         thereafter questions the other part. An
                                         element of fair play is inbuilt in this
                                         principle. It is also a species of estoppel
                                         dealing with the conduct of a party. We
                                         have already dealt with the provisions of
                                         the Contract Act concerning the conduct of
                                         a party, and his presumption of knowledge
                                         while confirming an offer through his
                                         acceptance unconditionally.
                                  27.2.State of Punjab v. Dhanjit Singh Sandhu
                                         [State of Punjab v. Dhanjit Singh Sandhu,
                                         (2014) 15 SCC 144] : (SCC pp. 153-54,
                                         paras 22-23 & 25-26)
                                      “22.    The       doctrine   of   “approbate   and
                                             reprobate” is only a species of estoppel,
                                             it implies only to the conduct of parties.
                                             As in the case of estoppel it cannot
                                             operate against the provisions of a
                                             statute. (Vide CIT v. MR. P. Firm Muar
                                             [CIT v. MR. P. Firm Muar, AIR 1965 SC
                                             1216] .)
                                      23. It is settled proposition of law that once an
                                             order has been passed, it is complied
                                             with, accepted by the other party and
                                             derived the benefit out of it, he cannot
                                             challenge it on any ground. (Vide
                                             Maharashtra SRTC v. Balwant Regular
                                             Motor Service [Maharashtra SRTC v.
                                             Balwant Regular Motor Service, AIR
                                             1969 SC 329] .) In R.N. Gosain v.
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         29/50




                                            Yashpal Dhir [R.N. Gosain v. Yashpal
                                            Dhir, (1992) 4 SCC 683] this Court has
                                            observed as under : (R.N. Gosain case
                                            [R.N. Gosain v. Yashpal Dhir, (1992) 4
                                            SCC 683] , SCC pp. 687-88, para 10)
                                      ‘10. Law does not permit a person to both
                                            approbate and reprobate. This principle
                                            is based on the doctrine of election
                                            which postulates that no party can
                                            accept and reject the same instrument
                                            and that ‘a person cannot say at one
                                            time that a transaction is valid and
                                            thereby obtain some advantage, to which
                                            he could only be entitled on the footing
                                            that it is valid, and then turn round and
                                            say it is void for the purpose of securing
                                            some other advantage’.’
                                                        ***
                                      25. The Supreme Court in Rajasthan State
                                            Industrial Development & Investment
                                            Corpn. v. Diamond & Gem Development
                                            Corpn. Ltd. [Rajasthan State Industrial
                                            Development & Investment Corpn. v.
                                            Diamond & Gem Development Corpn.
                                            Ltd., (2013) 5 SCC 470 : (2013) 3 SCC
                                            (Civ) 153] , made an observation that a
                                            party cannot be permitted to “blow hot
                                            and    cold”,     “fast   and   loose”   or
                                            “approbate and reprobate”. Where one
                                            knowingly accepts the benefits of a
                                            contract or conveyance or an order, is
                                            estopped to deny the validity or binding
                                            effect on him of such contract or
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         30/50




                                            conveyance or order. This rule is applied
                                            to do equity, however, it must not be
                                            applied in a manner as to violate the
                                            principles of right and good conscience.
                                      26.   It is evident that the doctrine of election
                                            is based on the rule of estoppel, the
                                            principle that one cannot approbate and
                                            reprobate is inherent in it. The doctrine
                                            of estoppel by election is one among the
                                            species of estoppel in pais (or equitable
                                            estoppel), which is a rule of equity. By
                                            this law, a person may be precluded, by
                                            way of his actions, or conduct, or silence
                                            when he has to speak, from asserting a
                                            right which he would have otherwise
                                            had.”
                    21. The learned counsel for the State refers to and relies

       on a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in

       2022 LiveLaw (SC) 232 (Surjeet Singh Sahni versus State of

       U.P. & Others), wherein it has been held as follows:-

                                      “5. As observed by this Court in catena
                                            of decisions, mere representation
                                            does not extend the period of
                                            limitation and the aggrieved person
                                            has     to   approach       the     Court
                                            expeditiously and within reasonable
                                            time. If it is found that the writ
                                            petitioner is guilty of delay and
                                            latches, the High Court should
                                            dismiss it at the threshold and ought
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         31/50




                                            not to dispose of the writ petition by
                                            relegating the writ petitioner to file
                                            a representation and/or directing
                                            the      authority       to     decide     the
                                            representation, once it is found that
                                            the original writ petitioner is guilty
                                            of delay and latches. Such order
                                            shall not give an opportunity to the
                                            petitioner to thereafter contend that
                                            rejection         of   the    representation
                                            subsequently has given a fresh
                                            cause of action.”
                    22. Similarly, the learned counsel for the State refers to

       and relies on a judgment of this Court passed in C.W.J.C. no.

       13306 of 2023 (Gyasuddin versus the State of Bihar & Others),

       wherein it has been held as follows:-

                                  “6. Having heard the Ld. counsel for the parties
                                        and having gone through the materials on
                                        record, this Court finds that the present writ
                                        petition is fit to be dismissed on the ground
                                        of delay and laches alone, inasmuch as the
                                        petitioner      has    approached    this    Court
                                        belatedly after a lapse of about 26 years.
                                        Thus, considering the principles laid down
                                        by the Hon’ble Apex Court in a catena of
                                        judgments, as referred to by the Ld. counsel
                                        for the Respondent-State and recorded
                                        herein above in the preceding paragraphs,
                                        as also considering the maxim-“equity aids
                                        the vigilant and not those who slumber on
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         32/50




                                        their rights”, this Court is of the view that
                                        since the petitioner has not filed the writ
                                        petition within a reasonable period of time,
                                        this Court is not under any legal obligation
                                        to entertain the writ petition, especially
                                        considering the fact that the petitioner has
                                        not offered any reason whatsoever, for the
                                        enormous delay which has taken place in
                                        approaching this Court, hence, the present
                                        writ petition is dismissed on the ground of
                                        delay and laches.
                                  7.    In fact, in a judgment, rendered by the
                                        Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of P. S.
                                        Sadasivaswamy vs. State of Tamil Nadu,
                                        reported in (1975) 1 SCC 152, the Hon’ble
                                        Apex Court has held that in a service
                                        matter/promotion     matter,   an   aggrieved
                                        person should approach the Court at least
                                        within six months or at the most a year of
                                        the arising of a cause of action and it would
                                        be a sound and wise exercise of discretion
                                        for the Courts to refuse to exercise their
                                        extraordinary powers under Article 226 of
                                        the Constitution of India, in the case of
                                        persons     who     do   not   approach    it
                                        expeditiously for relief and such petitions
                                        should be dismissed in limine, inasmuch as
                                        entertaining such petitions is a waste of
                                        time of the Court, the same clogs the work
                                        of the Court and impedes the work of the
                                        Court in considering legitimate grievances.
                                        In yet another judgment, rendered by the
                                        Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Naresh
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         33/50




                                        Kumar vs. Department of Atomic Energy &
                                        Others, reported in (2010) 7 SCC 525, the
                                        Hon’ble Apex Court has held that the High
                                        Court was not in error while dismissing the
                                        writ petition on the ground of unexplained
                                        delay and laches of about 8 years.
                                  8. At this juncture, it would be gainful to
                                        reproduce paragraphs No. 1, 16, 17 and 34
                                        of the Judgment rendered by the Hon’ble
                                        Apex Court in the case of Chennai
                                        Metropolitan Water Supply & Sewerage
                                        Board (Supra), herein below:-
                                      “1. The present appeal, by special leave, is
                                            directed against the judgment and order
                                            dated 22-11-2012 passed by the High
                                            Court of Judicature of Madras in
                                            Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply &
                                            Sewerage Board v. T.T. Murali Babu
                                            whereby        the        Division   Bench    has
                                            affirmed the judgment and order dated
                                            21-7-2011 in WP No. 25673 of 2007
                                            whereunder the learned Single Judge
                                            had allowed the writ petition, and after
                                            setting      aside         the   punishment    of
                                            dismissal, directed reinstatement of the
                                            respondent with continuity of service but
                                            without back wages.
                                      16. Thus, the doctrine of delay and laches
                                            should not be lightly brushed aside. A
                                            writ court is required to weigh the
                                            explanation offered and the acceptability
                                            of the same. The court should bear in
                                            mind        that     it     is   exercising   an
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         34/50




                                            extraordinary and equitable jurisdiction.
                                            As a constitutional court it has a duty to
                                            protect the rights of the citizens but
                                            simultaneously it is to keep itself alive to
                                            the primary principle that when an
                                            aggrieved person, without adequate
                                            reason, approaches the court at his own
                                            leisure or pleasure, the court would be
                                            under legal obligation to scrutinise
                                            whether the lis at a belated stage should
                                            be entertained or not. Be it noted, delay
                                            comes in the way of equity. In certain
                                            circumstances delay and laches may not
                                            be fatal but in most circumstances
                                            inordinate delay would only invite
                                            disaster for the litigant who knocks at
                                            the doors of the court. Delay reflects
                                            inactivity and inaction on the part of a
                                            litigant — a litigant who has forgotten
                                            the          basic      norms,      namely,
                                            “procrastination is the greatest thief of
                                            time” and second, law does not permit
                                            one to sleep and rise like a phoenix.
                                            Delay does bring in hazard and causes
                                            injury to the lis.
                                      17. In the case at hand, though there has been
                                            four years' delay in approaching the
                                            court, yet the writ court chose not to
                                            address the same. It is the duty of the
                                            court       to   scrutinise   whether   such
                                            enormous delay is to be ignored without
                                            any justification. That apart, in the
                                            present case, such belated approach
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         35/50




                                            gains       more       significance        as   the
                                            respondent employee being absolutely
                                            careless to his duty and nurturing a
                                            lackadaisical           attitude       to       the
                                            responsibility             had             remained
                                            unauthorisedly absent on the pretext of
                                            some kind of ill health. We repeat at the
                                            cost    of        repetition   that    remaining
                                            innocuously oblivious to such delay does
                                            not foster the cause of justice. On the
                                            contrary, it brings in injustice, for it is
                                            likely to affect others. Such delay may
                                            have impact on others' ripened rights
                                            and may unnecessarily drag others into
                                            litigation which in acceptable realm of
                                            probability, may have been treated to
                                            have attained finality. A court is not
                                            expected to give indulgence to such
                                            indolent persons — who compete with
                                            “Kumbhakarna” or for that matter “Rip
                                            Van Winkle”. In our considered opinion,
                                            such delay does not deserve any
                                            indulgence & on the said ground alone
                                            the writ court should have thrown the
                                            petition overboard at the very threshold.
                                      34. Judged on the anvil of the aforesaid
                                            premises, the irresistible conclusion is
                                            that the interference by the High Court
                                            with        the     punishment        is     totally
                                            unwarranted and unsustainable, and
                                            further the High Court was wholly
                                            unjustified in entertaining the writ
                                            petition after a lapse of four years. The
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         36/50




                                            result of aforesaid analysis would entail
                                            overturning the judgments and orders
                                            passed by the learned Single Judge and
                                            the Division Bench of the High Court
                                            and, accordingly, we so do.”
                    CONSIDERATION AND ANALYSIS

                    23. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and

       after going through the records, it appears that the petitioner was

       initially engaged as a daily wage employee in the year 1979, to

       perform the duties of a Class-IV employee and later on, was

       given minimum scale of pay along with other similarly situated

       employees w.e.f January 1998, in compliance of order dated

       16.01.1998 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 11255 of 1995. The petitioner

       kept on working on the post, however temporary status was

       granted to him after 1998, when minimum scale of post was

       granted and the petitioner started getting salary from the State

       Government. Finally, the petitioner was appointed on the

       sanctioned post of Peon/Chaukidar vide office order contained in

       Memo No. 2867 dated 14.08.2008, issued under the signature of

       the Chief Engineer, Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur, in

       view of the roaster clearance given by the Commissioner, Tirhut

       Division vide his letter no. 3807 dated 16.08.2008 and in view of

       the directions contained in letter dated 16.03.2006 and

       01.04.2006, issued from the Personal and Administrative Reforms
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         37/50




       Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. Accordingly, he was

       appointed as a Peon in the pay scale of Rs. 2500-3200/- with all

       the applicable allowances and was posted in the Tirhut Division

       No.1, Muzaffarpur. Later on, his service was confirmed w.e.f.

       14.08.2008 vide letter no. 3644 dated 15.10.2008, issued under

       the    signature      of    the    Chief     Engineer, Water   Resources

       Development Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. The

       petitioner was not granted the benefit of his past service,

       although, admittedly he was working on the post since 1979,

       without any break and therefore, he filed a writ petition bearing

       C.W.J.C. No. 5882 of 2012, for a direction to count his service

       from his initial date of appointment/engagement and for giving

       pensionary and other benefits. The above-mentioned writ petition

       was disposed of vide order dated 19.04.2012 passed by a learned

       Single Judge of this Court with a direction to the respondents to

       consider the representation of the petitioner in accordance with

       law. Subsequently, vide letter no. 3314 dated 05.01.2022, issued

       under the signature of the Chief Engineer, Water Resources

       Department, Muzaffarpur, the claim of the petitioner for counting

       his past services and shifting the date of regularisation, only for

       the limited purposes of counting pensionary benefits and other

       benefits, was rejected. It appears that while issuing the
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         38/50




       appointment letter to the petitioner on 14.08.2008, it was

       specifically mentioned that "इनकी ननयु नकक पूररकः असथायी है । पूरर की कायररक

       अरनध की गरना से रा अरनध के नलए मानय नहीं होगी।" and based on the

       above, the respondent-authorities did not consider the case of the

       petitioner for counting his service from the initial date of

       engagement as a daily wager i.e. 1979. It is not in dispute that the

       petitioner continuously performed the duties of a daily wager

       from 1979, without any break, on a sanctioned post and was

       granted minimum scale of pay w.e.f. January, 1998. He was

       finally regularised on 14.08.2008, however the said appointment

       letter was issed with a rider, that his previous services would not

       be countered for giving any pensionary benefit. The Chief

       Engineer rejected the claim of the petitioner for counting his past

       service on the above mentioned ground, without even taking into

       consideration the fact that in the State of Bihar not very large

       percentage of population has the source of livelihood, while the

       remaining population do not have any permanent means to fetch a

       source of livelihood. The petitioner found the source of livelihood

       for his family and still for the reasons best known to the

       authorities, the petitioner had to consistently remain before either

       this Court or before the authorities concerned, to secure the

       financial resource to feed his family, all through his life. The
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         39/50




       petitioner admittedly was working as a daily wager since 1979,

       till regularisation in 2008 and finally, superannuated in the year

       2013, thereby he worked for almost 34 years and retired without

       finding a permanent financial stability. While considering the

       case of the petitioner, this Court came across a judgment rendered

       by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in the case of Ashok

       Kumar Sharma versus the State of Bihar and Others (LPA No.

       1690 of 2013), wherein similar issue had come up for

       consideration before the Hon’ble Division Bench, wherein the

       Hon’ble Division Bench was pleased to hold that “Having

       considered the matter, in our view, learned counsel for the

       appellants is correct. Considering the history of events up to

       1990, as noted above, what was considered for regularization

       was a daily wager having worked for more than 240 days

       simplicitor, was the earlier State Government decision and which

       had been extended pursuant to trade union agreement. This was

       also in consonance with the resolution of the State Government in

       the Personnel Department dated 10.05.2005. which is a part of

       the proceedings itself. This clearly shows that right till the year

       2005, State was only contemplating regularization with

       restriction that the said daily wager must have worked for 240

       days. There was a clear distinction maintained when the 2006
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         40/50




       resolution was taken. There were two classes. First, where the

       State Government was bound by the trade union agreement in

       respect of daily wagers up to 11.12.1990 and second those who

       came       thereafter.     Therefore,       there   were   two   different

       categorizations in this resolution dated 16.03.2006. It is wrong to

       say that there was conflict between the Clause-1 of the said

       resolution and Clause-3. The two contemplated two different

       periods. The writ petitioners/appellants, falling within the first

       period i.e. till 11.12.1990, were rightly treated and regularized as

       per Annexure-6 to the writ petition with effect from 22.12.2006.

       This distinction was not brought out clearly before the learned

       Single Judge because of which the learned Single Judge applied

       Clause-3 of this resolution, which applied to only those people

       who had joined as daily wagers after 11.12.1990. Having

       considered the matter, in our view, the impugned order, being

       Annexure-7 to the writ petition, recalling the regularization order

       dated 22.12.2006 (Annexure-6 to the writ petition), is set aside.

       The effect would be that the three writ petitioners/appellants

       would be deemed to be working duly regularized vide Annexure-6

       to the writ petition. As their services are terminated by Annexure-

       7 dated 02.01.2013 and have not worked since then, upon their

       reinstatement, they would be deemed as regularized employees
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         41/50




       but they would not get any back wages. They would be reinstated

       within two months from today. They would also be entitled to

       continuity in service.”

                    24. From the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble

       Division Bench in the case of Ashok Kumar Sharma (supra), it

       will transpire that the State authorities were engaging persons on

       daily wages basis to carry out the work of the State Government

       in different departments. It is not in dispute that the petitioner was

       engaged in the year 1979 and a conscious decision was taken by

       the State of Bihar vide Memo No. 5940 dated 18.06.1993, to

       regularise the services of daily wage employee, who were

       appointed prior to the cut off date i.e. 01.08.1985 and in the said

       resolution, it was clearly mentioned that after the cut off date, no

       recruitment will be made on daily wage. The petitioner was

       appointed in 1979, therefore, his case is covered by the resolution

       dated 18.06.1993, which subsequently was extended, in view of

       the demands raised by the employees trade union and two groups

       were classified. The case of the petitioner falls within the first

       classified group, wherein all such employees were directed to be

       considered for regularization, who had worked for 240 days, prior

       to 01.08.1985. The petitioner was regularised on 14.08.2008 and

       was entitled for grant of pensionary benefits, counting his
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         42/50




       services from 1979, since he had continuously discharged the

       duty of the post and his duties were perennial in nature and he

       kept on discharging the duty, as a regular employee. No

       complaint whatsoever has been brought on record by the

       authorities concerned to suggest that the petitioner did not

       perform his duties to the satisfaction of                   the respondent

       authorities.

                    25. In a recent decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court

       of India dated 19.08.2025 passed in Civil Appeal No. 8558 of

       2018 (Dharam Singh & Ors. versus State of U.P. & Anr.), the

       Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, while considering regularization

       of persons appointed on daily wages, allowed the civil appeal and

       in paragraph nos. 11, 13, 17 and 18 has held as follows:-

                                   “11. Furthermore, it must be clarified that the
                                         reliance placed by the High Court on
                                         Umadevi (Supra) to non-suit the appellants
                                         is misplaced. Unlike Umadevi (Supra), the
                                         challenge before us is not an invitation to
                                         bypass the constitutional scheme of public
                                         employment. It is a challenge to the State’s
                                         arbitrary refusals to sanction posts despite
                                         the employer’s own acknowledgement of
                                         need and decades of continuous reliance on
                                         the very workforce. On the other hand,
                                         Umadevi (Supra) draws a distinction
                                         between illegal appointments and irregular
                                         engagements and does not endorse the
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         43/50




                                         perpetuation of precarious employment
                                         where the work itself is permanent and the
                                         State has failed, for years, to put its house
                                         in order. Recent decisions of this Court in
                                         (Jaggo v. Union of India4 and in Shripal &
                                         Another v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad 5 )
                                         have emphatically cautioned that Umadevi
                                         (Supra) cannot be deployed as a shield to
                                         justify exploitation through long-term “ad
                                         hocism”, the use of outsourcing as a proxy,
                                         or the denial of basic parity where identical
                                         duties are exacted over extended periods.
                                         The principles articulated therein apply
                                         with full force to the present case. The
                                         relevant paras from Shripal (supra) have
                                         been reproduced hereunder:
                                   “14. The Respondent Employer places reliance
                                         on Umadevi (supra)2 to contend that daily-
                                         wage or temporary employees cannot claim
                                         permanent absorption in the absence of
                                         statutory rules providing such absorption.
                                         However, as frequently reiterated, Uma
                                         Devi      itself   distinguishes    between
                                         appointments that are “illegal” and those
                                         that are “irregular,” the latter being
                                         eligible for regularization if they meet
                                         certain conditions. More importantly, Uma
                                         Devi cannot serve as a shield to justify
                                         exploitative engagements persisting for
                                         years without the Employer undertaking
                                         legitimate recruitment. Given the record
                                         which shows no true contractor-based
                                         arrangement and a consistent need for
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         44/50




                                         permanent horticultural staff the alleged
                                         asserted ban on fresh recruitment, though
                                         real, cannot justify indefinite daily-wage
                                         status or continued unfair practices.
                                   15. It is manifest that the Appellant Workmen
                                         continuously rendered their services over
                                         several years, sometimes spanning more
                                         than a decade. Even if certain muster rolls
                                         were not produced in full, the Employer's
                                         failure to furnish such records-despite
                                         directions to do so-allows an adverse
                                         inference under well-established labour
                                         jurisprudence. Indian labour law strongly
                                         disfavors      perpetual      daily-wage    or
                                         contractual engagements in circumstances
                                         where the work is permanent in nature.
                                         Morally and legally, workers who fulfil
                                         ongoing municipal requirements year after
                                         year cannot be dismissed summarily as
                                         dispensable, particularly in the absence of
                                         a genuine contractor agreement. At this
                                         juncture, it would be appropriate to recall
                                         the     broader    critique     of   indefinite
                                         “temporary” employment practices as
                                         done by a recent judgment of this court in
                                         Jaggo v. Union of India3 in the following
                                         paragraphs:
                                   “22. The pervasive misuse of temporary
                                         employment contracts, as exemplified in
                                         this case, reflects a broader systemic issue
                                         that adversely affects workers' rights and
                                         job security. In the private sector, the rise
                                         of the gig economy has led to an increase
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         45/50




                                         in precarious employment arrangements,
                                         often characterized by lack of benefits, job
                                         security, and fair treatment. Such practices
                                         have been criticized for exploiting workers
                                         and       undermining          labour        standards.
                                         Government institutions, entrusted with
                                         upholding the principles of fairness and
                                         justice, bear an even greater responsibility
                                         to avoid such exploitative employment
                                         practices. When public sector entities
                                         engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it
                                         not only mirrors the detrimental trends
                                         observed in the gig economy but also sets a
                                         concerning precedent that can erode public
                                         trust in governmental operations.
                                   ………
                                   25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary
                                         employees, particularly in government
                                         institutions, often face multifaceted forms
                                         of exploitation. While the foundational
                                         purpose of temporary contracts may have
                                         been to address short-term or seasonal
                                         needs, they have increasingly become a
                                         mechanism to evade long-term obligations
                                         owed       to     employees.     These        practices
                                         manifest in several ways:
                                   •     Misuse of “Temporary” Labels: Employees
                                         engaged         for    work    that     is    essential,
                                         recurring, and integral to the functioning of
                                         an      institution     are    often    labelled     as
                                         “temporary” or “contractual,” even when
                                         their     roles       mirror   those     of     regular
                                         employees. Such misclassification deprives
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         46/50




                                         workers of the dignity, security, and
                                         benefits that regular employees are entitled
                                         to, despite performing identical tasks.
                                   •     Arbitrary      Termination:         Temporary
                                         employees are frequently dismissed without
                                         cause or notice, as seen in the present case.
                                         This practice undermines the principles of
                                         natural justice and subjects workers to a
                                         state of constant insecurity, regardless of
                                         the quality or duration of their service.
                                   •     Lack of Career Progression: Temporary
                                         employees       often      find     themselves
                                         excludedfrom        opportunities   for     skill
                                         development, promotions, or incremental
                                         pay raises. They remain stagnant in their
                                         roles, creating a systemic disparity between
                                         them and their regular counterparts,
                                         despite their contributions being equally
                                         significant.
                                   •     Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions
                                         increasingly resort to outsourcing roles
                                         performed      by     temporary     employees,
                                         effectively replacing one set of exploited
                                         workers with another. This practice not
                                         only perpetuates exploitation but also
                                         demonstrates a deliberate effort to bypass
                                         the obligation to offer regular employment.
                                   •     Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits:
                                         Temporary employees are often denied
                                         fundamental benefits such as pension,
                                         provident fund, health insurance, and paid
                                         leave, even when their tenure spans
                                         decades. This lack of social security
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         47/50




                                         subjects them and their families to undue
                                         hardship, especially in cases of illness,
                                         retirement, or unforeseen circumstances.””
                                   13. As we have observed in both Jaggo (Supra)
                                         and Shripal (Supra), outsourcing cannot
                                         become a convenient shield to perpetuate
                                         precariousness      and     to   sidestep       fair
                                         engagement practices where the work is
                                         inherently perennial. The Commission’s
                                         further contention that the appellants are
                                         not “full-time” employees but continue
                                         only by virtue of interim orders also does
                                         not advance their case. That interim
                                         protection was granted precisely because of
                                         the long history of engagement and the
                                         pendency of the challenge to the State’s
                                         refusals. It neither creates rights that did
                                         not exist nor erases entitlements that may
                                         arise upon a proper adjudication of the
                                         legality of those refusals.
                                   17. Before concluding, we think it necessary to
                                         recall that the State (here referring to both
                                         the Union and the State governments) is not
                                         a    mere      market     participant     but     a
                                         constitutional employer. It cannot balance
                                         budgets on the backs of those who perform
                                         the most basic and recurring public
                                         functions. Where work recurs day after day
                                         and year after year, the establishment must
                                         reflect that reality in its sanctioned strength
                                         and engagement practices. The long-term
                                         extraction     of   regular      labour     under
                                         temporary labels corrodes confidence in
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         48/50




                                         public administration and offends the
                                         promise of equal protection. Financial
                                         stringency certainly has a place in public
                                         policy, but it is not a talisman that
                                         overrides fairness, reason and the duty to
                                         organise work on lawful lines.
                                   18. Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that
                                         “ad-hocism” thrives where administration
                                         is opaque. The State Departments must
                                         keep and produce accurate establishment
                                         registers, muster rolls and outsourcing
                                         arrangements, and they must explain, with
                                         evidence, why they prefer precarious
                                         engagement over sanctioned posts where
                                         the work is perennial. If “constraint” is
                                         invoked, the record should show what
                                         alternatives were considered, why similarly
                                         placed workers were treated differently,
                                         and how the chosen course aligns with
                                         Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of
                                         India.     Sensitivity        to       the    human
                                         consequences of prolonged insecurity is not
                                         sentimentality.   It     is        a   constitutional
                                         discipline that should inform every decision
                                         affecting those who keep public offices
                                         running.
                    26. Similarly, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in a

       decision dated 01.06.2026 passed in Civil Appeal No. 8354-8356

       of 2026 arising out of SLP(C) No. 28802-28804 of 2019 (Bhikni

       Devi etc versus the Union of India & Ors), while allowing the

       appeal, in paragraph no. 76 has held that the temporary status
Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                         49/50




       casual labourers would be entitled to pensionary benefits on

       superannuation, even in the absence of regularization.

                    27. In the present case, the petitioner has already been

       regularised, however his past services have not been considered

       for granting the benefits of pension.

                    28. Accordingly, the order contained in Letter No. 3314

       dated 05.12.2012, issued under the signature of the Chief

       Engineer, Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur and

       paragraph no.2 of the appointment letter contained in Memo No.

       2867 dated 14.08.2008, issued under the signature of the Chief

       Engineer, Water Resources Department, Muzaffarpur, wherein it

       has been mentioned that “Purb ki Karyarat Awadhi Ki Ganana

       Seva Awadhi ke Liye Manya Nhi Hogi” are set aside. Since the

       petitioner performed the duties, which were perennial in nature,

       he cannot be denied pensionary benefits and other benefits,

       treating his services from 1979, only for the purposes of giving

       pension and other benefits. The petitioner is held entitled for all

       the pension and pensionary benefits, treating his services from

       1979, notionally. The respondents are directed to make payment

       of all the pensionary benefits to the petitioner within a period of

       three months from the date of receipt/production of a copy of the

       order.
             Patna High Court CWJC No.18407 of 2013 dt. 16-06-2026
                                                       50/50




                                 29. The entire exercise must be completed within a

                    period of three months and the benefits accruing to the petitioner

                    must be credited in his account within the aforementioned period

                    of three months.

                                 30.    With     the     aforementioned   observations   and

                    directions, the writ petition is allowed.

                                 31. Pending applications if any, shall also stands

                    disposed of.




                                                  (Ritesh Kumar, J)
AjayMishra/-
AFR/NAFR                       AFR
CAV DATE                  07.04.2026
Uploading Date            16.06.2026
Transmission Date              NA


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.