Bombay High Court
SURESH VISHNU JADHAVversusTHE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THR THE SEC. MINISTRY OF LABOUR AND LABOUR WELFARE AND ORS
Work with this judgment
Open a tool, attach the original court file and add your question or case details. You choose when to generate.
Use this judgment as a legal authority. Your own parties and facts stay for you to enter.
- Decided
- Disposal
- Rejected
Holding
The petitioner has no legal right to medical leave encashment as the Maharashtra Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981, applicable to the Board, override the earlier circular and do not provide for such encashment.
Summary
The petitioner, a retired clerk of the Pune Mathadi Hamal and Other Manual Workers Board, sought a writ directing the Board to pay Rs.6,07,858 as medical leave encashment, relying on a 1993 circular that allowed such encashment. The Board, following a 2010 resolution, had adopted the Maharashtra Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981, which do not provide for medical leave encashment, and consequently denied the claim. The petitioner argued that the earlier circular remained valid and that the Board could not be treated like the State Government for the purpose of applying the 1981 Rules. The respondents contended that the 2010 resolution superseded the 1993 circular and that the Board was bound by the 1981 Rules. The Court examined the statutory scheme of the Maharashtra Mathadi, Hamal and Other Manual Workers Act and the applicable service rules, concluding that the Board had no legal obligation to honour the encashment claim. Accordingly, the petition was dismissed as devoid of merit.
Issues considered
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to medical leave encashment under the 1993 circular despite the Board's later adoption of the Maharashtra Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981.
- Whether the Maharashtra Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981, which exclude medical leave encashment, supersede the earlier circular.
- Whether the Board's denial of the encashment claim is legally valid under the Maharashtra Mathadi, Hamal and Other Manual Workers Act, 1969.
- Whether the petitioner has locus standi to invoke Article 226 of the Constitution for relief.
Legislation cited
- Constitution of India — s. Article 226
- Maharashtra Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981
- Maharashtra Mathadi, Hamal and other Manual Workers Act, 1969
Subjects
- medical leave encashment
- Maharashtra Mathadi Board
- service rules applicability
- circular vs resolution
- Article 226
- writ petition
- service conditions
Judgment
11_WP_17503_2025.DOC
Prasad
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.17503 OF 2025
Suresh Vishnu Jadhav …...Petitioner
Versus
The State Of Maharashtra thr. the Sec.
Ministry Of Labour And Labour Welfare & Ors. …...Respondents
_______
Mr. Divyesh Jain a/w Shantanu S Kolhe, for the Petitioner.
Mr. P.P. Kakde, Addl. GP a/w A.R. Deolekar, AGP, for the Respondent - State.
_______
CORAM: G. S. KULKARNI &
DR. NEELA GOKHALE, JJ.
DATE: 23rd SEPTEMBER 2026
P.C.
1. We have heard learned Counsel for the parties in the present petition. This
petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, prays for the
following substantive reliefs:
“[A] Call for record and proceedings of the case.
[B] Quash and set aside the impugned communication dated 20.06.2025
issued by the Respondent No.2 Joint Labour Commissioner, Maharashtra State,
Mumbai and impugned communication dated 09.07.2025 issued by the
respondent No.3 Pune Mathadi Hamal and other Manual Workers Board, Pune
and for that purpose issue necessary orders.
[C] Issue appropriate writ, order or direction, thereby directing the
Respondent No.3 Pune Mathadi Hamal and other Manual Workers Board, Pune
to disburse an amount of Rs.6,07,858/- as and by way of medical leave
encashment in favour of the petitioner along with interest thereupon and for
that purpose issue necessary orders.
[D] Pending hearing and final disposal of this Writ Petition, direct the
respondent No.3 Pune Mathadi Hamal and other Manual Workers Board, Pune
to forthwith disburse an amount of Rs. 6,07,858/- as and by way of medical
leave encashment in favour of the petitioner along with interest thereupon and
for that purpose issue necessary orders.
[E] Grant ad interim relief in terms of prayer clauses 'D'.
Page 1 of 6
11_WP_17503_2025.DOC
[F] Pass such other and further order as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and
proper in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case.”
2. The relevant facts which are required to be noted are as follows:
2.1 The Petitioner had joined as a Clerk with Respondent No.3-Board in
the year 1992 and after continuous service with the Board he superannuated
on 31.12.2024. After his superannuation he made and application to
Respondent No.2-Joint Labour Commissioner, praying for disbursement of
Rs.6,07,858/- as and by way of medical leave encashment.
2.2 On 05.03.2025, Respondent No.2 directed Respondent No.3 to take
decision on the Petitioner’s application. Respondent No.3 is also stated to
have sent a clarification on 05.03.2025.
2.3 On 20.06.2025, Respondent No.2–Joint Labour Commissioner
denied the claim of the Petitioner by a communication, inter alia, stating that
the Maharashtra State Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981 have been made
applicable to Respondent No.3-Board, which do not make any provision for
the medical leave encashment and hence the request as made by the
Petitioner for such medical leave encashment cannot be granted.
2.4 Further by communication dated 09.07.2025, Respondent No.3
informed the Petitioner that in view of the Maharashtra Civil Service
(General Condition of Services) Rules, 1981 having been made applicable to
Respondent No.3, medical leave cannot be encashed in favour of the
Petitioner.
3. On such factual matrix, we have heard learned Counsel for the Petitioner.
His submission in regard to the Petitioner’s legal right to claim such encashment of
Page 2 of 6
11_WP_17503_2025.DOC
medical leave, he states that reliance of the Petitioner is on the Circular dated
25.06.1993, under which the Board had resolved at the relevant time that
encashment of medial leave would be granted. The Petitioner also moved an
application dated 25.06.2025 under the RTI to verify if the resolution dated
25.06.1993 has been cancelled or set aside and the reply received was vide
communication dated 15.07.2025, stating that it was not cancelled. It is in these
circumstances, the present petition has been filed.
4. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner has submitted that the legal right to
medical encashment has closed from circular dated 25.06.1993 which has been
issued by the Respondent No.3–Board, constituted under Section 6 of the
Maharashtra Mathadi, Hamal and Other Manual Workers Act, 1969. He
submitted that the Petitioner would become entitled for medical leave encashment
under the provisions of the said circular. It was further submitted that the stand
taken by Respondent No.2 is not correct that the Maharashtra Civil Service
(Leave) Rules, 1981 would become applicable, inasmuch as, the Board cannot be
held to be at par with the State Government so that such Rules be adopted by the
Board. It is also his contention that many other employees were granted such
benefit. It is his submission that such Rules would become applicable only to the
State Government and not the employees of the Mathadi Board. It is his
contention that circular being not withdrawn, such accrued right under the circular
which was conferred on the employees could not be taken.
5. On the other hand, on behalf of Respondent Nos.1 to 3, reply Affidavit of
Shri Nitin Krishna Kavale, Asst. Labour Commissioner and the Chairman of
Page 3 of 6
11_WP_17503_2025.DOC
Respondent No.3 Board is filed, in which, in opposing the petition, it is inter alia
contended that the Petitioner’s case ought not to be accepted for the reason that
subsequent decision was taken by the Board and more particularly in its Board
meeting held on 31.05.2010, when a resolution was passed to make Maharashtra
Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1981 applicable to the Mathadi Board, and accordingly
the terms and conditions of services are now governed by the Maharashtra Civil
Services Rules, 1981, which includes the Maharashtra Civil Service (Leave) Rules,
1981. It is therefore contended that the resolution of the Board dated 25.06.1993,
on which the reliance is placed by the Petitioner is no longer helpful. The relevant
averments made in the reply Affidavit are required to be noted, which read thus:
“8. I say that some of the Mathadi Boards in the State of Maharashtra had made
Maharashtra Civil Services Rules applicable to their employees and most of the Mathadi
Boards were paying salaries to their employees as per the pay scales applicable to the State
Government employees but there was no parity in the service conditions of all the
Mathadi Boards. The State Government had therefore directed vide its Circular No. SGA-
152002(37/3)/Kamgar-5, Mantralaya, Mumbai dated 10.10.2002 to pass appropriate
resolutions in the board meetings to make various M.C.S. Rules applicable to its
employees. Accordingly, the Respondent No. 3 Board had passed Resolution in its Board
meeting held on 31.05.2010 and had made various M.C.S. Rules applicable to its
employees including Maharashtra Civil services (Leave) Rules, 1981. The said meeting
was attended by the Union Representatives representing the employees of the Respondent
Board as well as by the Employers Representative and Government Representative and
the said Resolution was passed with consent of the said representatives in Tripartite Board.
9. I say that the Respondent Board had earlier passed Resolution in its Board meeting held
on 25.06.1993, whereby the employees of the Board were granted Medical Leave with an
option to accumulate the said medical leave and its encashment on certain terms and
conditions. However, after making the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981
applicable to the employee of the Respondent Board, the Resolution passed in the
meeting held on 25.06.1993 in respect of Medical Leave had lost its applicability and the
service conditions regarding Medical Leave are governed by Maharashtra Civil Services
(Leave) Rules, 1981.
10. I say that the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981 did not provide for
encashment of Medical Leave to the employees and as such the employees of Respondent
Board were not entitled for encashment of Medical Leave but inadvertently the
Respondent Board continued to provide leave encashment facility to its employees even
Page 4 of 6
11_WP_17503_2025.DOC
after Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981 were made applicable.
11. I say that the Petitioner retired on superannuation on 31.12.2024 and on retirement
claimed Rs. 6,07,858/- towards encashment of accumulated Medical Leave and when the
matter came before the then Chairman of the board for approval of the said claim, the
then Chairman noticed the irregularity in the claim of encashment of medical leave. It
came to his notice that there was earlier Resolution of the Board for grant of medical leave
encashment but there was no such provision of encashment of medical leave in
Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981 subsequently made applicable to the
employees of the Respondent Board. The then Chairman of the Board therefore informed
about the same to the Jt. Commissioner of Labour (Mathadi) vide his letter dated
5.03.2025 and sought guidance as to whether the employees of the Respondent Board
should be provided the benefit of medical leave encashment or not.
12. I say that the Respondent Board received letter dated 20.06.2025 from the office of Jt.
Commissioner of Labour (Mathadi), whereby it was informed to the Respondent Board
that the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981 have been made applicable to the
employees of the Respondent Board and there is no provision of medical leave
encashment in the said Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981, hence the claim of
Mr. Suresh Vishnu Jadhav, the Petitioner herein, cannot be granted.
13. I say that the Petitioner had also approached the office of Commissioner of Labour
vide his letter dated 4.03.2025 for grant of benefit of medical leave encashment and in
response thereto the Respondent No. 3 Board received letter dated 12.03.2025 from the
office of Commissioner of Labour whereby the Respondent Board was directed to take
appropriate action on the letter of Mr. Suresh Vishnu Jadhav as per the directions given by
the Jt. Commissioner of Labour (Mathadi).
14. I say that the Respondent No. 3 thereafter vide its letter dated 9.07.2025 informed the
Petitioner that his claim of medical leave encashment cannot be granted in view of the
provisions of Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981 having been made applicable
to the employees of the Respondent Board. I say that thus the Respondent Board has not
committed any illegality or irregularity while rejecting the claim of the Petitioner and the
impugned communication of the Respondent Board dated 9.07.2025 is perfectly legal,
proper and justified and needs to be confirmed by this Hon'ble Court.
15. I say that the Petitioner has contended that the right to encashment of medical leave
flows from the Resolution dated 25.06.1993 whereby the employees of the Respondent
Board were conferred with the benefits of medical leave encashment, however, the
Respondent Board has passed subsequent resolution in the meeting held on 31.05.2010,
whereby the Maharashtra Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1981 have been made applicable to
the employees of the Respondent Board. The said resolution was passed by the full-
fledged Tripartite Board in confirmation with the State Government directives to bring
uniformity in the service conditions of the employees of all the Mathadi Boards.
Therefore, after the subsequent resolution of the Board dated 31.05.2010, the service
conditions made applicable to the employees of the Board vide resolution dated
25.06.1993 cease to apply and stands amended. The Petitioner therefore is not entitled to
claim the benefit of medical leave encashment on the basis of resolution dated 25.06.1993
Page 5 of 6
11_WP_17503_2025.DOC
contending that the said resolution has not been set aside by the Respondent Board.”
6. It is on the aforesaid conspectus we have heard learned Counsel for the
parties, we find no substance in the contention as urged on behalf of the
Respondent that mere applicability of the circular at the relevant time would not
accrue any legal right on the Petitioner and more particularly when now a position
subsists from the year 2010 that the Mathadi Board has adopted applicability of the
Maharashtra Civil Service Rules, 1981. Such applicability is certainly not set aside
or challenged by the Petitioner. We are not persuaded to agree such contention as
urged on behalf of the Petitioner.
7. Considering the scheme of this Act where the Board is empowered to take
its independent decisions within its authority as conferred by the Maharashtra Civil
Service Rules, 1981 and specific Rules namely Maharashtra Service (Leave) Rules,
1981, do not make any provision for encashment of medical leave.
8. In this view of the matter, in our opinion, Petitioner would not have any
legal right to seek encashment merely because some benefit was granted under the
circular at the relevant time.
9. Petition is devoid of merits. It is accordingly rejected. No costs.
(DR. NEELA GOKHALE, J) (G. S. KULKARNI, J.)
PRASAD
RAJENDRASING
RAJPUT
Digitally signed by
PRASAD
RAJENDRASING RAJPUT
Date: 2026.09.28
11:14:18 +0530
Page 6 of 6
Checking your session…
To request removal of this judgment, sign in and send a removal request. We review requests within 10 working days.