Patna High Court
Anugrah Narayan SinhaversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors
Work with this judgment
Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.
Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.
- Decided
- Disposal
- ALLOWED
- Bench
- RITESH KUMAR
Holding
The order deducting 20% of the petitioner’s pension is set aside as it was passed without evidence, without proper consideration of the petitioner’s reply, and without the requisite finding of pecuniary loss under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules.
Summary
The deceased petitioner, a former Divisional Forest Officer, was suspended and faced departmental charges, after which a disciplinary authority deducted 20% of his pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules. Although the enquiry officer found the charges unproved and recommended exoneration, the authority repeatedly imposed the same pension reduction despite multiple show‑cause notices and the petitioner’s replies. The High Court had earlier set aside the punishment orders in 2001 and 2002, directing fresh notices and reasoned orders, but the authority again reiterated the deduction in 2010 without fresh B.P.S.C. approval or consideration of the petitioner’s defence. The Court held that the 2010 order was void as it was based on no evidence, lacked a finding of pecuniary loss, and violated its earlier directions. Consequently, the order was set aside and the legal heirs were directed to be paid the deducted pension amount with interest. The writ petition was allowed.
Issues considered
- Whether the disciplinary authority validly deducted 20% of the petitioner’s pension under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules.
- Whether the authority complied with the requirement of consulting the Bihar Public Service Commission before imposing the punishment.
- Whether the authority considered the petitioner’s reply to the show‑cause notice and the enquiry report before passing the order.
- Whether the order can be sustained in the absence of any finding of pecuniary loss to the State.
Legislation cited
- Bihar Pension Rules — s. 43(b)
- Constitution of India — s. Article 226, Article 227
Subjects
- pension deduction
- departmental enquiry
- disciplinary action
- Rule 43(b)
- Bihar Public Service Commission
- show‑cause notice
- quashing order
- legal heirs
- interest
Judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.17121 of 2013
======================================================
1.1. Jayanti Sinha Wife of Late Anugrah narayan Sinha, Resident of Zulu Park,
Hazaribag, P.O. - Hazaribagh, P.S. - Hazaribag, Jharkhand.
1.2. Sanjay Sinha Son of Late Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Resident of Zulu Park,
Hazaribag, P.O. - Hazaribagh, P.S. - Hazaribag, Jharkhand
1.3. Rajeev Sinha Son of Late Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Resident of Zulu Park,
Hazaribag, P.O. - Hazaribagh, P.S. - Hazaribag, Jharkhand
1.4. Seema Hazari Daughter of Late Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Resident of
Faridabad, P.O. Faridabad, P.S. - Gurgaon, District- Gurgaon Haryana.
1.5. Sapna Sachdeva Daughter of Late Anugrah Narayan Sinha, W/o Raghubir
Singh, Resident of Dada Ji Wheels, Ashok Rajpath, Opposite Patna College,
Patna - 800004.
1.6. Anita Baijal Daughter of Late Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Resident of New
Delhi, P.O. - New Delhi, P.S. - New Delhi, District- New Delhi.
1.7. Sunita Bajaj Daughter of Late Anugrah Narayan Sinha, Resident of Rajnagar
Ext Gaziabad, P.O. - Gaziabad, P.S. Gaziabad, District- Gaziabad, U.P.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State Of Bihar
2. Deputy Secretary Department Of Environment In Forest Government Of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Principal Chief Conservator Of Forest, Bihar, Patna.
4. The Account General, Veer Chand Patel, Marg, Patna.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Dhananjay Kashyap, Advocate
Mr. Nagadeo Choubey, Advocate
For the State : Mrs. Binita Singh, S.C.-28
Mr. Vivek Anand Amritesh, A.C. to S.C.-28
For the A.G. : Mr. Arun Kumar Arun, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RITESH KUMAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 15-06-2026
Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
Re: I.A. No.2 of 2026
2. The present interlocutory application has been
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
2/18
filed for recall/modification of direction contained in order
dated 20.04.2026, insofar as it relates to imposition of cost of
Rs.5,000/- to be deposited before the Patna High Court Legal
Services Committee, if the counter affidavit will not be filed
within the period prescribed in the order dated 20.04.2026.
3. For the reasons mentioned in the interlocutory
application, I.A. No.2 of 2026 is allowed.
C.W.J.C. No.17121 of 2013
4. The present writ petition has been filed for the
following reliefs:
“i) For issuance of a writ in the
nature of writ of certiorari or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction, quashing the order bearing
memo no. 1539 dated 18.06.2010 issued under the
signature of the Principal Secretary Department of
Environment and Forest, Government of Bihar
whereby the pension of the petitioner has been
reduced by 20%.
ii) For the issuance of the writ in the
nature of the writ of mandamus or any other
appropriate writ, order or direction, commanding
the respondent authorities to grant 100% pension
to the petitioner with arrears of pension payable to
him.
iii) For any other relief”
FACTS OF THE CASE
5. The brief facts, which are necessary for
adjudication of the present writ petition, are that the deceased
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
3/18
petitioner, while serving in the Bihar Forest Service, was put
under suspension vide notification contained in Memo
No.1537, dated 04.04.1996 and a departmental proceeding was
initiated against him vide order no.1852, dated 24.04.1996.
Altogether five charges were framed against the deceased
petitioner. Immediately thereafter, he superannuated from
service on 30.04.1996, while working as Divisional Forest
Officer, Social Forest Division, Dumka. Later on, the
departmental proceeding against the deceased petitioner was
converted into the proceeding under Section 43(b) of the Bihar
Pension Rules. Subsequently, the enquiry officer as well as the
conducting officer were appointed and the deceased petitioner
was granted an opportunity to file his reply to the show-cause
notice/charges levelled against him. After thoroughly
conducting the departmental proceeding, the enquiry officer
submitted his report before the disciplinary authority, wherein
he recommended for exoneration of the deceased petitioner
from the charges levelled against him and found the charges to
be not proved against him. It is the case of the deceased
petitioner that without affording any opportunity of filing the
second show-cause reply, by the order contained in Memo
No.2025, dated 02.06.1999, the punishment of deduction of
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
4/18
20% of the pension was passed against him. Being aggrieved
with the order dated 02.06.1999, the deceased petitioner filed a
writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No.9684 of 2001 before this
Hon’ble Court. The writ petition filed by him was heard and
vide order dated 15.10.2001, passed by a Hon’ble Single Judge
of this Court, the impugned order of punishment dated
02.06.1999 was set aside and the matter was remitted back to
the concerned authorities for giving fresh opportunity to the
deceased petitioner to offer his comments with regard to the
tentative reasons, on which the competent authority proposes
to differ from the enquiry report and after giving such
opportunity to the deceased petitioner, the authorities were
directed to proceed in the matter and pass fresh order in
accordance with law. The entire exercise was directed to be
completed preferably within a period of three months and
immediately thereafter decision with regard to the pensionary
benefits payable to the deceased petitioner was directed to be
taken in accordance with law, within a further period of one
month thereafter. Pursuant thereto, a second show-cause notice
was issued to the deceased petitioner vide letter bearing
No.4076, dated 21.12.2001, issued under the signature of the
Deputy Secretary, Department of Environment and Forest. An
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
5/18
explanation was submitted by him on 04.01.2002 before the
Secretary-cum-Commissioner, Department of Forest and
Environment, Government of Bihar. The disciplinary authority
proceeded to pass final order contained in Memo No.1407,
dated 12.04.2002, whereby the earlier order of deduction of
20% from the pension of the deceased petitioner was
reiterated. Being aggrieved with the punishment order dated
12.04.2002, the deceased petitioner again filed a writ petition
bearing C.W.J.C. No.8600 of 2002. The said writ petition was
heard by a Hon’ble Single Judge of this Court and vide order
dated 25.07.2007, the Hon’ble Single Judge proceeded to
quash the order contained in Memo No.1407, dated 12.04.2002
and again remitted back the matter to the State Government
with a direction to issue fresh show-cause notice, indicating
the grounds of difference of opinion. It was further directed
that after issuance of the show-cause notice, the deceased
petitioner may file a reply within a period of six weeks and the
final order shall be passed within three weeks thereafter. It was
further directed that such order must be a reasoned order and
must reflect consideration of reply to the show-cause notice
filed by the deceased petitioner. It is further case of the
deceased petitioner that in compliance of the order dated
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
6/18
25.07.2007, passed in C.W.J.C. No.8600 of 2002, fresh show-
cause notice was issued to him, which has got no difference,
from the earlier show-cause notice issued to him, since in the
fresh show-cause notice contained in Letter No.242, dated
22.01.2008, again it was reiterated that why the order be not
kept as it is with regard to deduction of 20% pension of the
deceased petitioner. Immediately thereafter, a show-cause
reply was filed by the deceased petitioner on 03.04.2008,
whereby he denied all the charges levelled against him and
gave the details of each of the charges, which were levelled
against him and which were found to be not sustainable by the
enquiry officer in his enquiry report. It is further case of the
deceased petitioner that the disciplinary authority again vide
order contained in No.1539, dated 18.06.2010 proceeded to
pass the same punishment/order of deduction of 20% pension
of the deceased petitioner.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE SUBSTITUTED PETITIONERS
6. The learned counsel for the substituted
petitioners submits that despite the fact that the impugned
order of punishment passed against the deceased petitioner
vide Memo No.2025, dated 02.06.1999 and resolution bearing
No.1407, dated 12.04.2002, having been quashed by the
Hon’ble Single Judge of this Court and the matter was remitted
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
7/18
back to the disciplinary authority to give detail reason for
differing with the enquiry report submitted by the enquiry
officer, the disciplinary authority reiterated the punishment
order passed against the deceased petitioner, of deduction of
20% of pension and issued a fresh show-cause notice on
22.01.2008, whereby with a pre-determined mind, he again
directed the deceased petitioner to file his reply to the show-
cause notice that why 20% of the pension be not deducted. He
further submits that the disciplinary authority again without
even considering the reply filed by the deceased petitioner on
03.04.2008, proceeded to pass the order of punishment against
the deceased petitioner, whereby 20% of pension of the
deceased petitioner was again directed to be deducted. The
learned counsel for the substituted petitioners submits that the
disciplinary authority before passing the order of punishment,
did not bother to consult the Bihar Public Service Commission,
which is mandatory, before passing any order of punishment
against a Gazetted Officer. He further submits that the
disciplinary authority ought to have considered the reply
submitted by the deceased petitioner before passing the
impugned order of punishment dated 18.06.2010 and the final
order with regard to deduction/reduction of pension has been
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
8/18
passed without any consultation with the Bihar Public Service
Commission, which is mandatory in terms of law. He submits
that the disciplinary authority was adamant from the beginning
to punish the deceased petitioner and despite quashing of the
order of punishment passed against him by this Hon’ble Court,
not once, but twice, he again reiterated the same order of
punishment only to satisfy his ego. He further submits that in
the entire departmental proceeding and during course of
enquiry, it was found that no pecuniary loss has been caused to
the State exchequer and therefore, the punishment order passed
against the deceased petitioner is itself bad and is not
sustainable. He submits that in terms of Rule 43(b) of the
Bihar Pension Rules, for imposing punishment, pecuniary loss
caused to the State exchequer is mandatory.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
7. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the State, while relying on the counter affidavit filed
on behalf of respondents no.3 to 5 on 08.05.2026, submit that
vide Letter No.3731, dated 28.09.1999 of the Department of
Environment and Forest, Government of Bihar, the Bihar
Public Service Commission was duly requested to grant its
approval on the decision taken by the State Government for
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
9/18
deduction of 20% pension of the deceased petitioner. The
B.P.S.C. vide its Letter No.1671, dated 29.10.1999 sought for
certain clarification/documents and thereafter the deceased
petitioner was issued second show-cause notice on 02.12.1999.
He submitted his reply to the second show-cause notice on
16.12.1999. All the documents, asked for by the B.P.S.C., were
duly provided, however before formal approval of the B.P.S.C.
could be obtained, an order was passed by this Hon’ble Court
in C.W.J.C. No.9684 of 2001, rendering the proceeding before
the B.P.S.C. as infructuous. Subsequently, vide Letter No.691,
dated 22.02.2002 of the Department of Environment and
Forest, Government of Bihar, the B.P.S.C. was again requested
to grant its approval with regard to deduction of 20% pension
of the deceased petitioner. The B.P.S.C. vide Letter No.45,
dated 06.04.2002 granted its formal approval to the decision of
the State Government, with regard to deduction of 20%
pension of the deceased petitioner and thereafter vide
Resolution No.1407, dated 12.04.2002, the order of
punishment to the tune of deduction of 20% pension of the
deceased petitioner was passed. It has further been submitted
that subsequently in terms of order dated 25.07.2007, passed in
C.W.J.C. No.8600 of 2002, notices were issued to the deceased
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
10/18
petitioner and after considering the reply submitted by him, the
impugned order, contained in Memo No.1539 dated
18.06.2010, was passed. He submits that the order dated
18.06.2010 is a detailed, speaking and reasoned order, which
has been passed in compliance of order dated 25.07.2007,
passed by this Hon’ble Court in C.W.J.C. No.8600 of 2002.
From the order passed by the disciplinary authority, it will
transpire that the order has been passed after due application of
mind by the disciplinary authority to all the materials on
record, including the explanation submitted by the deceased
petitioner. Only after assigning valid and cogent reasons and
after due application of independent mind, the final decision
with regard to deduction of 20% pension of the deceased
petitioner was passed. It has further been submitted that prior
to issuance of Resolution No.1407, dated 12.04.2002, the State
Government duly and completely had the entire process of
consultation with the B.P.S.C. in as much as vide Letter
No.691, dated 22.02.2002, all the relevant
information/documents and records pertaining to the
departmental proceeding were forwarded to the B.P.S.C., for
seeking approval and final approval was granted on
06.04.2002. Thus, the requirement of consultation with the
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
11/18
B.P.S.C. stood duly concluded prior to passing of the order.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State further
submits that subsequent to the order dated 25.07.2007, passed
in C.W.J.C. No.8600 of 2002, it was only for the limited
purpose of issuing a fresh show-cause notice and for passing
reasoned order and throughout the entire subsequent process,
the charges against the deceased petitioner as well as the
quantum of punishment proposed remained identical, in every
material facts and circumstances of the case. The subject
matter of consultation placed before the B.P.S.C. in the year
2002 remained identical in every material respect to the subject
matter of the fresh order passed in 2010. The approval already
obtained from the B.P.S.C. remained valid, subsisting and fully
applicable rendering any requirement of fresh consultation
unnecessary. He submits that there is no infirmity in the
impugned order dated 18.06.2010 passed by the disciplinary
authority and the deceased petitioner has not pointed out any
infirmity in the order passed by the disciplinary authority in
the present writ petition. He finally submits that the order
passed by the disciplinary authority is in accordance with law
and there is no infirmity in the impugned order dated
18.06.2010 and the deceased petitioner has rightly been
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
12/18
awarded punishment of deduction of 20% of pension.
FINDINGS
8. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties
and after going through the records, it appears that the
departmental proceeding was initiated against the deceased
petitioner for the charges levelled against him vide Memo
No.1852, dated 24.04.1996. Altogether five charges were
levelled against him with regard to financial irregularity and
other charges. The enquiry officer, after conducting a detailed
enquiry, submitted his report before the disciplinary authority,
wherein he came to the conclusion that the charges levelled
against the deceased petitioner are not proved. He
recommended for exoneration of the deceased petitioner from
the departmental proceeding/charges which were levelled
against him. The disciplinary authority, without issuing of any
second show-cause notice to the deceased petitioner,
proceeded to award punishment against him of deduction of
20% of pension. The same was assailed by the deceased
petitioner by filing a writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No.9684 of
2001. The Hon’ble Single Judge of this Court vide order dated
15.10.2001, while remitting the matter to the disciplinary
authority, set aside the order of punishment and directed for
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
13/18
issuance of fresh notice upon the deceased petitioner, with a
liberty to him to file his reply to the said fresh notice and
directed for passing fresh order, after considering the reply
submitted by him. The disciplinary authority again vide Letter
No.4076, dated 21.12.2001, issued show-cause notice to the
deceased petitioner with a predetermined mind, wherein he
was directed to file his show-cause reply, that why the
punishment of 20% reduction in pension be not kept as it is, as
passed vide Memo No.2025, dated 02.06.1999. The deceased
petitioner filed reply to the said notice, however the
disciplinary authority again vide Memo No.1407, dated
12.04.2002 proceeded to pass the same order, i.e., deduction of
20% of pension of the deceased petitioner. The said order
dated 12.04.2002 was again assailed by him, by filing a writ
petition bearing C.W.J.C. No.8600 of 2002. The writ petition
filed by the deceased petitioner was finally disposed of vide
order dated 25.07.2007, passed by a Hon’ble Single Judge of
this Court by remitting the matter again to the disciplinary
authority, after setting aside the order contained in Memo
No.1407, dated 12.04.2002, with a direction to issue fresh
show-cause notice, indicating the grounds of difference of
opinion and after such show-cause notice, the deceased
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
14/18
petitioner was given liberty to file his reply, within a period of
six weeks and the final order was directed to be passed within
three weeks thereafter. It appears that again vide Letter
No.242, dated 22.01.2008, show-cause notice was issued to the
deceased petitioner wherein again the same show-cause, which
was issued earlier and was set aside by this Hon’ble Court, was
issued that why the order of punishment of deduction of 20%
of pension be not kept as it is. The deceased petitioner filed his
reply to the said notice dated 22.01.2008 on 03.04.2008,
wherein he gave his defence to each of the charges levelled
against him. However, the disciplinary authority again without
even considering the reply filed by him, proceeded to affirm
the earlier orders and passed the order of punishment vide
Memo No.1539, dated 18.06.2010, whereby the order of
deduction of 20% pension of the deceased petitioner has been
reiterated. It appears that despite repeated opportunities, being
granted by this Court to the respondent authorities/disciplinary
authority to rectify the earlier infirmity, which was there in the
issuance of show-cause notice/order of punishment, the
disciplinary authority kept on reiterating the same and
ultimately passed the order of punishment of reduction of 20%
of pension of the deceased petitioner. In the counter affidavit, a
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
15/18
defence has been taken that since the order was reiteration of
the earlier orders passed by the disciplinary authority, therefore
there was no requirement of taking fresh opinion of the
B.P.S.C. on the matter of giving punishment to the deceased
petitioner. In the opinion of this Court, when the order of
punishment was set aside by this Court twice and the matter
was remitted back to the disciplinary authority to pass fresh
order, after issuance of fresh show-cause notice to the deceased
petitioner, wherein the disciplinary authority was directed to
give reasons for his difference with the enquiry report
submitted by the enquiry officer, however the disciplinary
authority, in complete violation of the directions issued by this
Hon’ble Court, again reiterated the same by issuing show-
cause notice on 22.01.2008, whereby he again with a pre-
determined and pre-occupied mind asked the deceased
petitioner to submit his reply to the show-cause notice, that
why the earlier order, by which the punishment of 20% of
deduction of pension was imposed, be not kept as it is. Further,
the proceeding against the deceased petitioner was held under
Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules and in the entire enquiry
report, there is no finding with regard to the deceased
petitioner causing any pecuniary loss to the State exchequer
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
16/18
has come, therefore the punishment order passed under Rule
43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules is also not fit to be sustained.
9. From the consideration made above, this Court
is of the considered opinion that the impugned order contained
in Memo No.1539, dated 18.06.2010 deserves to be set aside
and is accordingly, set aside. Since during pendency of the
present writ petition, the writ petitioner has already died and
his legal heirs have been substituted vide order dated
28.10.2024 passed in this case, there is no justification in
remitting back the matter to the disciplinary authority for
consideration of the matter afresh.
10. The High Court under Article 226/227 is
entitled to interfere when the finding of fact, based on no
evidence and if in every case where no valid evidence is laid at
the enquiry proceeding, there is a remand made, it would be
offering a premium to the negligence of the
management/disciplinary authority and condoning the levity
with which the departmental enquiry was conducted. It is the
disciplinary authority, who appoints the Enquiry Officer and
the Presenting Officer and it is expected that the Presenting
Officer would be well versed in the procedures and also be
informed in the manner in which evidence has to be laid before
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
17/18
the Enquiry Officer, to prove the misconduct, alleged against a
delinquent employee. In a disciplinary enquiry proceeding, it is
also the trite principle that the standard of proof is
preponderance of probability as distinguished from proof
beyond reasonable doubt, as would be required in a criminal
prosecution. However, if there is no evidence laid at the
enquiry, there is no question of any preponderance of
probability being drawn to find the allegations proved nor can
the delinquent be penalised on the basis of peremptory finding
without any valid evidence. The disciplinary authority had an
opportunity in a properly constituted enquiry proceeding and if
in such a proceeding no evidence was laid, the punishment of
dismissal has to be found to be imposed on no valid evidence.
11. Accordingly, the legal heirs of the deceased
petitioner are entitled for payment of the entire deducted
amount of 20% of pension of the deceased petitioner within a
period of four months from the date of receipt/production of a
copy of the order. If the entire deducted amount of 20% of
pension of the deceased petitioner will not be paid in the
account of the legal heirs of the deceased petitioner within the
aforementioned period of four months, the legal heirs of the
deceased petitioner would be entitled for interest @ 6% from
Patna High Court CWJC No.17121 of 2013 dt.15-06-2026
18/18
the date of filing of the writ petition till the date of its actual
payment.
12. With the aforementioned observations and
directions, the writ petition is allowed.
13. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Ritesh Kumar, J.)
Sanjay/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR
CAV DATE NA
Uploading Date 18.06.2026
Transmission Date NA
Checking your session…
Lawyer court records for this case
Associated through the court’s case reference.
To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.