Created by Fuzzy Cloud

Patna High Court

Dhanesh Singh and OrsversusThe State Of Bihar and Ors

Work with this judgment

Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.

Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.

Decided
Disposal
DISPOSED

Holding

The court held that the university must adjudicate the petitioners’ claims in accordance with the earlier directives and, if found justified, grant them the benefits of absorption.

Summary

The petitioners, non‑teaching employees of Magadh University, claimed that their services were validly absorbed into university service under the notification dated 02‑01‑2006 pursuant to Section 4(i)(14) of the Bihar State Universities Act and that they were entitled to pay, increments, seniority and promotion. They relied on their inclusion in the provisional list of absorption contained in Letter No. 25/C dated 12‑02‑1990 and on the earlier judgment in Akhilanand Singh & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors., which directed universities to recognize such cases. The High Court examined the earlier directive and the parameters fixed in the Mahasangh’s case, concluding that the university must adjudicate the petitioners’ claims within two months and, if justified, grant the consequential benefits and arrears of salary. The court therefore ordered the Registrar of Magadh University to act accordingly and disposed of the writ petition.

Issues considered

  • Whether the petitioners’ services were legally and validly absorbed under Section 4(i)(14) of the Bihar State Universities Act.
  • Whether the university is bound by the earlier judgment in Akhilanand Singh & Ors. v. State of Bihar and the Mahasangh’s case to recognize the petitioners’ absorption.
  • Whether the petitioners are entitled to arrears of salary, interest, and other benefits arising from the alleged absorption.

Legislation cited

Subjects

  • absorption
  • university service
  • non‑teaching employees
  • writ of mandamus
  • arrears of salary
  • Bihar State Universities Act
  • seniority
  • promotion

Judgment

                      IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
                                Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.18827 of 2018
                 ======================================================
           1.     Dhanesh Singh and Ors son of Late Mathura Prasad, resident of Village-
                  Akhtiyarpur, P.S. Nagarnausa, District Nalanda.
           2.    Gauri Shankar Singh, son of Guru Charan Prasad, resident of Village-
                 Shahjahanpur, P.S. Shahjahanpur, District Patna.
           3.    Vijay Narayan Rai son of Late Ganga Rai, resident of Village- Kalma Siko,
                 Kila Road, Nepali Kothi, P.S. Chowk Thana, District- Patna.
                                                                           ... ... Petitioner/s
                                                   Versus
           1.    The State Of Bihar and Ors
           2.    The Principal Secretary, Human Resources Development Department, Govt.
                 of Bihar, Patna.
           3.    The Director, Higher Education, Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
           4.    The Vice- Chancellor, Magadh University, Bodh Gaya.
           5.    The Registrar, Magadh University, Bodh Gaya.

                                                           ... ... Respondent/s
                 ======================================================
                 Appearance :
                 For the Petitioner/s   :       Mr. Binodand Mishra, Advocate
                                                Mr. Arvind Kumar, Advocate
                 For the State          :       Mr. Subash Chandra Mishra -SC-16
                 ======================================================
                 CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJIT KUMAR
                                       ORAL ORDER

3   31-03-2026                    In the instant petition, petitioners have prayed for the

                   following relief(s):-

                                                       “(i)     For     issuance    of
                                             appropriate declaration holding that
                                             service of petitioners have been legally
                                             and validly absorbed in the University
                                             service vide notification dtd. 02.01.2006
                                             in terms with the provisions of Sec. 4(i)
                                             (14) of the Bihar State Universities Act
                                             and also for declaration that the
                                             petitioners are entitled to all the
                                             consequential benefits of absorption
                                             such as pay, increments, salary,
                                             seniority and promotion in accordance
                                             with law.
                                                       (ii) For issuance of a writ in
Patna High Court CWJC No.18827 of 2018(3) dt.31-03-2026
                                           2/5




                                     the nature of writ of mandamus
                                     commanding the respondents to treat the
                                     petitioners as validly absorbed and
                                     grant him all the consequential benefits
                                     of absorption.
                                                (iii) For issuance of an
                                     order/direction including the writ in the
                                     nature     of    writ    of   mandamus
                                     commanding the respondents to make
                                     payment of unpaid arrears of salary to
                                     the petitioner from November 2006 till
                                     date and grant him interest on unpaid
                                     arrears of salary at the rate of 12%
                                     from the date it became due till the date
                                     payment is made.
                                                (iv) For issuance of any other
                                     writ/writs to which the petitioners are
                                     found entitled to in the facts and
                                     circumstances of this case.”

                      2. By referring to Annexure-2 as contained in Letter

          No. 25/C dated 12.02.1990 issued by the Department of Human

          Resource Development, Bihar Govt., learned Senior Counsel

          submits that the name of these petitioners finds place in the list

          of 4th Phase absorption, which is appended with the said letter,

          and the same has been approved by the Co-ordinate Bench in

          the case of Akhilanand Singh & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors.

          (CWJC No. 17670 of 2017) reported in 2018 (3) PLJR 1029,

          wherein the Co-ordinate Bench has made a categorical direction

          that in the matter where the name of individual teaching and

          non-teaching employees finds place in the provisional list of the

          absorption contained in Letter Nos. 181C, 38C, 36C and as also
Patna High Court CWJC No.18827 of 2018(3) dt.31-03-2026
                                           3/5




          with respect to the non-teaching employees in letter No. 25C are

          concerned, the University was required to recognize their cases

          as eligible for absorption in view of judgment in Mahasangh’s

          case and the University was also required to issue appropriate

          notification in the light of Letter No. 181C, 38C, 36C and 25C

          and accordingly, the Court has not approved the action of the

          University, in reviewing the notification of absorption taken by

          the University, which is supported by the report of Justice

          Agarwal Commission, judgment in Mahasangh’s Case and

          Letter Nos. 181C, 38C, 36C and 25C.

                      3. On this strength, Senior Counsel next submits that

          on detailed consideration and deliberations having been made

          by the Co-ordinate Bench, the authorities of the Universities

          were directed to take a decision with regard to individual cases

          in the light of deliberations made in the aforesaid case, within

          the time-line framed in the said case, the individual is found

          covered by the aforesaid discussion, necessary decisions and

          notification were required to be issued by the University within

          the time frame so indicated and the relevant portion of the order

          as contained in Paras 30, 34 & 39, which has re-produced as

          under:-

                                          “30. It is also admitted on behalf
                                of the State that the sanction post if falls
Patna High Court CWJC No.18827 of 2018(3) dt.31-03-2026
                                           4/5




                                vacant on account of death, retirement or
                                transfer subsequent to the cut-off date may
                                be available for consideration of case of
                                those incumbents who were appointed on
                                the date of of conversion and were eligible
                                on the date of appointment for their
                                consideration against the post which fall
                                vacant on account of death, retirement or
                                transfer.
                                           34. In matters where the name of
                                individual teaching and non-teaching
                                employee figures in the provisional list of
                                absorption contained in in letter No. 181C,
                                38C and 36C and so far as the non-teaching
                                employees 25C are concerned, the
                                University was required to recognize their
                                cases as eligible for absorption in view of
                                the judgment in Mahasangh's case and the
                                University was required to issue appropriate
                                notification in the light of the letter No.
                                181C, 38C, 36C and 25C and as such the
                                Court does not approve the action of the
                                University in notification of absorption
                                taken by the University if supported by the
                                report of Justice in reviewing the
                                Commission, Judgment in Mahasangh's
                                case, letter No. 181(C), 38(C), 36(C) and
                                25.
                                           39. In view of the above, the
                                University is directed to take decision with
                                regard to the individual cases in the light of
                                the discussions above within a time frame of
                                four months and in case the individual is
                                found covered by the aforesaid discussion,
                                necessary decision and notification may be
                                issued by the University within the time
                                frame indicated above.”

                      4. Senior counsel next submits that the University

          officials are required to adjudicate the claim of these petitioners,

          who are non-teaching employees and are guided by the list
           Patna High Court CWJC No.18827 of 2018(3) dt.31-03-2026
                                                      5/5




                     appended with Letter No. 25/C dated 12.02.1990, which till date

                     have been considered by the University, as per the parameter

                     fixed in the case of Mahasangh’s case, and the said judgment

                     was tested before Hon’ble Division Bench as also before

                     Hon’ble Supreme Court and the same has attained finality at the

                     level of Hon’ble Apex Court.

                                 5. In view of the stand so taken by the learned Senior

                     Counsel, this Court finds appropriate to direct the Registrar,

                     Magadh University to adjudicate the claim of these petitioners

                     within a period of two months from the date of representation,

                     which shall be made by these petitioners or legal heirs within a

                     period of four weeks form today and necessary orders so passed

                     shall be communicated and if the claim of these petitioners are

                     found justified, then benefits shall also be extended in their

                     favour, within the same time.

                                 6. With the above observations, the instant writ

                     petition stands disposed of.

                                 7. Interlocutory Application(s), if any, stands disposed

                     of in above terms.



                                                  (Ajit Kumar, J)
abhishekkr/-

U


Continue reading with your account

Sign in to read the full judgment. It’s free.

Sign in to read

Checking your session…

Lawyer court records for this case

Associated through the court’s case reference.

To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.

For a signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's website.